Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you gave DC his last name?

488 replies

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:10

If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tsort · 18/11/2022 13:08

Algor1thm · 18/11/2022 13:06

She's an absolute delight 😂

That must be why you keep coming back. 😂

@WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie’s post sums it up beautifully.

OP posts:
Algor1thm · 18/11/2022 13:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

She's an absolute delight 😂

Tsort · 18/11/2022 12:39

WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie · 18/11/2022 12:29

OP: "If you aren't married/kept you own name, why did you give your DCs their dads name."

PPs: " I gave them my name" or "I took my husbands name and gave it to our dc too"

OP: "ummm... thanks. But that's not what I asked"

PPs: "you're so rude. We're only answering the question..."

Next time I see a thread asking "if you're 5ft 7 and a size 14, how much do you weigh" I'm going to answer that I'm not 5ft 7, or a size 14 but weigh x.
Or if someone asks which shampoo is best for curly hair ill tell them that I don't have curly hair but I use L'Oréal.

I mean I'm only answering the question. My answer is irrelevant, but I'm answering anyway.

This is perfection. Thank you. 🤣🤣🤣

OP posts:
WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie · 18/11/2022 12:29

OP: "If you aren't married/kept you own name, why did you give your DCs their dads name."

PPs: " I gave them my name" or "I took my husbands name and gave it to our dc too"

OP: "ummm... thanks. But that's not what I asked"

PPs: "you're so rude. We're only answering the question..."

Next time I see a thread asking "if you're 5ft 7 and a size 14, how much do you weigh" I'm going to answer that I'm not 5ft 7, or a size 14 but weigh x.
Or if someone asks which shampoo is best for curly hair ill tell them that I don't have curly hair but I use L'Oréal.

I mean I'm only answering the question. My answer is irrelevant, but I'm answering anyway.

Tsort · 18/11/2022 12:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Again, all been painstakingly explained to you.

And, yes, please do.

OP posts:
Bellaboo01 · 18/11/2022 12:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tsort · 18/11/2022 11:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Abraxan · 18/11/2022 10:51

I teach siblings at school at the moment. I thought they looked very similar, we're only a year and a bit apart, but had different surnames so wasn't sure.

Turns out that the eldest has dad's surname and the youngest has mum's surname. Parents are unmarried and that's how they decided to get round the surname dilemma. White British, so not a culture based decision and both children are the same sex, so not liked to that either.

Never known if it before.

Bellaboo01 · 18/11/2022 10:47

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:56

I’m not ‘picking apart’ anything. I asked a straightforward question that isn’t applicable to you. You (despite allegedly understanding the question) decided to…just write something anyway?

I don’t care why you took your husband’s last name, which is why I didn’t ask. And, as you did, I am also not interested in why your kids have his last name. If you decide to ‘go off on your own tangent’ and answer questions nobody asked, be prepared for people to assume you misunderstood the actual question.

'People' - you mean you!

You are clearly just coming across as aggressive for some reason to many of the people who have totally innocently replied to your post.

Hope you've 'calmed down' a bit today - it's nearly the weekend!

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:58

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 17/11/2022 16:52

I should probably explain, I simplified things a bit to stop my original post from becoming an essay. Basically, the first either of us knew we were having a baby was when my DP went into labour. (Think Sonia on Eastenders Christmas special).

We were two under 25s less than 11 months into a relationship that wasn't going that well, and suddenly there was a baby in the middle of it. We talked about adoption in the first 24 hours, we talked at length about our future in those first 10 days or so.

DP was going to be the primary caretaker to start with, even if we stayed together. She was living with her parents and there was no room for me. I was living in a houseshare with 2 other people. It took us 4 months to get to a point where we could live together, and more importantly were sure we wanted to live together.

By the time we took DD to be registered at 2 weeks or whatever it was, DP had bonded with her. I hadn't really. I wasn't at the house all the time, and when I was, DP and her parents were on top of everything, had everything worked out, and I was trying to work out my relationship with my child whilst also feeling like I was intruding. I knew I wanted to be involved, knew I wanted this child, but she was a responsibility to me, she wasn't a person yet. I think to DP, giving her my last name was a way to try to prove that link, that bond

That all seems perfectly fair, then (not that you need my sign off). I’m pleased everything worked out for you!

OP posts:
Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:56

Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:50

I explained WHY i didnt keep my surname which in-turn explained WHY my kids have their Dad's name!

Geeezzz - lightenup!

I’m not ‘picking apart’ anything. I asked a straightforward question that isn’t applicable to you. You (despite allegedly understanding the question) decided to…just write something anyway?

I don’t care why you took your husband’s last name, which is why I didn’t ask. And, as you did, I am also not interested in why your kids have his last name. If you decide to ‘go off on your own tangent’ and answer questions nobody asked, be prepared for people to assume you misunderstood the actual question.

OP posts:
fdgdfgdfgdfg · 17/11/2022 16:52

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:29

That’s interesting.

Partner said that if we split up, then daughter would be spending bulk of time with her (which I thought was fair enough with a young child), so she wanted me to have the surname bond with her.

This starts from a premise that I’m not really comfortable with. The common assumption that women will be the primary caretakers in the case of a split and men the secondary or NRP needs to be examined, imo. Unless we’re talking about a breastfed babe in arms, then why?

However, great that you found something that works for you.

I should probably explain, I simplified things a bit to stop my original post from becoming an essay. Basically, the first either of us knew we were having a baby was when my DP went into labour. (Think Sonia on Eastenders Christmas special).

We were two under 25s less than 11 months into a relationship that wasn't going that well, and suddenly there was a baby in the middle of it. We talked about adoption in the first 24 hours, we talked at length about our future in those first 10 days or so.

DP was going to be the primary caretaker to start with, even if we stayed together. She was living with her parents and there was no room for me. I was living in a houseshare with 2 other people. It took us 4 months to get to a point where we could live together, and more importantly were sure we wanted to live together.

By the time we took DD to be registered at 2 weeks or whatever it was, DP had bonded with her. I hadn't really. I wasn't at the house all the time, and when I was, DP and her parents were on top of everything, had everything worked out, and I was trying to work out my relationship with my child whilst also feeling like I was intruding. I knew I wanted to be involved, knew I wanted this child, but she was a responsibility to me, she wasn't a person yet. I think to DP, giving her my last name was a way to try to prove that link, that bond

Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:50

Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:46

Blimey!! you are strict!! The usual Mumsnet police, pickiin apart an innocent comment - ha ha!

I still didn't misunderstand the actual question, just went off on my own tangent!

I explained WHY i didnt keep my surname which in-turn explained WHY my kids have their Dad's name!

Geeezzz - lightenup!

Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:46

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:33

The question is: If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

It’s explicitly directed at women who do not have the same last name as their husband.

Blimey!! you are strict!! The usual Mumsnet police, pickiin apart an innocent comment - ha ha!

I still didn't misunderstand the actual question, just went off on my own tangent!

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:33

Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:27

I didn't misunderstand the question.

Just that my children took my surname because i have the same surname as my husband! I should have been clearer probably (just explained why i had the same name as my H).

The question is: If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

It’s explicitly directed at women who do not have the same last name as their husband.

OP posts:
Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:29

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 17/11/2022 15:15

I'm a father whose daughter has my last name instead of my partners.

We were together less than a year when our daughter was born (Very happy accident). We'd both said we were uninterested in marriage, and weren't even living together at that point.

I just assumed that she'd have her mothers name, to the point that when we finally decided it would sound stupid with her last name (think Lois Lane, Lana Lang, Pepper Potts type alliteration), at which point partner said she wanted her to have my surname. I was surprised, we were both being very sensible about the fact that this was a very short relationship that'd had an absolute bomb dropped on it, and we were under no illusions that we'd definitely still be together in 3 months time.

Partner said that if we split up, then daughter would be spending bulk of time with her (which I thought was fair enough with a young child), so she wanted me to have the surname bond with her. I didn't really have an argument against it, so thats what happened.

15 years later, we're still together, still not married, daughter still has my surname and not her Mums. We have the "marriage" conversation once a year, its become a tradition at this point, and have never decided its worth changing the status quo.

Purely from a logistics point of view, I'm so glad that daughter has my surname. As a father you get questioned so much more about your relationship with a child.

For instance, me and daughter went to the Harry Potter studio tour last year. Partner couldn't have been less interested so just the two of us went. Stayed in a hotel the night before, and even with the same surname on the booking, I still got questioned on my relationship to my daughter, and receptionist confirmed with daughter too.

That’s interesting.

Partner said that if we split up, then daughter would be spending bulk of time with her (which I thought was fair enough with a young child), so she wanted me to have the surname bond with her.

This starts from a premise that I’m not really comfortable with. The common assumption that women will be the primary caretakers in the case of a split and men the secondary or NRP needs to be examined, imo. Unless we’re talking about a breastfed babe in arms, then why?

However, great that you found something that works for you.

OP posts:
Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:27

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:24

I think you’ve misunderstood the question.

I didn't misunderstand the question.

Just that my children took my surname because i have the same surname as my husband! I should have been clearer probably (just explained why i had the same name as my H).

Tsort · 17/11/2022 16:24

Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:23

I changed my surname to my husband's when we married 20 years ago because i wanted to.....I could....so i did.

I like his surname and i fancied a change :)

I like the sentiment/tradition behind it but, i'm not sure why.

I think you’ve misunderstood the question.

OP posts:
Bellaboo01 · 17/11/2022 16:23

I changed my surname to my husband's when we married 20 years ago because i wanted to.....I could....so i did.

I like his surname and i fancied a change :)

I like the sentiment/tradition behind it but, i'm not sure why.

Algor1thm · 17/11/2022 15:41

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 17/11/2022 15:15

I'm a father whose daughter has my last name instead of my partners.

We were together less than a year when our daughter was born (Very happy accident). We'd both said we were uninterested in marriage, and weren't even living together at that point.

I just assumed that she'd have her mothers name, to the point that when we finally decided it would sound stupid with her last name (think Lois Lane, Lana Lang, Pepper Potts type alliteration), at which point partner said she wanted her to have my surname. I was surprised, we were both being very sensible about the fact that this was a very short relationship that'd had an absolute bomb dropped on it, and we were under no illusions that we'd definitely still be together in 3 months time.

Partner said that if we split up, then daughter would be spending bulk of time with her (which I thought was fair enough with a young child), so she wanted me to have the surname bond with her. I didn't really have an argument against it, so thats what happened.

15 years later, we're still together, still not married, daughter still has my surname and not her Mums. We have the "marriage" conversation once a year, its become a tradition at this point, and have never decided its worth changing the status quo.

Purely from a logistics point of view, I'm so glad that daughter has my surname. As a father you get questioned so much more about your relationship with a child.

For instance, me and daughter went to the Harry Potter studio tour last year. Partner couldn't have been less interested so just the two of us went. Stayed in a hotel the night before, and even with the same surname on the booking, I still got questioned on my relationship to my daughter, and receptionist confirmed with daughter too.

Good point. I grew up with my mum's surname and my parents were separated. We had an absolute nightmare every time he took us on holiday. Several times we were taken into a separate room to be questioned about him. Once they nearly didn't let us over a border in Europe and my dad had to get my mum on the phone before they'd let us go.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 17/11/2022 15:15

I'm a father whose daughter has my last name instead of my partners.

We were together less than a year when our daughter was born (Very happy accident). We'd both said we were uninterested in marriage, and weren't even living together at that point.

I just assumed that she'd have her mothers name, to the point that when we finally decided it would sound stupid with her last name (think Lois Lane, Lana Lang, Pepper Potts type alliteration), at which point partner said she wanted her to have my surname. I was surprised, we were both being very sensible about the fact that this was a very short relationship that'd had an absolute bomb dropped on it, and we were under no illusions that we'd definitely still be together in 3 months time.

Partner said that if we split up, then daughter would be spending bulk of time with her (which I thought was fair enough with a young child), so she wanted me to have the surname bond with her. I didn't really have an argument against it, so thats what happened.

15 years later, we're still together, still not married, daughter still has my surname and not her Mums. We have the "marriage" conversation once a year, its become a tradition at this point, and have never decided its worth changing the status quo.

Purely from a logistics point of view, I'm so glad that daughter has my surname. As a father you get questioned so much more about your relationship with a child.

For instance, me and daughter went to the Harry Potter studio tour last year. Partner couldn't have been less interested so just the two of us went. Stayed in a hotel the night before, and even with the same surname on the booking, I still got questioned on my relationship to my daughter, and receptionist confirmed with daughter too.

Tsort · 17/11/2022 14:13

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/11/2022 13:51

See, my instinct here is to make an argument in support of my assertion. But actually, reviewing it, and given your response, I think I was wrong. I'd say she's making a point, but that it's not really relevant given the way you framed your question.

So...yeah...I got it mixed up. Apologies...

No worries at all! We all miss stuff/get mixed up occasionally.

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/11/2022 13:51

Tsort · 17/11/2022 13:27

You think? The question was: If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

In what way does Because we're a family, and we all have the same name answer that and what question does it ask of me?

See, my instinct here is to make an argument in support of my assertion. But actually, reviewing it, and given your response, I think I was wrong. I'd say she's making a point, but that it's not really relevant given the way you framed your question.

So...yeah...I got it mixed up. Apologies...

Tsort · 17/11/2022 13:27

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/11/2022 13:18

I think she’s understood the question perfectly, and the answer is intended to ask a question of you.

You think? The question was: If you kept your name/aren’t married, but gave DC their father’s last name (as opposed to double barrelling or giving them you own), may I ask why?

In what way does Because we're a family, and we all have the same name answer that and what question does it ask of me?

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/11/2022 13:18

Tsort · 18/10/2022 23:38

I don’t think you’ve understood the question.

I think she’s understood the question perfectly, and the answer is intended to ask a question of you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread