Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 15/11/2022 20:58

Yes but the Spaniards have beautiful musical surnames. Whitehead-Trott just doesn’t have the same ring to it.

Notanotherusername4321 · 15/11/2022 20:57

To me, double barrelled surnames are unnecessarily long and convoluted. Mine and my husband's would have been 5 syllables long. It's also kicking the can down the road. When your child has a child, which names do they pass on and which do they drop? Do they combine to give a quadruple barrelled name? Does the next generation go for eight?

ask the Spanish?

they seem to have managed well enough with the double barrel method of naming 🤷‍♀️

the UK way isn’t the only way to do things.

Tsort · 15/11/2022 20:47

Algor1thm · 15/11/2022 19:52

We all have the same name. It was important to me that we all do, because to me that's part of being a family. I like being 'The Smiths*'. I didn't care about giving up my name and my husband did. It didn't feel patriarchal as it was all of my own free will, no pressure. Women's rights are about choice, not one way of doing things.

To me, double barrelled surnames are unnecessarily long and convoluted. Mine and my husband's would have been 5 syllables long. It's also kicking the can down the road. When your child has a child, which names do they pass on and which do they drop? Do they combine to give a quadruple barrelled name? Does the next generation go for eight?

I didn't care about giving up my name and my husband did.

Why do you think that is, though? It’s been discussed throughout the thread, but why do you think so many women don’t care about giving up their name and so many men to? Patriarchy. You can make any choices you wish, but you should acknowledge that said choices do not exist in a vacuum.

It's also kicking the can down the road. When your child has a child, which names do they pass on and which do they drop? Do they combine to give a quadruple barrelled name? Does the next generation go for eight?

Two points, here. Is adhering to patrilineal naming conventions not just kicking the can down the road for your daughter(s)? The expectation that they will at some point change their names?

Secondly, quite a lot of the world has double barrelled names for thousands of years. Nobody is right barrelled yet. People keep their birth names for their entire lives and pass on one of their last names to their kids. So, Jane Smith Jones and Tim Green Brown would have kids with the last names ‘Smith Green’ or ‘Jones Brown’, depending on which name their parents wanted to pass down.

OP posts:
Notanotherusername4321 · 15/11/2022 20:20

I didn't care about giving up my name and my husband did. It didn't feel patriarchal as it was all of my own free will, no pressure. Women's rights are about choice, not one way of doing things

thing is it’s not a completely free choice is it? If it were we’d see 50% of men giving up their names alongside women. Yet it’s nearly exclusively always women who make this “choice”.

women are raised knowing that society’s expectation is marriage and children, and they will change their names. It’s all they ever know, their mums did it, their friends mums did it. Most of us have practised writing Mrs boy crush throughout secondary school. The importance of taking someone else’s name is subconscious.

conversely, men know they will go through life with one name, one title. They know society won’t judge them for being married or not, and that it’s even irrelevant in their lives. Compared to women who announce whether they are married when simply giving their name.

so is it any surprise that it’s always women who are less attached to their surname than men?

Rainyday4321 · 15/11/2022 20:04

Because he wanted them to have his name and it wasn’t the ditch I wanted to die in.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 15/11/2022 20:00

I didn't want my kids to have my stepdads name.

Algor1thm · 15/11/2022 19:52

We all have the same name. It was important to me that we all do, because to me that's part of being a family. I like being 'The Smiths*'. I didn't care about giving up my name and my husband did. It didn't feel patriarchal as it was all of my own free will, no pressure. Women's rights are about choice, not one way of doing things.

To me, double barrelled surnames are unnecessarily long and convoluted. Mine and my husband's would have been 5 syllables long. It's also kicking the can down the road. When your child has a child, which names do they pass on and which do they drop? Do they combine to give a quadruple barrelled name? Does the next generation go for eight?

Tsort · 15/11/2022 19:46

Notanotherusername4321 · 15/11/2022 19:30

I had exactly one comment about not changing my name, from my cousin, and I told him to mind his own sexist business. I can’t think of anything else

most of dh’s relatives refuse to accept I have kept my own name and address all Christmas cards to “mr and Mrs dh’s name”

what they are even more resistant to is the fact I don’t want to be known as “Mrs”. This is far from unusual- lots of long threads here from women who think “Mrs” confers a status on them as a married women, and women using Dr somehow have ideas above their station. We should be recognised for our marital achievement and not our academic ones.

I’m pretty…confrontational, I suppose? Whatever the opposite of non-confrontational is. This is disrespect, and I wouldn’t tolerate it. You will address me correctly or you will not address me at all.

However, it really doesn’t come up in my life. When we got married, work asked if I wanted my name/email changed, but that’s it.

I also don’t think I know anyone under 50 who uses or is called ‘Mrs’. Fully aware that this isn’t the case for much of the country, but DH and I are pretty standard in our specific demographic, so there’s not a lot of friction. MN is very much a window into another world for me, in many respects.

OP posts:
Tsort · 15/11/2022 19:36

GerbilsForever24 · 15/11/2022 18:00

Let's see... we had the people who thought it was funny to comment to me that they knew I didn't want to be Mrs DH Name so they were going to use it just to irritate me. Then the people who responded to a post I put on facebook alerting them that I wasn't taking DH Name who had quite a lot to say about why wouldn't I want to and, my personal favourite, how does DH feel about it? (DH felt very strongly it had nothing to do with him and was barely polite in responding to that Facebook post). Then there was the man in my office who told me he thought it was "sad" that I didn't want to share DH's name. The lady at the bank who told me that she "had" to change my name on our joint bank account as "it's the law".

A LARGE number of people who have told me some version of, "it's too complicated to remember both you and DH's name" or "It's too long to write both your names on the card so we'll just use DH's name" (Funny, this was't a problem before we were married. Also, I have one friend who says this but then just addresses stuff to me instead!)

DH has had a number of friends attempt to commiserate with him because I wouldn't take his name (in the months after the wedding).

The PTA who used my name and DH's surname when listing me on something, notwithstanding that my name is on my facebook, my email and my WhatsApp - all avenues through which they had communicated with me. (admittedly, this doesn't count in the 'people who have commented' section really, but I add it here on the basis that it DOES fit in the 'people who just can't get their head around me not changing my name').

These are just the examples I can think of off the top of my head. I am sure there are more. The sharp comments were me responding, and sometimes DH, - we lost patience pretty quickly.

How incredibly frustrating!

OP posts:
Notanotherusername4321 · 15/11/2022 19:30

I had exactly one comment about not changing my name, from my cousin, and I told him to mind his own sexist business. I can’t think of anything else

most of dh’s relatives refuse to accept I have kept my own name and address all Christmas cards to “mr and Mrs dh’s name”

what they are even more resistant to is the fact I don’t want to be known as “Mrs”. This is far from unusual- lots of long threads here from women who think “Mrs” confers a status on them as a married women, and women using Dr somehow have ideas above their station. We should be recognised for our marital achievement and not our academic ones.

Kattouswhiskers · 15/11/2022 19:21

I'm not married (and even if I was I wouldn't change my name; even in my parents generation in our family the women kept their names- and I actually wish I had my mothers' to keep that matrilienal line).

So it's purely about the kids, who very much have my name. Was it an explicitly feminist choice? Yes. Does it mean you're a bad feminist if you don't? No. But it is good to recognise how culture and patriarchy constrain and shape our decision-making.

I do think there will be some variation depending on where you live in how surprising people think this is. As others on the thread have pointed out, naming traditions are different in different communities/countries- somewhere very multicultural things stand out less. Arab women, for example, do not take their husband's name (and the law is changing quite fast in some countries in the region to allow children to also take their mother's name). Spanish surnames are a combination of names from both sides.

It would be particularly rude to ask, so I'm sad for some posters that others think it's any of their business (and still seem to be living in 1930).

GerbilsForever24 · 15/11/2022 18:00

Tsort · 15/11/2022 11:56

Where are you and what did they say? Sharp comments? Who on Earth thinks they are entitled to an opinion re what you’re called?!

I had exactly one comment about not changing my name, from my cousin, and I told him to mind his own sexist business. I can’t think of anything else.

Let's see... we had the people who thought it was funny to comment to me that they knew I didn't want to be Mrs DH Name so they were going to use it just to irritate me. Then the people who responded to a post I put on facebook alerting them that I wasn't taking DH Name who had quite a lot to say about why wouldn't I want to and, my personal favourite, how does DH feel about it? (DH felt very strongly it had nothing to do with him and was barely polite in responding to that Facebook post). Then there was the man in my office who told me he thought it was "sad" that I didn't want to share DH's name. The lady at the bank who told me that she "had" to change my name on our joint bank account as "it's the law".

A LARGE number of people who have told me some version of, "it's too complicated to remember both you and DH's name" or "It's too long to write both your names on the card so we'll just use DH's name" (Funny, this was't a problem before we were married. Also, I have one friend who says this but then just addresses stuff to me instead!)

DH has had a number of friends attempt to commiserate with him because I wouldn't take his name (in the months after the wedding).

The PTA who used my name and DH's surname when listing me on something, notwithstanding that my name is on my facebook, my email and my WhatsApp - all avenues through which they had communicated with me. (admittedly, this doesn't count in the 'people who have commented' section really, but I add it here on the basis that it DOES fit in the 'people who just can't get their head around me not changing my name').

These are just the examples I can think of off the top of my head. I am sure there are more. The sharp comments were me responding, and sometimes DH, - we lost patience pretty quickly.

Tsort · 15/11/2022 11:56

GerbilsForever24 · 15/11/2022 09:47

That's really good to hear. I'm not convinced it would the case around here - I had to make some pretty sharp comments to people who had a LOT to say about me not taking DH's name. It was kind of mind blowing to be honest.

And I've had the odd comment at intervals ever since. But your story gives me hope that things really are changing.

Where are you and what did they say? Sharp comments? Who on Earth thinks they are entitled to an opinion re what you’re called?!

I had exactly one comment about not changing my name, from my cousin, and I told him to mind his own sexist business. I can’t think of anything else.

OP posts:
GerbilsForever24 · 15/11/2022 09:47

Kattouswhiskers · 14/11/2022 19:31

@GerbilsForever24 no one has ever asked me to justify why the kids have my name and not DPs. Not once. In nine years so far.

In case any casual readers were wondering if it would be an issue.

A family member has 2 kids, one with each surname. No questions either.

It would be pretty rude to ask, no?

That's really good to hear. I'm not convinced it would the case around here - I had to make some pretty sharp comments to people who had a LOT to say about me not taking DH's name. It was kind of mind blowing to be honest.

And I've had the odd comment at intervals ever since. But your story gives me hope that things really are changing.

emptythelitterbox · 15/11/2022 02:54

My son is named after his father. He likes it. His father passed when he was very young.

My daughter has my surname. It's a very cool surname.
My daughter mistakingly gave her DC the father's surname which is an ugly embarrassing name.
She later had it changed to our cool surname.

mangoesaretheonlyfruit · 15/11/2022 02:43

Tsort · 14/11/2022 23:01

Unclear on the purpose of returning to a thread you’ve barely contributed to…to announce that you’re out. Okay? What are you looking for, exactly? Oh, no! Please don’t go?

Shame the poster didn’t stick around to see she’d earned another queenly rebuke from unpleasant OP 😆

mangoesaretheonlyfruit · 15/11/2022 02:36

CousinKrispy · 14/11/2022 13:39

I think throwing around "internalized misogyny" is a bit reductive. Real life is complicated.

For example, I "followed tradition" but was perfectly aware it was a sexist tradition. I didn't go along with it because I was blind to it being a patriarchal tradition.

But it was not something I wanted to have a fight or create bad feeling about. To me, there were other issues in my marriage that were more important.

I needed to conserve my energy for those and eventually I was able to use that energy to do other more important things (e.g. break free from a shitty relationship, after having tried my utmost to make it work). Rocking the boat over what surname to use just wasn't high on the priority list.

Also my surname is one that gets misspelled, mispronounced, and sometimes mocked, especially in the UK. Why would I saddle my child with it? And personally I think double-barrelled names are pretentious (though if that's what someone else wants to do, fine.)

So it's a lot more complicated than pointing the finger and chortling over someone else's "internalized misogyny." I also shave my legs once every 3 months or so. I'm perfectly happy to admit that that's sexist too but I do it anyway because I don't live in some idealogically pure feminist world, I live in the real world, and I consider other things I do to have far more feminist impact than this issue.

This. All of this.

Notanotherusername4321 · 14/11/2022 23:09

How feasible would it have been for my partner to take my surname without us getting married, so we all had the same name? I always assumed this is not possible, so DC has to take one of our names

deed poll. Simple.

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 14/11/2022 23:08

@SophieIsHereToday that is interesting as I have also found similar as a woman, with the same surname as my childs, that I feel less exposed in parents evenings, medical appointments etc. I think it is partly because I do not stick out a single parent, which I am, and that does have lower societal expectations. However it is assumed that I am not a single parent, which is quite handy and avoids a lot of predjudice. My kids also feel very tied to me the ‘Banananas’ family, which makes me feel nice. Of course I didn’t know I’d end up a single parent!

Tsort · 14/11/2022 23:07

SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 22:36

Ah, I misunderstood this question when it was asked previously I think.

In my case, DP and I are not married. So we have different surnames to each other.

How feasible would it have been for my partner to take my surname without us getting married, so we all had the same name? I always assumed this is not possible, so DC has to take one of our names.

I think you can change your name whenever you want to whatever you want, either without or via deed poll. Not entirely certain, however.

Your relationship sounds strong, supportive, equitable and loving, though. As does @Notanotherusername4321’s. It’s disgusting what your partners have had to deal with.

OP posts:
Notanotherusername4321 · 14/11/2022 23:06

Not trying to be goady, this is a genuine question. I’m sorry you’ve had to experience those situations and it sounds horrible for the lovely sounding men you’ve married, but I don’t get why all of you having your last names wasn’t the solution

Did you read my post? I explained it.

because dh had had a shit time keeping an active parenting role with his kids from his 1st marriage and remaining involved with schools etc, as I explained.

to start he didn’t want to break the remaining link he had with them so changing his name was never an option. Second can you imagine the issues he’d have had phoning schools and gp’s with a different name to his kids? He’d have had to be producing the kids birth certs, his marriage cert and the letter showing PR before anyone would believe him. as it was you wouldn’t believe the documentation we had to produce even when he had the same name. So many refused to speak to him without his ex’s permission.

as an aside, when his ex got remarried she changed her name to her new husbands. Interesting how that fits into the “want the same name as my kids” reason for name changing.

IMissVino · 14/11/2022 23:02

SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 20:37

We did actually. I have a more unique name, which I like and am attached to (although it has its problems with spelling etc). All being equal we might have gone for my name as his is quite common and therefore he feels less of an identity with his name.

But the idea of my partner facing barriers/discrimination as being a very involved parent, made me sympathetic to the idea that having the same name might help him. For him to enter spaces which are mostly for women and children, he wanted to be connected by name to his child so the connection didn't need explaining. I'm hoping as our DC gets older that there will be more involved dad's and actually this wasn't necessary.

He's actually incredibly supportive of me being a "strong" woman and likes how I'm very determined to push through barriers. I think feeling his support on this for over a decade made me immediately want to support him when I could see him having similar barriers. Up until now, he's led a very stereotypical "male" life.

I think the patriarchy hurts those who don't conform to those societal expectations. Usually this affects women but not exclusively.

But yes, we did discuss it in depth and it wasn't clear at the beginning which name was best for us.

Sounds like an amazing partnership.

Tsort · 14/11/2022 23:01

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/11/2022 22:14

As MN threads go this one's unusual. As it's unfolded it's amounted to nothing more than a set of imperious demands for women to explain and justify their personal decisions to a complete stranger.

It doesn't work like that. You can create a thread: you don't get to dictate everything others post on it. Conversations evolve, or they stagnate as this one has.

Frankly I'm amazed so many people have gone along with the didactic tone and queenly rebukes on this thread. Naming discussions interest me as a rule, but this is beyond tedious. I'm out. 🥱

Unclear on the purpose of returning to a thread you’ve barely contributed to…to announce that you’re out. Okay? What are you looking for, exactly? Oh, no! Please don’t go?

OP posts:
supersonicginandtonic · 14/11/2022 22:45

@MarieIVanArkleStinks it's ridiculous isn't it? If you give a child the fathers surname, your weak, have no self-esteem, it's due to misogyny etc etc.
They can't accept that some of us just don't give a shit. We have 4 different surnames in our house, it's never been an issue, it's just a name after all 🤷‍♀️
I just respect what other people call their kids.

SophieIsHereToday · 14/11/2022 22:36

Ah, I misunderstood this question when it was asked previously I think.

In my case, DP and I are not married. So we have different surnames to each other.

How feasible would it have been for my partner to take my surname without us getting married, so we all had the same name? I always assumed this is not possible, so DC has to take one of our names.