Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
IMissVino · 14/11/2022 22:14

@SophieIsHereToday and @Notanotherusername4321 I apologise if I’m being thick, but I don’t understand why you all just couldn't/didn’t use your last names?

Not trying to be goady, this is a genuine question. I’m sorry you’ve had to experience those situations and it sounds horrible for the lovely sounding men you’ve married, but I don’t get why all of you having your last names wasn’t the solution.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 22:14

As MN threads go this one's unusual. As it's unfolded it's amounted to nothing more than a set of imperious demands for women to explain and justify their personal decisions to a complete stranger.

It doesn't work like that. You can create a thread: you don't get to dictate everything others post on it. Conversations evolve, or they stagnate as this one has.

Frankly I'm amazed so many people have gone along with the didactic tone and queenly rebukes on this thread. Naming discussions interest me as a rule, but this is beyond tedious. I'm out. 🥱

SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 21:31

Notanotherusername4321 · 14/11/2022 21:06

*This is an interesting twist on the ways in which the patriarchy hurts men as well as women, isn’t it?

I understand your decision, but did you ever discuss all of you having your name?*

we did. My name is clearly linked to my country of origin and I like the link to my heritage, so would never change it.

like pp with dh as an involved parent we decided on his name for similar reasons to @SophieIsHereToday .

dh is divorced and had a shitty time having to “prove” he was the father of his children at every step. Schools, gp’s, all refused to engage with him until we sent legal letters, and that was with the same name. Whereas once I had to take sdc to a&e in an emergency and they automatically assumed I was mum, until I said I couldn’t consent until a parent got there.

He was worried that a man travelling with kids with a different name would be looked on suspiciously- he takes dd’s away for their hobby and a 40 year old man in the same room as a 15 year old with a different name…? Plus many people assume stepdad and question PR, he had enough of that when he had the same name!

so from personal experience that a female with a child with different names is automatically trusted, whereas a man isn’t, we went with dh’s name.

I am sorry to hear you experienced these kinds of problems. I had hoped we were being paranoid and protecting ourselves against something that wouldn't happen. I hadn't thought far enough ahead to imagine potential issues as a mid-teen.

For us, double barrel of both our names was too long to be practical for DC to carry. But DC have my surname as their second middle name. So we are currently using both our surnames for education purposes. I expect we might drop this at some point but it's nice to have my surname linked to DC.

Notanotherusername4321 · 14/11/2022 21:06

*This is an interesting twist on the ways in which the patriarchy hurts men as well as women, isn’t it?

I understand your decision, but did you ever discuss all of you having your name?*

we did. My name is clearly linked to my country of origin and I like the link to my heritage, so would never change it.

like pp with dh as an involved parent we decided on his name for similar reasons to @SophieIsHereToday .

dh is divorced and had a shitty time having to “prove” he was the father of his children at every step. Schools, gp’s, all refused to engage with him until we sent legal letters, and that was with the same name. Whereas once I had to take sdc to a&e in an emergency and they automatically assumed I was mum, until I said I couldn’t consent until a parent got there.

He was worried that a man travelling with kids with a different name would be looked on suspiciously- he takes dd’s away for their hobby and a 40 year old man in the same room as a 15 year old with a different name…? Plus many people assume stepdad and question PR, he had enough of that when he had the same name!

so from personal experience that a female with a child with different names is automatically trusted, whereas a man isn’t, we went with dh’s name.

SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 20:37

Tsort · 14/11/2022 20:20

This is an interesting twist on the ways in which the patriarchy hurts men as well as women, isn’t it?

I understand your decision, but did you ever discuss all of you having your name?

We did actually. I have a more unique name, which I like and am attached to (although it has its problems with spelling etc). All being equal we might have gone for my name as his is quite common and therefore he feels less of an identity with his name.

But the idea of my partner facing barriers/discrimination as being a very involved parent, made me sympathetic to the idea that having the same name might help him. For him to enter spaces which are mostly for women and children, he wanted to be connected by name to his child so the connection didn't need explaining. I'm hoping as our DC gets older that there will be more involved dad's and actually this wasn't necessary.

He's actually incredibly supportive of me being a "strong" woman and likes how I'm very determined to push through barriers. I think feeling his support on this for over a decade made me immediately want to support him when I could see him having similar barriers. Up until now, he's led a very stereotypical "male" life.

I think the patriarchy hurts those who don't conform to those societal expectations. Usually this affects women but not exclusively.

But yes, we did discuss it in depth and it wasn't clear at the beginning which name was best for us.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 20:20

SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 20:02

My partner does more of the nursery drop offs and this is likely to be the case through school, school clubs etc. He felt it would be difficult to be a man and pick up his child who had a different surname.

I have plenty of examples where my life is difficult because of sexism and not being what society expected. I can imagine he is right, a man who is heavily invested in his schools is seen as odd. He had a longer paternity leave then me and some running a baby classes mentioned to me they found it strange to have a dad there. It's a form of sexism that I won't have to experience.

I'm not sure if having a matching surname will help much but having a different surname would give him another hurdle to overcome. In the other side, I'm the main earner and he supports me with dealing with those prejudices and supporting me as well.

I guess in a way it's due to the patriarchy but it's our way as a couple to support each other when we have chosen less gender conforming roles. And it was a very active decision. Still would be nice for me to have the same name as DC but I think it was the right thing for us

This is an interesting twist on the ways in which the patriarchy hurts men as well as women, isn’t it?

I understand your decision, but did you ever discuss all of you having your name?

OP posts:
SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 20:02

My partner does more of the nursery drop offs and this is likely to be the case through school, school clubs etc. He felt it would be difficult to be a man and pick up his child who had a different surname.

I have plenty of examples where my life is difficult because of sexism and not being what society expected. I can imagine he is right, a man who is heavily invested in his schools is seen as odd. He had a longer paternity leave then me and some running a baby classes mentioned to me they found it strange to have a dad there. It's a form of sexism that I won't have to experience.

I'm not sure if having a matching surname will help much but having a different surname would give him another hurdle to overcome. In the other side, I'm the main earner and he supports me with dealing with those prejudices and supporting me as well.

I guess in a way it's due to the patriarchy but it's our way as a couple to support each other when we have chosen less gender conforming roles. And it was a very active decision. Still would be nice for me to have the same name as DC but I think it was the right thing for us

Kattouswhiskers · 14/11/2022 19:31

@GerbilsForever24 no one has ever asked me to justify why the kids have my name and not DPs. Not once. In nine years so far.

In case any casual readers were wondering if it would be an issue.

A family member has 2 kids, one with each surname. No questions either.

It would be pretty rude to ask, no?

Georgie8 · 14/11/2022 18:29

I didn’t change my name when I married, I frankly couldn’t be bothered. Husband never commented.
Knew our first child was going to be a girl, so chose names -3 forenames! His surname sounded better with the forenames we (I) chose and double-barrelling would have been madness. However, I was still unsure.
Then my older sister (decade + older who knew our grandparents) told me that our father had changed his name and our surname belonged to our paternal grandmother’s third husband -someone completely unrelated to us!
Went with my husband’s surname thereafter!

Secretusername3 · 14/11/2022 18:12

Most of my friends have given their kids the dads surname. They are all working women and take on most of the childcare also. It’s absolutely their right to do this, but I do think it’s strange that women won’t admit that it is a feminist issue - I mean all women can’t statistically have more awkward names than men, and why are women the one’s who ‘don’t really mind’ - if it truly was a 50/50 choice we’d have 50/50 taking on surnames. But we don’t, and this is worth discussing. Maybe not for ourselves, but for our son’s and daughters?

Tsort · 14/11/2022 18:00

ghostsandpumpkinsalready · 14/11/2022 17:56

Impure surnames would have sounded ridiculous double barrelled so I have all the kids their father's surname 🤷‍♀️
They know I'm mum so I can't see a problem.

Any particular reason they didn’t all get yours?

OP posts:
theDudesmummy · 14/11/2022 17:59

We are married but I did not take his name. I did give DS his name, so DS has the same name as his siblings (paternal half-sibs). Also my name is more of a pain to spell, and because of what our names are we can't hyphenate the two together unless we want DS to sound ridiculously pompous.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 17:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I SO want to know what it was now! 😂

OP posts:
ghostsandpumpkinsalready · 14/11/2022 17:56

Impure surnames would have sounded ridiculous double barrelled so I have all the kids their father's surname 🤷‍♀️
They know I'm mum so I can't see a problem.

GrapesAreMyJam · 14/11/2022 17:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 17:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Do you have male relatives with that last name? If so, have they kept it or changed it?

OP posts:
GrapesAreMyJam · 14/11/2022 17:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

DeepDown12 · 14/11/2022 17:24

I kept my name, DD has her father's last name. We're married and I was fine with her having his surname since I got to choose the first name (I'm not British). Both of our cultures are now reflected in DD's names and it feels right.

Murdoch1949 · 14/11/2022 17:19

I always find this the most bizarre decision any woman makes, and I put it down to their lack of esteem in a desperate act to make the father think they're a family. We all know that relationships end, and a high percentage of children remain with their mum. So there are millions of women mothering children with a different second name to them, a lovely reminder of the man who abandoned them (possibly). In my family my grandchildren all took their mother's name, and had any of my sons suggested otherwise I would have been ready for them! My sons regularly get called by their children's names, they don't care and the children think it's hilarious.

Insertdeadcatsnamehere · 14/11/2022 17:15

Angelofthenortheast · 14/11/2022 14:33

This is such an important feminist conversation OP - thanks for initiating it!

Being totally honest I find it quite disheartening the amount of women on here saying stuff like "his name is nicer". It seems a bit unlikely that every man out there just has a nicer surname than every woman - and yet I've personally met only ONE family whose children had the mothers name. It's not a coincidence. It's a symptom of a fear of feminism and the reassurance of tradition

I said that, and it definitely is. I have had "jokes" from all quarters about my surname all my life and was pleased not to have to saddle my kids with it. I did think it through and came to the conclusion that I couldn't do that to them on a matter of my principles (instinct wojld havebeen to give them my name I guess) I do think though that, since I have my father's surname, then either way they'd have a man's name wouldn't they?! (and my dad is fine btw!). All their given names are from my side and go back longer than both possible surnames anyway and are far more meaningful to me. I take your point about tradition and I suppose there was an element of it being easier (DP didn't care either way though). I think it essentially boils down to me not really thinking that it's of that much importance.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 17:13

AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 17:09

Ok. I’m tired of your patronising, superiority complex bullshit now.

Over and out!

Nobody makes you keep coming back. You can just stop doing so. 🤷🏽‍♀️

Coming back to specifically tell me you’re flouncing is pretty special, though. Thanks for that.

OP posts:
AngeloMysterioso · 14/11/2022 17:09

Tsort · 14/11/2022 13:27

Indeed. You just happen to not give a shit, for reasons that you won’t examine. Like lots of other women also don’t care for some, completely unconnected reason. And most men do care, for some unfathomable reason.

And none of this has anything to do with misogyny, internalised or otherwise, and it’s condescending to suggest it does.

Right.

Ok. I’m tired of your patronising, superiority complex bullshit now.

Over and out!

spiderlight · 14/11/2022 16:34

Because he has a more interesting/unusual last name. Mine is incredibly common and late in the alphabet - I grew up being called last and being missed off the ends of lists. The name also flowed much better with DH's surname. DS has a forename we both chose, my dad's name as his middle name, and DH's surname, so he has one name from each side of the family and one that's uniquely his own.

lovelypidgeon · 14/11/2022 16:28

I changed my name on marriage because we had already discussed having children and I wanted to have the same name as them. The idea that we could be married and give the DC my name, or that DH could change is name to mine, didn't even occur to me. It annoys me now that I didn't even think to challenge any of this. However, I also struggle with the idea of giving my DC a name that has been passed on from my male ancestors for generations- it is my name but the history of it ignores all the mothers. If I had my time to come again I would like to choose a new name for all of us.

I have quite a few friends who have decided that marriage is not for them, but have children and a male partner. All of them have given the DC their partner's name. Reasons officially given are always along the lines of liked the name better, it was important to him but she didn't feel as strongly, nice to have a link to his family history etc etc. From more personal discussions it seems that often a big part of the thinking is actually that they have already caused a 'fuss' by not getting married so they feel that giving the DC their Dad's name appeases the extended family and seems more acceptable to wider society.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 16:21

LadyinLavende · 14/11/2022 16:12

France:
My kids are in their 30s and the law has changed since they were born:

Actually, I had always intended to keep my own name, but when you live in France it's automatic! You don't lose it when you get married; Many women choose to be known as Mme Hisname, but on legal documents even on identity cards it says Mme Hername, épouse Hisname:
And because of this, there's no "keeping his name when you get divorced": he actually has to give his permission for that to happen, otherwise it's automatically back to your own name:

And none of this Hisname for boys and Hername for girls: all the children born of the same two parents have to have exactly the same surname, so the choice you make when the first is born dictates what the rest of their siblings will be called:

These days you can choose to give your kids Hisname, Hername or double barrel them (without hyphens, in either order):
What you cannot do is pick an entirely new name and say "we are going to be the family Lavende: M, Mme and three kids all called Lavende:":
The name you get from your parents is the one you will have to use your whole life (unless you do a very complicated and costly court procedure: it happened to someone I knew whose husband was not the father of her kid: after the divorce she had another whole lot of legal procedings to undertake to change the kid's name to that of the new husband -who was also the genetic father):

Unmarried parents
If the parents agree whose name the child will have and make a joint declaration then the possibilities are the same as for a married couple, but if the mother registers the birth and the father only does the paperwork afterwards, then the child will have the mother's name:
If the parents are not married there is a procedure (this is France - they are world champions of paperwork) whereby the father can recognise his offspring by making a declaration even before the birth.......... and if I understand things correctly
www.demarches.interieur.gouv.fr/particuliers/choix-nom-famille-enfant-pere-mere

if the parents don't agree and are concerned that the other may try to give their name to the child by making an anticipatory declaration, one or both can lodge an official objection and then the "registrar" will give the child both parents' names in alphabetical order

This is all so interesting! I had no idea. Thanks for sharing.

OP posts: