Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the optician messed up my prescription

59 replies

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 00:24

I have been mildly short sighted for years, but its been fairly consistent.
2017 R -4.25 L -4.50
2019 R -4.50 L -4.50

For my last eye test, I seemed to have undergone substantial improvement, which -seems unlikely in my 50s.
R -2.75 L -3.50

I phoned optician more than once to query this . I was intending to buy specs elsewhere (I get contacts from this optician but can get better deal on specs somewhere else) and wanted to be sure. Plus I know perfectly well that my eye sight hasnt improved.

Opticians were hostile on the phone, adamant that prescription was correct and that I just didnt understand the notation.
And to be fair..I am not an optician. But I have bought lots of specs and contact lenses over the years so have a vague idea.
I did keep asking them to compare with my previous prescriptions on their system and tell me if they thought it was a likely change but they just wouldnt engage. They just kept repeating, "Its correct" like a mantra.

So I order the specs using the prescription.. Specs arrive and the distance vision is duly worse than old specs. Its not just a period of adapting. It is noticeably worse, which would tie in with the weaker prescription.

Not sure what to do now. I am going to pay for another eye test with a different optician, and am willing to bet it will come out something like the 2017/2019 ones.

I appreciate there will be a margin of error in prescriptions, but life long gently deteriotating short sightedness doesnt just get substantially better does it? Or does it?
New specs have pretty shit vision, I cant use them and they cost a few hundred quid, and my old specs have decent vision but only one leg!

Other point of note is that the person doing the test was a probationer or something (not the term they used but it was something like that)

Has anybody had asimilair issue (large high street chain)

OP posts:
BananaCocktails · 19/10/2022 03:45

i wouldn’t say -4.25 is mild short sightedness that’s moderate
I worked in opticians for years
did you have to use the scanner which gives an idea of your prescription before the optician sees u as that would correctly analyse your prescription?

it’s very rare for short sightedness to correct that many diopters even with onset longsightedness and the longsightednesses wouldn’t correct it to that degree
I would put in a complaint to the practice manager and head office if need be
I was -1.75 4 years ago +0.00 now at 43 I’m -3.25 both eyes +1.00

SirenSays · 19/10/2022 03:31

Specsavers got my sisters prescription so wrong we thought she'd been given someone else's by mistake.

ShakespearesSisters · 19/10/2022 03:27

Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 01:37

Just so you're aware if you take your prescription elsewhere to the original prescriber the opticians you go to are judged to have accepted the prescription and are responsible for any rechecks.
This was brought in to save customers having to go back and forth between different prescribing and dispensing opticians so the optician who made up the glasses (as they got the money for them) are now the ones you need to see. However from the sound of your post it looks like you got them online so you need to ask the online provider for the way forward as you they should remake them free of charge and reimburse you for any recheck. Basically once you take your prescription elsewhere you are now in the hands of the dispensing company to fix the problems (unless there is a gross error such as putting a reading prescription as your distance one).
The likelihood is you've probably become less shortsighted, but not perhaps as much as the jump the optometrist gave you (and hopefully it's not a transcription error altogether ).
The probation probably means pre-registration optometrist- so essentially they are still under supervision whilst doing their final year of professional examinations after university. These optometrists tend to be very thorough, but lack experience so may not consider that you're unlikely to get on with such a big change in prescription all in one go.
Rechecks are not at all unusual in opticians so just ask to speak to the dispensing optician at the opticians you purchased your glasses from if it's a physical practice and they will book you in with their optometrist for another test which will be free and if it's online ask their procedure for this.

Yep, @Headunderthecovers has it. When you take a prescription elsewhere, it is the responsibility of where you purchase your glasses to make things right.
We have to sort it if someone brings us a prescription from elsewhere and struggles with vision when made correctly to said prescription. It is meant to make it easier for the patients and probably evens out between opticians. Having purchased from a dispensing only online retailer complicates it but they must have a procedure for this eventuality.
On a different note, my rx changed from -4.50 to -3.50 about 6 years ago. But I could see fine with my new prescription so a big change is not uncommon. It has crept back up again now though.

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 02:11

You pays your money you takes your chance !

Online can't be accurate because they can't measure pupil distance and getting that wrong can cause prism which pulls the eye - personally having worked for over 10 years in the industry I wouldn't recommend because it does tend to be good luck rather than good management.

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 02:02

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:51

Then the problem could be balance or pupil distance or something else entirely . Online retailers can't measure your accurate pupil distance to
Centre the lens . Disaster waiting. I'd never recommend to anyone unless
You have the simplest of rx .

Have to say my husband who is grossly short sighted and long sighted, galloping astimatism, just shocking eyesight. Honestly, if i put his glasses on it would feelnlije my brain imploding! He gets his varifocals online. Loves them. Has totally ditched contact lenses as these specs suit him so well.
And I have had no problem till now. They just arent sharp.

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:53

Take the glasses to an reputable optician who
Can check the actual prescription in the specs is what the actual prescription is .
Online retailers are - scuse me but - shite .

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:51

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:47

"My DP uses the cheap online glasses retailers and has no issue"

I have always used an on online glasses retailer and this is my first ever problem.
My husband does too and he has the the most diabolical eyesight. He never has a prob either with online glasses.

Then the problem could be balance or pupil distance or something else entirely . Online retailers can't measure your accurate pupil distance to
Centre the lens . Disaster waiting. I'd never recommend to anyone unless
You have the simplest of rx .

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:47

"My DP uses the cheap online glasses retailers and has no issue"

I have always used an on online glasses retailer and this is my first ever problem.
My husband does too and he has the the most diabolical eyesight. He never has a prob either with online glasses.

OP posts:
PissedOffNeighbour22 · 19/10/2022 01:43

A few years ago I had a test at boots then had the prescription made by specsavers because at that point my job gave vouchers towards the cost of glasses needed for screen use but only via specsavers.

Went to collect them and couldn't understand why they were so difficult to see in. Turns out the prescription apparently was for the opposite of what I'd been told I needed, therefore I had to pay the full £200 for the glasses as they weren't classed as for screen use. Specsavers were of no help so I've still never worn the bloody glasses.

The next year I had my eyes tested somewhere else and was told I don't need glasses (every test before and since said I have a slight astigmatism that doesn't need correcting, but otherwise great vision). I'll never use boots opticians again and would be very wary of taking a prescription somewhere else.

My DP uses the cheap online glasses retailers and has no issues.

MadelineUsher · 19/10/2022 01:41

You were unreasonable to order specs elsewhere using their prescription that you disputed. Waste of money.

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:38

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:21

Op it looks like you're looking at you're reading rx not you're distance rx ?

2019

SPH R -4 50 L -4.50
Near add 2.0 both eyes

Current
SPH R -2.75 L -3.25
Near add 2.0 both eyes

OP posts:
Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 01:37

Just so you're aware if you take your prescription elsewhere to the original prescriber the opticians you go to are judged to have accepted the prescription and are responsible for any rechecks.
This was brought in to save customers having to go back and forth between different prescribing and dispensing opticians so the optician who made up the glasses (as they got the money for them) are now the ones you need to see. However from the sound of your post it looks like you got them online so you need to ask the online provider for the way forward as you they should remake them free of charge and reimburse you for any recheck. Basically once you take your prescription elsewhere you are now in the hands of the dispensing company to fix the problems (unless there is a gross error such as putting a reading prescription as your distance one).
The likelihood is you've probably become less shortsighted, but not perhaps as much as the jump the optometrist gave you (and hopefully it's not a transcription error altogether ).
The probation probably means pre-registration optometrist- so essentially they are still under supervision whilst doing their final year of professional examinations after university. These optometrists tend to be very thorough, but lack experience so may not consider that you're unlikely to get on with such a big change in prescription all in one go.
Rechecks are not at all unusual in opticians so just ask to speak to the dispensing optician at the opticians you purchased your glasses from if it's a physical practice and they will book you in with their optometrist for another test which will be free and if it's online ask their procedure for this.

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:32

My guess is he's using readers for distance !

Go back and get clarification on which is which .

doittwice · 19/10/2022 01:32

I used to be -2.75 left and 2.5 right and now since last year I am -1.75 on both eyes. At first it felt odd with the new glasses, it took me a couple of days to train but now there's no way in hell I can wear my old glasses. I'm mid 30s btw.

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:28

Short answer is if you can't see we'll go
Back !

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:26

JestersTear · 19/10/2022 01:23

This happened to my DH, who put his new specs to one side and went back to his old ones after a couple of days. I queried this and it turned out that he couldn't see properly with his new readers or everyday glasses. I insisted he took them back as we're not rich and they're a shop like any other at the end of the day.
Turned out that it had been a newly qualified optician who had done his test and she'd put pluses where there should have been minuses or something (didn't really understand what DH was telling me) anyway, they compared his old lenses while he waited and he had his new ones all sorted again within a week.

Actuallly there are two ways to
Write prescriptions - either + cyl or minus cyl

It's maths . It's technical. But you can just convert the cyl either way - it's more likely the dispensing optician got it wrong there . I worked with both + and - cyl so could convert the rx to either . It's actually quite simple but too complicated to explain here !

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:23

God my Maths ! I meant if your a -1.50 with a +2.00 you'd be a +0.50 for reading

Doh !

I think you're looking at you're reading prescription op not your distance ? You need to query

JestersTear · 19/10/2022 01:23

This happened to my DH, who put his new specs to one side and went back to his old ones after a couple of days. I queried this and it turned out that he couldn't see properly with his new readers or everyday glasses. I insisted he took them back as we're not rich and they're a shop like any other at the end of the day.
Turned out that it had been a newly qualified optician who had done his test and she'd put pluses where there should have been minuses or something (didn't really understand what DH was telling me) anyway, they compared his old lenses while he waited and he had his new ones all sorted again within a week.

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:21

Op it looks like you're looking at you're reading rx not you're distance rx ?

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:20

It's maths .

You could be a -1.50 distance but a +1.50 reading which means no reading g specs required. They cancel each other out .

But as we age the reading add gets higher .

This means if we have a minus rx of say -1.50 our reading add may end up +2.00 - means the actual reading rx is -0.50 - so you can't just take specs off to read .

It's just maths . I was a dispensing optician for 10 years before my current job .

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:17

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:05

Was this your reading rx ? Or distance ?

Former dispensing optician here .

Thats my distance. (Reading is 1.5)

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:16

As a short sighted person reading g without specs is very common.

But the higher the prescription the harder that gets .

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:13

TheVillageShop · 19/10/2022 00:59

"Alas as well as long term slightly short sighted, I am also getting gently long sighted!"

That happens. The only answer really is to go for varifocals, but I would have thought the optician would have recommended them. I couldn't live without mine - I can see far and near and in-between, but I can still read in bed without any glasses.

I am only 1.5 for long sight. I dont even notice it, wouldnt even occur to me to use reading glasses. The only time i cant read is with my distance specs on, so i just pop thrm onto my forehead to read.

I have varifocal contacts as you cant just pop a contact out of the way to read! They are Ok, dont do either job perfectly, so a bit of a compromise.

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:09

I'm a similar rx to
You op .

But presbyopia is a thing - so our reading rx gets worse - that means if you're a minus rx the reaading g is less - I'm now 50 and in varifocals .

My distance remains similar to yours but my reading add changes the reading rx to a lesser minus .

Presbyopia happens to us all . It's an age thing . They eye is the only muscle in the body that hardens with age making it more difficult to focus at close range

You need to query the rx and find out what the distance rx is compared to the reading rx .

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:08

TheVillageShop · 19/10/2022 00:55

Short sight often does improve with age (as we become naturally more near-sighted) but if you don't feel they are right they should certainly offer a free re-test, and new glasses with the new prescription if it is found to differ from the first eye test. I've had that happen and got a refund for the first 'wrong' specs. You should at least have been given a two week trial with your new glasses but it is complicated if you ordered the specs from a different place that did they eye test - I'm unclear if you did that.

My short sight has improved over the years now I'm older (now mid-sixties), so that aspect of it does ring true. But several times I've felt my new glasses aren't as good as my old scratched worn ones, so I do sympathise.

I just cant believe that mine has improved though.
Its just very slowly got worse over the decades, -0.25 at a time! To improve from -4.50 to -2.75 in what was slightly under 2 years seems so unlikely.
Plus I cant see veru well in the weaker glasses.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread