Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the optician messed up my prescription

59 replies

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 00:24

I have been mildly short sighted for years, but its been fairly consistent.
2017 R -4.25 L -4.50
2019 R -4.50 L -4.50

For my last eye test, I seemed to have undergone substantial improvement, which -seems unlikely in my 50s.
R -2.75 L -3.50

I phoned optician more than once to query this . I was intending to buy specs elsewhere (I get contacts from this optician but can get better deal on specs somewhere else) and wanted to be sure. Plus I know perfectly well that my eye sight hasnt improved.

Opticians were hostile on the phone, adamant that prescription was correct and that I just didnt understand the notation.
And to be fair..I am not an optician. But I have bought lots of specs and contact lenses over the years so have a vague idea.
I did keep asking them to compare with my previous prescriptions on their system and tell me if they thought it was a likely change but they just wouldnt engage. They just kept repeating, "Its correct" like a mantra.

So I order the specs using the prescription.. Specs arrive and the distance vision is duly worse than old specs. Its not just a period of adapting. It is noticeably worse, which would tie in with the weaker prescription.

Not sure what to do now. I am going to pay for another eye test with a different optician, and am willing to bet it will come out something like the 2017/2019 ones.

I appreciate there will be a margin of error in prescriptions, but life long gently deteriotating short sightedness doesnt just get substantially better does it? Or does it?
New specs have pretty shit vision, I cant use them and they cost a few hundred quid, and my old specs have decent vision but only one leg!

Other point of note is that the person doing the test was a probationer or something (not the term they used but it was something like that)

Has anybody had asimilair issue (large high street chain)

OP posts:
isladeltesoro · 19/10/2022 01:07

I would make an appointment at the same optician, go back with your old and new glasses, and say there is a problem with the new ones. Don't mention the prescription again, just say your vision is a lot worse with the new glasses.

They should have you put them on, look at the screen and then try adding back/taking away lenses to improve the vision. Don't waste money on another eye test until you've given them the chance to sort it!

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:05

Was this your reading rx ? Or distance ?

Former dispensing optician here .

TheVillageShop · 19/10/2022 00:59

"Alas as well as long term slightly short sighted, I am also getting gently long sighted!"

That happens. The only answer really is to go for varifocals, but I would have thought the optician would have recommended them. I couldn't live without mine - I can see far and near and in-between, but I can still read in bed without any glasses.

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 00:56

PickAnyName · 19/10/2022 00:50

If you are short-sighted, your vision does tend to “improve” as you get older, in that as your “normally sighted” friends are having to hold things at arm’s length you won’t need to… but if your distance vision is wrong that’s no help at all. I would suggest either going back, or visiting another branch of the same chain, to say your are not satisfied with the prescription and would like it checked by a senior optometrist. Any correction should be free. They should be able to change the arms on your glasses if one is missing.

Alas as well as long term slightly short sighted, I am also getting gently long sighted!
Unfortunately a corrected prescription doesnt replace my useless new specs which is my main bugbear.

OP posts:
TheVillageShop · 19/10/2022 00:55

Short sight often does improve with age (as we become naturally more near-sighted) but if you don't feel they are right they should certainly offer a free re-test, and new glasses with the new prescription if it is found to differ from the first eye test. I've had that happen and got a refund for the first 'wrong' specs. You should at least have been given a two week trial with your new glasses but it is complicated if you ordered the specs from a different place that did they eye test - I'm unclear if you did that.

My short sight has improved over the years now I'm older (now mid-sixties), so that aspect of it does ring true. But several times I've felt my new glasses aren't as good as my old scratched worn ones, so I do sympathise.

MooseBeTimeForSnow · 19/10/2022 00:54

Once you’ve got your second opinion I’d be asking for a full refund from the original, both for the exam and the glasses. I’d even go so far as the small claims court.

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 00:52

Yes I am going to try that once I am armed with a second prescription from a different optician. Could also complain to NHS who presumably pay them to do tests.

Its annoying to have bought useless specs but even more annoying that its happened after I tried to query it in advance and they absolutely wouldnt countenance an error. Or compare to previous tests that THEY did.

OP posts:
PickAnyName · 19/10/2022 00:50

If you are short-sighted, your vision does tend to “improve” as you get older, in that as your “normally sighted” friends are having to hold things at arm’s length you won’t need to… but if your distance vision is wrong that’s no help at all. I would suggest either going back, or visiting another branch of the same chain, to say your are not satisfied with the prescription and would like it checked by a senior optometrist. Any correction should be free. They should be able to change the arms on your glasses if one is missing.

KitchenSupper · 19/10/2022 00:41

I had this happen years ago although it was only half a diopter in one eye. I ordered contacts from them and they were obviously wrong as soon as I put them in. Had a new test and new lenses asap for free. It was a small independent optician.

If it’s a chain, can you contact somewhere central?