Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
Tsort · 19/10/2022 01:15

user1477391263 · 19/10/2022 01:12

I AM married. Did not take his name, but did give the kids his surname. We live in Japan, and it's usual for bi-national kids to get the Japanese surname as it makes it more straightforward for them growing up here--even in cases where it's the mother who is Japanese, the kids nearly always take her Japanese surname here.

I think the rule for humanity should be, give the kids whichever surname is more suitable or just nicer, and this would also helpfully weed out some of the God-awful surnames that are out there.

I remember once watching a news segment about gender selection technology for conceiving a boy or a girl, and a guy with the surname Hollobone who had two daughters was interviewed on the news segment, and he was whinging on about how he wanted to have a son so he could "pass on my family name." I was like, who on earth would want to pass on the surname "Hollobone"? If you do have a son, your future daughter-in-law, if she has any sense, will insist on giving the kids her surname....!

I know a ‘Moist’ who was very cross when his wife wouldn’t take his name or agree to give it to the kids, or even hyphenate. It was a total dealbreaker and I don’t blame the poor woman.

I didn’t know that about bi-national kids in Japan, so thank you.

OP posts:
Tsort · 19/10/2022 01:13

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/10/2022 01:12

Because I knew what DD's first name would be and he didn't get any kind of say. I also chose the middle name. I threw him the surname, bless him. Grin

Fair. 😂

OP posts:
Tsort · 19/10/2022 01:12

Nizanb · 19/10/2022 01:06

It may be different for me because I only took on my current surname when I was 8 years old.

I have my original surname on my BC. That name didn't belong to my mother or my father (it's complicated), but was chosen by mum.

I ended up with a different name to my siblings, my mum, my dad, my grandparents.... I was the only person I knew in the entire family with that name. It always felt wrong, like I didn't "belong" in any line of the family.

I ended up living with my maternal grandmother and step-grandfather and decided I wanted to have the same last name as they did.

I guess that might make me more aware of where the name I chose to have came from. Step-GD and grandmother had children together with his surname so I do have relatives with this name now.

That totally makes sense. You actively chose your name, so of course its origins are key for you.

Mine has always just been…there. It feels like a key part of my person that was handed to me at birth, like my big toe or my wonky eyesight. Ride or die till the end. 😂

OP posts:
user1477391263 · 19/10/2022 01:12

I AM married. Did not take his name, but did give the kids his surname. We live in Japan, and it's usual for bi-national kids to get the Japanese surname as it makes it more straightforward for them growing up here--even in cases where it's the mother who is Japanese, the kids nearly always take her Japanese surname here.

I think the rule for humanity should be, give the kids whichever surname is more suitable or just nicer, and this would also helpfully weed out some of the God-awful surnames that are out there.

I remember once watching a news segment about gender selection technology for conceiving a boy or a girl, and a guy with the surname Hollobone who had two daughters was interviewed on the news segment, and he was whinging on about how he wanted to have a son so he could "pass on my family name." I was like, who on earth would want to pass on the surname "Hollobone"? If you do have a son, your future daughter-in-law, if she has any sense, will insist on giving the kids her surname....!

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/10/2022 01:12

Because I knew what DD's first name would be and he didn't get any kind of say. I also chose the middle name. I threw him the surname, bless him. Grin

supersonicginandtonic · 19/10/2022 01:09

Because I wanted too. All my kids have their dads names. I'm not bothered about my name in the slightest.

Nizanb · 19/10/2022 01:06

Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:54

I think the final question raises an interesting point, as I don’t think of our last names as ‘belonging’ to anyone other than me and my DH. Clearly this isn’t the case for lots of posters, but where the names ‘come from’ is utterly immaterial to me. My name is my name.

It may be different for me because I only took on my current surname when I was 8 years old.

I have my original surname on my BC. That name didn't belong to my mother or my father (it's complicated), but was chosen by mum.

I ended up with a different name to my siblings, my mum, my dad, my grandparents.... I was the only person I knew in the entire family with that name. It always felt wrong, like I didn't "belong" in any line of the family.

I ended up living with my maternal grandmother and step-grandfather and decided I wanted to have the same last name as they did.

I guess that might make me more aware of where the name I chose to have came from. Step-GD and grandmother had children together with his surname so I do have relatives with this name now.

Tsort · 19/10/2022 01:00

Georgeandzippyzoo · 19/10/2022 00:51

I agree with BecksOclock that some of your responses are coming across as judgemental, although you may not be meaning them too.
Comments such as those regarding using the term 'maiden ' name is because that's what it's known as, nothing more, not about being owned by your father (although it may the origins).
Other pp have similar negative tones. I've never felt that I was owned/belonged to any man. I was brought up to be my own person and see these as digs at my choices as if I'm not an independent person in my own right. Feel free to have differing view points but don't belittle others choices because they hold different ones to you.

I haven’t belittled anyone. Nor have I said anyone is wrong. I certainly haven’t mentioned anything about people being owned - I think you’ll find that’s your projection. What I’ve done is ask ‘why’?

If you think being asked why one has said or done something is a dig or belittling of said action, then that’s extremely unfortunate. However, I don’t accept your inference as my responsibility.

OP posts:
Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:54

Nizanb · 19/10/2022 00:49

Because he was the last person of child-bearing age in his family with his surname, whereas, in my family, there are a few people of the right age to have kids with my surname.

"His" surname is his mother's maiden name, and "my" surname is actually my step-grandfather's name, so which is less patriarchal really?

I think the final question raises an interesting point, as I don’t think of our last names as ‘belonging’ to anyone other than me and my DH. Clearly this isn’t the case for lots of posters, but where the names ‘come from’ is utterly immaterial to me. My name is my name.

OP posts:
Georgeandzippyzoo · 19/10/2022 00:51

Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:17

I have expressed my opinion in the comments. I’m interested enough to start an MN thread about it (not sure that qualifies as ‘so’ interested, tbh) and I’ve engaged with posters. I’ve seen lots of people’s POV and asked questions of others. As is the custom on threads.

Can I ask why this appears to discomfit you?

I agree with BecksOclock that some of your responses are coming across as judgemental, although you may not be meaning them too.
Comments such as those regarding using the term 'maiden ' name is because that's what it's known as, nothing more, not about being owned by your father (although it may the origins).
Other pp have similar negative tones. I've never felt that I was owned/belonged to any man. I was brought up to be my own person and see these as digs at my choices as if I'm not an independent person in my own right. Feel free to have differing view points but don't belittle others choices because they hold different ones to you.

Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:50

Confusion101 · 19/10/2022 00:44

I despise double barrelled names, and I like tradition. 😊

If you didn’t get married or got married and kept your name, tradition would be that DC took your name, though (this is based on the assumption that you’re in the U.K., which you obviously might not be).

OP posts:
Nizanb · 19/10/2022 00:49

Because he was the last person of child-bearing age in his family with his surname, whereas, in my family, there are a few people of the right age to have kids with my surname.

"His" surname is his mother's maiden name, and "my" surname is actually my step-grandfather's name, so which is less patriarchal really?

Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:48

BecksOclock · 19/10/2022 00:42

@Tsort does not discomfit me in the slightest.

I am just wondering about the reasoning behind your curiosity, that's all. I assumed this was a conversation, however where you've been asked a question, you've gotten defensive and answered by firing back a question (see your reply to me). Which I always find odd in a thread where someone is asking other people to be open and express their reasonings behind something. To then bounce back any questions asked of yourself just doesn't mix well in the conversation in my opinion. Although perhaps, a discussion wasn't your aim and you are simply wanting straight answers to your question. Which is fair enough.

But either way, you're entitled to be curious, of course.

You asked a question and I answered it, with a fair bit of detail. I then asked you a question. That’s ‘firing back a question’? Okay, then.

I wish you all the best in conversations that are more to your taste.

OP posts:
Cas112 · 19/10/2022 00:48

Because I wanted to

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 19/10/2022 00:46

I preferred his name? He didn't ask. He was actually surprised when I said his name with my 1st in hospital.

Confusion101 · 19/10/2022 00:44

I despise double barrelled names, and I like tradition. 😊

BecksOclock · 19/10/2022 00:42

@Tsort does not discomfit me in the slightest.

I am just wondering about the reasoning behind your curiosity, that's all. I assumed this was a conversation, however where you've been asked a question, you've gotten defensive and answered by firing back a question (see your reply to me). Which I always find odd in a thread where someone is asking other people to be open and express their reasonings behind something. To then bounce back any questions asked of yourself just doesn't mix well in the conversation in my opinion. Although perhaps, a discussion wasn't your aim and you are simply wanting straight answers to your question. Which is fair enough.

But either way, you're entitled to be curious, of course.

Caraoke · 19/10/2022 00:37

I didn't decide fully until we had the first baby in our arms and the combination of names we decided on just felt right. A first name I liked since I was a child, a middle name from my mum's family and his dad's surname. We're all important to him and any combination of names would have been fine, I wanted a name that would suit him/be him, rather than follow a rule or tradition just because. It was always 50/50 until then that he could have my name or his dad's but I just liked the 'ring' to that whole name, it felt like it was made for him once I met him.

I like oh's name, when I first met him I liked the 'ring' to his name too, it's a known name but not very common where we live, he was the first one I'd met. Whereas I've got an Irish name and live in Scotland where there's thousands of us. Also the opposing vowel sounds in the first name i loved and my surname were too jarring and they flowed much nicer with oh's name. If I had chosen a different first name he may have taken my name.

Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:34

Mangogogogo · 19/10/2022 00:30

12 years ago I gave my son my surname. 8 years ago I gave my daughter his!

so I’ve been on both sides and honestly it’s neither here nor there to me! By the time I had my daughter I wasn’t bothered as it really didn’t excite me that much having the same surname as my kids.

i also took in a child without my surname. My son with my surname doesn’t feel any more my child than the others so I guess I’m just indifferent to it all!

i wouldn’t double barrel as I personally don’t like it but honestly don’t care who’s surname anyones kids have. Give them a cool as fuck surname if you want! I would chose something like Targaryen 😁

I love that! Please meet, Adam Jones, Leila Mohammed (cultural approximations of DH and I’s names) and their daughter, Zara Lannister. 😂😂😂

OP posts:
Mangogogogo · 19/10/2022 00:30

12 years ago I gave my son my surname. 8 years ago I gave my daughter his!

so I’ve been on both sides and honestly it’s neither here nor there to me! By the time I had my daughter I wasn’t bothered as it really didn’t excite me that much having the same surname as my kids.

i also took in a child without my surname. My son with my surname doesn’t feel any more my child than the others so I guess I’m just indifferent to it all!

i wouldn’t double barrel as I personally don’t like it but honestly don’t care who’s surname anyones kids have. Give them a cool as fuck surname if you want! I would chose something like Targaryen 😁

Merryoldgoat · 19/10/2022 00:29

I’m married but kept my surname: Our sons have DH’s name. I just wanted people to know they were his and didn’t want questions about it.

I kept mt name simply because I like it. When I’m called Mrs (DH NAME) it doesn’t bother me - it wasn’t a statement about anything.

Dixiechickonhols · 19/10/2022 00:26

www.sheltons-solicitors.co.uk/blog/why-do-you-have-to-re-register-the-birth-of-your-child

Bit more info. I should say it’s for English Law.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 19/10/2022 00:25

Because my surname isn't mine, it's my ex husband's. I won't be going back to my maiden name so made no sense to give my kids that name. It's an unusual name and I don't think my kids would appreciate having it.

We were supposed to be getting married anyway so didn't really matter at the time, however I'm not sure I want to get married again and my DP would never push me to set a date, so currently both kids have his name and there's no wedding in sight.

Tsort · 19/10/2022 00:22

MistyGreenAndBlue · 19/10/2022 00:12

I'm surprised at a lot of these answers. Usually on threads where this comes up, most posters seem to think it's traditional to give a child the father's name. Even though a look through history clearly shows it isn't.

I've often wondered the same as you OP. I gave my child my name and nothing on this earth would have moved me on that.

But people can do what they want I guess. Some fascinating reasons on here too. Interesting insight.

Yes, some really interesting reasons that wouldn’t have occurred to me. And I’ve learnt about ‘legitimation by subsequent marriage’ which I had never heard of before.

OP posts:
doubtfulguest · 19/10/2022 00:19

A few reasons. Firstly, I felt sorry that he couldn't experience carrying and giving birth. Secondly, I felt it would hurt him if I didn't, even though I don't think he would have objected. Thirdly, it doesn't matter to me that we don't share a surname. Fourthly, I know it would have caused ill feeling with in laws and, while I will stick my neck out for something I feel strongly about, I didn't re this. Overall, I think I am not insecure about it as there is no doubt my son is mine, shared surname or not.