Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask your experience of having a very bright child?

383 replies

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 14:03

We just had our first parents evening and DS's report was extremely good. (Understatement)
His reading and writing are excellent (never done any of this at home or prior to him starting school 6wks ago). Excellent Maths skills, very good at PE, excellent imagination and creativity, very confident and mature. The teacher said usually children are very academic OR very creative but he literally has it all and is working at the very top end for everything. He's been standing up and speaking in assembly and she has to ask him to put his hand down and let other children answer sometimes as she knows he will know the answer (absolutely fine with this). Also very mature and expressive language.

We don't focus on academics in our house, but more on values of being kind. She said he has a special friendship and bond with a little girl who needs additional help and checks she is ok and has her specialised equipment etc Also he is described as having beautiful manners and being genuinely liked by other children.

So.....After Parents evening other parents were chatting and sharing and I found myself feeling embarrassed and uncomfortable sharing DS's as I didn't want to look like I was bragging or make him (or me) look smug. I found myself really playing it down, and even making up areas that he could improve (DS not there). Is it inevitable that I can't be proud of him or that I'll always have to play his successes down? Am I overthinking? A couple of parents did comment he was very mature and not an "average 4yr old". I don't want him to feel different or feel bad for being intelligent. (Me and DH are average, degree educated but not by any stretch academic).

I know it sounds like a stealth boast but it's really not.

OP posts:
Chickpea17 · 19/10/2022 16:38

I'm not trying to be rude so please don't take it that way but he's four and only time will tell if he's truly intelligent.
At this age it's not a indication of what to expect ahead unless he's three or four years ahead of his peers.
When asked just say he seems happy and really enjoying it.

Sago1 · 19/10/2022 16:33

I had a parent actually come up to me at pick up and tell me she had been talking to the maths teacher and apparently our son was doing well!
Their son was top at everything!
Our son had come from the local state primary into a prep school so joined as a new boy.
I was furious and politely told her if I wanted a progress report I would get it myself!

A few weeks later at pick up I opened the boot of my car which was full of Fortnums bags (Gifts for my husbands staff) the same woman’s husband looked in the car asked me if I had had a nice time in London spending my husbands money!!!!

It was such a shame as in my sons year there were so many lovely families, they were the only competitive ones, they caused a lot of angst because they wanted to have the cleverest,sportiest most musical son.

Their wonderful son was expelled for bullying and unfortunately this far has not done very well in life.

StonwEd · 19/10/2022 16:29

Haven't rtft so apologies and I'm sure his has been said but I had one like that at your kids age, absolute genius.
He's just received perfectly good but very average gcse results.
Don't panic, yours will probably turn out to be average too and you won't have to worry about playing him down

Pumpkin20222 · 19/10/2022 16:28

WhataboutThewhataboutery · 19/10/2022 14:17

My dd was extremely advanced from the age of 6 months when she started taking and by 12 months was having very in depth conversations and knew a lot and how to count, alphabet etc I thought people were jealous when they looked horrified at this taking baby they were confronted with. One dr recoiled then came back with colleagues and they started very random conversations with her to test was she mimicking or was she holding and developing conversations and they were astounded .

at school she was on the gifted and talented register and very much ahead of her peers. She won a scholarship at 11 and was meant to start private school but she had a total breakdown and was then assessed for ASD. She has a very high IQ and is hugely intelligent but struggled in every other area of life. We had to home educate her and she got level 9s in all her gcses but her functioning in other areas of life is severely affected

This sounds so much like my niece. Amazing reading and alphabet skills, also early maths, which may have been memorising rather than methodology. Unfortunately, accompanied by a huge dose of anxiety and difficult social interactions. Very frustrating early education and schools did not clearly flag up the need for assessment. Where it sounds like hints were made, these were ignored. Best wishes for the future.

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 16:27

vitahelp · 19/10/2022 16:25

I was surprised when you said he was 4, I assumed this was about an older child especially the parts about checking in on another child and speaking in assembly.
But anyway, I don't think there is anything wrong with what you are doing (downplaying things). You are just protecting yourself from being labelled a show-off and also protecting other parents from feeling down about how their child is doing.
It reminds me of when wealthy people find themselves downplaying their money and pretending they don't have as much as they do so people don't judge them as a rich show off.

He's very much an old soul. My granny always says "He's been here before"
Thank you.

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 16:26

MarshaBradyo · 19/10/2022 16:22

I admit when I got to the end of this post I was surprised by the he's 4

He’s just started. I expected an older dc who you needed advice for

Just relax

Absolutely not in question I need to relax...Story of my life 😆 Don't disagree with you.

OP posts:
vitahelp · 19/10/2022 16:25

I was surprised when you said he was 4, I assumed this was about an older child especially the parts about checking in on another child and speaking in assembly.
But anyway, I don't think there is anything wrong with what you are doing (downplaying things). You are just protecting yourself from being labelled a show-off and also protecting other parents from feeling down about how their child is doing.
It reminds me of when wealthy people find themselves downplaying their money and pretending they don't have as much as they do so people don't judge them as a rich show off.

MarshaBradyo · 19/10/2022 16:22

I admit when I got to the end of this post I was surprised by the he's 4

He’s just started. I expected an older dc who you needed advice for

Just relax

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 16:18

popandchoc · 19/10/2022 16:12

If someone asked i'd say it's fine but just say he's doing really well. You don't need to go into details of how great he is. I also wouldn't bring it up unless someone does ask.

No I haven't, this was in direct response to being put on the spot and asked.

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 16:17

vivainsomnia · 19/10/2022 16:06

Oops! Special. Secondary school was just the same. teachers saying she was very able, excellent reports, but otherwise it was never really mentioned.

She never had issues making friends. She was of course known for her brains but it didn't define her at all. She mixed very well.

Her career is proving that she is indeed intellectually very superior, but again, no big deal made of it.

I always found that it was other parents who mentioned that she was very bright. In the end, if your child is kind and not bragging, other kids and parents won't show any resentment or anything and you'll get so used to it, you won't feel so inclined to discuss it with others.

Yes it definitely has been other parents mentioning it. I really haven't and am the opposite of "inclined to discuss it" I'd rather talk about anything else lol.
I will definitely make sure DS remains grounded. Sounds like your DD has managed that perfectly.

OP posts:
popandchoc · 19/10/2022 16:12

If someone asked i'd say it's fine but just say he's doing really well. You don't need to go into details of how great he is. I also wouldn't bring it up unless someone does ask.

ambermorning · 19/10/2022 16:11

Hi OP. I think it's lovely to be proud of your DS but I'm not sure why you need advice on how to speak about him to other parents??? Just say, "all fine thanks." Why is this even a thing?

Many children are pronounced "gifted" in reception for all manner of reasons. Very few remain gifted at 16. They all develop at different times and at different rates in different areas. Just relax and see how he goes. Be proud of him sure, but also be normal.

vivainsomnia · 19/10/2022 16:06

Oops! Special. Secondary school was just the same. teachers saying she was very able, excellent reports, but otherwise it was never really mentioned.

She never had issues making friends. She was of course known for her brains but it didn't define her at all. She mixed very well.

Her career is proving that she is indeed intellectually very superior, but again, no big deal made of it.

I always found that it was other parents who mentioned that she was very bright. In the end, if your child is kind and not bragging, other kids and parents won't show any resentment or anything and you'll get so used to it, you won't feel so inclined to discuss it with others.

vivainsomnia · 19/10/2022 16:02

I was informed that DD was probably gifted when she was 4. I didn't really paid attention to it. She then attended a school that never made a big deal of it. There were no official gifted and talented group but the school was very good at challenging the more able pupils.

It's when she got the pupil of the year award (115 children) that I thought that maybe shewa

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 16:01

Don't worry everyone. Six pages in and I get it.

No one is really interested, no one cares, other parents are either nosy/competitive or just being polite. Only ever acceptable to answer in any detail to blood relatives. DS is 4 and it's either possible/impossible to tell if he's bright anyway but if he is it'll probably all go to shit when he's older anyway and there'll be a queue of people ready to be gleeful about that if I dare mention anything positive about him in the next 10+yrs. (I'm obviously being a little sarcastic but genuinely I get the message 😁)

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 15:57

Chilesstanton · 19/10/2022 15:55

OP, other parents don’t care how well your kid is doing, how exceptional he is, etc. If asked out of courtesy, respond courteously (read: briefly) and move it along.

Yes thank you...message received loud and clear!

OP posts:
Chilesstanton · 19/10/2022 15:55

OP, other parents don’t care how well your kid is doing, how exceptional he is, etc. If asked out of courtesy, respond courteously (read: briefly) and move it along.

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 15:54

TheOrigRights · 19/10/2022 15:47

Yeah, I've never really been a "chatting to parents" person so I've clearly missed this 🙈 I work and am completing my Degree full time too so don't often have the opportunity which is a shame.

Didn't your son go to nursery? Mine both went to my campus nursery which was full of the children of highly educated academics. I think there was less competitive parenting there than I ever saw at the village state primary they went to.

He did, he attended Private Nursery 2 days a week but they still have Covid style drop offs and pick ups which aren't conducive to chatting unfortunately. (Very long socially distanced line).
Nursery was music focused "Montessori style" with a lot of Academic Parents (we live on an Industrial Estate round the corner in a terraced house just for clarity lol, furthest from posh and Academic you could possibly imagine)

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 19/10/2022 15:47

Yeah, I've never really been a "chatting to parents" person so I've clearly missed this 🙈 I work and am completing my Degree full time too so don't often have the opportunity which is a shame.

Didn't your son go to nursery? Mine both went to my campus nursery which was full of the children of highly educated academics. I think there was less competitive parenting there than I ever saw at the village state primary they went to.

Panapan · 19/10/2022 15:47

Sorry you’ve been laid into so much for this question. I have a yr 1 child like this and agree it’s best just to say that he’s doing fine, without comment (and then gush as much as you like to the grandparents, who are happy to listen!). One of the key dangers that I see with my child is that he is so used to getting things right that he reacts badly to making mistakes (eg he wants to cross out a whole page and start again if he spells something wrong). I’m therefore really trying to work on the growth mindset mentioned by a PP so that he sees mistakes as a learning opportunity not as a failure. We’ve also had discussions with him about not boasting (he doesn’t, but we wanted to pre-empt any sign of it) and the importance of making others feel good by noticing their strengths.

TheOrigRights · 19/10/2022 15:45

At 23 my older son does say that being labelled Gifted and Talented (do they have that now?) didn't do him any favours. He's not G&T, he was very able, but nothing exceptional. He was taken out of class with another girl and assigned different (extension) work. I certainly didn't put extra expectations on him or (hopefully) give him any notion he was superior to any of his peers.
In an ideal situation all children's needs would be met in the classroom. I think this might have been some government funded this of that time.

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 15:44

TheOrigRights · 19/10/2022 15:39

I've only read the OP's posts.

This stuck out "After Parents evening other parents were chatting and sharing".
This is unusual and most people have learnt by the time their child is about 2 that in fact everyone thinks their child is the best but only to share this with interested parties (your partner, grandparents, really close friends), unless specifically asked.

It sounds like your son is doing really, really well. You must be proud.
Both my sons are pretty bright and I generally just let them get on with it and support them as needed. I tell them to work hard and that if they do so they'll have more choices open to them.

Yeah, I've never really been a "chatting to parents" person so I've clearly missed this 🙈 I work and am completing my Degree full time too so don't often have the opportunity which is a shame.

I guess despite a select few being appalled at my OP, it served its purpose and I definitely am much more aware going forward.

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 19/10/2022 15:39

I've only read the OP's posts.

This stuck out "After Parents evening other parents were chatting and sharing".
This is unusual and most people have learnt by the time their child is about 2 that in fact everyone thinks their child is the best but only to share this with interested parties (your partner, grandparents, really close friends), unless specifically asked.

It sounds like your son is doing really, really well. You must be proud.
Both my sons are pretty bright and I generally just let them get on with it and support them as needed. I tell them to work hard and that if they do so they'll have more choices open to them.

Wiluli · 19/10/2022 15:38

You are lucky she enjoys school so much . My daughter 5 went to school reading as a year 3 and maths year 3 but she struggles as she find school boring . She is being assessed by potential plus U.K. . She loves science , has an elephant memory and a massive imagination and great storytelling skills . At the moment she is fascinated with black holes .
I knew she was advanced and out reading as she started reading well aged 3 and without any help but I did not realise how advanced .

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 15:33

FinallyHere · 19/10/2022 15:18

Agree there is no need to lie.

There is always that fall back 'there were notes'

Other people really only care about their own DC so won't press you if you are a little mysterious. They may even assume the 'notes' were not wholly good. 😀

Enjoy.

"There were notes" Love it!! I'll remember that one!

OP posts: