Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask your experience of having a very bright child?

383 replies

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 14:03

We just had our first parents evening and DS's report was extremely good. (Understatement)
His reading and writing are excellent (never done any of this at home or prior to him starting school 6wks ago). Excellent Maths skills, very good at PE, excellent imagination and creativity, very confident and mature. The teacher said usually children are very academic OR very creative but he literally has it all and is working at the very top end for everything. He's been standing up and speaking in assembly and she has to ask him to put his hand down and let other children answer sometimes as she knows he will know the answer (absolutely fine with this). Also very mature and expressive language.

We don't focus on academics in our house, but more on values of being kind. She said he has a special friendship and bond with a little girl who needs additional help and checks she is ok and has her specialised equipment etc Also he is described as having beautiful manners and being genuinely liked by other children.

So.....After Parents evening other parents were chatting and sharing and I found myself feeling embarrassed and uncomfortable sharing DS's as I didn't want to look like I was bragging or make him (or me) look smug. I found myself really playing it down, and even making up areas that he could improve (DS not there). Is it inevitable that I can't be proud of him or that I'll always have to play his successes down? Am I overthinking? A couple of parents did comment he was very mature and not an "average 4yr old". I don't want him to feel different or feel bad for being intelligent. (Me and DH are average, degree educated but not by any stretch academic).

I know it sounds like a stealth boast but it's really not.

OP posts:
Cookiemonster2022 · 20/10/2022 12:09

There's increasing number of very average or below average parents who keep hoping or expecting their children turn out to be geniuses. This expectation is unrealistic and puts undue pressure on them. Wouldn't it be nice to just let children be children and let them enjoy their lives like some of our parents let us enjoy our childhood, cause at the end most people are just left with disappointments that their children didn't grow up to be the genius and prodigy they expected them to be.
Also, another point is to realise your own dreams and not push your own dreams onto your kids, seen many of my parents generation doing that as well as my friends caught up in the same cycle. Why not try to be that genius yourself which you expect your child to be.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 11:50

Tandora · 20/10/2022 11:22

OP your responses to @Bluebellandpansies were aggressive in the extreme and not at all called for. For example, you called her a “nasty person” (which btw is against talk guidelines) , and I don’t recall her calling you any names? I understand you are feeling sensitive, having been given a little bit of a hard time on here, but there is no excuse for lashing out at people . Your OP was somewhat insufferable/ classic PFB, and bluebell was making light. This is AIBU, take your lumps. I think you have learned your lesson. At the end of the day you can still feel happy and proud that your four year old had a lovely first school report, unlike (for example) the pp who was hurt by your post after having just had quite the opposite experience and facing a possible ASD diagnosis. At the end of the day there are ‘problems’ and problems.

I respectfully disagree. Her comment was extremely unkind and uncalled for. The post was nasty and I stand by that. I'm certainly not the only one who thought the same.

I wrote a nice reply to the other poster but I can't be held responsible for absolutely every feeling anyone has. That's totally unfair. There would be zero posts on here if that was the case.

Other people having more serious problems doesn't diminish my OP. I've got plenty of them myself.

As for "aggressive in the extreme" Honestly- have one of the many grips I've been handed 🤣

OP posts:
Plumbear2 · 20/10/2022 11:48

I've read through the OP again. Nothing suggests you have a very bright child. Lots of children are described in the same way as yours when they start reception. Kids who aren't as advanced now can over take yours by the time they start year 1. There are lots of different abilities in reception, it dosent mean yours will be a genius at 4 just because they are slightly more advanced at 4. One of my son's failed the phonics test, now in year 10 he is in all top sets and getting 7s and 8s in English. You really carnt tell what they will be like 6 weeks into reception.

RuthGalloway · 20/10/2022 11:41

I understand and made one of these threads once, and it went the same way.

My middle son is academically very able. He is 16 now. He was a very sensitive and nervy child. He suffered from tics and anxiety. He overcame much of that in Years 7-10, but also hid his intelligence in those years. He did not want to stand out. He loves rugby, XBOX, and house parties. He is arsey as hell and will argue with me about anything. He is a very good boy. I don't worry about him too much anymore.

He is in Year 12 now and hopefully making some kind of peace with what makes him unique. I don't think his intelligence has helped him have an easier life yet. He isn't lazy in that he can hold a Saturday job, but he is lazy with school work.

His older brother is smart but within the normal distribution of intelligence. He works hard and is thriving at an elite university. He was easier to raise than my son who is exceptionally gifted, embarrassed about it, and a bit lazy.

My advise is not to make a fuss about it. He'll find his way and you'll react as you go along.

LiveInSunshine · 20/10/2022 11:37

I’ve taught reception children who could read on entry, write mini stories of 3-4 sentences and were confident enough on a number square to operate in multiplying 2 digit numbers. Generally understood concepts well. The ones I knew and still know grew into pleasant well adjusted young adults with friends. Got into good universities etc.

I’ve also taught kids who struggled heavily in reception. Poor gross motor, verbal dyspraxia even and totally not ready to focus. Turned into extremely bright pleasant children who did very well.

I’ve also taught children who picked up phonics well in reception and had lovely speech, but went on to struggle a little with learning later on.

Two of my own 5 children have not been so extreme but have followed similar patterns. My eldest was that child in school who got it all, grew up and carried on generally doing well. My third was a summer born boy who was the reception delinquent child, no focus and like trying to teach a toddler. Turned into a bright pleasant boy and is excellent academically now he’s older.

I see it as a bit of a rollercoaster, it’s pretty unpredictable in reception. Enjoy your child, make them happy and relax.

GettingStuffed · 20/10/2022 11:28

Encourage them to progress, I skimmed school and it wasn't until my A level exams I realised that I needed to work at stuff, too late and it ruined my life

vitahelp · 20/10/2022 11:25

I've got one of those and call it a piano. My Mum has the same one and has played piano for 50 years, teaches and completed all grades. Her friend recently changed from acoustic to electric Yamaha and he is a professional pianist and teacher. I doubt either of them refer to their pianos as toys 😂

Tandora · 20/10/2022 11:22

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:12

I'm sorry but I can't make head nor tail of your last post. Probably wise to re-read stuff before clicking send 😉
I'm not sure replying to people is "last word he" whatever that means. You should have said if you just wanted to make your bitter little comment without anyone having the right to respond. I might be an overthinker but I'm not a pushover and will stand up for myself when needed.

OP your responses to @Bluebellandpansies were aggressive in the extreme and not at all called for. For example, you called her a “nasty person” (which btw is against talk guidelines) , and I don’t recall her calling you any names? I understand you are feeling sensitive, having been given a little bit of a hard time on here, but there is no excuse for lashing out at people . Your OP was somewhat insufferable/ classic PFB, and bluebell was making light. This is AIBU, take your lumps. I think you have learned your lesson. At the end of the day you can still feel happy and proud that your four year old had a lovely first school report, unlike (for example) the pp who was hurt by your post after having just had quite the opposite experience and facing a possible ASD diagnosis. At the end of the day there are ‘problems’ and problems.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 11:19

Seebee · 20/10/2022 10:56

Yep. She’s describing an attic. A loft is a loft, as mama says. An electronic keyboard, I’d also describe as a piano, in shorthand, if it’s set up to behave like one (on a frame, with a piano seat). HTH

Thank you, yes it has legs and a piano seat so "looks like" an upright piano, and according to Yamaha is a Digital Piano.

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 11:18

FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco · 20/10/2022 11:03

Is it a full size one, OP (ie. does it have 88 keys?)

It is, it's described as a "Yamaha Digital Piano" I bought digital so I could control the volume and wouldn't annoy our lovely neighbours as their son has ASD and is sensitive to noise.
Turns out I shouldn't have bothered as I'm seriously untalented!! 🤣🤣

OP posts:
FourForYouGlenCocoYouGoGlenCoco · 20/10/2022 11:03

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:45

It's not a toy. I bought it as an adult to learn on.
A keyboard I believe is completely different and has different functions.
This literally just plays music with no fancy stuff.

It is called a "piano" by the manufacturer, just calling it what it is. It wasn't my choice of description.

Understand you've strong feelings though if it's your career you're clearly passionate about it. You could have explained all that without first calling me a liar though, and then secondly being so scathing about the fact my piano isn't good enough to be called one?

Is it a full size one, OP (ie. does it have 88 keys?)

Seebee · 20/10/2022 10:56

Mamamia7962 · 20/10/2022 08:56

PurpleWisteria1 - Lots of houses in the UK have attics! Can't believe you don't know this. A loft is a roof space accessed by a loft hatch, whereas an attic is a room at the top of a house accessed by stairs.

Yep. She’s describing an attic. A loft is a loft, as mama says. An electronic keyboard, I’d also describe as a piano, in shorthand, if it’s set up to behave like one (on a frame, with a piano seat). HTH

EssexCat · 20/10/2022 10:48

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 19:19

I'm really not.

On this thread I've admitted:

I got the title wrong
I gave too much detail in the OP
I overthink
I have anxiety
I had PND and was a terrible mother for a full year

I've got lots and lots of faults but I'm not going to just sit and accept every single nasty thing that's being thrown at me. Like everyone else I do have some good points.

Oh bless you. Fair play to you. I think you’ve taken it really well.

I won’t repeat the advice but I think you’ve got it! The main thing is to never really say much, just smile and nod. Said as a mum of a now 18 year old….
I do just want to to pick up on the thing about having PND and being a terrible mother, that made me feel so sad for you as I really sympathise.

Puppers · 20/10/2022 10:09

6 weeks into reception there's no way to judge whether a child is going to be a high academic achiever. It's easy to quickly spot the children who are likely to struggle, and the rare ones who are prodigies, but really a 6 week snapshot of a 4 year old is not very revealing or helpful in predicting future accomplishments.

I was "gifted and talented" as a child. My very strong advice - if your child does turn out to be a high achiever at school - would be to not make your child's intellect or academic ability central to their identity. It's an enormous amount of pressure to be under. My family really ballsed it up, although I know it came from a good place. They were just proud of me, but being constantly told how clever you are and how good at everything you are does eventually give you the impression that this is where all your value lies. I was a very anxious child and inwardly terrified of not doing well at something, although my mum says she didn't realise I felt this way. I have made lots of bad choices in life because I didn't want to take risks. I only did things that I knew I would succeed at. Probably the biggest example being that I did a course at uni that just wasn't right for me at all, because I knew I'd fly through it. The course I should have done, which would have opened up doors to incredible things, felt too risky and the idea of not succeeding was just too frightening. I've had similar experiences in jobs.

As with the vast majority of gifted youth, I actually just turned out to be a very ordinary adult. On a par with other adults who've been fortunate enough to go through a good education system. But still those hang ups from my childhood are hard to shake off so I always feel not good enough. I haven't lived up to the expectations I felt people placed on me.

My daughter is a high achiever at school and is basically the same as I was. I am very careful with the way I handle this. I always, without fail, praise her for her effort NOT her output. Every single time. I try and encourage activities that I know she doesn't find easy, like sports, because it's important to me that she learns the goal is not always to be the best; it's to have fun and to learn something new. I make sure she knows that being good at writing or maths or spelling is not even close to being the most interesting or valuable thing about her by not making a big deal of it. I tell her every day that she is funny, that she is a good friend, that she's a brilliant sister etc.

Don't fall down the trap of making your child's achievements all about your pride in them. Easily done because of course we all love our kids and are proud of them.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:46

Oneofthosedreadfulparents · 20/10/2022 09:38

Firstly, you're allowed to feel proud of your son. Navigating other parents is a skill you'll pick up quickly, humble is a good look that will get you and your son a long way, but it sounds like you've picked that up already.

If he continues to progress more quickly than his peer group, you'll have a few challenges to think carefully about. His 'difference' will become apparent to his friends, probably around year 3 or 4, and if he's got good teachers who help him and his friends navigate that difference, that will help. Keep an eye out for changing friendships at this stage. Maybe think about exposing him to out of school activities that involve a different peer group than his school friends, so he's got other social circles.

Absolutely agree with the advice to help him find activities that he finds more challenging and needs to work at. Not yet, but towards the end of primary age, keep an eye out for activities he shies away from, and think about why that might be. Definitely encourage some physical activities, ideally some team sports if you can.

Not one to worry about yet, but take a deep breath when you get to teenage years - and this may well be earlier than you expect. If your son is a curious, questioning type, you may find your every request and decision challenged - not through defiance or naughtiness, but a genuine desire to understand exactly how their ever expanding world works. Be prepared for every parenting inconsistency to be thrown back at you, and don't be afraid to admit mistakes and talk about the important balance of heart vs head.

Find something that can join you all together as a family - board games, music, geo caching, paddle boarding - something that brings everyone together on a level - and turn to it when times are challenging for any of you (especially your other child!).

It can be a bumpy ride at times, but having a kid who makes you wonder every day is a massive privilege. If you can, find other parents in a similar situation - being able to talk honestly without that feeling as if you're bragging is so helpful. And enjoy it (quietly, of course!)

Great advice, thank you so much for such a detailed post, I appreciate it.

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:45

PurpleWisteria1 · 20/10/2022 09:35

Well I guess so. But it’s not a piano. It’s a keyboard.
My career is in playing the piano so it just winds me up I guess.
A piano has hammers and strings. It’s a stringed instrument, not a plug in electrical toy.

It's not a toy. I bought it as an adult to learn on.
A keyboard I believe is completely different and has different functions.
This literally just plays music with no fancy stuff.

It is called a "piano" by the manufacturer, just calling it what it is. It wasn't my choice of description.

Understand you've strong feelings though if it's your career you're clearly passionate about it. You could have explained all that without first calling me a liar though, and then secondly being so scathing about the fact my piano isn't good enough to be called one?

OP posts:
Bogofftosomewherehot · 20/10/2022 09:40

My DC got 12 x grade 9's at GCSE, 4 xA* at A level and now at a top Uni. Their talents were picked up in primary school (along with diagnosis for ADHD, ASD and anxiety).

If your child is truly G&T I would be less worried about how I say "Little Jimmy is doing just fine thank you" and be more worried about the pressure, fear of failure and what might drive them in the future to remain "top".

As for your question, just say "all good thank you". Truth is, others parents don't give a shit, they're just being nosey, Anything else will appear to be a stealth brag.

Oneofthosedreadfulparents · 20/10/2022 09:38

Firstly, you're allowed to feel proud of your son. Navigating other parents is a skill you'll pick up quickly, humble is a good look that will get you and your son a long way, but it sounds like you've picked that up already.

If he continues to progress more quickly than his peer group, you'll have a few challenges to think carefully about. His 'difference' will become apparent to his friends, probably around year 3 or 4, and if he's got good teachers who help him and his friends navigate that difference, that will help. Keep an eye out for changing friendships at this stage. Maybe think about exposing him to out of school activities that involve a different peer group than his school friends, so he's got other social circles.

Absolutely agree with the advice to help him find activities that he finds more challenging and needs to work at. Not yet, but towards the end of primary age, keep an eye out for activities he shies away from, and think about why that might be. Definitely encourage some physical activities, ideally some team sports if you can.

Not one to worry about yet, but take a deep breath when you get to teenage years - and this may well be earlier than you expect. If your son is a curious, questioning type, you may find your every request and decision challenged - not through defiance or naughtiness, but a genuine desire to understand exactly how their ever expanding world works. Be prepared for every parenting inconsistency to be thrown back at you, and don't be afraid to admit mistakes and talk about the important balance of heart vs head.

Find something that can join you all together as a family - board games, music, geo caching, paddle boarding - something that brings everyone together on a level - and turn to it when times are challenging for any of you (especially your other child!).

It can be a bumpy ride at times, but having a kid who makes you wonder every day is a massive privilege. If you can, find other parents in a similar situation - being able to talk honestly without that feeling as if you're bragging is so helpful. And enjoy it (quietly, of course!)

PurpleWisteria1 · 20/10/2022 09:35

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:08

It's an electrical piano 🎹
Can I ask genuinely why does it bother you? Surely it's a great invention for those who don't have the space/money for a traditional one?

Well I guess so. But it’s not a piano. It’s a keyboard.
My career is in playing the piano so it just winds me up I guess.
A piano has hammers and strings. It’s a stringed instrument, not a plug in electrical toy.

Plumbear2 · 20/10/2022 09:20

In my experience of 25 years in total going to parents evening for my kids, the teachers put a positive spin on everything Eg, always puts there hand I up really means they need to give others a chance. Always standing up and talking in assembly either means they need to give others a chance or he shouldn't be talking or standing in assembly. You need to decode what the teacher actually means.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:12

Bluebellandpansies · 20/10/2022 08:31

Last word, he ? I'll leave it to you. No doubt it was it was lost. Lol. Happy that you are having a laugh. Good day OP.😀

I'm sorry but I can't make head nor tail of your last post. Probably wise to re-read stuff before clicking send 😉
I'm not sure replying to people is "last word he" whatever that means. You should have said if you just wanted to make your bitter little comment without anyone having the right to respond. I might be an overthinker but I'm not a pushover and will stand up for myself when needed.

OP posts:
red4321 · 20/10/2022 09:08

On the advice of his reception teacher many moons ago, we’ve really worked on finding things he will find difficult so that he learns what it’s like not to be able to do something. In his case, swimming hasn’t come easily to him and it has been good for him to have to work at something and experience ‘failure’.

My son in this category definitely finds it hard if he encounters something he thinks he can't do as he's used to coasting through and finding it all easy. He's improved at not panicking and taking his time to work it out but he used to not bother and give up.

He's also very disorganised around school admin (although, again, not projects that interest him) and isn't as resilient emotionally as his brother.

My other son was slow to read but is organised and highly conscientious. He's ended up getting exam grades that his brother won't be able to beat (not something we talk about, other than my mother who keeps mentioning it!). He's also a lot easier to parent so definitely swings and roundabouts...

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 09:08

PurpleWisteria1 · 20/10/2022 08:44

It’s a loft. And no, that’s very much NOT a piano!

It's an electrical piano 🎹
Can I ask genuinely why does it bother you? Surely it's a great invention for those who don't have the space/money for a traditional one?

OP posts:
Thefoxsays · 20/10/2022 09:03

My DD was similarly bright in P1 - however I would say most of her peers have caught up now. I think she was just a bit more mature than some of her classmates & able to apply herself to learning which can be difficult for some children at a young age! She is still achieving what she needs to be but there is no massive difference between her & the other kids. Her teachers also comment on her kindness etc I think that's the part to be most proud of IMO - some children are definitely more empathetic but when they're 4 it really is about what you're showing and teaching them at home. So his academic prowess may or may not last, but you will always be proud of how kind he is. As an aside to this I was a bright child, I was 2 years ahead for literacy & moved up in primary school - I now have a low paid health care job & instead of going to uni I decided to travel.. so being bright doesn't equal success!

vivainsomnia · 20/10/2022 09:00

OP, your thread is totally justified because it shows exactly how unpleasant sine people become the moment you mention your child extra ability.

So you are right to approach it all with caution. Even though it was never an issue, I always felt a bit worried answering people's question about my child because it always that I couldn't give them the answer they were really after.

I remember one mum who I knew was very into her kids education, wanting them to be at the top, competitive etc..., asking how my DD had found a math test. I was frozen because my DD had just told me she'd found it very easy. If I was honest, I was bragging. If I lied and said she also found it difficult, I would have come as bragging to when they'd found she'd got too marks. So I just say I didn't know as she hadn't mentioned it. Even then it felt a bit like bragging but not as much.

So you do constantly have to think before answering and it's a bit annoying but once you get it right and people know that you really are not a bragger, it really is ok.

Swipe left for the next trending thread