Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
TiredButDancing · 16/11/2022 17:01

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 16:54

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

all I’ll say is that if you think women get it easy when they change their first name, or plan to change their surname when they’re not getting married then you’re very, very much mistaken.

To be clear, I'm talking about women changing their name on marriage because of "abuse". My point was, and still is, that it's almost always abused women who say, "I took my DH's name because I didn't want my dad's name" never abused men who say, "I took DW's name because I didn't want my dad's name". As per my BIL example - he hates his dad but still fought with SIL to ensure she gave their DC his name.

I suspect anyone, man or woman, who chooses to change their name outside of the standard convention of marriage, would be asked questions. But if it's done for marriage, it's the woman who tends to do it not the men and who always seems to have a reason.

MalagaNights · 16/11/2022 16:59

Because it's traditional to do so here.

Because I'm married to him.

I like tradition and didn't see a need to make a statement on this issue.

Our relationship is strong and equal, not every decision needs to be about a symbolic statement against the patriarchy.

What a tiresome and pointless way that would be to live.

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 16:54

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

all I’ll say is that if you think women get it easy when they change their first name, or plan to change their surname when they’re not getting married then you’re very, very much mistaken.

Notanotherusername4321 · 16/11/2022 16:48

I understand the point you're making but I instinctively disagree. I think it's more likely that abused women find it easier to change their names because the concept of a women changing her name is not considered weird in the same way that a man changing his name is

I agree. In my last job I managed a database and women would request access, then when I couldn’t find them on the system it was “teehee, I got married, it must be under my maiden name”. Infuriating.

but when one man changed his name to his new wife’s he was the talk of the company for months. Lots of not very nice comments about trousers and hens.

my name is difficult to spell and even harder to pronounce. However my dad died when I was 9 so I never considered changing it, never practiced writing mrs boy crush at school like my friends. It was simply never an option. I don’t have one moments regret not having the same name as my kids, in fact it has a surprising amount of positives.

TiredButDancing · 16/11/2022 16:33

@JustLyra I understand the point you're making but I instinctively disagree. I think it's more likely that abused women find it easier to change their names because the concept of a women changing her name is not considered weird in the same way that a man changing his name is.

If a woman changes her name, there is seldom a single question asked. If a man changes his name, lots of questions are asked. There's also this slightly odd societal view that a man's name is sooo important and that might be partly why your brother doesn't feel he can change it.

I'm not for a second saying he MUST change it. Just that I'm not convinced that women changing their names in the case of abuse is because they are stronger. It's simply less taboo for them to do so and therefore easier.

Tsort · 16/11/2022 16:33

magma32 · 16/11/2022 16:26

I didn’t realise this thread was still going but yep agree OP definitely rooted in patriarchal traditions, one way or another and for the majority I bet, not all obviously. I just don’t get how men seem to have all the cool names but women seem to have shit ones they don’t like or have negative associations with but men don’t seem to have that issue 🤷‍♀️

It died down, then rose again. The never ending thread. 😂

OP posts:
Tsort · 16/11/2022 16:29

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 16:24

So while I also totally respect anyone who makes this decision, it does seem to be abused women and girls who choose to give up their name more often than abused boys and men.

Which may actually be a sign of strength in the women.

One of my brothers hates our childhood surname. Absolutely detests it. Also hates his first name.

He’s chosen not to have children to avoid giving them his surname and refused to marry his partner for years unless she guaranteed she’d never change her name.

However, he’d never change his name because in his eyes that would let my father “win” and said multiple times “but what would people think”

I gave my girls ex’s surname with the intention of changing to that when we married. When that didn’t happen I planned to change my surname to something else when I turned 30, but by then I’d met DH and decided to go with his when we married.
I changed my first name informally at 14 when I moved school and legally at 18.

Yet when people look at him and I it’s somehow me that’s viewed as the weak victim of patriarchy because I changed my name…

Which may actually be a sign of strength in the women.

In our society, a woman changing her name doesn’t require strength, though. It is the widely accepted norm to which society expects one to conform. Whether or not you’re happy with said conformity is a personal choice, but conforming isn’t a difficult thing to do.

I don’t disagree with the rest of what you’ve said.

OP posts:
MsMarch · 16/11/2022 16:29

I said my main reason was that I didn't care and my husband did. You didn't like that answer.

I didn’t dislike it. I asked you why you thought that was. It’s not a particularly philosophical question, but clearly it’s not one that you liked very much.

I do think this is a key point whether we want to acknowledge it or not. WHY didn't you care when you husband did? And more relevantly, why is it that it is ALWAYS the men who care while the women don't? Could it possibly have anything to do with growing up surrounded by women who have changed their name while men don't? It's totally normalized.

G874 · 16/11/2022 16:27

I grew up in the same situation and it never bothered me!

G874 · 16/11/2022 16:27

I gave both of my DC's their dads last names simply because I have a horrible last name that isn't straightforward to spell. Coupled with my first name that is also hard to pronounce/spell I'd spend years correcting my name and didn't want to put my children through the same thing. Their dads (diff dads) have nice normal last names 😂
Obviously there is the fact that I will always have a different last name to my children but

magma32 · 16/11/2022 16:26

I didn’t realise this thread was still going but yep agree OP definitely rooted in patriarchal traditions, one way or another and for the majority I bet, not all obviously. I just don’t get how men seem to have all the cool names but women seem to have shit ones they don’t like or have negative associations with but men don’t seem to have that issue 🤷‍♀️

Tsort · 16/11/2022 16:24

TiredButDancing · 16/11/2022 16:15

This is very very interesting. BIL has used his traumatic and difficult childhood that included being abandoned by a waste of a father, as an excuse to be a victim his whole life. And yet, now that you mention it, I note that not only has he continued to use his own surname, he massively and totally guilted SIL into using his surname for their DC, even though they weren't married and she would have liked them to have her name.

So while I also totally respect anyone who makes this decision, it does seem to be abused women and girls who choose to give up their name more often than abused boys and men. n fact, I had a friend at university whose step dad had adopted him (with all that implies re his birth father) and given him his name but my friend legally changed his name back to his birth dad's as soon as he could.

What you’ve described with your BIL seems fairly common, sadly. And, I completely agree, it does seem to be abused women and girls who choose to give up their name more often than abused boys and men.

The situation your uni mate sounds particularly sad.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 16/11/2022 16:24

So while I also totally respect anyone who makes this decision, it does seem to be abused women and girls who choose to give up their name more often than abused boys and men.

Which may actually be a sign of strength in the women.

One of my brothers hates our childhood surname. Absolutely detests it. Also hates his first name.

He’s chosen not to have children to avoid giving them his surname and refused to marry his partner for years unless she guaranteed she’d never change her name.

However, he’d never change his name because in his eyes that would let my father “win” and said multiple times “but what would people think”

I gave my girls ex’s surname with the intention of changing to that when we married. When that didn’t happen I planned to change my surname to something else when I turned 30, but by then I’d met DH and decided to go with his when we married.
I changed my first name informally at 14 when I moved school and legally at 18.

Yet when people look at him and I it’s somehow me that’s viewed as the weak victim of patriarchy because I changed my name…

Tsort · 16/11/2022 16:20

Algor1thm · 16/11/2022 16:08

I said my main reason was that I didn't care and my husband did. You didn't like that answer. I think on balance his surname is slightly nicer. You want me to give you some sort of philosophical answer and I don't have one for you unfortunately.

Clearly this was something you put a lot of thought into (and still are) and that's fine. But do you understand that for some people it isn't that big a deal? I picked my child's first name - that's something I care a lot more about. So I guess my husband and I had equal say.

I said my main reason was that I didn't care and my husband did. You didn't like that answer.

I didn’t dislike it. I asked you why you thought that was. It’s not a particularly philosophical question, but clearly it’s not one that you liked very much.

Clearly this was something you put a lot of thought into (and still are) and that's fine. But do you understand that for some people it isn't that big a deal?

I think it’s interesting, I started a thread to discuss it and that’s what a few of us are doing. If you don’t want to put thought into or discuss it, I’m certainly not forcing you to do so.

OP posts:
TiredButDancing · 16/11/2022 16:15

Tsort · 15/11/2022 23:02

I’m glad for them. I honestly don’t know of any man that has done this for those reasons (I know one that double barrelled, but that was because they both wanted both of their names). I was having a conversation upthread about men with abusive backgrounds and the reasons they almost never drop their last names (as opposed to women). So, it’s good to hear that some men are managing to shed the mantle of hurt.

This is very very interesting. BIL has used his traumatic and difficult childhood that included being abandoned by a waste of a father, as an excuse to be a victim his whole life. And yet, now that you mention it, I note that not only has he continued to use his own surname, he massively and totally guilted SIL into using his surname for their DC, even though they weren't married and she would have liked them to have her name.

So while I also totally respect anyone who makes this decision, it does seem to be abused women and girls who choose to give up their name more often than abused boys and men. n fact, I had a friend at university whose step dad had adopted him (with all that implies re his birth father) and given him his name but my friend legally changed his name back to his birth dad's as soon as he could.

GerbilsForever24 · 16/11/2022 16:12

Junipercrumble · 16/11/2022 15:36

I have never liked my surname. It is exactly the same as a household product and I was bullied mercilessly during my school years over it.
For that reason, I gave my DC their fathers surname despite us being unmarried and I'm so happy for them that they can go through life without watching people chuckle when they say their surname.
Think of it as a choice between 'microwave' and 'Evans'.

What did your brothers do? Because I don't doubt what you're saying, but I think this "my name is terrible" thing seems to disproportionately affect women. Ditto the "I don't want my father's name to be perpetuated".

Which, in my opinion, is just another sign of how insidious this patriarchy malarkey is. We're all so ingrained we think it's a choice rather than realising that it's a choice that's made after years of conditioning. I choose not to murder anyone. I truly believe that is the right choice. But of course, because my society says it's not okay to murder, that makes that choice a LOT easier than if I lived in a society where murder was normal.

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 16:10

Tsort · 15/11/2022 23:02

I’m glad for them. I honestly don’t know of any man that has done this for those reasons (I know one that double barrelled, but that was because they both wanted both of their names). I was having a conversation upthread about men with abusive backgrounds and the reasons they almost never drop their last names (as opposed to women). So, it’s good to hear that some men are managing to shed the mantle of hurt.

I probably see more of it because of circumstance and being involved with a group.

Names changes come up because a lot of people know I rid myself of the stupid first name my ridiculous parents gave me. So the whole palaver of changing name is something I’m used to

Algor1thm · 16/11/2022 16:08

Tsort · 16/11/2022 11:33

As above, I haven’t said you’re wrong to give your children any name. I have asked you questions about things you’ve said, which you’ve ignored and decided I was telling you what to name your children.

I do want people’s reasoning, so I think it’s interesting that you seem incapable of conversation about your choices in this respect, and that this is so recurrent on this thread.

I said my main reason was that I didn't care and my husband did. You didn't like that answer. I think on balance his surname is slightly nicer. You want me to give you some sort of philosophical answer and I don't have one for you unfortunately.

Clearly this was something you put a lot of thought into (and still are) and that's fine. But do you understand that for some people it isn't that big a deal? I picked my child's first name - that's something I care a lot more about. So I guess my husband and I had equal say.

Tsort · 16/11/2022 15:38

Junipercrumble · 16/11/2022 15:36

I have never liked my surname. It is exactly the same as a household product and I was bullied mercilessly during my school years over it.
For that reason, I gave my DC their fathers surname despite us being unmarried and I'm so happy for them that they can go through life without watching people chuckle when they say their surname.
Think of it as a choice between 'microwave' and 'Evans'.

Think of it as a choice between 'microwave' and 'Evans'.

Made me cackle! 😂

OP posts:
Junipercrumble · 16/11/2022 15:36

I have never liked my surname. It is exactly the same as a household product and I was bullied mercilessly during my school years over it.
For that reason, I gave my DC their fathers surname despite us being unmarried and I'm so happy for them that they can go through life without watching people chuckle when they say their surname.
Think of it as a choice between 'microwave' and 'Evans'.

babyjellyfish · 16/11/2022 15:24

I said earlier in this thread that my reasoning largely came down to my name not being an easy one to have in the country where I live, and not wanting to burden a new person with it.

Ironically, if I had had a double barreled surname, as my mum wanted, I would be able to drop half of it and use my mum's birth name, which is easier to spell and pronounce here.

My husband and his brothers are all married to foreign women. We have all kept our surnames, and all, so far, given the children our husband's surnames. One of my sisters in law has also given her children first and middle names which betray absolutely no sign of their other culture, whereas it is really important to me that my culture is represented in my children's given names. I suspect that comes down to racism, as the culture she comes from is viewed in quite a negative way, whereas British culture is not.

I hope that my daughter, if she ever marries, keeps her birth surname. Even though it is not mine and I have no personal stake in it. It will be part of her identity from birth, and I don't want her to feel it's only a borrowed name.

Tsort · 16/11/2022 11:33

Algor1thm · 16/11/2022 08:51

@Tsort oh you are the OP. Well you asked for people's reasoning, clearly just because you wanted to find all the women who've passed on their husband's names then tell them how wrong they were 😂 Here I was thinking you might actually be interested in the thought process, but you're actually here telling women what they should and shouldn't be doing. Why do you care what names other people give their children? Bizarre.

As above, I haven’t said you’re wrong to give your children any name. I have asked you questions about things you’ve said, which you’ve ignored and decided I was telling you what to name your children.

I do want people’s reasoning, so I think it’s interesting that you seem incapable of conversation about your choices in this respect, and that this is so recurrent on this thread.

OP posts:
Tsort · 16/11/2022 11:27

Algor1thm · 16/11/2022 08:47

It's up to my daughter what she does, completely her choice. Everyone has a choice to make about this if they choose to get married and have kids. My choice has no bearing on hers. Interestingly, I have my mum's surname not my dad's and yet chose to take my husband's. Perhaps part of that was that I hated growing up in a family where we had different surnames. But gives an indication that there's certainly no automatic pressure to do what your mum did.

I'm not here to argue about whether I made the right choice or not. I'm certainly not here saying that all women should take their husband's surname. I'm saying it's about choice. OP asked why I made the decision I did and I gave my personal reasons (for me and my family, not yours or anyone elses).

It's up to my daughter what she does, completely her choice. Everyone has a choice to make about this if they choose to get married and have kids.

The same way it would be completely the kids’ choices which name they passed on, if they were double barrelled. So, why is only one of those options ‘kicking the can down the road’, according to you? I keep asking, but you’re not answering.

I'm not here to argue about whether I made the right choice or not. I'm certainly not here saying that all women should take their husband's surname. I'm saying it's about choice. OP asked why I made the decision I did and I gave my personal reasons (for me and my family, not yours or anyone else's).

Again, I haven’t asked you to defend your choice, nor have I said it was the wrong one. You don’t seem to understand what’s been said to you (quite a few times, now). Which is interesting.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 16/11/2022 11:22

Its interesting that same sex couples don't face this judgement regarding names. There are no expectations.

Misogyny is so deeply entrenched.

GerbilsForever24 · 16/11/2022 10:59

babyjellyfish · 16/11/2022 10:38

I wonder whether women feel less attached to their surnames because they are conditioned from a very young age to believe that they are only temporary, until they get married and take their husband's name, whereas men haven't grown up with this expectation that they would change theirs anyway one day so no point getting too attached.

Yes, absolutely. And anyone who doesn't see that this is the patriarchy at work is missing an important point. I didn't care as much about my DH's surname for the DC as he did. But of course that's because of the way the two of us were brought up and the messages we got practically from birth. I can acknowledge that and that the choices I make as a result are not made in a vacuum. I am not trying to convince myself that the choice was entirely mine and had nothing to do with wider societal issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread