Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I've done nothing wrong by making money on a charity

433 replies

Thealarmhasgoneoffagain · 18/10/2022 16:11

I bought a dress for £60 in a charity shop. I didn't think many people would recognise the brand as it's locally made but it would have cost about £300 I think and would probably be a ooak. I'm asuming the charity shop knew this though because of the high price.

I bought the dress for me but it doesn't fit. I didn't want to get a refund from a charity shop but at that price I can't redonate it either. So I put it on my local FB page askimg for offers. I said it was from the charity shop but I didn't put how much I paid. If anyone asked I would have told them.

Someone offered me £100 and I accepted. They collected it and messaged me afterwards to say how happy they were.

Before I could remove the post someone commented that they worked in the shop and it cost £50. Now I'm getting lots of abuse about being greedy and ripping off the charity. The lady who bought it has put angry faces on it. I also have a couple of things on there for free and people have made nasty comments on those. I've removed all my posts now.

I don't feel bad about making money on the dress as that was never my intention. £60 was much, much more than I would normally spend in a charity shop and tbh I don't want to donate the £40. It was a proper charity shop, not one run by little old ladies who price everything at 50p because they don't know any better.

The lady who bought it, offered £100 and never asked how much I paid and was happy until she found out I paid less. I do feel bad that she won't enjoy the dress though as it's a beautiful dress.

AIBU for keeping the £40?

OP posts:
ShouldIdo · 19/10/2022 06:46

girlmom21 · 18/10/2022 16:41

Delete the post and forget about it

This

Tiani4 · 19/10/2022 06:24

Yanbu

You should email a complaint about that charity shop worker, screenshot what she wrote. Bullying a customer online as they happened to find out that the customer resold something they owned (having bought it) is clearly a disciplinary offence. If it's a volunteer doing this, they are likely to be removed from working in that shop.

Charities hate bad press and with your story about what happened and the harassment this worker caused you by bullying online (& she was dishonest) , is not something the charity will want to happen to any of their customers. She's a liability to this charity and it was a pretty nasty thing to do

Block the buyer , always delete your sale post once as it's sold (so there would be nothing to comment on ) - if you're getting nasty DMs from anyone, screenshot and report the person to the fb group moderator for sending unwelcome abusive messages

Read the fb standards, as any fb group not abiding by them can lose their fb page.

As an aside take screenshots of any nasty messages on your posts from repeat offenders . I hope you screenshot the first post that charity worker left - screenshot it as soon as she puts another one up.

If someone keeps doing that, it becomes an actual crime, malicious communications (likely to cause distress). Surprising I know but if someone was repeatedly harassing you online having stated something untrue (that you bought for £50) even by posting on your fb posts, it's an offence if the aim is to cause you distress- so any name calling etc and it's have to be repeated posts . You can report it online to police

www.stuartmillersolicitors.co.uk/malicious-communications-act-offences/

MissMaple82 · 19/10/2022 05:49

scaredoff · 18/10/2022 16:39

I don't think you did anything wrong. The person from the shop who commented on your post certainly did though, and I'd complain to the shop.

And I never understand why people buy things without trying them on in the shop.

Not one charity shop I've been in in my town has a changing area, not one!

MissMaple82 · 19/10/2022 05:48

Soontobe60 · 18/10/2022 16:29

I’d have donated the extra money to a charity TBH. That’s the guilty conscience in me though!

How weird.

MissMaple82 · 19/10/2022 05:47

You've done sod all wrong, I avoid Facebook because it's full of twats just waiting to pounce for any reason whatsoever. I bet half of the commenters don't even buy from charities or recycle. Don't give it any more headspace.

WiddlinDiddlin · 19/10/2022 04:38

Buying cheap and selling at a profit is... basic business sense.

I don't know why stupid people get worked up about it, they should see the mark up on some of the products they'll undoubted buy in their life times and it won't be the people who put the hard work into making an item that get that price!

If chazzers can't shift stock, stock sits there, people stop going in, chazzer makes no money.

If you come in and buy high end stuff, they're making money (after all its 100% profit for them, they don't buy their stock!) and shifting stock to make room for new stock.

My advice is not to sell such stuff on local FB groups - because they're full of small minded idiots who don't understand how retail works.

WhosafraidofVirginiaWoolf · 19/10/2022 04:24

Megifer · 18/10/2022 16:27

Yanbu, god people can be so weird 🤣🤣

I did this loads, bought bargains from charity shops, ebayed them on. Made enough to go on a few holidays over the years.

Only reason I stopped doing it is it just got too much hard work. Best bargain I got was a nearly new Stone Island coat for £30, sold it for £150 🙌

I could have written your post, word for word 😃

ohfook · 19/10/2022 04:18

PurBal · 18/10/2022 16:15

I know people who have side hustles based on buying cheap, steaming, taking nice photos and listing elsewhere. No I don’t think you’ve done anything wrong. The shop knew it was valuable and listed it as such. They know they don’t have the breadth of targeting the market as the internet does. I used to work for a charity shop about 10 years ago (employed not volunteered) and I wouldn’t have had a problem, everyone is happy. Maybe try Vinted or similar next time.

Yes I have a friend who does this too. I've never thought there's anything wrong with it. The charity get the money they asked for and she gets a bit too.

montysma1 · 19/10/2022 04:05

The charity shop worker is way out of line to comment.
You bought the dress. Its your dress.
At that point its none of her business what you do with it, whether you sell it or set it on fire.

onlythreenow · 19/10/2022 01:10

I would be sending in a complaint about the "worker" who posted an incorrect price and incited hate against you along with examples of the nastiness you got online and the results of that

I do agree with this - highly unprofessional behaviour from them.

CraigDavid · 18/10/2022 22:29

You haven't done anything wrong.

Metabigot · 18/10/2022 22:28

Also worked in charity, some of the chains train staff to cream off the more valuable stock and it goes to the ebay department but that depends on 70 year old Joan whos on donation duty knowing the difference between high end and low end brands which as you can imagine can be patchy.

PhilomenaPringle · 18/10/2022 22:17

You don't go into charity shops looking to spend £100 on one item. They're known for cheap spends. And they don't have the resources to hold an online auction to reach a wider audience. They price it at what they think they will get from local footfall. They don't have warehouses full of identical goods, they have lots of one offs and the best way they can make a profit is to shift it fast so they can keep restocking with new goods.
You're failing to understand that a) goods don't fetch the same price on all platforms and in all places and b) the business model isn't based on squeezing every last penny out, but on keeping stock moving fast

I've worked in a charity shop for 10+ years, first as a volunteer and then as paid staff. The above is exactly correct.

IchWill · 18/10/2022 21:55

You've done nothing wrong, other than provide a back story in the advert, if you'd just stated it wasn't new, that would have sufficed.

When all is said and done, the charity got what they were asking for it, you got a few extra quid in your pocket, and another woman got a dress at a price she was happy to pay.

The charity shop worker definitely shouldn't have waded in and stirred the pot. Incredibly unprofessional.

Ignore and block the trolls on FB. Hope you buy something nice with your £40. :)

reallypuzzledoverthis · 18/10/2022 21:53

The charity shop shouldn’t have posted on your advert anyway, they got what they asked so that’s the end of it for them

EstellaRijnveld · 18/10/2022 21:49

The only thing you did wrong was to mention that you'd originally bought it from a charity shop.

MrsClatterbuck · 18/10/2022 21:46

How many times have we seen on TV items bought in a charity shop or car boot sale for very little being valued at a much greater amount. Don't see the owner being questioned about are they going to give the difference back to the charity no they are congratulated on their find.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 18/10/2022 21:43

Other charities perhaps do send stuff off to be listed centrally but it would depend on volume of stuff. moving stuff around costs money and it's cheaper to list locally.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 21:37

FamilyTreeBuilder · 18/10/2022 21:17

Partly true.

Every charity does things differently. Oxfam has its own online shop and managers/volunteers list things on it. They are not "collected", this all happens in the store.

But it is dependent on having volunteers to photograph stuff from every conceivable angle, write the listing, package it up, take it to the post office. It's time consuming and when there is only one computer for the whole shop, often not possible. So often we'll try to sell stuff in the store. In the situation the OP describes we'd have chosen to put a £60 dress out for sale in the store rather than sell online too, I know we have customers prepared to pay that much, we've sold items for that much in the past.

To get a wee bit extra we'd have to go through the whole listing thing - say 30 minutes to 45 minutes including packaging and posting. In that time I could have priced three black bags of donations for 10 times the extra i'd have made putting the item online.

Thanks @FamilyTreeBuilder - I thought I'd seen stuff advertised online from Oxfam, but didn't realise the logistics. I made the assumption that evrything was taken away to some sort of Alladin's cave of 2nd hand goods.

I'm actually doubly impressed with volunteers who will go to all this trouble.

girlmom21 · 18/10/2022 21:22

TowerblocksAndSunflowers · 18/10/2022 20:31

You should give the extra £40 to charity. No doubt about that in my mind.

If you resold a BNWT New Look dress for an extra fiver on top of what you paid for it, what would you do with the money?

FamilyTreeBuilder · 18/10/2022 21:17

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 20:26

I'm pretty sure that some (eg Oxfam) instruct managers to put good condition designer items aside, and they are collected and advertised and sold online.

Partly true.

Every charity does things differently. Oxfam has its own online shop and managers/volunteers list things on it. They are not "collected", this all happens in the store.

But it is dependent on having volunteers to photograph stuff from every conceivable angle, write the listing, package it up, take it to the post office. It's time consuming and when there is only one computer for the whole shop, often not possible. So often we'll try to sell stuff in the store. In the situation the OP describes we'd have chosen to put a £60 dress out for sale in the store rather than sell online too, I know we have customers prepared to pay that much, we've sold items for that much in the past.

To get a wee bit extra we'd have to go through the whole listing thing - say 30 minutes to 45 minutes including packaging and posting. In that time I could have priced three black bags of donations for 10 times the extra i'd have made putting the item online.

missmamiecuddleduck · 18/10/2022 21:00

fruitbrewhaha · 18/10/2022 16:36

You've done nothing wrong I would also complain regarding the post from someone stating they worked at the charity shop.

Lots of people benefit from working for a charity. Some people get paid very well for either directly working or contracting out a service to charities. Some people even set up charities and trusts as a means to avoid tax. Some set them up as a means to earn living and pay themselves a considerable pay packet, it's a racket. Some charities are receive huge sums of public money and donations to peddle all sort of dangerous misinformation and recruit and pay some very unsavoury individuals.

This. Charities are money making entities.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 20:46

Seconded @BatshitBanshee - it was a mean and spiteful thing to do.

It has caused distress to OP who got piled on, it seems, and it has taken the gloss off the dress for the other woman. She was thrilled with her purchase, but now feels (wrongly) that she has been cheated.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 18/10/2022 20:45

No you were not wrong.

The shop worker OTOH was very wrong.

FB is a shit fest.

BatshitBanshee · 18/10/2022 20:42

The only person I would have a negative opinion on after this is the busybody charity shop worker who burst her piss to be in the comments with incorrect information and leading the charge in bullying you and harassing you online. Not very charitable behaviour acting like some social media "heavy" in the name of a charity. I'd be complaining to the head office.