Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
GerbilsForever24 · 14/11/2022 14:11

Lots of women don’t care about it, the vast majority of men do care about it. Why do you think that is? Seriously, think it through.

Absolutely. We are married, I kept my name. But the DC have DH's name. We talked about it. But because of the way we'd been brought up, I found i just didn't care as much about the DC having my name. I had spent most of my life just assuming that any children would have my future DH's name. And he had spent most of his life just assuming that any children would have his name.

DH did try to convince me that we should do a girl/boy thing - so any boys have his name (we knew DC1 was a boy so I wonder how much that affected his thinking Grin ) and any girls have my name. From a purely feminist perspective, there's no doubt that would have been a better option. But I made a conscious decision not to go that route because I just couldn't face it and again, after 30+odd years of not expecting it, I just didn't care enough.

I still regularly have to explain why I don't have the same name to people, or get called Mrs DH name+ and the thought of having to constantly justify why the DC had different surnames was too much for me, even if I could see it wasn't the "feminist" decision.

  • one of the things I am loving about DS new school is that they clearly have a policy of properly checking parental names. I am consistently referred to in communication and in person as Ms MyName and it's very pleasant.
Herecomestreble1 · 14/11/2022 14:03

I'm married but our son has my name as DH took my name when we married. Would recommend as a route to ensure your children have your name regardless of marriage! 😁

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 14:02

Because my surname isn't mine, it's my ex husband's.

It IS your name. It's yours unless you believe that no woman ever retains ownership of her own name; that it's always only on loan to them from a man.

And here's where the disparity lies. Women, even in 2022, come under all manner of pressure to take their husbands' names on marriage. This is in evidence all over MN, with people telling those women their names are not really theirs but their fathers'. Offline I've had outright rudeness, and people (MiL for one) refusing to address me by my own family name (they know fine well what it is).

At the same time we meet the counter-expectation that a woman's name - her whole identity - lasts only as long as her relationship lasts. In many cases this is a temporary measure. As soon as her association with that man ends, it's frequently assumed that the name will be handed back like any old borrowed item. IMO, these two expectations really don't sit well together. Women's names are not library books, to be handed back when the loan period expires: nor are we chattels to be tagged like cattle with the name of the man we happen to be associated with.

The child's name question doesn't apply to me, but on every thread about naming conventions I'm struck by the strange contradiction in the two positions above.

Herecomestreble1 · 14/11/2022 14:02

I'm married but

SallyWD · 14/11/2022 14:00

We had our first child before we married but I knew we would marry. I always intended to take DH's surname because I really like it! It sounds so good with my first name (unlike my maiden name). I also wanted us to have a family name. I couldn't be bothered with having a double barrelled name. It wouldn't have sounded good. Seeing as I preferred DH's surname it was an easy decision.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:58

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 13:39

I think throwing around "internalized misogyny" is a bit reductive. Real life is complicated.

For example, I "followed tradition" but was perfectly aware it was a sexist tradition. I didn't go along with it because I was blind to it being a patriarchal tradition.

But it was not something I wanted to have a fight or create bad feeling about. To me, there were other issues in my marriage that were more important.

I needed to conserve my energy for those and eventually I was able to use that energy to do other more important things (e.g. break free from a shitty relationship, after having tried my utmost to make it work). Rocking the boat over what surname to use just wasn't high on the priority list.

Also my surname is one that gets misspelled, mispronounced, and sometimes mocked, especially in the UK. Why would I saddle my child with it? And personally I think double-barrelled names are pretentious (though if that's what someone else wants to do, fine.)

So it's a lot more complicated than pointing the finger and chortling over someone else's "internalized misogyny." I also shave my legs once every 3 months or so. I'm perfectly happy to admit that that's sexist too but I do it anyway because I don't live in some idealogically pure feminist world, I live in the real world, and I consider other things I do to have far more feminist impact than this issue.

It’s not pointing a finger and chortling to recognise the patriarchal constructs within which we live and make our decisions. Examining why we do what we do is often treated with suspicion and it really shouldn’t be. And while you weren’t blind to it being a patriarchal tradition, a quick skim of the responses on this thread illustrates that this is not the case for all posters.

I’m not saying that women need to make ideologically pure feminist choices. I’m asking that women examine the choices they’ve made and questioning the motivations behind them. If they don’t want to do that, they don’t have to engage - it’s an MN thread, not a prison.

I will say that the very idea of not expressing an opinion, having a conversation or taking a stand in a relationship because one doesn’t want to rock the boat and is conserving one’s energies for other issues seems exceedingly toxic to me. I wouldn’t want to be in such a relationship. However, that’s not what this thread is about, and is none of my business.

OP posts:
WhatATimeToBeAlive · 14/11/2022 13:40

Ihatethenewlook · 18/10/2022 23:12

Because he promised to marry me. But he didn’t. I know have a different last name to my 3 children. This is changing very soon. Isn’t it mad how men consider a marriage ceremony more tying than having 3 children

Presumably you thought the same if you had 3 children without getting married.

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 13:39

I think throwing around "internalized misogyny" is a bit reductive. Real life is complicated.

For example, I "followed tradition" but was perfectly aware it was a sexist tradition. I didn't go along with it because I was blind to it being a patriarchal tradition.

But it was not something I wanted to have a fight or create bad feeling about. To me, there were other issues in my marriage that were more important.

I needed to conserve my energy for those and eventually I was able to use that energy to do other more important things (e.g. break free from a shitty relationship, after having tried my utmost to make it work). Rocking the boat over what surname to use just wasn't high on the priority list.

Also my surname is one that gets misspelled, mispronounced, and sometimes mocked, especially in the UK. Why would I saddle my child with it? And personally I think double-barrelled names are pretentious (though if that's what someone else wants to do, fine.)

So it's a lot more complicated than pointing the finger and chortling over someone else's "internalized misogyny." I also shave my legs once every 3 months or so. I'm perfectly happy to admit that that's sexist too but I do it anyway because I don't live in some idealogically pure feminist world, I live in the real world, and I consider other things I do to have far more feminist impact than this issue.

TimBoothseyes · 14/11/2022 13:30

Because I didn't want her growing up having to repeatedly spell out her surname and having it continually mispronounced. It was a small way of making her life a bit better in the future. As an adult she has told me a few times that she is glad I gave her her dad's last name and not mine.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:28

LadyinLavende · 14/11/2022 13:23

Because it was a legal requirement in the country where they were born, unfortunately.
I did insist on thm all having my own name as a "middle" name, but it only appears when their full names are listed on official documents:

Oh, interesting! May I ask which country? What about if parents are unmarried and the father is absent, do DC still get the man’s last name?

OP posts:
Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:27

AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 13:23

Quite simply not giving a shit.

Indeed. You just happen to not give a shit, for reasons that you won’t examine. Like lots of other women also don’t care for some, completely unconnected reason. And most men do care, for some unfathomable reason.

And none of this has anything to do with misogyny, internalised or otherwise, and it’s condescending to suggest it does.

Right.

OP posts:
AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 13:23

Tsort · 14/11/2022 11:28

So, no, you didn’t think about the motivations behind your decision or why you’re ‘not arsed’ and he is. Which is what I asked.

If it’s not internalised misogyny, then what is it?

Quite simply not giving a shit.

LadyinLavende · 14/11/2022 13:23

Because it was a legal requirement in the country where they were born, unfortunately.
I did insist on thm all having my own name as a "middle" name, but it only appears when their full names are listed on official documents:

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:16

@PeekabooAtTheZoo No worries! I thought it was interesting, but totally get how it would be outing.

OP posts:
Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:14

ShiningStarQueen · 14/11/2022 13:09

Good question tbh. I still maintain though that it’s got a better ring to it than my maiden name. Although saying that, my DS is considering changing his surname to my maiden name now he’s over 18 because when my mum passes away, the family name will die out otherwise.

Off topic, but your DS sounds like a lovely young man. That’s really deep and compassionate thinking for a teenager.

OP posts:
PeekabooAtTheZoo · 14/11/2022 13:11

@Tsort thank you. Sorry, I was trying to add to the discussion and maybe inspire other women to think about it all.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:11

Same1977 · 14/11/2022 13:07

Well perhaps the abused men are oppressed here by thinking they don't feel they can change name without society looking down on them (being weak etc).I can openly say I was traumatised by my father's family and don't wish to associate with them.

Perhaps they were. Or perhaps they absorbed the societal programming that a man’s name is permanently his and a woman’s is transient, so changing their names never even occurred to them. Or perhaps a combination of both.

All of the reasons we’ve listed stem from patriarchal societal structures, though. And they warrant examination and discussion.

OP posts:
ShiningStarQueen · 14/11/2022 13:09

Good question tbh. I still maintain though that it’s got a better ring to it than my maiden name. Although saying that, my DS is considering changing his surname to my maiden name now he’s over 18 because when my mum passes away, the family name will die out otherwise.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:07

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 14/11/2022 13:05

Sorry just realised how completely outing that is, even with the names changed, because of how unusual it is for women to do what my family did with our names, so I'm going to report myself.

Totally understandable. I’ll report it for you, as well.

OP posts:
Same1977 · 14/11/2022 13:07

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:03

You’re conflating rather a lot of things, here. Having an equal partnership doesn’t mean a man can’t fix your car or support you to stay home with your child. I have those things and I’m delighted that you do, if you want them. Feminism is about the freedom to make informed choices.

And while it’s not immediate, as that’s physically impossible (men don’t give birth, women do), quite a lot of women go back to work soon after childbirth - they can’t afford not to.

This does not change the fact that patriarchal structures exist and oppress women and that said structures should be examined. And, yes, the trope of distancing oneself from an abusive/absent/estranged father by eschewing his name exists almost entirely for women, very seldom for men. So it makes sense to wonder why that is.

Well perhaps the abused men are oppressed here by thinking they don't feel they can change name without society looking down on them (being weak etc).I can openly say I was traumatised by my father's family and don't wish to associate with them.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:05

Blanketpolicy · 14/11/2022 12:49

I personally dislike double-barrelled names. Just pick a name, it's really not that hard and I think not fair on the child to be stuck with a ridiculous name because its parents can't sort themselves out.

ds got our married family name so it was straight forward.

If we hadn't decided to get married before he was born he would have had my surname. If we had got married after he was born I would have kept my name to be aligned with ds and dh would have been fine with that (these sorts of things don't bother him either way)

I’m specifically asking women who kept their names why they gave their DC their husband’s name.

OP posts:
PeekabooAtTheZoo · 14/11/2022 13:05

Sorry just realised how completely outing that is, even with the names changed, because of how unusual it is for women to do what my family did with our names, so I'm going to report myself.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:03

Same1977 · 14/11/2022 12:40

I am not responsible about abused men's actions and only can explain mine.
Would it please you if i said well my husband wanted our child to have his name and I wanted my child to have mine.We tossed a coin and he won.
In my 20s I liked to think I was so darn oppressed by patriarchal traditions.In my 30s I appreciate a man who fixes my car, supports me without asking to be the one who stays at home with our daughter etc.Yes it's a traditional set up and it makes me happy.
It's a 2 way street.I hope you fight just as hard to go back to work straight after birth just like men do after their child is born ,to pay for everything equally etc.

You’re conflating rather a lot of things, here. Having an equal partnership doesn’t mean a man can’t fix your car or support you to stay home with your child. I have those things and I’m delighted that you do, if you want them. Feminism is about the freedom to make informed choices.

And while it’s not immediate, as that’s physically impossible (men don’t give birth, women do), quite a lot of women go back to work soon after childbirth - they can’t afford not to.

This does not change the fact that patriarchal structures exist and oppress women and that said structures should be examined. And, yes, the trope of distancing oneself from an abusive/absent/estranged father by eschewing his name exists almost entirely for women, very seldom for men. So it makes sense to wonder why that is.

OP posts:
Legallypinkish · 14/11/2022 13:01

Because I knew we’d get married at some point.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 14/11/2022 12:58

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request