Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
Tsort · 14/11/2022 16:18

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 16:03

Maybe I misunderstand the thread, but then I'm not sure what the purpose is. You asked why people gave DC their father's surname but why are you asking? So you can tsk at people for not doing the right thing, or so you can gain greater understanding of why they do it?

I've shared my experience because I'm pointing out that what might seem like a simple choice can be much more complex in real life, and also it might be trivial compared to other things going on.

And also that having a name that is routinely made fun of and wanting to spare your kid that is a perfectly valid reason ;-)

It will be very interesting to see how trends on this change over time and if it becomes more usual for children to be given the mother's name.

If you actually wanted to know what I was asking and why, you’d read my comments. You certainly don’t have to, but if you can’t be bothered to do that, there’s no point to this conversation.

OP posts:
LadyinLavende · 14/11/2022 16:12

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:28

Oh, interesting! May I ask which country? What about if parents are unmarried and the father is absent, do DC still get the man’s last name?

France:
My kids are in their 30s and the law has changed since they were born:

Actually, I had always intended to keep my own name, but when you live in France it's automatic! You don't lose it when you get married; Many women choose to be known as Mme Hisname, but on legal documents even on identity cards it says Mme Hername, épouse Hisname:
And because of this, there's no "keeping his name when you get divorced": he actually has to give his permission for that to happen, otherwise it's automatically back to your own name:

And none of this Hisname for boys and Hername for girls: all the children born of the same two parents have to have exactly the same surname, so the choice you make when the first is born dictates what the rest of their siblings will be called:

These days you can choose to give your kids Hisname, Hername or double barrel them (without hyphens, in either order):
What you cannot do is pick an entirely new name and say "we are going to be the family Lavende: M, Mme and three kids all called Lavende:":
The name you get from your parents is the one you will have to use your whole life (unless you do a very complicated and costly court procedure: it happened to someone I knew whose husband was not the father of her kid: after the divorce she had another whole lot of legal procedings to undertake to change the kid's name to that of the new husband -who was also the genetic father):

Unmarried parents
If the parents agree whose name the child will have and make a joint declaration then the possibilities are the same as for a married couple, but if the mother registers the birth and the father only does the paperwork afterwards, then the child will have the mother's name:
If the parents are not married there is a procedure (this is France - they are world champions of paperwork) whereby the father can recognise his offspring by making a declaration even before the birth.......... and if I understand things correctly
www.demarches.interieur.gouv.fr/particuliers/choix-nom-famille-enfant-pere-mere

if the parents don't agree and are concerned that the other may try to give their name to the child by making an anticipatory declaration, one or both can lodge an official objection and then the "registrar" will give the child both parents' names in alphabetical order

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 16:03

Maybe I misunderstand the thread, but then I'm not sure what the purpose is. You asked why people gave DC their father's surname but why are you asking? So you can tsk at people for not doing the right thing, or so you can gain greater understanding of why they do it?

I've shared my experience because I'm pointing out that what might seem like a simple choice can be much more complex in real life, and also it might be trivial compared to other things going on.

And also that having a name that is routinely made fun of and wanting to spare your kid that is a perfectly valid reason ;-)

It will be very interesting to see how trends on this change over time and if it becomes more usual for children to be given the mother's name.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 15:51

Beamur · 14/11/2022 14:53

Because I wanted DD to have the same surname as her (half) siblings. I had no doubt she would never question.my relationship to her, but wanted to help the siblings feel more like family.

I can’t remember who the poster was who asked about reasons for giving the DC the man’s name that weren’t patriarchal, in my opinion. So, unfortunately I can’t tag them. But, this is an example. I think this is just lovely, personally.

OP posts:
Tsort · 14/11/2022 15:46

hebbedy · 14/11/2022 14:45

OP, this is a good point.

I felt like I was already "pushing it" by not taking DH's name (not by DH but just by society).

I felt "too cheeky" to say the kids should have my name, as there is no real reason as to why they should have mine name over his.

Again, not anything DH said or did, just my own internal dialogue that it was one thing not to change my name, but another thing entirely to not let DH have his name passed on.

And in this sense it just kind of happened that they would have DH's name, as that is not what would have "traditionally" happened.

What is in a name? I guess.

I think a lot of us have had this exact same experience and thought process. The ‘pushing it’, but DC names being a step too far thing is very familiar to me. I think we thoroughly scandalised some of our relatives.

Anyway, you’re definitely not alone.

OP posts:
KatieKline · 14/11/2022 15:34

Several reasons:

  1. We had been engaged for 7 years before DS1 came along
  2. We were always going to get married at some point, and it was important to me that I had the same name as my children - we eventually got married 4 years later
  3. I hated my maiden name, I was constantly having to spell it for people - every time. Cannot under-estimate the frustration of having to spell your name
  4. When DH was my then bf and we talked of marriage he was quite open to changing his name to my maiden name, but I was firm that I would be changing my name because of no. 3 above. I have no regrets in giving our children DH's name and taking his name
MumsteadPlum · 14/11/2022 15:32

For me it was mainly that I've always disliked my surname (literally just don't like the sound of it - no issues with family background), so I thought the kids might prefer his. We're not married, no intention to, and wouldn't change my own name (despite not really liking it - it's mine).

My mum kept her name when she married my dad, and all three of us were given my dad's surname but my brother decided to switch to my mum's.

I think also I felt like there could be no disputing the kids were mine - they came out of my body - so giving them his surname gave an indication of that family connection - albeit that proves nothing and could be deemed proprietorial (and obviously biology isn't the be all and end all either, for either parent).

If I'd liked my own surname, though, I might have felt differently 🤔

LeSquigh · 14/11/2022 15:30

Mostly because my name is the name of my ex and I haven't changed it but even if it wasn't my child would still have their dads name because it is very normal in the UK to do so. I have never come across kids having anything other than their fathers name (unless there is a specific reason not to) in real life and only encountered children taking their mothers surname on Mumsnet.

I haven't read all the comment but I did read one that said it is traditional for children of unmarried parents to take the mothers name. Absolute NONSENSE, it absolutely is not.

babyjellyfish · 14/11/2022 15:01

Whataboutno · 14/11/2022 14:55

Because it didn't bother me and it's just a name. It seemed more important to him, even though they are both girls so can't carry on the name anyway 😅

Why can't they?

Tsort · 14/11/2022 14:56

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 14:25

"I will say that the very idea of not expressing an opinion, having a conversation or taking a stand in a relationship because one doesn’t want to rock the boat and is conserving one’s energies for other issues seems exceedingly toxic to me. I wouldn’t want to be in such a relationship. However, that’s not what this thread is about, and is none of my business."

Yeah no shit Sherlock! 😂That's why I left. But like a lot of women in abusive relationships, it took time to get there, and the building of a lot of confidence and gathering of a lot of resources. Leaving a toxic relationship is incredibly difficult and it's a complex situation, and that's exactly why I brought it up: because real life is very complex and sometimes making the more feminist choice on something that is (to one individual) less important may be valuable in paving the way for being able to make healthy choices on something far more important.

I get where you're coming from, I'm a bit perplexed by women who change their name upon marriage and wonder "But don't you REALISE it's a patriarchal tradition?!" But at the same time I've come to realise that, yeah, life is complex, and the big picture of how someone lives and what kind of choices they make is a lot more interesting than focusing on whether they've toed the line on this one little piece of the puzzle just because I happen to think they should be behaving in a particular way.

You seem to have decided this thread is about something it’s not and also that you and I disagree about the above. I don’t believe we do.

OP posts:
Whataboutno · 14/11/2022 14:55

Because it didn't bother me and it's just a name. It seemed more important to him, even though they are both girls so can't carry on the name anyway 😅

Beamur · 14/11/2022 14:53

Because I wanted DD to have the same surname as her (half) siblings. I had no doubt she would never question.my relationship to her, but wanted to help the siblings feel more like family.

GerbilsForever24 · 14/11/2022 14:50

Tsort · 14/11/2022 14:44

I’m specifically asking women who kept their names why they gave their DC their husband’s name.

Answered above but I'd add that I think it does demonstrate the instinctive fall back to the patriarchy. I'm not sure if I'd call it misogyny but it definitely is the patriarchy. In the same way that the father's name often comes first in official communication re the child, even if the mother is the one who does all the engagement.

So in my case, I was absolutely aware of it but made the decision anyway, albeit not without some detailed conversations about it.

I am interested in the women who weren't married who did it. I always told DH that if I'd had a baby without being married, that baby would have my name and he agreed. On sort of the same basis - growing up the assumption was that if I got pregnant without being married, I'd be a single mum and that child would have my name. So it seemed obvious to me, even though if I'd got pregnant with DH pre marriage I absolutely would not have been a single mum.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 14:50

Angelofthenortheast · 14/11/2022 14:33

This is such an important feminist conversation OP - thanks for initiating it!

Being totally honest I find it quite disheartening the amount of women on here saying stuff like "his name is nicer". It seems a bit unlikely that every man out there just has a nicer surname than every woman - and yet I've personally met only ONE family whose children had the mothers name. It's not a coincidence. It's a symptom of a fear of feminism and the reassurance of tradition

Nope, clearly not a coincidence. However, people react very negatively when you point that out.

I think it’s interesting (and a bit sad) how reluctant a lot of women are to even have the conversation.

OP posts:
hebbedy · 14/11/2022 14:47

hebbedy · 14/11/2022 14:45

OP, this is a good point.

I felt like I was already "pushing it" by not taking DH's name (not by DH but just by society).

I felt "too cheeky" to say the kids should have my name, as there is no real reason as to why they should have mine name over his.

Again, not anything DH said or did, just my own internal dialogue that it was one thing not to change my name, but another thing entirely to not let DH have his name passed on.

And in this sense it just kind of happened that they would have DH's name, as that is not what would have "traditionally" happened.

What is in a name? I guess.

I should add that I'm from a different culture to DH and they both have first names and middle names that are from my culture.

hebbedy · 14/11/2022 14:45

OP, this is a good point.

I felt like I was already "pushing it" by not taking DH's name (not by DH but just by society).

I felt "too cheeky" to say the kids should have my name, as there is no real reason as to why they should have mine name over his.

Again, not anything DH said or did, just my own internal dialogue that it was one thing not to change my name, but another thing entirely to not let DH have his name passed on.

And in this sense it just kind of happened that they would have DH's name, as that is not what would have "traditionally" happened.

What is in a name? I guess.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 14:44

SallyWD · 14/11/2022 14:00

We had our first child before we married but I knew we would marry. I always intended to take DH's surname because I really like it! It sounds so good with my first name (unlike my maiden name). I also wanted us to have a family name. I couldn't be bothered with having a double barrelled name. It wouldn't have sounded good. Seeing as I preferred DH's surname it was an easy decision.

I’m specifically asking women who kept their names why they gave their DC their husband’s name.

OP posts:
Mosik · 14/11/2022 14:40

It was to be mine for girls and his for boys. We got boys.
In hindsight 27 years later I wish I'd given them my name as a middle name. I loathe hyphenated names and didn't think of it until later.

Angelofthenortheast · 14/11/2022 14:33

This is such an important feminist conversation OP - thanks for initiating it!

Being totally honest I find it quite disheartening the amount of women on here saying stuff like "his name is nicer". It seems a bit unlikely that every man out there just has a nicer surname than every woman - and yet I've personally met only ONE family whose children had the mothers name. It's not a coincidence. It's a symptom of a fear of feminism and the reassurance of tradition

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 14:25

"I will say that the very idea of not expressing an opinion, having a conversation or taking a stand in a relationship because one doesn’t want to rock the boat and is conserving one’s energies for other issues seems exceedingly toxic to me. I wouldn’t want to be in such a relationship. However, that’s not what this thread is about, and is none of my business."

Yeah no shit Sherlock! 😂That's why I left. But like a lot of women in abusive relationships, it took time to get there, and the building of a lot of confidence and gathering of a lot of resources. Leaving a toxic relationship is incredibly difficult and it's a complex situation, and that's exactly why I brought it up: because real life is very complex and sometimes making the more feminist choice on something that is (to one individual) less important may be valuable in paving the way for being able to make healthy choices on something far more important.

I get where you're coming from, I'm a bit perplexed by women who change their name upon marriage and wonder "But don't you REALISE it's a patriarchal tradition?!" But at the same time I've come to realise that, yeah, life is complex, and the big picture of how someone lives and what kind of choices they make is a lot more interesting than focusing on whether they've toed the line on this one little piece of the puzzle just because I happen to think they should be behaving in a particular way.

MsMarch · 14/11/2022 14:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I'm always surprised at how many women hate their surname vs how many men don't seem to have this issue.

Particularly amusing in the case of a very good friend who said she couldn't WAIT to ditch her (admittedly,, very dodgy) surname but who has nothing to say about her brother's wife happily giving up her perfectly normal and non-offensive surname.

GerbilsForever24 · 14/11/2022 14:23

Notanotherusername4321 · 14/11/2022 14:19

DH did try to convince me that we should do a girl/boy thing - so any boys have his name (we knew DC1 was a boy so I wonder how much that affected his thinking Grin ) and any girls have my name. From a purely feminist perspective, there's no doubt that would have been a better option

I strongly dislike this option because I don’t like the idea of a family gender divide. The families I know with opposite sex children tend to split that way anyway- boy plays football with dad, girl goes shopping with mum etc. the idea that girls somehow belong to mum while boys are dads is abhorrent to me.

so I don’ t think it’s feminist at all. It’s a further division of the sexes to two different sides and roles. I wonder how kids would feel as well, that one parent is “more” than the other.

Well, i think in DH and my case, the thinking was a patriarchal line and a matriarchal line.

As DH is busy packing DD's ballet kit to take her to ballet shortly, while I am thinking about how I must stop MN so that I can get my work finished in time to take DS to his sports activity this evening, and these sorts of splits are pretty normal in our house, I'm not really concerned about anyone thinking the girls are mine and boys are DH.

WordtoYoMumma · 14/11/2022 14:22

His surname just sounds way better with the names we chose than mine does!!

Notanotherusername4321 · 14/11/2022 14:19

DH did try to convince me that we should do a girl/boy thing - so any boys have his name (we knew DC1 was a boy so I wonder how much that affected his thinking Grin ) and any girls have my name. From a purely feminist perspective, there's no doubt that would have been a better option

I strongly dislike this option because I don’t like the idea of a family gender divide. The families I know with opposite sex children tend to split that way anyway- boy plays football with dad, girl goes shopping with mum etc. the idea that girls somehow belong to mum while boys are dads is abhorrent to me.

so I don’ t think it’s feminist at all. It’s a further division of the sexes to two different sides and roles. I wonder how kids would feel as well, that one parent is “more” than the other.

GrapesAreMyJam · 14/11/2022 14:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.