Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brexit got Britain done

181 replies

katmeouws · 18/10/2022 22:10

Thats it really.

OP posts:
user1477391263 · 19/10/2022 04:27

The problems facing the UK are not "caused by BREXIT" for the most part (the whole world is a bit of a shit-tip right now), but BREXIT is certainly exacerbating pretty much all of them and making them a lot worse.

I think we're going to have to commit to rejoining, humiliating through it will be. It will take a long time though.

Can't wait for a Labour govt. I'm not naive enough to imaging the problems will go away, but just unfreezing relations with the EU would feel like a step forward.

Walkaround · 19/10/2022 04:23

Liebig · 19/10/2022 00:11

There was a good Vice documentary on canvassing the whole spectrum of voters in the UK at the time, and it did a better job of conveying the underlying sentiment than the Beeb or ITV did, or even Channel 4 half the time.

This was, of course, when Vice was actually good. LBC also had a lot of soul searching post-Brexit vote to figure out just how they got it so wrong.

I genuinely don't think a lot of people on my side of the vote put any more thought into it outside of I like things how they are and everyone else can do one.

Meanwhile, got guys in Blackpool being told they've never had it so good being part of the world's largest trading bloc, so they better not rock the boat.

And yes, this all became a shitshow, but nothing pisses me off more than people unobjectively going with the status quo and thinking any opposing view is purely Active Measures from the other side.

This is how you get Le Pen almost being voted in in France, or Five Star, Trump or any number of other movements that are railing against the establishment by utilising populist anger at the very well off making out like crooks on a system that, actually, isn't as great as many would have you think.

It will be painful to break up the system as it is, but when you've got nothing to lose, who gives a shit?

The death throes of neoliberalism are pretty apparent now. Hell, look at how much Biden's lot are trying to instigate hostilities with China. Guessing the military industrial complex sees dollar signs after Ukraine and wouldn't mind a little branching out.

Or our leaders are just that fucking stupid. I mean...

I think an awful lot of people who thought they had nothing to lose are realising they still had plenty more to lose. And nobody liked things as they were. Some people recognised, though, that the destabilising effect of Brexit for Europe was a lose-lose for everyone. At a time when the world has never needed unity and co-operation more, the UK chose to accelerate the growth of discord. Brexit was never going to advantage anyone except hedge fund managers and disaster capitalists, and Putin and Trump thought it was an excellent idea - there’s nothing like weakening your competitors for leaders like that. You only had to look at who around the world was most welcoming of the Brexit vision to know it was not people or countries with kindly intent towards the UK.

NicolaSixSix · 19/10/2022 00:42

Liebig · 18/10/2022 23:40

The currency was being devalued long before Brexit, and was massively overvalued in most respects. Try again.

As for rejoining, you‘ll want to reconsider with the economic numbers coming out. They’ve got bigger problems to deal with presently, like trying to get through the next 12 months with any industry.

Macron is basically looking at the proverbial gravity assisted razor outcome of his actions, and Germany’s coalition has single-handedly ruined German heavy industry.

Also, Deutsche Bank being raided almost weekly now. Nothing to see here.

@Liebig do provide sources, please - I haven’t seen anything about Germany’s heavy industry being ruined? Or riots in the last 24h?

Morceaux · 19/10/2022 00:22

When we’re at the point when even The Telegraph are publishing articles about how “Project Fear” was right (and if anything, did not go far enough) surely there can’t be that many Brexit-believers left?

Liebig · 19/10/2022 00:15

worriedatthistime · 19/10/2022 00:05

@Liebig I don't care whose next to be honest but its time for a change
How i see it is they all screw you over if your in the middle one way or the other
Wish some new parties would emerge really
And the thing I would like most is for manifestos to be legally binding , so people actually get what they voted for

I think this past week has shown that the manifestos are soundly in the hands of those who ally themselves with bond vigilantes and other finance and corporate overlords.

No one I've seen so far has the balls to actually address these things, because no after Corbyn crashed and burned is going to have the vision to look past the current paradigm and imagine better.

Might as well temper expectations, hence, Labour get in and more or less follow the muted "growth" plan that Trussonomics shat out and Hunt moulded into being Turbo Austerity instead.

And when that fails, hoo boy, if you think the Tories were a little populist and fash then I can't wait to see what comes after people become fully disillusioned with the two main parties after two decades of no prosperity growth (which, by the way, no one can change regardless).

Liebig · 19/10/2022 00:11

worriedatthistime · 19/10/2022 00:03

@ChocFrog its funny how most remainers think anyone who voted brexit is clueless , why did you vote remain? I personally was remain but I know some very clever people who voted leave and actually listened to them and their reasons rather than accuse them of being thick, etc
Maybe remain could of one if more people had listened rather than assume

There was a good Vice documentary on canvassing the whole spectrum of voters in the UK at the time, and it did a better job of conveying the underlying sentiment than the Beeb or ITV did, or even Channel 4 half the time.

This was, of course, when Vice was actually good. LBC also had a lot of soul searching post-Brexit vote to figure out just how they got it so wrong.

I genuinely don't think a lot of people on my side of the vote put any more thought into it outside of I like things how they are and everyone else can do one.

Meanwhile, got guys in Blackpool being told they've never had it so good being part of the world's largest trading bloc, so they better not rock the boat.

And yes, this all became a shitshow, but nothing pisses me off more than people unobjectively going with the status quo and thinking any opposing view is purely Active Measures from the other side.

This is how you get Le Pen almost being voted in in France, or Five Star, Trump or any number of other movements that are railing against the establishment by utilising populist anger at the very well off making out like crooks on a system that, actually, isn't as great as many would have you think.

It will be painful to break up the system as it is, but when you've got nothing to lose, who gives a shit?

The death throes of neoliberalism are pretty apparent now. Hell, look at how much Biden's lot are trying to instigate hostilities with China. Guessing the military industrial complex sees dollar signs after Ukraine and wouldn't mind a little branching out.

Or our leaders are just that fucking stupid. I mean...

worriedatthistime · 19/10/2022 00:05

@Liebig I don't care whose next to be honest but its time for a change
How i see it is they all screw you over if your in the middle one way or the other
Wish some new parties would emerge really
And the thing I would like most is for manifestos to be legally binding , so people actually get what they voted for

Foronenightonly01 · 19/10/2022 00:05

But you’ve almost always got more dollar for your pound than that have for a Euro….that makes no sense🤷🏼‍♀️. I’m off to bed….not going to argue with # …

worriedatthistime · 19/10/2022 00:03

@ChocFrog its funny how most remainers think anyone who voted brexit is clueless , why did you vote remain? I personally was remain but I know some very clever people who voted leave and actually listened to them and their reasons rather than accuse them of being thick, etc
Maybe remain could of one if more people had listened rather than assume

Liebig · 19/10/2022 00:02

worriedatthistime · 19/10/2022 00:00

@Liebig the even more worrying thing is its not looking like we have much better in the opposition, unless they can pull something out of the bag
We had austerity whilst in the eu as well
The eu doesn't make you exempt from problems like people seem to think

I voted for Jezza, but we can't have filthy communists running things. We got no more, see? Spent it all.

So now we can have either Red Team or Blue Team enforced and enhanced super austerity. I, personally, want Red Team because they're the best, even if blue is a great colour.

Liebig · 19/10/2022 00:01

worriedatthistime · 18/10/2022 23:58

@Liebig your wasting your time , people like this only see what they want and what suits their narrative
Like those who think we can just rejoin , like the eu don't even get a say
Brexit was never going to be a smooth ride and even of successful it wasn't going yo ever be in one year or two, anyone would realise that

I may just move on to the next hilarious folks: the Scottish nationalists. Surely they'll do a better Brexit?

Which is galling as I have Scots ancestry in me.

worriedatthistime · 19/10/2022 00:00

@Liebig the even more worrying thing is its not looking like we have much better in the opposition, unless they can pull something out of the bag
We had austerity whilst in the eu as well
The eu doesn't make you exempt from problems like people seem to think

ChocFrog · 18/10/2022 23:58

StarfishBrain · 18/10/2022 23:06

I do wonder what our grandchildren will learn about Brexit in their history lessons. I mean, what the hell did people expect to happen?! It has to be one of the most stupid things a democratic country has ever decided to do. Utterly idiotic in every way. The effects will still be felt even then if somebody in Government doesn't at least find a braincell and rejoin the single market. I can't imagine the grandchildren will be any more impressed than young adults today.

Yep.

The real lesson to take from it though is how easily and enthusiastically Britain voted for a man who’d been sacked more than once for dishonesty - because he promised them everything would be great.

What future politicans have learned is that the winner is the person who tells the biggest lie. That’s dangerous. ☹️

worriedatthistime · 18/10/2022 23:58

@Liebig your wasting your time , people like this only see what they want and what suits their narrative
Like those who think we can just rejoin , like the eu don't even get a say
Brexit was never going to be a smooth ride and even of successful it wasn't going yo ever be in one year or two, anyone would realise that

Liebig · 18/10/2022 23:56

Linning · 18/10/2022 23:49

I do think pre-Brexit, was the last time the UK was taken seriously on both the international and political scene, yes.

I don’t necessarily think Brexit is behind every single thing that has gone wrong with the UK in the last couple of years as both Covid and the war have had clear impacts of their own, BUT Brexit definitely was the beginning of the downwards public spiral of UK politicians making the choice to put their ego above the good of the country and just making worse and worse decisions as they went to save face even if there is no way to save face after so many poor decisions were purposefully made in such a short period of time.

I think pre-Brexit, the UK was a prestigious influential country with its flaws but well-regarded internationally, probably in many ways “at the top of its game.” Now, and without wanting to cause offense, it’s turned a bit into a laughing stock. It’s hard to take seriously an island-nation that has voted against its best interest and which nobody actually want or know how to lead and that seem to be each day a bit more driven to the ground.

It’s rough because Brexit has made the UK dependent on seeming appealing to other countries outside the EU and it’s very hard to feel like investing into the UK or to see the appeal in the UK or it as still competitive when things are in the state they currently are.

The first sensible post I've seen in here.

The total lack of leadership and competence in the ruling elite of this nation is a much bigger concern right now. As we are now seeing.

Liebig · 18/10/2022 23:55

StarfishBrain · 18/10/2022 23:47

Person who uses currency devaluation to talk about Brexit, but conveniently misses the Euro dropping even more than Sterling.

It hasn't.

Which is lower?

Brexit got Britain done
worriedatthistime · 18/10/2022 23:54

@Kendodd well pretty much the opening post is and many haven't mentioned the other issues just
Brexit
I mean come on things like a match to rejoin , to people understand that you can't just re join ffs

Linning · 18/10/2022 23:49

I do think pre-Brexit, was the last time the UK was taken seriously on both the international and political scene, yes.

I don’t necessarily think Brexit is behind every single thing that has gone wrong with the UK in the last couple of years as both Covid and the war have had clear impacts of their own, BUT Brexit definitely was the beginning of the downwards public spiral of UK politicians making the choice to put their ego above the good of the country and just making worse and worse decisions as they went to save face even if there is no way to save face after so many poor decisions were purposefully made in such a short period of time.

I think pre-Brexit, the UK was a prestigious influential country with its flaws but well-regarded internationally, probably in many ways “at the top of its game.” Now, and without wanting to cause offense, it’s turned a bit into a laughing stock. It’s hard to take seriously an island-nation that has voted against its best interest and which nobody actually want or know how to lead and that seem to be each day a bit more driven to the ground.

It’s rough because Brexit has made the UK dependent on seeming appealing to other countries outside the EU and it’s very hard to feel like investing into the UK or to see the appeal in the UK or it as still competitive when things are in the state they currently are.

Liebig · 18/10/2022 23:49

StarfishBrain · 18/10/2022 23:46

Did you miss the UKIP movement that forced their hand?

No, it did not. UKIP had a couple of MPs at their peak? Everyone could have safely ignored the nutters - if they cared about the country more than their political party of course.

The EU was nowhere in voter's top 10 concerns whatsoever for decades.

Why don't you try again.

Yeah, no. This was not something that just popped up 12 months before Brexit happened.

Again, the immigration and destitution in the areas I'm familiar with was definitely a driving factor and this was well before 2016.

worriedatthistime · 18/10/2022 23:48

@Foronenightonly01 someone can have a different opinion and actually present some facts and not be a bot , rather than just the one line its all brexit

Fawful · 18/10/2022 23:48

Can't be dealing with that faux brown-red shit... I thought that died a long time ago. Night.
(You're full of beans for a Tuesday night @liebig!)

StarfishBrain · 18/10/2022 23:48

Honestly, I am so depressed that some people are this thick.

Off to bed now.

TooBigForMyBoots · 18/10/2022 23:48

worriedatthistime · 18/10/2022 23:41

Are people actually aware of issues around the world incl europe
Brexit will have played a part but add a pandemic and then a war and you have much bigger problems
Actually its now harder to actually see the impact brexit alone would of had

The damage was predicted and came true, but people were told to shut up, they just weren't BeLeaving enough and moved out of government. The actual bill for the divorce is eye-watering and rising.

StarfishBrain · 18/10/2022 23:47

Person who uses currency devaluation to talk about Brexit, but conveniently misses the Euro dropping even more than Sterling.

It hasn't.

StarfishBrain · 18/10/2022 23:46

Did you miss the UKIP movement that forced their hand?

No, it did not. UKIP had a couple of MPs at their peak? Everyone could have safely ignored the nutters - if they cared about the country more than their political party of course.

The EU was nowhere in voter's top 10 concerns whatsoever for decades.

Why don't you try again.