Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 16/11/2022 10:38

I wonder whether women feel less attached to their surnames because they are conditioned from a very young age to believe that they are only temporary, until they get married and take their husband's name, whereas men haven't grown up with this expectation that they would change theirs anyway one day so no point getting too attached.

babyjellyfish · 16/11/2022 10:38

I wonder whether women feel less attached to their surnames because they are conditioned from a very young age to believe that they are only temporary, until they get married and take their husband's name, whereas men haven't grown up with this expectation that they would change theirs anyway one day so no point getting too attached.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 16/11/2022 09:02

On principle I would have given DC my surname, but I actually hate my surname and DH has a beautiful surname, so I happily gave them his. I put mine as one of their middle names.

Delatron · 16/11/2022 08:58

Well we decided to have kids first then get married. But when we did get married I decided his name didn’t work with mine and Iiked my name! To be fair - he offered to take my name - but by then the kids had his name. I was going to double barrel. But the bottom line is - all the admin put me off.

It doesn’t bother me too much as I know he would have been supportive whatever I said I wanted to do.

Algor1thm · 16/11/2022 08:51

@Tsort oh you are the OP. Well you asked for people's reasoning, clearly just because you wanted to find all the women who've passed on their husband's names then tell them how wrong they were 😂 Here I was thinking you might actually be interested in the thought process, but you're actually here telling women what they should and shouldn't be doing. Why do you care what names other people give their children? Bizarre.

Algor1thm · 16/11/2022 08:47

Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:37

I didn’t say you should have pushed for anything. I asked you why, in your opinion, your husband cared and you didn’t and whether you recognised the fact that people’s feelings/attachment to their last names is often so gendered is essentially patriarchy in action.

And, again, is adhering to patrilineal naming conventions not just kicking the can down the road for your daughter(s)? The expectation that they will at some point change their names? Why do you think the choice of which of their two names to pass on is somehow problematic for kids, but you’re fine with female children ultimately not passing on their last name at all? I’m afraid I’m not following your logic.

It's up to my daughter what she does, completely her choice. Everyone has a choice to make about this if they choose to get married and have kids. My choice has no bearing on hers. Interestingly, I have my mum's surname not my dad's and yet chose to take my husband's. Perhaps part of that was that I hated growing up in a family where we had different surnames. But gives an indication that there's certainly no automatic pressure to do what your mum did.

I'm not here to argue about whether I made the right choice or not. I'm certainly not here saying that all women should take their husband's surname. I'm saying it's about choice. OP asked why I made the decision I did and I gave my personal reasons (for me and my family, not yours or anyone elses).

sagalooshoe · 15/11/2022 23:41

We'd been together 10 years already and thought we'd get married at some point. He died though out of the blue.

Tsort · 15/11/2022 23:38

SophieIsHereToday · 15/11/2022 23:32

This is interesting.

But could it be super simple. Boys have been brought up to believe they will keep their name and have a family who take their name. Girls are brought up too think their name is not permanent.

Taught this long enough, it's a deep assumption. Like a religious belief. Hard for people, especially men, to shake.

Of course this is still a patriarchal construct but maybe it just is because people have learnt it so young

I agree with you, but I also see how what @Bananasinpyjamas21 is describing could be a massive factor. It’s probably all of these things, to greater or lesser degree for different people, within different contexts.

I can’t find any research on this from this perspective, but I’d love it if some existed. As it’s not my specific area, here’s hoping that perhaps this thread will inspire someone to do some. 😊

OP posts:
SophieIsHereToday · 15/11/2022 23:32

Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:26

I get what you mean. If there were any such research, it would make fascinating reading. I’ll see what I can dig up.

This is interesting.

But could it be super simple. Boys have been brought up to believe they will keep their name and have a family who take their name. Girls are brought up too think their name is not permanent.

Taught this long enough, it's a deep assumption. Like a religious belief. Hard for people, especially men, to shake.

Of course this is still a patriarchal construct but maybe it just is because people have learnt it so young

Tsort · 15/11/2022 23:02

JustLyra · 15/11/2022 22:57

Yeah, off the top of my head I can think of 2 that did and also 1 that double barrelled, but the kids only had her name.

I’m glad for them. I honestly don’t know of any man that has done this for those reasons (I know one that double barrelled, but that was because they both wanted both of their names). I was having a conversation upthread about men with abusive backgrounds and the reasons they almost never drop their last names (as opposed to women). So, it’s good to hear that some men are managing to shed the mantle of hurt.

OP posts:
Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:57

Puppyseahorse · 15/11/2022 22:47

Has anyone ever heard of a man who really hates his name/ prefers his wife’s name/ doesn’t want to be reminded of his father and so chooses not to pass on his name to his children?

I don’t know a single one.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 15/11/2022 22:57

Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:54

Interesting. Did any of these men take their wives’ last names?

Yeah, off the top of my head I can think of 2 that did and also 1 that double barrelled, but the kids only had her name.

Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:54

JustLyra · 15/11/2022 22:51

I know a few from a support group (we all had abusive parents).

Of the 12 only 1 gave their children their surname. Most gave their partners names, including at least 4 guys, and a few picked completely new family names.

Interesting. Did any of these men take their wives’ last names?

OP posts:
JustLyra · 15/11/2022 22:51

Puppyseahorse · 15/11/2022 22:47

Has anyone ever heard of a man who really hates his name/ prefers his wife’s name/ doesn’t want to be reminded of his father and so chooses not to pass on his name to his children?

I know a few from a support group (we all had abusive parents).

Of the 12 only 1 gave their children their surname. Most gave their partners names, including at least 4 guys, and a few picked completely new family names.

Puppyseahorse · 15/11/2022 22:47

Has anyone ever heard of a man who really hates his name/ prefers his wife’s name/ doesn’t want to be reminded of his father and so chooses not to pass on his name to his children?

Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:37

Algor1thm · 15/11/2022 21:52

I appreciate my feelings didn't develop in a vacuum, but should I have pushed for us all to have my surname even though I literally didn't care? How bizarre would that be.

See above, how do you make the decision which of your surnames to pass on? You're back at having to make a decision about whose surname gets to live on...

I didn’t say you should have pushed for anything. I asked you why, in your opinion, your husband cared and you didn’t and whether you recognised the fact that people’s feelings/attachment to their last names is often so gendered is essentially patriarchy in action.

And, again, is adhering to patrilineal naming conventions not just kicking the can down the road for your daughter(s)? The expectation that they will at some point change their names? Why do you think the choice of which of their two names to pass on is somehow problematic for kids, but you’re fine with female children ultimately not passing on their last name at all? I’m afraid I’m not following your logic.

OP posts:
Soproudoflionesses · 15/11/2022 22:31

Cos my maiden name is shit!! Couldn't wait to get rid of it and wouldn't want to inflict it on a small child.

Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:31

Algor1thm · 15/11/2022 21:49

In Spanish culture the grandmother's surname is dropped and the grandfather's name is ultimately passed on. How is that less sexist? By what method are you supposed to choose which of your two double barrelled names to pass on? You're right back to square one.

Nope. You can choose to pass on either last name from either parent. So not sexist at all.

And, again, why do you think the choice of which of their two names to pass on is somehow problematic for kids, but you’re fine with female children not passing on their last name at all?

OP posts:
Tsort · 15/11/2022 22:26

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 15/11/2022 21:28

I think it would be really interesting to scratch beneath the surface, beyond the ‘my name was awkward’, ‘I just wasn’t bothered but DH was’…
They aren’t really the real reason, otherwise we would have 50/50, but there are patriarchal and with that psychological reasons too aren’t there?

Wanting to feel attached, part of a team, part of a family. And as it’s the male name, wanting to feel attached or part of them, to relinquish a bit of responsibility to the man? I’m not being provocative, I can see the attraction in a way. I’ve struggled holding everything together for years by myself, single parent, the earner, the main parent, everything. Sometimes that fantasy of a childhood of a Prince who just takes care of everything… it’s quite pervasive still in society look at ‘Pretty Woman’ etc films.

And perhaps that is why it is still important, as divorce rates are high, men aren’t necessarily staying for their kids, it’s a protective factor? (and I know there are women who leave etc, but on the whole women are left with the kids).

Also, is it a way to say, look I want you the man to stick around for these kids. I the woman is usually the main carer, we are pregnant and give birth, so I want you to feel really connected too through them having your name.

My DH was married before and they all took his name, including his wife. His wife is still very attached to the name and years after divorce hasn’t changed it. She’s mentioned to me a few times that she is Ms DH, once when we were at a family gathering and someone called me and DH ‘Mr and Mrs DH’ (I took no offence) but Ex overheard and took great offense. At first I found it quite awkward but sometimes I now think, well it was simpler for his Ex, and made DH feel strongly that he had a role. Our names are quite meaningful I guess.

I wonder if there is any interesting research out there about those deeper psychological meanings?

I get what you mean. If there were any such research, it would make fascinating reading. I’ll see what I can dig up.

OP posts:
Algor1thm · 15/11/2022 21:52

Tsort · 15/11/2022 20:47

I didn't care about giving up my name and my husband did.

Why do you think that is, though? It’s been discussed throughout the thread, but why do you think so many women don’t care about giving up their name and so many men to? Patriarchy. You can make any choices you wish, but you should acknowledge that said choices do not exist in a vacuum.

It's also kicking the can down the road. When your child has a child, which names do they pass on and which do they drop? Do they combine to give a quadruple barrelled name? Does the next generation go for eight?

Two points, here. Is adhering to patrilineal naming conventions not just kicking the can down the road for your daughter(s)? The expectation that they will at some point change their names?

Secondly, quite a lot of the world has double barrelled names for thousands of years. Nobody is right barrelled yet. People keep their birth names for their entire lives and pass on one of their last names to their kids. So, Jane Smith Jones and Tim Green Brown would have kids with the last names ‘Smith Green’ or ‘Jones Brown’, depending on which name their parents wanted to pass down.

I appreciate my feelings didn't develop in a vacuum, but should I have pushed for us all to have my surname even though I literally didn't care? How bizarre would that be.

See above, how do you make the decision which of your surnames to pass on? You're back at having to make a decision about whose surname gets to live on...

AFS1 · 15/11/2022 21:51

Because I really hate my surname!

Algor1thm · 15/11/2022 21:49

Notanotherusername4321 · 15/11/2022 20:57

To me, double barrelled surnames are unnecessarily long and convoluted. Mine and my husband's would have been 5 syllables long. It's also kicking the can down the road. When your child has a child, which names do they pass on and which do they drop? Do they combine to give a quadruple barrelled name? Does the next generation go for eight?

ask the Spanish?

they seem to have managed well enough with the double barrel method of naming 🤷‍♀️

the UK way isn’t the only way to do things.

In Spanish culture the grandmother's surname is dropped and the grandfather's name is ultimately passed on. How is that less sexist? By what method are you supposed to choose which of your two double barrelled names to pass on? You're right back to square one.

PoctorDepper · 15/11/2022 21:43

At the time, it mattered a lot more to DS's father than it did to me. Then after a year of having a different name to my son I couldn't stand it anymore and changed MY name to match my sons surname. Two years after that, his dad and I split up and now I'm stuck with my exes name because I don't want a different name to my son and would need XPs permission to change it, which there is no way in hell he would do.

Little lad is 7 now, so have learned to live with it.

Cuppasoupmonster · 15/11/2022 21:30

There’s no deeper psychological meaning with mine, it doesn’t sound very nice and I constantly get asked how it’s spelt. DH’s just sounds nicer, that was it 🤷🏼‍♀️ no patriarchy in this house, he does all nappy changes when I breastfeed, we’re taking shared parental leave and on a balance he probably does more of the hands on childcare than I do.

Bananasinpyjamas21 · 15/11/2022 21:28

I think it would be really interesting to scratch beneath the surface, beyond the ‘my name was awkward’, ‘I just wasn’t bothered but DH was’…
They aren’t really the real reason, otherwise we would have 50/50, but there are patriarchal and with that psychological reasons too aren’t there?

Wanting to feel attached, part of a team, part of a family. And as it’s the male name, wanting to feel attached or part of them, to relinquish a bit of responsibility to the man? I’m not being provocative, I can see the attraction in a way. I’ve struggled holding everything together for years by myself, single parent, the earner, the main parent, everything. Sometimes that fantasy of a childhood of a Prince who just takes care of everything… it’s quite pervasive still in society look at ‘Pretty Woman’ etc films.

And perhaps that is why it is still important, as divorce rates are high, men aren’t necessarily staying for their kids, it’s a protective factor? (and I know there are women who leave etc, but on the whole women are left with the kids).

Also, is it a way to say, look I want you the man to stick around for these kids. I the woman is usually the main carer, we are pregnant and give birth, so I want you to feel really connected too through them having your name.

My DH was married before and they all took his name, including his wife. His wife is still very attached to the name and years after divorce hasn’t changed it. She’s mentioned to me a few times that she is Ms DH, once when we were at a family gathering and someone called me and DH ‘Mr and Mrs DH’ (I took no offence) but Ex overheard and took great offense. At first I found it quite awkward but sometimes I now think, well it was simpler for his Ex, and made DH feel strongly that he had a role. Our names are quite meaningful I guess.

I wonder if there is any interesting research out there about those deeper psychological meanings?