Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Changechangychange · 20/10/2022 00:49

idonotmind · 18/10/2022 20:59

"Because that’s who it is about, ultimately: children. You can make the economic case for childcare until the cows come home, but far more important is the wellbeing and education of children, who have a right to high-quality care and education that meets their social and emotional needs."

This.

If it's heavily subsidized and affordable for all, it evens up the odds of disaffected/socially disadvantaged children succeeding. Instead of falling by the wayside by the time they are 4.

Not that the Tories would care about that.

We live in Canada and the cost of daycare is $8.35 a day. PER DAY. That means that women can work and be independent. So you get kids from all walks of life having the same start in life. The same lessons, same food and social interactions.

I cannot praise the system in Canada enough.

I was definitely not paying $8 per day in Toronto! It was $1500 per month for a full time place in nursery, for a two year old. Not radically different to London.

pattihews · 20/10/2022 00:44

Oh, and I forgot to say that when you're in a household earning £90k, whether that's gross or net, you are doing okay by any standard.

pattihews · 20/10/2022 00:40

I don't want to seem glib, but I think one's mid 20s into late 30s, which is when we're most likely to be raising young children, is a crunch period in many women's lives, when family and work and mortgage and so on come together. I think very few people don't go through a pinch point which at the time feels as if it'll last for ever. It won't. You will get through this. But yes, bloody tough as a single parent.

As you say, we can't help everyone.

Magn · 19/10/2022 23:16

@pattihews yes but that's bigger all help with the bills right now. I've not seen the other thread anyway to comment on exact numbers, just trying to make it clear that there are an awful lot of people who you'd think are doing great who aren't and a lot of people you'd think wouldn't be doing great who are. Personally I'm hugely conflicted on where the help should go because it's clear we can't help everyone.

pattihews · 19/10/2022 22:45

And when your children are in school and when you've paid off your student loan and when your career has progressed a bit you will be absolutely rolling in it and moving off to live somewhere bigger and nicer and offering your children an interesting and varied life — and they won't.

I may be misremembering, but I seem to recall that the thread about struggling to survive on £90k was after tax and deductions.

Magn · 19/10/2022 21:35

@pattihews £90k pa isn't 7.5k pm, it's more like £4.5k after tax and NI. Assume you have student loans too so that's another £600 per month for plan 1. Personally I earn slightly less than that and after mortgage on an ex council house, full time childcare of over £2k, and all the other bills of food, fuel to get to work, car inc MOT and insurance, council tax, gas+electricity, I am worse off right now than I would be if I didn't work and lived in a council house claiming benefits. I know this because one of my neighbours talks extremely loudly outside about how much they get for housing benefit, etc., for claiming as a single parent and how they have their live in partner's (who is parent to their kids) entire wage to put towards the deposit on help to buy on the house so that's another load of tax subsidising their lifestyle choices. I couldn't afford three kids under school age because of childcare costs - someone on universal credit can because someone else pays for it. I reckon they're costing the state about the same amount I pay in tax each year and they've got a shipload more money at the end of each month than I have. Are you happier subsidising them instead?

Don't pretend the worst off at any one time are always those earning the least when they get help with the biggest costs. Quite frankly I don't know how people who are being honest and those just above benefits are surviving right now.

pattihews · 19/10/2022 20:34

PoTayToes80 · 19/10/2022 20:12

@pattihews

Well assuming we had a fair and just tax system, I think I’d be happy with the concept that childcare was affordable for all and that some of all our taxes went towards this.

Ditto healthcare. Many people can afford private healthcare, but I believe healthcare is something that should be provided to all systems by the state as part of a properly functioning society.

I don't disagree with you.

I'm reeling from reading threads on here where people taking home £90K pa (£7.5k a month) and with £40k in savings are complaining that with interest rates and inflation they won't be able to cope. I don't want to be subsidising people who can't cope on £90k pa, I want my taxes to go to the poorest.

Cuppasoupmonster · 19/10/2022 20:22

And you can’t ‘personal finance’ your way out of £1,500p/m nursery bills. Double that for two children.

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 19/10/2022 20:22

@gogohmm what year was this?

OP posts:
gogohmm · 19/10/2022 20:20

When mine were tiny I stayed at home but found work I could do around them, we had one old car, no mobile phones (yes they had been invented!) no pay tv, no gym and I only went to free child activities at the library and church. Bought cheap or second hand etc. Kids need their parent more than stuff. We lived in one bed flat until we had 2 children then a 2 bed which I got a job doing the end of tenancy cleans and communal areas.

If both parents work, I'm not sure why I should help pay the bill, cut back to a lifestyle you can afford (low income get help with costs already)

KitchenSupper · 19/10/2022 20:15

FreddyHG · 18/10/2022 20:59

Sorry I don't see why I should pay for other people's childcare choices. Having a child is a choice and should come with responsibility including how you fund it. Compulsory education fine I even resent child benefit. Too many people want to have children with no responsibility for how to adequately look after them financially. And if this does mean only the rich can afford children that is fine by me at least they aren't costing net taxpayers money to fund their lifestyle choices.

Then I don’t see why other people’s children should pay for your pension and healthcare in retirement.

PoTayToes80 · 19/10/2022 20:14

@pattihews

Argh, all citizens not systems

PoTayToes80 · 19/10/2022 20:12

@pattihews

Well assuming we had a fair and just tax system, I think I’d be happy with the concept that childcare was affordable for all and that some of all our taxes went towards this.

Ditto healthcare. Many people can afford private healthcare, but I believe healthcare is something that should be provided to all systems by the state as part of a properly functioning society.

ImAvingOops · 19/10/2022 20:11

Childcare is expensive, difficult to find, unavailable for shift workers (who are likely to really need it), and gets dumped on grandparents (who may not want or be able to do it easily). But if someone becomes a sahm, they are called a sponger on society, bad example for their kids, not feminist etc. Society can't have it both ways - either it wants women to be back in the workplace, paying tax, or it doesn't!

Heavily subsidised, good childcare would, as said by a pp, protect those children with shitty parents and help produce adults who in turn make positive contributions to society and maybe not turn into shitty parents themselves. It would be an investment in our future society.

The truth is that as much as some posters resent any accommodation for children, we need them - every time you see a doctor, go to a shop, call a plumber, it's someone else's choice to have children which means those services are available!
It's really short sighted to say only the rich can procreate and the rich would soon change their minds on this when they realise there's no one to wipe their arse in the old people's home, or worse, Waitrose has run out of courgettes because there's no one to grow them!

pattihews · 19/10/2022 20:02

Hold your horses: I said I was going to play devil's advocate and you're at me with your axe and making assumptions about my own circumstances.

So, devils' advocate hat on. Why should a single low-income person working in a care home or as a cleaner in a hospital pay 2% more in tax so that someone with children can go out to work and afford a second car or a second foreign holiday for her family? Of course in many cases it's about personal enrichment. People with two children in childcare may be paying £1500 a month for their care. If they don't have to pay it they'll have £1500 extra to spend on themselves. Or save it towards private school fees.

Imagine that one of your children was in the position of the care worker or the NHS cleaner. Would you really think that was fair?

PoTayToes80 · 19/10/2022 19:48

@pattihews

Because it’s better for the economy for as many people as possible to be in employment?

It’s not really about enrichment it’s about earning a salary and housing and feeding your family.

And who exactly do you think is going to do all those low income jobs (supermarkets, caring jobs, nursery workers, the list goes on) if they have to quit because they can’t afford care for their children? Unless of course you think only wealthy people should have children.

How do you think those women are going to live when they’re elderly and they’ve got no pension to speak of because of the years out of work raising children?

What happens to all that government revenue from taxes and NI that will just disappear when those women can’t work anymore?

All of us pay taxes towards public services that we may never use, you’re not unique in that respect.

YukoandHiro · 19/10/2022 19:25

Well said @HighlandPony

pattihews · 19/10/2022 19:20

I don't think that's a good analogy. No one's denying health care to children and infants. And you've drawn attention to the high costs of maternity and obstetric care which those who don't have children don't run up.

Heavily subsidising parents so that they can both work and enrich themselves while the state picks up childcare costs is something else.

I don't disagree with subsidising childcare costs but if I wanted to I could argue why, say, a single person struggling to pay rent or a mortgage should be taxed extra to pay for your child to be looked after so you and your partner can both go out to work and afford the kind of property and cars and holidays the single person never could.

firef1y · 19/10/2022 19:15

FreddyHG · 18/10/2022 20:59

Sorry I don't see why I should pay for other people's childcare choices. Having a child is a choice and should come with responsibility including how you fund it. Compulsory education fine I even resent child benefit. Too many people want to have children with no responsibility for how to adequately look after them financially. And if this does mean only the rich can afford children that is fine by me at least they aren't costing net taxpayers money to fund their lifestyle choices.

And if only the rich have children who exactly is going to pay the taxes that will fund your pension and care as you age???

itsnotdeep · 19/10/2022 19:09

So those of you who think that it isn't the role of the state to provide childcare (and presumably the state should not be looking after smokers, or the obese, or drug users, or immigrants or alcoholics or people who have climbing or skiing or stupid accidents, or indeed anyone whose "choice" impacts on you) what do you think the answer is? That only those people who can afford £1700 a month for childcare should have children? That only those people who can exist without welfare benefits should have children?

Is that really the answer? Is it not the answer to make childcare more affordable? To make wages higher? so that people can live?

And what about those people who can afford children, but then something unforseen happens to them, they get ill, disabled, their partner dies, they lose their job, a covid pandemic decimates their industry, what happens then? That their partner walks out on them. What happens to the children then? They already exist. They already need childcare.

Surely you can see that it is the responsibility of the state to provide childcare. That it benefits society and the children, even if the feckless parents don't deserve it. That it will have an impact on productivity and the economy? I just don't get that view at all. To me it's clear that affordable, high quality childcare is absolutely part of the necessary infrastructure of any modern economy.

pattihews · 19/10/2022 13:18

I worked in Finland sporadically for a while. They had 24/7 childcare in state nurseries at the time and there was a lot of grumbling about parents abusing it. Part of my research involved finding out about childcare and I can remember talking to one professional who said the nursery he managed was particularly busy at weekends. As far as I'm aware, the abuse of the system led to use being limited but that might have been a local rather than national decision. When I was there income tax started at 40%, which I don't imagine would be popular here.

I'm in the eyebrow-raising camp. You have a baby and then you think about how you're going to care for it?

LokiDokiArtichoki · 19/10/2022 11:49

BabyShaark · 18/10/2022 23:12

“Why should I pay for you to have a child? If you can’t afford to look after your child, don’t have one,”

Sounds like a reasonable approach to me. For the protocol, I do have a DD in nursery and pay £1,700 per month. I made sure that I could afford this before I had her.

Gosh the Guardian makes my blood boil.

Same here. Then I had a heart attack caused by an unknown underlying condition which meant I could no longer do my hcp job. Then my husband left. I’m now reliant on disability benefits whilst looking for a job that fits in around school hours.
not everyone’s circumstances stay the same and unless you’ve planned for every eventuality you might just come unstuck at some point.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 19/10/2022 11:41

FreddyHG · 18/10/2022 20:59

Sorry I don't see why I should pay for other people's childcare choices. Having a child is a choice and should come with responsibility including how you fund it. Compulsory education fine I even resent child benefit. Too many people want to have children with no responsibility for how to adequately look after them financially. And if this does mean only the rich can afford children that is fine by me at least they aren't costing net taxpayers money to fund their lifestyle choices.

We already have a falling birth rate - below replacement level - and are going to have serious issues with an aging population.

I'm not against there being less humans overall, but if everyone who isn't rich stopped having children from today, we'd have major social problems. Unless we massively increased immigration, but that's not exactly popular...

MavisChunch29 · 19/10/2022 11:27

If we're asking why should I, why should younger people be paying for pensioners to sit around on state pensions and use up most of the valuable NHS resources? It makes me laugh when they say "I've worked all my life" (many women of retirement age now lived off their husband's salary and hardly worked a bloody day in their lives) and then ponitifcate about lazy people on benefits
(most of whom are actually working, and benefit fraud is tiny) and women wanting childcare when they are in receipt of the biggest state handout there is, and are costing the country far more than any other section of the population.

Some health problems they can't help but a lot of them could get off their arse and walk, or eat fewer custard creams and M&S ready meals and perhaps then they wouldn't always be cluttering up the GP and hospital and a younger working person might be able to get an appointment. And a load of them keep voting the Tories in as well. I hope this is coming to bite a lot of them on the arse now.

The answer to the "Why should I pay for other people?" is because we are in a society, and not just rolling around scratching our arses like chimps as the writer says. Being lazy good for nothings is not limited to any particular section of the population. Just that some seem to get more easily accused of it than others, and often those who are flogging their guts out, and by people who think a busy day is having a hair cut and a trip to Waitrose.

thecatsthecats · 19/10/2022 11:13

Hmm. Funnily enough I was just thinking about how it would be spectacularly unwise to build any sort of plan these days that relied on any form of government or indeed societal support.

I was actually thinking in terms of education. Even if a pro-education party took over today, then they'd still have fuck all money to provide the sort of decent education I had as a child.

The answer is to plan to provide for yourself and your family. Food, education, housing. Spectacularly not easy, but I'd not rely on anything. To be fair, my family have always operated this way, as we share care and resposibility for a disabled relative who would be stuffed on the state.