Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be more help for middle class families

384 replies

RootinandTootin · 19/10/2022 15:40

This isn't a hate mongering post, those on lower incomes and can't work should be helped. My issue is that there seems to be little to no support at all for middle class families. Myself and partner work 5 days a week and have 2 kids. Not a terrible wage so I can't complain about that but the energy cost, food bills and fuel are going to cripple us soon enough. We also have Christmas to think about and a couple of birthdays inbetween. I just feel so unbelievably stressed out all the time about it. I'm praying this all calms down by the end of next year when our mortgage is coming up to renewal. There is pretty much no help being offered to us (unless anyone has some hints). I can't see it getting any better and its pretty depressing, alongside other personal issues going on at the moment I just want to cry.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dolor · 07/12/2022 05:03

Hahahahahahaha

realmsofglory · 06/12/2022 23:34

I think you mean middle income not middle class.

Dancingqueenwannabe · 20/10/2022 18:39

Meili04 · 20/10/2022 01:08

This is bullshit that somehow having middle/high income jobs means you worked harder than poorer people. I have more responsibility and paperwork now but the hardest job I ever did was working 12.5 hour shifts in a care home for min wage. Me and my OH earn well now but we worked harder when we were younger for much less pay.

When did I say that having middle/high income jobs means you work harder than poorer people?
What I'm saying is that I work hard and its all going out onto bills and that's bullshit.
People who work hard but earn less are being given support, which they should as times are hard, but when are things going to be levelled out for those of us in the middle?? We need help too, not in the forms of handouts but life prices reducing!

YouSirNeighMmmm · 20/10/2022 14:07

YABU "To think there should be more help for middle class families"

What we need is a government who understand that they have a simple choice - use taxation and government spending to reduce inequality, so that those at the bottom can get by OK, those in the middle can work hard and prosper, and those at the top can get rich... or... continue the "small state, trickle down (lie)" tory / neo-liberal / post-1980 approach of "screw everyone who is not incredibly rich".

I genuinely believe that the only people who the Tory part serves are people who -

Are so rich that they have incredible private health-care, and the cash to pay for any operation that they or anyone in their family might need if the health cover doesn't cover it.

Genuinely do not care about anyone else, or the state or the roads they have to drive on, or whether British businesses have access to a healthy well-educated workforce etc etc

Russian / Chinese state actors trying to harm the west

Extremists in the UK (both authoritarian socialists and fascists) who believe the best way of bringing down capitalist liberal democracy is to have it eat itself.

Untamedfemale · 20/10/2022 13:59

Op you are lucky to be able to afford birthday and Christmas my children don’t even have warm hats or gloves my 8yr olds birthday is on the 4th of November and I cannot afford any I just about have enough to feed is and pay bills

Discovereads · 20/10/2022 13:50

Taxistaxing · 20/10/2022 12:40

@Discovereads an observation on your previous conversation...FYI if you move for a job, you don't have to sell your house, plenty rent it out and rent in the new area, especially if your job is likely to move around, and again hindsight maybe a wonderful thing, but when you took out the equity release, was this on the advice of an independent financial advisor as usually they give advice to try and retain assets when you are younger ie move out into lower cost in the short term and rent out higher cost asset until financially back on track or negotiate interest only for a period with mortgage lender.

FYI if you move for a job, you don't have to sell your house, plenty rent it out and rent in the new area
During the years we were moved about, rents were actually cheaper than mortgages for similar sized & quality homes so no, renting out the house we left behind was not a realistic option as it would not even pay for itself. It would be a significant loss every month. Back then interest rates were higher-ranging between 5-7% on a mortgage. Trust me did the cost analysis on that!

when you took out the equity release, was this on the advice of an independent financial advisor as usually they give advice to try and retain assets when you are younger ie move out into lower cost in the short term and rent out higher cost asset until financially back on track or negotiate interest only for a period with mortgage lender

Yes it was. At the time I was using my sick and holiday leave (so still technically on full pay and employed but getting close to running out and having to go on unpaid leave- so imperative to do this before I had £0 pay slips) and there was hope I might recover and be able to keep my job & career. I was in intensive long term rehabilitation. We had just modified our home for disability access- so any suitable properties to move into would be hard to find. Moving would have also uprooted the children from school- two of whom had SEN- when they had just settled in. An interest only period would not have made enough of a difference to the monthly mortgage payment as we’d only been in that house for a year so were at the start of that mortgage term.

I want to make clear that I didn’t lose my house/foot on the property ladder due to the equity release. If the rehabilitation had been fully successful, I would have returned to work and got back on track financially. The equity release carried us through those 10mos while we had that hope. As it turned out, the rehabilitation was only partially successful and at the end of the 10mos, I was put in for disability retirement. Which then had its own (didn’t know about) 14 months wait time as they processed it and assessed my medical records before paying out while I was simultaneously recalled back to the U.K. & replaced (this was a foreign posting).

It was then that we sold up. There was no point keeping a house in a foreign country we couldn’t pay the mortgage on. And we thought my disability pension and insurance would not have such a ridiculously long processing and approval time. We thought 2-3 months tops and I’d have an income and we could maybe use the equity buy a small place, the DCs could share rooms. That was the plan.

But over a year later, by the time the disability pension and insurance started to pay out, it was too late. We had had to live off the equity because not eligible for benefits with such cash in the bank. I know equity destined to be rolled into another house is exempt from benefits calculation for a window of time, but we soon passed that window and DWP knew we weren’t eligible to buy a home. I was not working and had no income for over a year so I couldn’t get a mortgage in my name during then, and my DH is an immigrant who did not have ILR (settled status) which is required for him to be eligible for a U.K. mortgage on his income which was PT (and still is) as he is my carer. So DWP counted the money as cash in the bank…as was their right to do so.

It is what it is. Perfect storm and all that.

Taxistaxing · 20/10/2022 12:40

@Discovereads an observation on your previous conversation...FYI if you move for a job, you don't have to sell your house, plenty rent it out and rent in the new area, especially if your job is likely to move around, and again hindsight maybe a wonderful thing, but when you took out the equity release, was this on the advice of an independent financial advisor as usually they give advice to try and retain assets when you are younger ie move out into lower cost in the short term and rent out higher cost asset until financially back on track or negotiate interest only for a period with mortgage lender.

whatkatydid2013 · 20/10/2022 10:06

I think it’s frightening how quickly your disposable income can be entirely consumed.

I consider us middle earners ( ~66k now) and fairly sensible with money. At the start of the year 50% of our income covered what I consider non negotiable costs (Mortgage, c tax, utilities, insurance, food/household essentials shopping, childcare, fuel/car maintenance & internet/phones).

Come April if we had to renew mortgage as well as all the other rises it would take 70% of our income to pay those.

I’m not going to suggest we need state support but I’d imagine if you started with similar income but used 70% of your income to start with you’d be left with basically no disposable income

DomPom47 · 20/10/2022 09:40

Ohnoohdear · 20/10/2022 07:56

My brother back in Sweden pay £150 a month for full time nursery. Less if you’re a lower income family believe. They also pay higher taxes. I think this is key as repopulating the country and supporting those who do should be the whole nations responsibility. Who is going to keep the economy going I. The future if people can’t afford to have kids?

150 versus me in London paying over £800 and that is because I am lucky enough to have family who can do some early collection so I get part time days a few times a month. I wouldn’t mind paying a bit more taxes if nursery’s were subsidised and also with the same quality of care and same level of qualified staff as Finland or Sweden. Like you said kids are an investment in the workers of the future. Childcare and education will be a big biggie for me when it comes to the next general election and manifestos.

Bunnyfuller · 20/10/2022 09:34

I get you op. Middle incomes earn just that bit too much to get any help, but the costs and inflation etc (combined with effective pay cuts) mean you can often be worse off than those getting help across the board. We basically pay full whack for absolutely everything.

We have a small mortgage, average cars (one we barely use because of fuel prices). Have not had heating on yet and will not for the foreseeable. Full price on bus passes for the kids, full council tax, no help at all.

it would be good if there was a sliding scale of assistance, rather than the hard cutoff and being expected to manage as if you were high income.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 20/10/2022 09:07

Cantstandbullshit · 20/10/2022 03:39

The so called richer people already subsidize you and the middle and lower class.

researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-8513/CBP-8513.pdf

according to this report the top 10% earners in the UK contribute 60% if the income tax receipts already so they subsidize you.

rhe reasons companies cannot be over taxed is because they generate significant amount of income tax through hiring and payroll and it is better for companies to invest in the economy to continue to drive growth and generate jobs than pay it to the government to spend on free stuff so you can eat out more.

your lesson, when things gets better make sure you save for the next rainy day because it will surely come again.

And if you raise taxes, the rich will find somewhere else to pay (lower ) taxes. Property owners in the Isle of Man and The Channel Islands must be delighted.
If you don’t believe me, have a look at what happened in France when they raised the upper tax levels, and impose a capital tax.

toulet · 20/10/2022 08:47

Yes the tax bandings too are way behind

OhamIreally · 20/10/2022 08:30

The child benefit threshold of 60k has never been updated since its implementation in January 2013. Yet another fiscal drag policy.

I'm a single parent and it does irk that I have one tax allowance, don't get child benefit and couples on 98k with pooled tax allowances do.

toulet · 20/10/2022 08:13

Why? Do you not know that our currency is based on debt?

The logic that you shouldn't give middle income people help because they can get into debt more easily & keep the economy going. Particularly with interest rates heading up 😆

Ohnoohdear · 20/10/2022 07:59

DomPom47 · 19/10/2022 19:44

More affordable childcare would be fabulous and have such a huge impact on my life. Husband and I work and have two kids but so much goes to childcare. I realise it was our decision to have kids etc but when I think of Scandinavian countries and what they pay for childcare I feel envious.

Oops! Above was a reply to you DomPom47 :)

Ohnoohdear · 20/10/2022 07:56

My brother back in Sweden pay £150 a month for full time nursery. Less if you’re a lower income family believe. They also pay higher taxes. I think this is key as repopulating the country and supporting those who do should be the whole nations responsibility. Who is going to keep the economy going I. The future if people can’t afford to have kids?

Comedycook · 20/10/2022 07:48

Growing up in the 1980s, I went to private school. It was full of kids from "normal" families...by that I mean, not rich. Mum in a part time secretarial job and dad in middle management or a cabbie for example. Ok, they may have made sacrifices to send their child there but they still managed it. Those kind of people nowadays wouldn't even be able to contemplate sending their child to private school. Our lives are getting worse and worse. I don't mean that sending your child to state school is a terrible thing, just the fact that so much that was previously accessible to the middle classes is now unaffordable.

Wage stagnation is such a huge problem. I was looking at admin jobs yesterday online, they pay the same as they did twenty years ago when I was looking for work.

shortandpaleandoldandugly · 20/10/2022 07:47

We're racing so fast to the bottom here we're likely to hit our heads on the ground. Since when does wanting to buy birthday and Christmas presents for your kids mean you're doing ok? Maybe we should just give them an orange or something as we huddle round a candle for warmth?! This is 2022. Our country has been utterly buggered as many of us predicted by idiotic voters and stupid politicians and yes, OP, I totally agree. The hard working middle earners will get no protections and very limited support and are likely to carry much of the strain of it.

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 07:47

toulet · 20/10/2022 07:46

Why would you give middle class help when they can take out debt which we literally need to keep the economy going,

This makes no sense

Why? Do you not know that our currency is based on debt?

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 07:47

Everything comes to an end. www.investopedia.com/tech/bitcoin-or-altcoin-can-one-them-replace-fiat/

markets.businessinsider.com/news/currencies/crypto-to-replace-fiat-within-10-years-financial-execs-say-deloitte-2021-8

www.onenewspage.com/video/20220323/14559413/The-UK-is-leading-the-way-in-replacing.htm

"The UK is leading the way in replacing fiat currency with a digital social credit system." It will probably start with your carbon footprint and go from there, maybe factor in fiat debts, maybe mortgage, and go on to behaviour.

toulet · 20/10/2022 07:46

Why would you give middle class help when they can take out debt which we literally need to keep the economy going,

This makes no sense

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 07:44

HappyMeal564 · 20/10/2022 07:41

@mavismorpoth the argument is we are being pushed out of even being able to afford a food shop and heating. I am unable to take out any debt to pay for that, I don't have the money to pay it back. Targeted help will not be given to help the squeezed middle. This was previously fine as we could manage, but now many are struggling to feed the kids and heat homes

They're not not helping because they haven't realised you need it. They're not helping because for whatever reason they don't want to, and nothing will make them.

HappyMeal564 · 20/10/2022 07:41

@mavismorpoth the argument is we are being pushed out of even being able to afford a food shop and heating. I am unable to take out any debt to pay for that, I don't have the money to pay it back. Targeted help will not be given to help the squeezed middle. This was previously fine as we could manage, but now many are struggling to feed the kids and heat homes

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 07:35

Mrsmch123 · 20/10/2022 00:40

I get the funded hours at three years old. It's prior to this I think is unnecessary. The money should in my option be put towards working parents who have to fund the under threes to return to work to make their fees more affordable.

We got it for age 2 as well because I was on benefits and not working at all, so we were very lucky, and my child enjoyed nursery but she wouldn't have gone if not for the funding and while I would have done other things with her many parents in the same situation wouldn't so that's why they give it to you. It's always about the children.

Why would you give middle class help when they can take out debt which we literally need to keep the economy going, fiat/debt-based economy. On benefits you can't get much credit but if you're employed you always can.

mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 07:32

Catfordthefifth · 19/10/2022 17:24

It's ridiculous when many ft working parents can't afford a place either. It is the biggest reason we only have one child.

It's not ridiculous because the assumption is that the former group are pretty poor and the child may live somewhat in poverty and get little other enrichment, and this stereotype is often true. It wasn't true of us, but it is true of many people who would bring in the same money and be claiming benefits, which we were at the time.