Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think what happened to Milli Vanilli is so sad

187 replies

ineeduourhelp · 18/10/2022 21:51

I was under 5 when this whole scandal happened so don't remember it at the time but till this day still play the track and absolutely love girl you know it's true.

I also have a crush on them (especially Fab 🤣)

But on a serious note it's so so sad what happened to these guys it breaks my heart - mainly because they could actually sing!

It's so bizarre they were not allowed to take over and start singing themselves as I'm convinced they could have had fame in their own right.

Was anyone perhaps a bit older to remember when all this happened?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Spanglybangles · 20/10/2022 12:35

@HyggeTygge Apologies, I actually should have written that as “I understand the only place…”, I haven’t fully checked Wiki myself, it’s something I read on a thread elsewhere. Anyway, I don’t believe for a moment that Mariah’s vocals are anywhere on the track, it appears to be a rumour that circulated some time ago, but debunked by most.

HyggeTygge · 20/10/2022 10:37

Spanglybangles · 19/10/2022 19:50

@Keyansier it still doesn’t ring true for me. S2S had several great vocalists in their collective and I believe recorded in London. Why would they have vocals added by a US ghost singer and then not credit her when other back up vocalists on their tracks have been credited? Not only that, why would rising star Mariah Carey not make it known that she sang on the album? If nothing else, it would help her credibility as an artist of black origin. I have listened to the part you specify and yes I can hear how it might be argued that her voice could be in there, but it just doesn’t ring true.

Finally, the only place that states as fact that Mariah’s vocals are on that album is Wiki….hardly a reliable source. Anyway, it’s not something to argue over, we can agree to disagree on this one. 🙂

Which wiki page are you talking about? I can't see it on the 'Back to Life' page or the Club Classics page - there should be a citation if it's on wikipedia (it's not really a "source" in itself).

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/10/2022 09:42

Just referencing pp's mention above of Cilla Black, I can barely listen to her awful squawking voice, but I do think she is absolutely sublime singing 'Anyone Who Had A Heart'.

Being fair, I think the way she does the first, softer, part is quite pleasant, but it's when she opens up the throttle from "knowing I love you so" that it starts getting hands-over-earsy.

StapFooterin · 20/10/2022 09:34

Just referencing pp's mention above of Cilla Black, I can barely listen to her awful squawking voice, but I do think she is absolutely sublime singing 'Anyone Who Had A Heart'.

twilightcafe · 20/10/2022 08:05

I always assumed Shirlie did the 'Hey, tell this jerk to take a hike...' rap on Young Guns (Go For It).
After all, the words came out of her mouth on Top of the Pops.

Nope. It was a session singer who came up with the rap, and that she was pushed for time because she had to dash to another studio to sing on a dog food commercial.

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/10/2022 07:35

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/10/2022 23:46

Although in my defence I was born in 1999 and just believed what my mother told me about who was who from the ‘80s.

It seems incredible enough now even to those of us who grew up without the internet, but all the info about who wrote or sang on what just wasn't widely available, if you didn't have the actual record/cassette/CD (assuming it properly credited everybody involved).

In the 80s and 90s, if you wanted to hear a song that you didn't already own, you actually had to go to a record shop and hope they would have it in stock - none of this 'any song ever released available free on demand in two seconds' (although there was Dial-a-Disc at a buttock-clenchingly high price-per-minute, if it was in the charts!), let alone getting old songs back into the charts after they're played in a popular film or TV series.

I just used to record top of the pops on my cassette player. And I had a double cassette player so I could copy cassettes. I hardly had any vinyl. Too expensive.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/10/2022 23:46

Although in my defence I was born in 1999 and just believed what my mother told me about who was who from the ‘80s.

It seems incredible enough now even to those of us who grew up without the internet, but all the info about who wrote or sang on what just wasn't widely available, if you didn't have the actual record/cassette/CD (assuming it properly credited everybody involved).

In the 80s and 90s, if you wanted to hear a song that you didn't already own, you actually had to go to a record shop and hope they would have it in stock - none of this 'any song ever released available free on demand in two seconds' (although there was Dial-a-Disc at a buttock-clenchingly high price-per-minute, if it was in the charts!), let alone getting old songs back into the charts after they're played in a popular film or TV series.

TheMarzipanDildo · 19/10/2022 23:32

BitossiBlues · 18/10/2022 23:35

Why do they think that? It's clearly the gorgeous and uber cool DC Lee in the earlier Wham videos. I was gutted when she left (but loved her in the Style Council)

To my shame, I thought that she of the Club Tropicana video was Pepsi (and I’m a Style Council fan! Blush). I now have no idea what Pepsi looked like.
Although in my defence I was born in 1999 and just believed what my mother told me about who was who from the ‘80s.

WeAreTheHeroes · 19/10/2022 23:13

I'd much rather listen to DW than CB. I think a lot of Cilla's success was down to the strength of the songwriting and the fact she was mates with the Beatles.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/10/2022 23:09

Cilla's voice was much stronger than Dionne's - in the same way that a ply-wood duvet would be much stronger than a silk one.

Ihlaria · 19/10/2022 23:07

Agree that her voice isn't strong as such. I mean she can't belt it out. But it has a certain limpid soaring quality and consistency of tone - harder to do than you'd think, to the extent she does it - that I think is perfect for Bacharach and David. No one can sing their songs like she does. Certainly not poor old Cilla!

WeAreTheHeroes · 19/10/2022 22:58

Ihlaria · 19/10/2022 22:45

@WeAreTheHeroes God knows, really. When you listen to the two side by side there's no selling point to Cilla's at all. (Other than that she was white.) But ... people bought it. Stupid people I guess.

I've never liked Cilla's voice. Never enough nuance or even light and shade. But then Dionne Warwick's voice wasn't particularly strong, but Bacharach and David loved it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/10/2022 22:45

Isn't Elton involved with that one, though? It is quite mediocre, but I suppose he can do what he likes with his own stuff.

Ihlaria · 19/10/2022 22:45

@WeAreTheHeroes God knows, really. When you listen to the two side by side there's no selling point to Cilla's at all. (Other than that she was white.) But ... people bought it. Stupid people I guess.

DonnaBanana · 19/10/2022 22:40

The Ride on Time sample was just a sample of a fragment of a much better original disco song called Love Sensation. Not much different in spirit to that weird Tiny Dancer remix thing going around the charts now.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/10/2022 22:35

Warwick herself said that's what happened. It was the timing and everything - she released a song, Cilla Black-nee-White did a version for the white folk straightaway.

Interesting - and very sad. Just who were these white people (I'm white) who would have chosen to hear Cilla's screeching angry cat sounds over Dionne's beautiful, smooth, velvet tones, just based on what colour the singer's skin happened to be? I suppose it's one small self-imposed punishment for the racists.

Ihlaria · 19/10/2022 22:27

Like, a note for note version, a karaoke cover.

Ihlaria · 19/10/2022 22:26

@WeAreTheHeroes Warwick herself said that's what happened. It was the timing and everything - she released a song, Cilla Black-nee-White did a version for the white folk straightaway.

Mookie81 · 19/10/2022 21:48

APJ1 · 19/10/2022 11:46

For anyone who remembers Phats & Small, with their late 90s hit Turn Around, singer Ben Ofedu (Vanessa Felt's partner) lives off of his success with that one song...only on the recording they were someone else's sampled vocals!

Love that song, you've inspired me to update my Spotify!

Spanglybangles · 19/10/2022 21:30

@Clymene agreed.

RestingMurderousFace · 19/10/2022 20:29

Fuzzbox was most definitely not Heather Small. 😁

Clymene · 19/10/2022 20:06

The Soul II Soil debut album was recorded in London with British producers. There's no way they got a random American backing singer in to record vocals

WeAreTheHeroes · 19/10/2022 19:56

I've listened to that track linked to several times and while there are similarities to MC's voice, I really don't think it is her. It does not sound like her.

Spanglybangles · 19/10/2022 19:50

@Keyansier it still doesn’t ring true for me. S2S had several great vocalists in their collective and I believe recorded in London. Why would they have vocals added by a US ghost singer and then not credit her when other back up vocalists on their tracks have been credited? Not only that, why would rising star Mariah Carey not make it known that she sang on the album? If nothing else, it would help her credibility as an artist of black origin. I have listened to the part you specify and yes I can hear how it might be argued that her voice could be in there, but it just doesn’t ring true.

Finally, the only place that states as fact that Mariah’s vocals are on that album is Wiki….hardly a reliable source. Anyway, it’s not something to argue over, we can agree to disagree on this one. 🙂

WeAreTheHeroes · 19/10/2022 19:44

I think it's a bit of a stretch to claim a racial element to Cilla Black covering Dionne Warwick's US hits here. They were written by two white guys for starters.

Swipe left for the next trending thread