Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask your experience of having a very bright child?

383 replies

MaryShelley1818 · 19/10/2022 14:03

We just had our first parents evening and DS's report was extremely good. (Understatement)
His reading and writing are excellent (never done any of this at home or prior to him starting school 6wks ago). Excellent Maths skills, very good at PE, excellent imagination and creativity, very confident and mature. The teacher said usually children are very academic OR very creative but he literally has it all and is working at the very top end for everything. He's been standing up and speaking in assembly and she has to ask him to put his hand down and let other children answer sometimes as she knows he will know the answer (absolutely fine with this). Also very mature and expressive language.

We don't focus on academics in our house, but more on values of being kind. She said he has a special friendship and bond with a little girl who needs additional help and checks she is ok and has her specialised equipment etc Also he is described as having beautiful manners and being genuinely liked by other children.

So.....After Parents evening other parents were chatting and sharing and I found myself feeling embarrassed and uncomfortable sharing DS's as I didn't want to look like I was bragging or make him (or me) look smug. I found myself really playing it down, and even making up areas that he could improve (DS not there). Is it inevitable that I can't be proud of him or that I'll always have to play his successes down? Am I overthinking? A couple of parents did comment he was very mature and not an "average 4yr old". I don't want him to feel different or feel bad for being intelligent. (Me and DH are average, degree educated but not by any stretch academic).

I know it sounds like a stealth boast but it's really not.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tiani4 · 23/10/2022 09:49

@MaryShelley1818
I agree @Oneofthosedreadfulparents wrote a really helpful detailed post. Hopefully PPs are RTFT and moving on from your original perhaps unintended clumsy title and original post as you've taken on board PPs comments already

So let's talk helpful stuff. In the spirit of what @Oneofthosedreadfulparents said

A couple other examples of how you can involve and build on DS's good start

Maths skills are really easy to help develop generally in life. Even at young ages, and as they grew up, I would involve my DCs in "what do you think is best value.., let's find mummy a bargain" when in the supermarket. It started with counting number of yoghurts in a pack for same price and what size, to actually looking at cost per gram... and deals...

All my DCs especially mathematical DS, got very good at working out value per gram and quality v quantity etc All maths skills. I gave them money and asked them to count out change ... and showed them receipts. By 9 my son was working out the 15% discount I'd get from NUS card and all my DCs do same for 10% discount I get from Blue light card...

When something broke in the house I'd say to my DCs let's look up instructions online- I'll read it (or they would once reading well)- can we see the pictures.. (you tube is so helpful)

I got books from library not just fiction ones. Evp I raged outside interests and developing outside school friendship too based on mutual interests. When learning is fun and seems to have a practical use - it becomes

There are good points Oneofthose made about you'll have more challenging teenagers (!!) if you encourage them to think for themselves, as learning context too is important, but you will end up with young adults who can logically think through new situations and apply their learning with confidence. And learn to negotiate.

Greengagesnfennel · 22/10/2022 20:37

Sorry op it is the british way. You need to play it down. Tbh at 4yo it's all a bit meaningless anyway.

Dogroses · 22/10/2022 01:32

I have a very bright DSS. Always top of the class, doing advanced work. Thinks he is a smarter than Everyone, including his parents. He doesn't like to try, is very entitled and will give up on everything if it isn't easy and immediate. Our biggest hope for him is that as he gets older he becomes more kind and empathetic. So we've downplayed academic achievements and emphasized social/emotional ones. I think he had the impression he was spectacular from quite a young age. His sister was more kind, creative and fun but never thought she was special.

I think what I'm saying is that you need to think of the whole child. At age 5 it was exciting that he was so clever. At 11 we thought who cares about maths, I wish he would stop bullying his siblings!

SandyY2K · 22/10/2022 01:23

@1Angelicfruitcake

I know my own children are often placed with children who need help with their behaviour which drives me mad because using my children shouldn’t be the go to!

I agree with you.

I’ve got to say OP that there are many here delighting in being a bit nasty or mocking. Some because, no matter the effort put in, their children struggle and so I can understand their response to this thread (still not right though). I can also guarantee they’ll be parents reading this who don’t put in any effort compared to you with their Children but are ready to have a go. Those types are just nasty!

I agree on this too. Some really nasty comments.

scarletisjustred · 22/10/2022 00:34

It is really important to praise effort and work because at the point when really bright children have to really work it can come as a huge shock. My eldest after an excellent school career - junior teachers said the same sort of things about academic skills - barely barely scraped through his final high school exams. In fact the sibling who had a teacher's aide in primary school and worked like a dog did better in those exams as he had really worked and had hours of extra tutoring. The oldest is now halfway through med school but it took a lot of effort to get there but they learnt a lesson. I still remember how they looked when they got those results - absolutely whiefaced because they knew the exams hadn't gone well but the marks were even worse than expected.

Overshadowed · 21/10/2022 23:16

I have one of these, hes 9. He honestly gets about 5 maths questions wrong a year, his writing was at year 5 standard in year 2 according to the senco. I just reply with a simple “good “. If he continues to be very bright other parents will find out from their child most likely. My ds helps others a lot in class it seems. He gets upset he is only allowed to answer a couple of questions a day whilst others answer more but again the teachers have said they know he will get the answer correct.
He has found school so far very easy but his behaviour is still impeccable. He struggles very much if he can’t get a physical task mastered quickly, such as he can’t tie his own shoelaces. Well he can but it’s only perfect 20% of the time at the moment so he refuses and would rather wear other shoes. His emotional health has been a worry the last few years, he takes it all in and doesn’t vocalise his feelings even though he’s capable of doing so. He takes a lot on and is a confidant of many friends and worries about them.
We have not discussed with him how bright he is but he knows from comparison and the work he is given.
I worry more about this DS than my other who has less friends and is academically’above’ or achieving.

Basically what I’m saying is whilst it’s lovely and nice to be proud, it isn’t always such a gift

LizzTruss · 21/10/2022 23:06

I was a very bright and able child and managed to land my dream job. However I found I wasn't very good at it so had to leave soon afterwards. So be careful what you wish for.

Anothermother3 · 21/10/2022 22:57

My first DC was definitely one of the ‘brightest’ academically at the start of school partly because of being petrified of being in trouble and very anxious. Hated the noise and busyness and me and the reception teacher were equally pleased one day when DC stepped out of line a bit without panicking. Yes DC is still bright academically a few years on but I wish they were happier at school. I wish findings friends and managing groups was easier. I wish having their one good friend leaving hadn’t left them completely lost socially. The school is not hugely resourced for differentiating (is any state school) it’s one form entry. Out of school music lessons (after a solid 6 months of showing interest) have been great and also led to less challenging social opportunities. Doesn’t sound like your DC has these difficulties so let him enjoy doing well and look at his interests and something he will enjoy outside of school if needed. Reading well is great as it means that getting through the mind numbing books is a faster process which reinforces the interest. I’d probably not post on aibu but one of the education forums of you want further constructive feedback on sustaining interest if that is needed. I wish they were okay based for another year or 2.

Tandora · 21/10/2022 20:33

Anon778833 · 20/10/2022 14:47

At the end of the day you can still feel happy and proud that your four year old had a lovely first school report, unlike (for example) the pp who was hurt by your post after having just had quite the opposite experience and facing a possible ASD diagnosis.

Some gifted children also have ASCs 🙄 stop stereotyping people on the spectrum.

Hey, Ofc gifted people can have ASC. No stereotyping at all in my post as I made no generalisations. I was merely referencing the particular experience of a pp.

Golaz · 21/10/2022 17:56

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Myrighteyeball · 20/10/2022 21:12

Hi OP, this post won't answer your original question but gives a few other suggestions FWIW. Your little one sounds a lot like my older child, concerning whom we received similar reports all the way through primary school. She is now 14, and doing very well academically and socially - but she now suffers from extreme perfectionism with all the issues that entails. So in case it helps: 1. As a pp has said, focus on effort and process as your son gets older "I saw how closely you focused on doing that assignment, I'm proud of you for working hard". "An A is a good result. What do you think helped you to get there?". 2. Choose one area eg maths and then repeatedly extend the child until they fail, then encourage persistence and resilience, and 'learning how to learn'. Really bright kids are often scared of failure when they get older as they don't experience it enough as children. 3. Ask everyone at dinner every night "What did you fail at today?" followed by "And what is one thing you learned from that?" and treat failure as a really good thing to be celebrated, not as something to be ashamed of. Giving your clever child a growth mindset will be one of the greatest things you can do. 4. If you can, work on your own worries about others' judgement. I'm also overly sensitive to that and have passed it onto my child, doing her a huge disservice. I'm not intending to have a pop at you at all, just sharing the things I wish I'd done better for my bright child.

carben · 20/10/2022 16:35

Forgot to say she was also an end of August birthday and born prematurely to boot.

carben · 20/10/2022 16:34

dizzydizzydizzy · 19/10/2022 14:29

DD was not that special in primary school, especially not in KS1. However, she was the youngest in the class. However, it became apparent when she was about 11 that she is super intelligent. She got 4xAstar in her A Levels. She did STEM subjects but equally could have done, art, history, English etc. She is now in a top Uni.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is that you just never know when they are very young. I was at primary with a girl who was so far ahead, that she used to read the story to the rest of the class. She went to grammar school with me but did not do particularly well.

I could have written your post - I think we're in a parallel universe😀. My DD used to regularly pee herself in KS1 because she would not ask to go to the toilet. Was virtually selectively mute which was pretty much an unknown condition at the time. Investigated for various special needs. Nothing particularly showed up. Came into her own from Yr 10 (still not chatty though!). Ended up with 8x9 and 2x8 (CAG's) and then 4xA* in maths, FM, comp sci and physics from a bog standard comp and managed to get a place at Oxford (started this Oct). You just never know how things are going to pan out.

tinx · 20/10/2022 15:16

My DS was told that in year 9 he was coaster and not as bright as the peers in his class (yes she actually said this) by an English teacher during parents evening !!

lol he received all grade 9’s and 8’s in his GCSE’s so good for him he worked his butt off

The teacher who branded him a coaster really wanted him to take her subject at a level because in the end he was one of the most respectful and kind students who took their education very seriously and never disrespected the teachers or messed around in class

lesson: don’t listen too much to what some teachers say go by what your child is actually able to do 👍

Anon778833 · 20/10/2022 14:49

Op, there is no point defending your position since everyone backs up their own kids/experiences.

I agree. On MN everyone is in a rush to tell people that all kids ‘level out’. Clearly, that isn’t true. If it were, all kids would get the same GCSE results.

Anon778833 · 20/10/2022 14:47

At the end of the day you can still feel happy and proud that your four year old had a lovely first school report, unlike (for example) the pp who was hurt by your post after having just had quite the opposite experience and facing a possible ASD diagnosis.

Some gifted children also have ASCs 🙄 stop stereotyping people on the spectrum.

Seebee · 20/10/2022 13:54

Op, there is no point defending your position since everyone backs up their own kids/experiences. Fwiw, as I said earlier, I had and have an incredibly bright (scholarships to the top 3 indie schools) son. I saw his brightness from the age of about 2. It was clear by reception. That said, he was not an all rounder at that age. He was exceptionally good at maths. Reading came later, writing very much later eg y5-6. But he was articulate and asked extremely intelligent qus (shockingly mature) from a very young age (age 4 type). So I knew he had potential. Also used to get picked for speaking roles haha, though he wasn’t much of a performer until much later!!

Tandora · 20/10/2022 13:08

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 11:50

I respectfully disagree. Her comment was extremely unkind and uncalled for. The post was nasty and I stand by that. I'm certainly not the only one who thought the same.

I wrote a nice reply to the other poster but I can't be held responsible for absolutely every feeling anyone has. That's totally unfair. There would be zero posts on here if that was the case.

Other people having more serious problems doesn't diminish my OP. I've got plenty of them myself.

As for "aggressive in the extreme" Honestly- have one of the many grips I've been handed 🤣

Sure thing- We’ll agree to disagree that it’s acceptable to call another poster a “nasty person” based on a short post that contained no personal insults of its own.

To clarify- I didn’t mean to suggest you were responsible for every feeling that everyone has, only that your OP was tone deaf and naive/ misguided, for reasons many others have already pointed out.

Plumbear2 · 20/10/2022 12:51

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 12:37

He was asked to stand up in assembly - he was given a speaking role. He would never just randomly stand up.

Tbf there's loads of information I haven't included in fear of more ridicule 🤣

I've had enough advice though to keep me on the right path, I understand your point 🙂

But that's not unusual. My 4 year olds where given speaking roles. My 4 year olds also cared for pupils with special needs as did most of the other 4 year olds in their classes. I've had 25 years of parent evenings. They always describe the positive, always say they are extremely bright. Like I said don't read to much into it because I can guarantee the teacher said the same to many other parents.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 12:37

Plumbear2 · 20/10/2022 12:25

To be fair the teacher will have said extremely bright to at least three quarters of her class. Teachers always speak positively but have hidden meanings Eg, they always put their hand up means they should give others a chance, or they always stand up in assembly means the shouldn't be doing that. My child was always described as extremely bright all the way through school even when he failed his phonics test ( but made up for that in later years). Even if you did tell the school parents how your parents evening I can guarantee the teachers said the exact same thing to them about their child, especially as we are talking about reception children. I'm saying don't read to much into it.

He was asked to stand up in assembly - he was given a speaking role. He would never just randomly stand up.

Tbf there's loads of information I haven't included in fear of more ridicule 🤣

I've had enough advice though to keep me on the right path, I understand your point 🙂

OP posts:
Plumbear2 · 20/10/2022 12:25

To be fair the teacher will have said extremely bright to at least three quarters of her class. Teachers always speak positively but have hidden meanings Eg, they always put their hand up means they should give others a chance, or they always stand up in assembly means the shouldn't be doing that. My child was always described as extremely bright all the way through school even when he failed his phonics test ( but made up for that in later years). Even if you did tell the school parents how your parents evening I can guarantee the teachers said the exact same thing to them about their child, especially as we are talking about reception children. I'm saying don't read to much into it.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 12:20

Cookiemonster2022 · 20/10/2022 12:15

It's not aimed at you. I just responded generally, you are taking it personally btw. There are hundreds of responses here, not everything is aimed at anyone specifically. I don't understand why you constantly feel the need to talk about your personal circumstances.

Errmmm because it's my thread? I've responded to people who've gave advice/criticism, and answered questions. Surely that's the point lol

Anyway glad to know it wasn't aimed at me. That makes more sense now 😊

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 12:17

Plumbear2 · 20/10/2022 11:48

I've read through the OP again. Nothing suggests you have a very bright child. Lots of children are described in the same way as yours when they start reception. Kids who aren't as advanced now can over take yours by the time they start year 1. There are lots of different abilities in reception, it dosent mean yours will be a genius at 4 just because they are slightly more advanced at 4. One of my son's failed the phonics test, now in year 10 he is in all top sets and getting 7s and 8s in English. You really carnt tell what they will be like 6 weeks into reception.

Why do people keep saying "genius" I've said (repeatedly) the complete opposite.
It was the teacher who said he was extremely bright so tbf I'll take her opinion over yours as you've never met him 😊

OP posts:
Cookiemonster2022 · 20/10/2022 12:15

It's not aimed at you. I just responded generally, you are taking it personally btw. There are hundreds of responses here, not everything is aimed at anyone specifically. I don't understand why you constantly feel the need to talk about your personal circumstances.

MaryShelley1818 · 20/10/2022 12:13

Cookiemonster2022 · 20/10/2022 12:09

There's increasing number of very average or below average parents who keep hoping or expecting their children turn out to be geniuses. This expectation is unrealistic and puts undue pressure on them. Wouldn't it be nice to just let children be children and let them enjoy their lives like some of our parents let us enjoy our childhood, cause at the end most people are just left with disappointments that their children didn't grow up to be the genius and prodigy they expected them to be.
Also, another point is to realise your own dreams and not push your own dreams onto your kids, seen many of my parents generation doing that as well as my friends caught up in the same cycle. Why not try to be that genius yourself which you expect your child to be.

I'm not sure who your post is aimed at but none of it is relevant to me.
Don't think/want/expect/believe him to be a genius and have repeatedly said this.
Also I left school with a handful of average GCSEs and now have (almost) 2 degrees studied for while working full time and with 2 very young children. I think I'm doing ok 👍🏻

OP posts: