Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
Caiti19 · 19/10/2022 04:10

I never changed my name with marriage because it never made sense to me to do so. Even logistically with banking and stuff - just wasn't bothered with the admin and thought it was a bit archaic. Legally, my name never changed. Kids have husband's last name. I don't like double-barrelled names. I find them clunky and too-long. I've no issue with the system of kids taking Dad's last name. I will sign with family last name at times too when it comes to school forms to avoid confusion.

Cuppasoupmonster · 19/10/2022 04:08

Because it’s mine too, and it’s a nicer surname than my maiden name which is clunky and awkward.

JaneorEleven · 19/10/2022 04:02

When I had my DC, my husband was a single Dad. I wanted my stepson, and my DC to feel like siblings despite having different Mums. This was especially important as my stepson didn’t have much of a relationship with his mum, so I wanted to build up our family.
All the kids grew up close, called themselves the JaneHusband brothers. I made the right choice for our set up, but under different circumstances I’d have given my kids my name.

comfyshoes2022 · 19/10/2022 03:58

I am married but kept my maiden name. I didn’t want my child to have a long/complicated double barreled name. And I am enough of a traditionalist that I wanted to go with my DH’s name. I was also worried that if we used my surname that people wouldn’t think DH was DC’s father.

Shitfather · 19/10/2022 03:55

Religious reasons. Deeply regret it as ex is a cunt. I blindly did it and belittled myself by not thinking through it. DS has asked to have my surname as his.

freckles20 · 19/10/2022 03:16

SavoirFlair · 19/10/2022 02:41

@Tsort Are you one of those people who post on Facebook

“Has anyone ever had to engage a financial advisor to track down hidden assets?” - no other context - and then you get a flurry of

“OMG you ok Hun? What’s happened?
“what?? Call me?”
”Are you breaking up?!”

of course generating dozens more comments than if you’d put an explanation of your situation and not been cryptic.

People have politely asked you why you want to know about this. Many OPs on here give a little to get back. You give a little context, because it encourages people to empathise and understand .

From your replies to peoples “why?” you’ve been deliberately short, dismissive and supercilious (Google it).

I would say YABU but I think you want me to somehow.

Ignore the comment above OP. You can give as much or as little context as you wish.

If someone doesn't want to respond to your question without more information they are free to move on.

Allthatmularkey · 19/10/2022 03:12

Partner and I (unmarried) each have our own surnames. When I was finally pregnant I was so bloody happy and felt so bonded to my unborn baby, and knew I would be taking a year of Mat leave off work, so I felt a bit like the cat who'd got the cream. Giving DC my DP's surname felt like an act of sharing. Seemed to make sense at the time. I'm generally pretty anti doing things coz they are patriarchy-normative, but I can see how this appears so, even though it didn't feel like that was my motivation at the time. If that makes sense?

freckles20 · 19/10/2022 03:11

Because I had a sinking feeling that his Dad wouldn't be in his life as much as I would.

I was right.

Sharing a surname has linked them together.

His Dad hasn't been as involved as me, which is a disappointment to me, but they love each other fiercely and I know how important his Dad is to DS.

He doesn't have to be a perfect Dad to be an important person in DS' life.

I'm glad that DS has his Dad's surname.

Dox9 · 19/10/2022 03:00

I am married and kept my name. Dc have dh's name. We live in his native country and both my first and last names are noticeably foreign. I hate having to spell out my name multiple times whenever people don't get it. However, I didn't take my dh name when I married because the concept of taking your dh's name did not sit right with me.
Based on my experience I was very keen on my dc having common names that most people know how to spell and pronounce. Choosing a local common last name (dh's) made sense to me.
Separately, my home country does not legally allow double-barrelled last names to be given to children. I could double-barrel mine on marriage (no thanks) but not dc's.

Relevanceiskey · 19/10/2022 02:58

SavoirFlair · 19/10/2022 02:41

@Tsort Are you one of those people who post on Facebook

“Has anyone ever had to engage a financial advisor to track down hidden assets?” - no other context - and then you get a flurry of

“OMG you ok Hun? What’s happened?
“what?? Call me?”
”Are you breaking up?!”

of course generating dozens more comments than if you’d put an explanation of your situation and not been cryptic.

People have politely asked you why you want to know about this. Many OPs on here give a little to get back. You give a little context, because it encourages people to empathise and understand .

From your replies to peoples “why?” you’ve been deliberately short, dismissive and supercilious (Google it).

I would say YABU but I think you want me to somehow.

@SavoirFlair I would actually argue a number of the "why do you want to know" comments seem very defensive of the fact the PP's have given their children their partners name...

Your whole post is very patronising and clearly designed to embarass OP/put them down. That's not a very nice trait to have is it. Do you always belittle people you don't agree with to seem "cooler"? Are you hoping lots of people jump on the "omg hero!!!" "Absolutely this^" train?

Why does OP have to have a specific reason to be curious about this subject?

Of course everyone is allowed to do what they want and people have plenty of good reasons for giving their partners names to their children. However - it's definitely an interesting subject to visit in 2022 where women are fighting back against these patriarchal traditions, as there is definitelyan argument for it being an outdated tradition with sexist undertones.

alotoftutus · 19/10/2022 02:41

I felt no connection to my own surname. I was given my dads surname and didn't have a relationship with him. When my parents had my brother 12 years after me (they were unmarried) my mum decided to give him her surname. I hated that I had a different name to my mum / brother and the side of the family I actually saw.

It actually really upset me having a different name to my children too - probably more so because IT was an issue I had carried from my childhood anyway. I did eventually end up marrying my children's father so we all have the same name now.

SavoirFlair · 19/10/2022 02:41

@Tsort Are you one of those people who post on Facebook

“Has anyone ever had to engage a financial advisor to track down hidden assets?” - no other context - and then you get a flurry of

“OMG you ok Hun? What’s happened?
“what?? Call me?”
”Are you breaking up?!”

of course generating dozens more comments than if you’d put an explanation of your situation and not been cryptic.

People have politely asked you why you want to know about this. Many OPs on here give a little to get back. You give a little context, because it encourages people to empathise and understand .

From your replies to peoples “why?” you’ve been deliberately short, dismissive and supercilious (Google it).

I would say YABU but I think you want me to somehow.

magma32 · 19/10/2022 02:25

@Tsort thanks I know others don’t mind having different surnames but in my situation it translated deeper than this, it really was a patriarchal thing, it makes me cringe now but I am stronger and wiser and actually see myself as the matriarch now haha. Wish I didn’t have to learn some lessons to get to this place but I guess that’s how it goes.

Reallyreallyborednow · 19/10/2022 02:14

Because as a woman having a different surname to kids is less likely to cause an issue.

a man travelling alone with kids, taking them to the GP, A&E, engaging with school etc is more likely to be viewed with suspicion if he has a different name. Assumed to be stepdad etc.

i took a stepchild to a&e once. It was automatically assumed I was mum, despite different surnames, and I had to point out I did not have PR and couldn’t consent to treatment.

i also like the degree of separation. It helped me keep my identity as a seperate person and not just mum. I don’t get added to social media or what’s app groups- they add dh instead 😂.

Beyondshit · 19/10/2022 02:04

It's amazing how many men's names are 'nicer' and 'easier to spell'. Every time, on every thread like this.

Ottersmith · 19/10/2022 02:01

Because women are trained to pander to men and men expect to have everything their way without putting in half as much effort. Completely crazy. I know so many women who's children have got their fathers surname even if they never see them and not the same name as their primary caregiver. Talk about accepting your place as a second class citizen. No way would I ever do that.

Carouselfish · 19/10/2022 01:54

Easier to spell, felt it gave me a bargaining chip re. more sway over first names, would never double barrel as think just sounds painfully pretentious when they are just common names.

Dustyblue · 19/10/2022 01:48

Really interesting thread.

I fall into your category OP. I would never change my own name but bowed to convention in giving DS my DP's surname (not married, together 22 years).

Don't like double barrel names, to me they sound pretentious unless they go way back historically.

I just couldn't think of a better way of doing it, but I like some of the suggestions here. And it really surprises me how many people these days are still confused that I have a different surname than my son (at the doctor's etc). Would've thought it's very common now!

StarfishBrain · 19/10/2022 01:37

Untitledsquatboulder · 18/10/2022 23:26

I didn't. I changed my name when we were married and I gave the children my name.

There's always one.

Is this what the OP asked?

StarfishBrain · 19/10/2022 01:36

The adoption thing never made sense to me either, but we were told he'd have to legally adopt them when we got married in order to change their names of they had mine. So we gave them his. And then never married.

This is total nonsenss. Children's names can be changed by deed poll as long as both parents agree.

Euridicefortuna · 19/10/2022 01:32

Redrumridesagain · 18/10/2022 23:35

Because we're a family, and we all have the same name.

This response always makes me laugh.My mum kept her name but we are/were still a family as half of my chromosomes were inherited from her and she raised me.My dads male pride wasn't hurt either and they had a good marriage; till death did them part.

SophieIsHereToday · 19/10/2022 01:27

Double barrel was long. He was worried about people assuming they aren't related and the sexism that might go with that. A man picking up a child with a different name is more likely to concern others.

I've experienced plenty of sexism and so am sympathetic when it goes the other way

Notcreativeatall · 19/10/2022 01:20

Because

  1. It was really important to him and not to me
  2. My name is difficult- I'd suffered with it as a child and didn't really want DS to do the same
  3. My name relates to my heritage- for DS its a less significant part of his- so he would have had a name that refers to 1/4 of his heritage which he'd constantly have to explain
  4. In theory my surname has a masculine and feminine version so to be totally correct DS'd have to have the masculine one which then wouldn't be the same as either my name or his dads
user1477391263 · 19/10/2022 01:18

I've been asked the past "What reverse culture shock do you get when you come back to the UK after living in Japan?" Most people assume I freak out about people wearing shoes in the house and things like that.

To be honest, one major culture shock for me about the UK, is this weird attitude that marriage is a sort of icing-on-the-cake-y type thing where you sort of think about maybe doing it after you've had the baby. It's just.... weird to me, like observing the anthropologically-interesting habits of a remote village in the Amazon rainforest. Like, why would any woman take such a risk?

I've lived my entire adult life outside the UK and this icing/cake attitude towards marriage was nowhere near as common in the 90s, when I was growing up in the UK. So yes. It makes me scratch my head.

Bumply · 19/10/2022 01:16

Because his name was shorter and easier to say and spell.

Swipe left for the next trending thread