Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the optician messed up my prescription

59 replies

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 00:24

I have been mildly short sighted for years, but its been fairly consistent.
2017 R -4.25 L -4.50
2019 R -4.50 L -4.50

For my last eye test, I seemed to have undergone substantial improvement, which -seems unlikely in my 50s.
R -2.75 L -3.50

I phoned optician more than once to query this . I was intending to buy specs elsewhere (I get contacts from this optician but can get better deal on specs somewhere else) and wanted to be sure. Plus I know perfectly well that my eye sight hasnt improved.

Opticians were hostile on the phone, adamant that prescription was correct and that I just didnt understand the notation.
And to be fair..I am not an optician. But I have bought lots of specs and contact lenses over the years so have a vague idea.
I did keep asking them to compare with my previous prescriptions on their system and tell me if they thought it was a likely change but they just wouldnt engage. They just kept repeating, "Its correct" like a mantra.

So I order the specs using the prescription.. Specs arrive and the distance vision is duly worse than old specs. Its not just a period of adapting. It is noticeably worse, which would tie in with the weaker prescription.

Not sure what to do now. I am going to pay for another eye test with a different optician, and am willing to bet it will come out something like the 2017/2019 ones.

I appreciate there will be a margin of error in prescriptions, but life long gently deteriotating short sightedness doesnt just get substantially better does it? Or does it?
New specs have pretty shit vision, I cant use them and they cost a few hundred quid, and my old specs have decent vision but only one leg!

Other point of note is that the person doing the test was a probationer or something (not the term they used but it was something like that)

Has anybody had asimilair issue (large high street chain)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Quveas · 20/10/2022 18:30

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 01:08

I just cant believe that mine has improved though.
Its just very slowly got worse over the decades, -0.25 at a time! To improve from -4.50 to -2.75 in what was slightly under 2 years seems so unlikely.
Plus I cant see veru well in the weaker glasses.

You may be right. Only another eye test will say. But I'm afraid that my eyesight did exactly this in my 50's.

underneaththeash · 20/10/2022 18:20

Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 23:14

@undertheleash It says that the prescribing optometrist is not responsible for the cost of the remake yet you said they are liable?

The guidance changes traditional thinking on some aspects of handling non-tolerance and states that when a practice accepts a ‘walk-in’ prescription then they should also accept responsibility for financing and managing any non-tolerance issues.

However in the original poster's case I would re contact the prescriber- namely the supervisor of the pre-reg optometrist via the head office customer services. If the pre-reg optometrist has made a mistake it is something they can learn from. The poster could request a senior optometrist does a recheck which wouldn't incur a charge at the same practice. Usually in most remakes/rechecks there's a couple of factors including glasses not always been made up correctly; hence the advice for the maker of the glasses to do the recheck (which is where it gets complicated with an online provider).

Ugh - it doesn't say that at all. It's for low changes in RX where you can't tell whose at fault. Like any medical conversation, you need to consider why?What could have happened in order for someone's prescription to be 1.5D less than before:

  1. The OA could have written in down wrong, which is a possibility given the add - in which case the prescribing practice are culpable or 2 could have been a 4.
  2. There is a pathology causing the add - macula oedema? But that should have been picked up.
  3. Is it likely that the OP had something temporary happen to her cornea/macula which made her 1.5D less myopic? I cannot think of anything. Unless they're a GP wearer and wearing reverse geometry lenses.
MinnieGirl · 20/10/2022 14:17

MadelineUsher · 20/10/2022 13:57

Did you only read the thread title?! She bought the glasses online from a separate business, and she raised her concerns with the original opticians.

No need for rudeness

Blondeshavemorefun · 20/10/2022 14:14

Your eyesight is practically the same as mine

there is no way mine would suddenly be as low as yours

something is def wrong

esp as the glasses you have in new , you can’t see properly out of them

MadelineUsher · 20/10/2022 13:57

MinnieGirl · 20/10/2022 08:38

Just go back to the store you bought the glasses from and say they are not right.
Get them to test your eyes with the glasses. All high street stores do this….
I had problems with my last set of varifocals, had to swop twice and it didn’t cost me anything. You can also point out that you thought the prescription was strange…

Did you only read the thread title?! She bought the glasses online from a separate business, and she raised her concerns with the original opticians.

MinnieGirl · 20/10/2022 08:38

Just go back to the store you bought the glasses from and say they are not right.
Get them to test your eyes with the glasses. All high street stores do this….
I had problems with my last set of varifocals, had to swop twice and it didn’t cost me anything. You can also point out that you thought the prescription was strange…

Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 23:42

The reason the spectacle maker is responsible is an in person dispenser would normally query a large change in prescription on your behalf with the prescriber before accepting the prescription. Online providers just make up whatever is given to them.

The difficulty in the prescriber being responsible for rechecks means all errors are just put down to the prescription-when often they are in the manufacture or measurements of glasses or a combination of the two.
It means the prescriber has to spend time checking the glasses for errors of lens and measurements without knowing what you have been given and factor these in to the problems.
When you consider the relative cost of an eye test to glasses cost you can see why the responsibility falls onto the dispenser. Otherwise eye tests become increasingly expensive- they are effectively subsidised by the cost of glasses in the UK. If glasses are cheaper such as USA then eye tests cost more. If everyone buys online then NHS sight tests will probably go the way of NHS dentistry as eye test fees become non cost effective for companies.

The large multiple companies normally have large customer care centres and want you to be happy with their service, so I would say with such a large change in prescription they would happily retest you- then it's up to your online supplier as to how the glasses are remade.

Hope that helps - it's a long winded explanation Smile

Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 23:14

@undertheleash It says that the prescribing optometrist is not responsible for the cost of the remake yet you said they are liable?

The guidance changes traditional thinking on some aspects of handling non-tolerance and states that when a practice accepts a ‘walk-in’ prescription then they should also accept responsibility for financing and managing any non-tolerance issues.

However in the original poster's case I would re contact the prescriber- namely the supervisor of the pre-reg optometrist via the head office customer services. If the pre-reg optometrist has made a mistake it is something they can learn from. The poster could request a senior optometrist does a recheck which wouldn't incur a charge at the same practice. Usually in most remakes/rechecks there's a couple of factors including glasses not always been made up correctly; hence the advice for the maker of the glasses to do the recheck (which is where it gets complicated with an online provider).

underneaththeash · 19/10/2022 21:54

Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 19:04

@underneaththeash It changed several years ago. AOP.

I don’t think you’ve read that link properly! It backs up what I posted previously.

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 19/10/2022 20:04

Is it Specsavers? My latest appointment gave me an 'improved' prescription which I do not for one second believe so I've ignored it and stuck with my old glasses. I also don't rate their customer service in general.

makingmiracles · 19/10/2022 19:16

Funny you should say this, I bought new glasses after 6yrs with one pair, when I started a new job may 2020, also went to specsavers after going previously with eye tech , they have never felt right- I thought I was just because I’d been so long with the old pair it was a case of getting used to them, but I’m convinced they messed up the prescription as I’m struggling to see things that should be crystal clear at a distance. Overall the glasss have been poor quality (£250+) cath kidson frames, which snapped at the arm a few months ago, they gave me replacement frame but after a short amount of time paint have chipped off under the lense right in my line of vision which highly irritates me as I can see it.

I’ve been called for another test but tbh I won’t be going back to specsavers- the pair I’d had for 6 yrs were far superior, these lenses have scratched so badly already- I don’t even know how as they are permanently on my face except when asleep.

Headunderthecovers · 19/10/2022 19:04

@underneaththeash It changed several years ago. AOP.

JestersTear · 19/10/2022 18:57

stillvicarinatutu · 19/10/2022 01:26

Actuallly there are two ways to
Write prescriptions - either + cyl or minus cyl

It's maths . It's technical. But you can just convert the cyl either way - it's more likely the dispensing optician got it wrong there . I worked with both + and - cyl so could convert the rx to either . It's actually quite simple but too complicated to explain here !

My brain now hurts 😂

Novum · 19/10/2022 10:03

My eyesight improved as I got older and long-sightedness started counteracting the short sight, but I agree it's also highly unlikely to have improved as quickly as these opticians claim. They really should have been prepared at least to double-check rather than obstinately insisting they were right.

I had an issue once where my sight just didn't seem as good with a new pair of glasses but the opticians insisted the prescription was right. Ultimately I gave up on it and just got used to the new prescriptions, but went to someone different for my next check. He said I needed quite a substantial change and, sure enough, the glasses I had after that were way better. The second optician did say my eyes were complicated, though.

TheOriginalEmu · 19/10/2022 09:49

-4.50 is not mildly short sighted just fyi.

i wouldn’t have bought new glasses if I wasn’t convinced the prescription was correct. Go elsewhere and get a retest and ask them to put the new lenses in your new glasses. Sorted.

Tinfoilandbrick · 19/10/2022 09:43

Similar experience for my teenage son recently at Specsavers. After waiting over 2 weeks, the frames had wrong prescription lenses in. Took the glasses back 2 days later and got a full refund then went to an independent optition who was able to put lens into the new frame on site .We walked out with a new pair 40 minutes after consultation. As an added bonus the lens didn't need thinning like they always did at Specsavers so I saved £50!

whatisheupto · 19/10/2022 09:13

isladeltesoro · 19/10/2022 01:07

I would make an appointment at the same optician, go back with your old and new glasses, and say there is a problem with the new ones. Don't mention the prescription again, just say your vision is a lot worse with the new glasses.

They should have you put them on, look at the screen and then try adding back/taking away lenses to improve the vision. Don't waste money on another eye test until you've given them the chance to sort it!

I agree with this.

Don't go in with new prescription from other opticians.

Just go in now with new glasses, play dumb and just say they don't seem quite right and could they check it out.

Dodie66 · 19/10/2022 09:08

Rather than getting completely new specs just get the lenses replaced. My optician changes just the lenses if I need a change in prescription. That will save you some money

underneaththeash · 19/10/2022 08:47

@Headunderthecovers that's not the case at all (I'm an optometrist). If the prescription is wrong it's wrong and the prescribing optometrist is liable, both under the Consumer Act and the College guidelines.

OP it's incredibly unlikely that your vision improved that significantly, unless there is something wrong with your actual eye (again unlikely as you can see better through your old glasses).

Speak to the practice manager in the original place, explain what's happened and ask for someone else to re-test you. Remember to take the new glasses with you for them to check.

FivePotatoesHigh · 19/10/2022 08:21

Absolutely baffled as to why you used the prescription if you thought it was wrong. You can’t really expect them to pay for that.

You should ask for a retest though.

Do your online glasses have any kind of cooling off period? I get my glasses from Vision Express and always have the option for a full refund if not happy.

Aprilx · 19/10/2022 07:37

I always thought short sightedness did improve with age and yes possibly within two years. But if you can’t see with your new glasses then obviously it is wrong. But to be honest, if I didn’t believe the prescription I wouldn’t have ordered glasses using it.

Bucksfar86 · 19/10/2022 07:10

Unfortunately If you didn't believe the prescription was correct, you shouldn't have gone elsewhere and
spent so much money 'wasting a few hundred quid'.

You already doubted the original test so should have gone elsewhere for another test or asked for a more senior optometrist to test you again, before purchasing anything.

I understand your frustration in thinking the prescription they gave you was wrong, but to go and buy new glasses whilst having a feeling that they're not going to be correct was a chance you decided to take. I doubt they will replace the money for them as they never provided them, whereas if you'd have bought the glasses from that opticians and they were wrong then they would have replaced them or refunded the money for the glasses.
Also I'm sure they'll have a clause somewhere that states they're not liable for glasses that they don’t provide even if they give the prescription.

Mol1628 · 19/10/2022 05:51

Specsavers messed my glasses up recently. They made a typo in the axis for my astigmatism so it was way off. They didn’t believe me at first when I said I couldn’t see out of my new glasses.

They did put it right though. Eventually.

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 03:54

BananaCocktails · 19/10/2022 03:45

i wouldn’t say -4.25 is mild short sightedness that’s moderate
I worked in opticians for years
did you have to use the scanner which gives an idea of your prescription before the optician sees u as that would correctly analyse your prescription?

it’s very rare for short sightedness to correct that many diopters even with onset longsightedness and the longsightednesses wouldn’t correct it to that degree
I would put in a complaint to the practice manager and head office if need be
I was -1.75 4 years ago +0.00 now at 43 I’m -3.25 both eyes +1.00

I honestly dont know what gadgets they used, i was wheeched between a few.
They did my previous tests though so they will be on file. I did ask them to compare as i thought the change was a bit drastic. But they wouldnt.

The fact that the distance prescription changed so much between prescriptions whilst the "Near Add" didnt change at all makes me think its an error.

OP posts:
montysma1 · 19/10/2022 03:45

"When you take a prescription elsewhere, it is the responsibility of where you purchase your glasses to make things right.
We have to sort it if someone brings us a prescription from elsewhere and struggles with vision"

Interesting , it really seems wrong that the specs maker would be responsible for a precription error by somebody else, if thats what this turns out to be.

OP posts: