Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be more help for middle class families

384 replies

RootinandTootin · 19/10/2022 15:40

This isn't a hate mongering post, those on lower incomes and can't work should be helped. My issue is that there seems to be little to no support at all for middle class families. Myself and partner work 5 days a week and have 2 kids. Not a terrible wage so I can't complain about that but the energy cost, food bills and fuel are going to cripple us soon enough. We also have Christmas to think about and a couple of birthdays inbetween. I just feel so unbelievably stressed out all the time about it. I'm praying this all calms down by the end of next year when our mortgage is coming up to renewal. There is pretty much no help being offered to us (unless anyone has some hints). I can't see it getting any better and its pretty depressing, alongside other personal issues going on at the moment I just want to cry.

OP posts:
Lily073 · 19/10/2022 17:10

It sounds like you're a middle income family and may have stretched yourself beyond your means. I don't believe the taxpayer should be expected to fund aspirational lifestyles (regardless of whether that applies to you or not)

toulet · 19/10/2022 17:07

Everyone has to tighten their belts and go without luxuries.

lol, you think everyone is?

mavismorpoth · 19/10/2022 17:07

Sounds like you're generally miserable. Is your job not fulfilling you? It's a third of your life and it should be highly enjoyable and rewarding.

toulet · 19/10/2022 17:06

I'm also quite fed up of pensioners continually being helped over other groups. I'm sure some do live in poverty..but plenty are very well off and a lot better off than a lot of families

and surely some of them have ended up in situations because they didn't "live within their means" or save but I assume once you cross a certain age it's acceptable?

WiddlinDiddlin · 19/10/2022 17:05

But we all want the life we had before...

I've only just managed to get some savings for the first time in my life - I am beyond gutted that in reality, my savings intended for improving my kitchen (currently falling apart, not disabled accessible, circa 1980s) are going to be spent on just surviving.

And once those are gone, I will be in debt.

This is what a cost of living crisis is - you won't be able to save, life will be pretty shit, you will end up in debt.

Why would it be different for middle income earners vs low income earners - you may earn more, but you have bigger mortgages, more expensive cars, are used to spendy holidays (or indeed, actually going on holidays!)...

If you were living within your means before, then you probably won't lose your home, but you will have to tighten things up and it won't be fun.

If you were living beyond your means before - well yeah you're pretty fucked now, as will many be.

GoSomewhereThatDoes · 19/10/2022 17:04

Furthermore, it is in all of our wider interest for people to have enough surplus money, so they are able to spend it in the retail and service industries, otherwise businesses struggle and jobs are lost

You want us to agree that middle earners should be given government help so that you can afford to keep socialising so us low earners still have a job to go to? Is that what you’re saying?

mummybearcub2022 · 19/10/2022 17:02

tickticksnooze · 19/10/2022 15:41

What help would you like?

Make child benefit a universal benefit again for a start.

toulet · 19/10/2022 17:02

We can't afford to cut taxes. Public services have been cut to the bone for a decade and being told to brace for more.

We need a wealth tax, it's not sustainable with the ageing population.

thecatsthecats · 19/10/2022 17:01

RootinandTootin · 19/10/2022 15:53

To be fair you're probably right i might be working class but still no help at all. I don't live above my means and I put food and keeping the kids warm first and foremost but I feel that if you are working then why shouldn't you be able to afford more than just the bare essentials. You should be able to aspire to better things and at the moment its just the same old day in and day out. Why is everyone happy with people struggling? I don't doubt pensioners and others have it worse but why should ANY of us should be struggling along, not with the taxes we all pay.

From a philosophical viewpoint, why do we as a species think we need more than that?

Magpies collect pretty objects, and bower birds decorate their nests, but the default model of existence for the past few eons has been that living creatures need to find food, make shelter for their babies and try not to get eaten by something bigger.

I do wonder whether humans generally make things worse for themselves by expecting more.

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 17:00

@Elwynne
Furthermore, it is in all of our wider interest for people to have enough surplus money, so they are able to spend it in the retail and service industries, otherwise businesses struggle and jobs are lost.

yes of course keep the middle class flush with money for nothing, so they can then pass it on to the working class for yet more work! Such a benefit to society.

Discovereads · 19/10/2022 16:58

@Elwynne
why should they have to accept such a dramatic downgrade in lifestyle when it is possible to raise money through taxing higher earners and businesses?

Oh how is that fair? God forbid a middle class family has to slum it like the working class for a temporary period so let’s tax the rich to keep them in the lifestyle they are accustomed to instead of levelling up the working class.

WaddleAway · 19/10/2022 16:58

Many have given themselves a lifestyle they are convinced they can afford because they can afford the monthly payments. The take the highest mortgage they can, pay for holidays abroad monthly, take cars on finance and then, when there’s nothing left per month they’re stuck

Many have to take the highest mortgage they can afford just to get on the property ladder, as prices are so high. Yes we did massively extend ourselves to buy a house, which we moved 200 miles for to a far cheaper area, because paying a mortgage was still cheaper than rent.

JanesBond · 19/10/2022 16:58

You want money from the government towards savings?

Grin
RootinandTootin · 19/10/2022 16:56

ChristinaXYZ · 19/10/2022 16:52

The country just cannot afford it. If they give the middle classes money where do you think that is coming from? The middle classes are a huge group - even if you mean the lower income level within that - say teachers and nurses - should they all get a 10% pay rise to keep up with inflation? That's an unbelievable amount of money. Should we shut a few hospitals to pay for it and shorten the school day so the schools can have fewer staff? Or maybe make the state pension age 75 or even phase it out altogether? Where do you think the help should come from? There are not not enough very rich people to tax to make the kind of money you are talking about.

It is hard OP. We're in a similar position - lots of work, little money. But compared with most of the rest of the world and most people through time we're incredibly lucky.

As a country we seem to have got to a point psychologically where we think the state should always bail us out.

I think ive possibly misworded what my intentions are. I don't want a handout or benefits I just want the life i had before. Instead of sticking massive taxes on fuel or energy so it hits middle earners (and everyone) I want the government to take it from people it probably has no impact on. Rishi Sunak might not be able to heat his pool but at least we can all live a better life then this. I'm not angry at people taking benefits, which I think probably equates to not a massive expense I'm angry at the rich and the government.

OP posts:
toulet · 19/10/2022 16:56

Many have given themselves a lifestyle they are convinced they can afford because they can afford the monthly payments. The take the highest mortgage they can, pay for holidays abroad monthly, take cars on finance and then, when there’s nothing left per month they’re stuck.

Where does this narrative come from? Most people buy if they can because it's cheaper.

My parents were far more irresponsible than me, taking out an interest only mortgage with a high LTV, they became millionaires though...

Tipsyturvychocolatemonster · 19/10/2022 16:54

Op you’re not getting my point, possibly on purpose as you don’t like it. No one is disputing the col crisis, it’s all over the news and a constant topic of conversation.

if your savings were so low a couple of unexpected bills and a new appliance or two wiped it out and already you can’t save any more before the shit really hits then you were already over extended. It doesn’t help now. But if salaries aren’t going to increase then you need to look at how you live.

Mortgages have just started going up, you’re on a fixed rate, so not impacted. The weather has been mild so extensive heating not required. What you’re posing isn’t the governments fault. Energy costs can be managed right now if you can manage heating and they are capped. It’s a fault of over extending.

yoire even stressed about birthdays and say you’re going to be crippled. Which tells us that irrelevant of what you earn you were already all but hand and mouth

WaddleAway · 19/10/2022 16:53

So you can afford the basics (food, heating etc) but you want help from the government so that you can afford luxuries and savings?

toulet · 19/10/2022 16:52

Housing costs have screwed up things for some many younger people.

ChristinaXYZ · 19/10/2022 16:52

The country just cannot afford it. If they give the middle classes money where do you think that is coming from? The middle classes are a huge group - even if you mean the lower income level within that - say teachers and nurses - should they all get a 10% pay rise to keep up with inflation? That's an unbelievable amount of money. Should we shut a few hospitals to pay for it and shorten the school day so the schools can have fewer staff? Or maybe make the state pension age 75 or even phase it out altogether? Where do you think the help should come from? There are not not enough very rich people to tax to make the kind of money you are talking about.

It is hard OP. We're in a similar position - lots of work, little money. But compared with most of the rest of the world and most people through time we're incredibly lucky.

As a country we seem to have got to a point psychologically where we think the state should always bail us out.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 19/10/2022 16:52

Sorry if i sounded hard. That doesnt mean that i want anyone to suffer though or that the government shouldnt be doing more for EVERYONE. Im just trying to put it in perspective that to me you sound like you are doing pretty ok.

Elwynne · 19/10/2022 16:51

OP I get it!

It isn't just happening in the UK here is a German news article talking about the reduction of spending power of middle class people. They equate class to earnings. If you're on reddit there are some great forums to chat about things like this, such as UK personal finance.

To all the miserable ones picking on you for not being middle class, this is 2022 not an episode of ruddy Downton Abbey. Yes people should live within their means but why should they have to accept such a dramatic downgrade in lifestyle when it is possible to raise money through taxing higher earners and businesses? We should all be working towards everyone having the best life they can, instead of hurtling towards serfdom in order for the richest to get richer. Furthermore, it is in all of our wider interest for people to have enough surplus money, so they are able to spend it in the retail and service industries, otherwise businesses struggle and jobs are lost.

Rosewaterblossom · 19/10/2022 16:51

I think the issue here is people often think anyone claiming benefits don't work. I work full time and I'm a single parent, I have to rely on benefit top ups though. One of the reasons people are relying on top benefits is because despite working, wages have been so low and stagnant for years alongside high rents people just never caught up to catch a break.

GoSomewhereThatDoes · 19/10/2022 16:50

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 19/10/2022 16:40

It's a spectrum, though. OP doesn't have to be the poorest person who ever lived. You have people on one side who are really poor, and people on the other who are really rich, and then a big group of people in the middle who are managing with different levels of comfort. If that tips so that a lot of the people who were previously managing are now struggling, then of course those people will feel like OP does! She doesn't have to be on the bones of her arse to be angry at the government causing economic havoc and then saying that we all need to tighten our belts and there's nothing they can do.

And if the level where you can claim benefits while working (working tax credit) remains the same while inflation skyrockets, then we'll see a lot of people tipping into poverty while being ineligible for state help.

Totally get this, but the OP can’t really be surprised that a few of us aren’t overly sympathetic. None of you middle income earners gave a shit about lower income earners having to work our fingers to the bone to afford the absolute basics. How many of you wrote to your MPs when your cleaners had to use food banks? Because I can recall a few posts concerned about their cleaners not declaring cash payments to the taxman, but none concerned about them living in poverty. And now you want us to be outraged on your behalf and agree you need government help because you’ve had to cut back on your social lives?

RootinandTootin · 19/10/2022 16:49

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 19/10/2022 16:40

It's a spectrum, though. OP doesn't have to be the poorest person who ever lived. You have people on one side who are really poor, and people on the other who are really rich, and then a big group of people in the middle who are managing with different levels of comfort. If that tips so that a lot of the people who were previously managing are now struggling, then of course those people will feel like OP does! She doesn't have to be on the bones of her arse to be angry at the government causing economic havoc and then saying that we all need to tighten our belts and there's nothing they can do.

And if the level where you can claim benefits while working (working tax credit) remains the same while inflation skyrockets, then we'll see a lot of people tipping into poverty while being ineligible for state help.

This is it, thank you for putting it so beautifully. Its not a race and I'm poorer then you should now you should suffer as well. I don't want people to suffer at all.

OP posts:
Wavescrashingonthebeach · 19/10/2022 16:49

You have a mortgage and can afford to save, and have spare money for Christmas and birthdays.
I had £60 set aside towards my sons Christmas presents which i now have to spend on food and petrol. My freezer is completely empty and i dont get paid until the end of the month. Im sorry if i cant really sympathise tbh you are rich in my eyes.