Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brexit got Britain done

181 replies

katmeouws · 18/10/2022 22:10

Thats it really.

OP posts:
Liebig · 19/10/2022 09:26

Fawful · 19/10/2022 09:15

France is not in recession; some people are on strike which is inconvenient, but that's what we do in France... imagine what they would do if they had a government like Truss's causing that spike in interest rates for no good reason after being put in power by 0.2% of the population. Applying a weird plan she has no mandate for. They would actually overthrow it!
If not because we elected a corrupt politician on the back of a Brexit slogan, who then had to be replaced, then how in your opinion did we in the UK end up in this situation of facing self-inflicted austerity, with a joke PM who is no longer even governing?

France is going to run out of diesel at this rate. If the Americans stop exports, then Europe is up the proverbial creek for distillate fuel.

And EdF still has strikes going on despite their nuclear fleet falling apart and not meeting the deadlines needed to ensure capacity factors are met for winter.

Just as America also sinner technically in recession, the news coming out is so bad that it’s inevitable now. Only the clueless economists who got shocked by 2008 happening are saying things are peachy.

Liebig · 19/10/2022 09:23

Kendodd · 19/10/2022 09:20

Fuck those that “knew what they were voting for” or do we have compassion?

I don't have compassion for Leave voters anymore. We're six years down the line, they've seen the danger they've put the fragile peace in NI in and they don't give a shit. And as for being racist, we most (not 100%) Leave voters I know are racist, why should I have compassion for people who think anyone foreign or brown should 'fuck off home'?

Vote Leave have pretty much shut down their Facebook page but if you don't believe how racist lots of Leave voters are you should take a look at that. People even celebrating the Grenfell fire with very few descending voices. I think they had two million followers at one point. This caricature of Leave voters being racist, it hasn't come from nowhere.

And yet, most of the Leave areas were the ones that took the most immigrants. Don’t be fooled by this racist diatribe, it doesn’t reflect well.

I guess, judging by the examples on here, that all the Remainers are genuinely all PMC middle class metropolitan elites who hate that their comfy positions have been impacted by the plebs wanting change.

See, I also have anecdotal evidence to support my chosen narrative.

Kendodd · 19/10/2022 09:20

Fuck those that “knew what they were voting for” or do we have compassion?

I don't have compassion for Leave voters anymore. We're six years down the line, they've seen the danger they've put the fragile peace in NI in and they don't give a shit. And as for being racist, we most (not 100%) Leave voters I know are racist, why should I have compassion for people who think anyone foreign or brown should 'fuck off home'?

Vote Leave have pretty much shut down their Facebook page but if you don't believe how racist lots of Leave voters are you should take a look at that. People even celebrating the Grenfell fire with very few descending voices. I think they had two million followers at one point. This caricature of Leave voters being racist, it hasn't come from nowhere.

Fawful · 19/10/2022 09:15

France is not in recession; some people are on strike which is inconvenient, but that's what we do in France... imagine what they would do if they had a government like Truss's causing that spike in interest rates for no good reason after being put in power by 0.2% of the population. Applying a weird plan she has no mandate for. They would actually overthrow it!
If not because we elected a corrupt politician on the back of a Brexit slogan, who then had to be replaced, then how in your opinion did we in the UK end up in this situation of facing self-inflicted austerity, with a joke PM who is no longer even governing?

Liebig · 19/10/2022 09:07

Hoppinggreen · 19/10/2022 09:05

Same here, we have done well out of it for a variety of reasons.
I still voted to Remain and really wish we had.
I DO think it’s partly responsible for the mess The UK is in now, not least because since Cameron Tory cabinets have been based on how Pro Brexit you are rather than any knowledge or ability

The Brexit Beast requires blood sacrifices every now and then. Ultimately, you see where that gets you when all you have are yes men and the best sycophants and ideologues, and no objectively competent leaders.

Hoppinggreen · 19/10/2022 09:05

Ihatethenewlook · 18/10/2022 23:44

Brexit is the best thing to ever happen to us as a family

Same here, we have done well out of it for a variety of reasons.
I still voted to Remain and really wish we had.
I DO think it’s partly responsible for the mess The UK is in now, not least because since Cameron Tory cabinets have been based on how Pro Brexit you are rather than any knowledge or ability

Wiluli · 19/10/2022 09:05

Liz1tummypain · 19/10/2022 08:13

I don't know if anyone can separate the effect of Brexit from COVID and now Ukraine. Is Europe generally in a better place ? I' d genuinely like to know.

Yes it is at the moment . At no stage we saw empty supermarkets , the energy crisis is there too but not to the extend of the U.K. either and above all none of the EU countries I visited or have family in have this gut wrenching feeding of going backwards with power cuts and having no money for basics as heating up the house .

Luckydip1 · 19/10/2022 09:04

Hopefully one of the political parties will have the balls to build closer trading ties with Europe, not reversing Brexit that will not happen for a generation unfortunately.

Liebig · 19/10/2022 09:00

Walkaround · 19/10/2022 04:23

I think an awful lot of people who thought they had nothing to lose are realising they still had plenty more to lose. And nobody liked things as they were. Some people recognised, though, that the destabilising effect of Brexit for Europe was a lose-lose for everyone. At a time when the world has never needed unity and co-operation more, the UK chose to accelerate the growth of discord. Brexit was never going to advantage anyone except hedge fund managers and disaster capitalists, and Putin and Trump thought it was an excellent idea - there’s nothing like weakening your competitors for leaders like that. You only had to look at who around the world was most welcoming of the Brexit vision to know it was not people or countries with kindly intent towards the UK.

The problem is, and as Vice and others picked up at the time or not long after, the messaging over this was completely fucked. Telling the masses reckoning on doing a rebel vote against the system that they’re racist or just stupid does not endear them to your cause.

It’s well known in psychology that people will spite themselves if they feel preyed upon or taken advantage of. The UK upper echelons and, even myself as a middle class professional, got a good taste of crab mentality because we didn’t effectively show the good side of being in the EU, only the Armageddon of leaving.

What happened after may or may not give one floating rights, but keep in mind those same people going “told you so” probably also post about the thousands going to suffer poverty or die because the economy is in tatters. So which is it? Fuck those that “knew what they were voting for” or do we have compassion?

Liebig · 19/10/2022 08:55

NicolaSixSix · 19/10/2022 00:42

@Liebig do provide sources, please - I haven’t seen anything about Germany’s heavy industry being ruined? Or riots in the last 24h?

France is going into general strike mode. Many loathe Macron’s administration.

List of companies insolvent this week.

Just BASF reducing output is a major issue. Anything energy intensive is cutting back or shuttering to keep the lights on.

Schulte · 19/10/2022 08:19

Liz1tummypain · 19/10/2022 08:13

I don't know if anyone can separate the effect of Brexit from COVID and now Ukraine. Is Europe generally in a better place ? I' d genuinely like to know.

A little bit. My home country has also suffered; I see reports of things running out in supermarkets, everyone has been told to save as much energy as they can, the government is worried about a winter Covid wave. But there were things that were easier because the country is part of the EU. For example, people could still travel relatively freely and visit other EU countries during Covid when the UK’s borders were closed. The petrol stations never ran out of petrol. And there seems to be some optimism that with gas storage nearly full, they will be ok over the winter.

notimagain · 19/10/2022 08:16

@NicolaSixSix

do provide sources, please - I haven’t seen anything about Germany’s heavy industry being ruined? Or riots in the last 24h?

I suspect the "riots" in Paris line comes from events in Paris yesterday where members of the so called Black Bloc got up to their old tricks of attaching themselves to a Trade Union demo and then causing trouble (as they do).

The reason for the march itself isn't austerity, though inflation has recently become an issue in the debate, the dispute that triggered the march has roots in a long standing argument over pay for tanker drivers and the Governments wish to force them to go back to work.

Lonelycrab · 19/10/2022 08:14

Blimey one poster obviously has too much time on their hands- almost half the thread is them! Reminds me of a certain other pro Brexit poster…

Brexit always was a shit idea, it’s just most people realise that now, and not just some people.

Where are the trade deals promised? Oh, turns out they don’t actually exist in reality. Well unless you count the really shit ones we signed with Aus/Nz.

Liz1tummypain · 19/10/2022 08:13

I don't know if anyone can separate the effect of Brexit from COVID and now Ukraine. Is Europe generally in a better place ? I' d genuinely like to know.

Walkaround · 19/10/2022 08:08

No point bickering over which leader was the most incompetent - it’s really silly to vote for massive change when you think the people who will be carrying it out are incompetent (or fantasists).

Walkaround · 19/10/2022 07:59

Florenz · 19/10/2022 07:19

Nothing "started with Brexit".
Brexit was a result of a very large amount of people being dissatisfied with how things were. If the government (successive governments) had not ignored the wishes of a large part of the electorate for decades, Brexit wouldn't have happened.

You can't write it off as a few ignorant, poorly educated people voting for something they didn't understand when 17 and a half million people voted for it.

The stupidity of Brexit had nothing whatsoever to do with IQ. That’s like claiming Nazi Germany only happened because Germans were all stupid, or Trump only happened because Americans are stupid, or all Russians are stupid because they have Putin. That not everyone who votes for or supports a situation is stupid doesn’t mean that some choices made in history aren’t fucking stupid. Anyone who voted for Brexit anticipating it would result in any improvements in their life rather than just accelerating an already inevitable decline (caused by precious short termism and self-centredness) made a stupid choice - doesn’t at all mean they have a low IQ. It does mean they removed yet more obstacles to the actual cause of the country’s decline, though. Kwasi Kwarteng doesn’t have a low IQ. He has certainly made some ludicrous choices..

CantFindTheBeat · 19/10/2022 07:42

Fawful · 18/10/2022 23:33

It hardly matters, @Liebig. The fact is that following the Brexit vote the UK got lumbered with increasingly incompetent leaders, that have made the country a hell of a lot worse than it needed to be. In fact it could hardly be worse if we'd stayed in.
I'm not hearing of France entering austerity for instance, in fact they're not even in recession. Your Eurozone cherry picking is not fooling anyone.

Don't forget that Cameron, a so-called competent leader, actually allowed a referendum to take place.

coffeerevelsrule · 19/10/2022 07:31

Florenz · 19/10/2022 07:19

Nothing "started with Brexit".
Brexit was a result of a very large amount of people being dissatisfied with how things were. If the government (successive governments) had not ignored the wishes of a large part of the electorate for decades, Brexit wouldn't have happened.

You can't write it off as a few ignorant, poorly educated people voting for something they didn't understand when 17 and a half million people voted for it.

No, Brexit was the result of people being dissatisfied and then lied to that it was all the EU/EU's immigrants' faults. These opportunists seized on Cameron's lazy and arrogant assumption that he could shut up those he viewed as 'swivel-eyed' lunatics in his own party and, well, here we are...

It doesn't matter how many people voted for it. They were lied to. No matter how many voted for it they were lied to and that's a fact. I agree that many felt left behind for years but the inevitable outcome of that was not Brexit. Those concerns could have been addressed within the EU easily.

And now we are all left behind, unless part of the right-wing cabal that wanted this shit in the first place.

PolkaDotMankini · 19/10/2022 07:28

Yes, Brexit was a terrible move that has hurt us a lot. The EU is far from a perfect organisation but leaving the single market was shooting ourselves in the foot on a massive scale.

Pinkypong · 19/10/2022 07:27

ShandaLear · 18/10/2022 23:19

I wish I’d voted for chaos with Ed Milliband. Heck, I’d take chaos with The Steve Miller Band now. Anything but this shower of twats.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 oh this cheered me up!

Endlesssummer2022 · 19/10/2022 07:24

Even the Torygraph are starting to acknowledge Brexit was a mistake.

We have no option other than to start with rejoining the Single Market and Customs Union.

Florenz · 19/10/2022 07:19

Nothing "started with Brexit".
Brexit was a result of a very large amount of people being dissatisfied with how things were. If the government (successive governments) had not ignored the wishes of a large part of the electorate for decades, Brexit wouldn't have happened.

You can't write it off as a few ignorant, poorly educated people voting for something they didn't understand when 17 and a half million people voted for it.

MarshaBradyo · 19/10/2022 06:56

Liebig · 19/10/2022 00:15

I think this past week has shown that the manifestos are soundly in the hands of those who ally themselves with bond vigilantes and other finance and corporate overlords.

No one I've seen so far has the balls to actually address these things, because no after Corbyn crashed and burned is going to have the vision to look past the current paradigm and imagine better.

Might as well temper expectations, hence, Labour get in and more or less follow the muted "growth" plan that Trussonomics shat out and Hunt moulded into being Turbo Austerity instead.

And when that fails, hoo boy, if you think the Tories were a little populist and fash then I can't wait to see what comes after people become fully disillusioned with the two main parties after two decades of no prosperity growth (which, by the way, no one can change regardless).

Right now people are putting a lot by Labour and depressingly if it is this stark realisation we are in trouble.

Although I’m hoping an end to war in Ukraine would help either party and us. And them

newnamethanks · 19/10/2022 06:55

Brexit. Britain got Done Over. Thanks leavers.

SuspiciousHedgehog · 19/10/2022 06:50

At least we saw off that Jeremy Corbyn, at least we haven't been transported to the early 1970s.

Ummmmmmmmm........