Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
Blanketpolicy · 14/11/2022 12:49

I personally dislike double-barrelled names. Just pick a name, it's really not that hard and I think not fair on the child to be stuck with a ridiculous name because its parents can't sort themselves out.

ds got our married family name so it was straight forward.

If we hadn't decided to get married before he was born he would have had my surname. If we had got married after he was born I would have kept my name to be aligned with ds and dh would have been fine with that (these sorts of things don't bother him either way)

gogohmm · 14/11/2022 12:42

Tradition I suppose. We did marry now split after 20 years

Same1977 · 14/11/2022 12:40

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/11/2022 09:08

I've lost the train of thought of normal people because I've pointed out that your husband's name is his father's as much as yours was your father's? More like I've touched a nerve.

I completely understand not wanting to associate with an abuser but don't understand why so many women only claim this on marriage. Presumably if it's that much of a trigger they would want to distance themselves as soon as they are legally able to and not wait until they get married. Just odd.

It's also telling that men too have terrible childhoods and awful relationships with their fathers and yet don't rush to change their name on marriage.......funny how it's just women.

I am not responsible about abused men's actions and only can explain mine.
Would it please you if i said well my husband wanted our child to have his name and I wanted my child to have mine.We tossed a coin and he won.
In my 20s I liked to think I was so darn oppressed by patriarchal traditions.In my 30s I appreciate a man who fixes my car, supports me without asking to be the one who stays at home with our daughter etc.Yes it's a traditional set up and it makes me happy.
It's a 2 way street.I hope you fight just as hard to go back to work straight after birth just like men do after their child is born ,to pay for everything equally etc.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 12:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 12:34

Just to add, I’ve REPEATEDLY answered that the reason I don’t care about my name is that I have a family made up of multiple names, I also was presented multiple times with the opportunity to change my own name to match other family members and declined. I don’t know why you think this is motivated by misogyny.

Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 12:30

@Tsort

It does seem like you’ve determined that everyone who doesn’t hold the same value as you is suffering from internalised misogyny, and that makes it hard to take you seriously. I answered all your questions, we just value different things. Of course no one in our society is untouched by patriarchy, but not every decision a woman makes is ruled by it. I’d encourage you to open your mind to the possibility that names
are just names to some people. I looked at my decision, asked myself honestly if I thought internalised misogyny played a part, and came back with the answer that it did not.

If my son wants my name when he grows up, he can have it, but it wouldn’t change our connection a single bit. Imagining my son with my name invokes no feeling in me other than “his current name sounds better”.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 12:25

Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 12:12

Why do you think this is? If not internalised misogyny, what is the alternative reason?

Genuine question- do you think that internalised misogyny is the only reason someone wouldn’t care about it? As I detailed below, I don’t find it important because I already don’t share the same last name as 90% of my family. It’s simply not something I value. I don’t think I’d value it if I were male, either.

That’s fine, but your DC could have had your name and your ex could have been the odd one out. Why did you settle upon the specific, patrilineal naming convention?

Why do you think women talk about not being attached to their last names and see them in the context of broader families (I’m estranged from my father/I wasn’t raised by my father/I don’t feel the need to carry on my father’s name), while men’s last names are theirs? How often do you hear of a man taking his wife’s last name because he is estranged from his father?

Odd that you latched onto my father there. I don’t think my name is HIS name, it’s my name. I only listed him because he (and my sister, who you skipped right over) also has that name. I haven’t changed my name, and nor would I.

And yes my ex COULD have been “the odd one out” (also a weird term, me and my son aren’t odd to each other because we don’t share the same name- as I said, names in my family vary greatly so he is NOT in
fact odd for not sharing the name of his mum) but like I said, HE cared about it. And yes I dug into that constantly with him, he was never able to produce a good reason why he cared other than “I just do” and he admitted that it probably was because of the patriarchal society we live in but he just felt strongly about it. HIS motivation here was definitely based in sexism, mine was just not having the same value as most people do.

Surely it would make more sense for DC to bear the name of the parent who birthed and looked after him than the parent who apparently did not? But he doesn’t.

Women are free to make any decisions the want around naming conventions, but it’s a bit bizarre to deny the motivations behind a lot of those decisions and the fact that they are made in a heavily patriarchal context and influenced by reflexive misogyny

Why? Like I’m genuinely befuddled why you think a name makes a family. Do you not have in-laws or other family members with different surnames? Are they not family? Do people cease to be family if they get married into another family name?

I’ll throw my hands up and admit I’m the weird one, but I literally do not think that sharing a name is important in a family. And as to my motivation why I don’t think that, as I said, I don’t share the same name as most of my family and it has never once been an issue or made me feel less like family.

Genuine question- do you think that internalised misogyny is the only reason someone wouldn’t care about it?

Lots of women don’t care about it, the vast majority of men do care about it. Why do you think that is? Seriously, think it through.

You've engaged with nothing I’ve said and answered nothing I’ve asked. You come close, touch the surface and then skid off. It’s interesting. There’s no point to this exchange if you won’t (or can’t) respond to what’s being said, and circular conversations are dull. So, I’ll leave you with this. Again.

Women are free to make any decisions the want around naming conventions, but it’s a bit bizarre to deny the motivations behind a lot of those decisions and the fact that they are made in a heavily patriarchal context and influenced by reflexive misogyny.

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 12:12

Why do you think this is? If not internalised misogyny, what is the alternative reason?

Genuine question- do you think that internalised misogyny is the only reason someone wouldn’t care about it? As I detailed below, I don’t find it important because I already don’t share the same last name as 90% of my family. It’s simply not something I value. I don’t think I’d value it if I were male, either.

That’s fine, but your DC could have had your name and your ex could have been the odd one out. Why did you settle upon the specific, patrilineal naming convention?

Why do you think women talk about not being attached to their last names and see them in the context of broader families (I’m estranged from my father/I wasn’t raised by my father/I don’t feel the need to carry on my father’s name), while men’s last names are theirs? How often do you hear of a man taking his wife’s last name because he is estranged from his father?

Odd that you latched onto my father there. I don’t think my name is HIS name, it’s my name. I only listed him because he (and my sister, who you skipped right over) also has that name. I haven’t changed my name, and nor would I.

And yes my ex COULD have been “the odd one out” (also a weird term, me and my son aren’t odd to each other because we don’t share the same name- as I said, names in my family vary greatly so he is NOT in
fact odd for not sharing the name of his mum) but like I said, HE cared about it. And yes I dug into that constantly with him, he was never able to produce a good reason why he cared other than “I just do” and he admitted that it probably was because of the patriarchal society we live in but he just felt strongly about it. HIS motivation here was definitely based in sexism, mine was just not having the same value as most people do.

Surely it would make more sense for DC to bear the name of the parent who birthed and looked after him than the parent who apparently did not? But he doesn’t.

Women are free to make any decisions the want around naming conventions, but it’s a bit bizarre to deny the motivations behind a lot of those decisions and the fact that they are made in a heavily patriarchal context and influenced by reflexive misogyny

Why? Like I’m genuinely befuddled why you think a name makes a family. Do you not have in-laws or other family members with different surnames? Are they not family? Do people cease to be family if they get married into another family name?

I’ll throw my hands up and admit I’m the weird one, but I literally do not think that sharing a name is important in a family. And as to my motivation why I don’t think that, as I said, I don’t share the same name as most of my family and it has never once been an issue or made me feel less like family.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 11:58

Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 11:43

🤨 It’s perfectly possible to not care about having the same name as your children and NOT be a quivering victim of internalised misogyny, and it’s condescending to pretend otherwise. It’s simply not important to me (and I detailed why above).

Quivering isn’t a requirement, but we can examine the reasons you detailed.

Because my ex cared about it and I didn’t.

Why do you think this is? If not internalised misogyny, what is the alternative reason?

I have a big, blended family and due to marriage, remarriage and other things, I only share my surname with my estranged father and one of my sisters, therefore I’m not a person who thinks you have to have the same last name to be family.

That’s fine, but your DC could have had your name and your ex could have been the odd one out. Why did you settle upon the specific, patrilineal naming convention?

Why do you think women talk about not being attached to their last names and see them in the context of broader families (I’m estranged from my father/I wasn’t raised by my father/I don’t feel the need to carry on my father’s name), while men’s last names are theirs? How often do you hear of a man taking his wife’s last name because he is estranged from his father?

I made him, I birthed him, I look after him, he could be called anything and that wouldn’t make me any less his mother. If he wants to change his name to mine when he’s older, or to anything different, I’ll help him.

Surely it would make more sense for DC to bear the name of the parent who birthed and looked after him than the parent who apparently did not? But he doesn’t.

Women are free to make any decisions the want around naming conventions, but it’s a bit bizarre to deny the motivations behind a lot of those decisions and the fact that they are made in a heavily patriarchal context and influenced by reflexive misogyny.

OP posts:
Darkstar4855 · 14/11/2022 11:44

Because I liked the sound of my partner’s surname more than mine and I didn’t want to burden my son with an unnecessarily long surname by double barrelling.

My partner was happy for him to have my surname though.

Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 11:43

🤨 It’s perfectly possible to not care about having the same name as your children and NOT be a quivering victim of internalised misogyny, and it’s condescending to pretend otherwise. It’s simply not important to me (and I detailed why above).

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 14/11/2022 11:41

TiaraBoo · 19/10/2022 00:03

I think I was just brain washed into thinking it’s the thing to do. I wouldn’t do the same thing now.

This is the truth of it for the vast majority. There's always the bollocks about ooh his surname is nicer but honestly people do it because it's considered the norm and they don't stop to think why. Why are surnames patrilineal and why do so many women go along with it and happily support it.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 11:40

youcantry · 14/11/2022 11:35

Because we knew we were going to marry. We are now divorced but I'm still keeping his name as I want to have the same name as my children

I’m asking women who kept their names. If you didn’t and never intended to, this post isn’t relevant to you.

OP posts:
PurpleNebula84 · 14/11/2022 11:35

Because I thought we were going to end up married and all that jazz - we didn't. I now deeply regret it as I'm now a single parent and it pains me that I don't have the same surname as my little girl. If I could do it all over again, she would have mine and if things had been different and we had got married, we could have gone through the process of re-registering the birth following the marriage so we all had the same surname. There won't be a next time with anyone, but if there was, lesson absolutely learnt!

youcantry · 14/11/2022 11:35

Because we knew we were going to marry. We are now divorced but I'm still keeping his name as I want to have the same name as my children

Tsort · 14/11/2022 11:28

AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 11:23

No I’m not.

I thought about whether or not they should have my surname or DH’s. I decided I wasn’t arsed.

I just didn’t then go on some massive introspective journey into deciphering precisely why I wasn’t arsed. You’re saying it’s internalised misogyny and suggesting I’m just some brainwashed little woman with no mind of her own, which I find quite insulting.

So, no, you didn’t think about the motivations behind your decision or why you’re ‘not arsed’ and he is. Which is what I asked.

If it’s not internalised misogyny, then what is it?

OP posts:
FabFitFifties · 14/11/2022 11:24

Tradition - and yes, the irony is not lost on me. I wouldn't do it again, neither would I agree to them having his religion. I have no religion. We are still a family unit, but I feel I compromised too far.

AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 11:23

Tsort · 14/11/2022 10:42

Can’t say I did much of a deep dive into my thought process to be honest. I just wasn’t that arsed.

Your response when asked why you didn’t care/he did. Direct quote.

So, now you’re contradicting yourself.

No I’m not.

I thought about whether or not they should have my surname or DH’s. I decided I wasn’t arsed.

I just didn’t then go on some massive introspective journey into deciphering precisely why I wasn’t arsed. You’re saying it’s internalised misogyny and suggesting I’m just some brainwashed little woman with no mind of her own, which I find quite insulting.

AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 11:19

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/11/2022 09:46

They are far more than anyone subscribing to an outdated patriarchal tradition where women were owned as property.

But I don’t believe that by giving my children their father’s surname as opposed to mine, that I am subscribing to that tradition. And you don’t get to say otherwise for me because I do in fact know my own mind.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 10:57

Confusion101 · 14/11/2022 10:55

@AliceAbsolum and @Tsort i wasn't asking in a condescending tone, I was genuinely asking if both people felt "why should I change" how would you come to a compromise.... Can't be arsed dealing with people jumping down my throat for asking a question! Unwatching!

And I genuinely asked if you’d ever asked a man that question. From your response, I’m assuming not.

OP posts:
Tsort · 14/11/2022 10:56

AthenaPopodopolous · 14/11/2022 10:52

So the children have their own fathers surname rather than my fathers surname. It’s traditional isn’t it and also so the children can research their family tree when older.

Why is their father’s surname his surname and yours is your father’s surname? Why doesn’t yours belong to you?

And re ‘it’s traditional’ - this post is specifically asking women who kept their last names upon marriage. If you did that, I’d be interested in why you kept one tradition while eschewing the other.

OP posts:
Confusion101 · 14/11/2022 10:55

@AliceAbsolum and @Tsort i wasn't asking in a condescending tone, I was genuinely asking if both people felt "why should I change" how would you come to a compromise.... Can't be arsed dealing with people jumping down my throat for asking a question! Unwatching!

AthenaPopodopolous · 14/11/2022 10:52

So the children have their own fathers surname rather than my fathers surname. It’s traditional isn’t it and also so the children can research their family tree when older.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 10:42

AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 10:35

Do you honestly think every woman on here who made a decision you wouldn’t have (which you clearly think is the “wrong” decision) hasn’t thought about it at all? Or do you think we’re all just fucking stupid?

Can’t say I did much of a deep dive into my thought process to be honest. I just wasn’t that arsed.

Your response when asked why you didn’t care/he did. Direct quote.

So, now you’re contradicting yourself.

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 14/11/2022 10:41

Because my ex cared about it and I didn’t. Also his name sounded better with our son’s first name.

I have a big, blended family and due to marriage, remarriage and other things, I only share my surname with my estranged father and one of my sisters, therefore I’m not a person who thinks you have to have the same last name to be family.

I made him, I birthed him, I look after him, he could be called anything and that wouldn’t make me any less his mother. If he wants to change his name to mine when he’s older, or to anything different, I’ll help him.