Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Power blackouts- why not during the day? *MNHQ editing to say this has become a more general power outage chat*

118 replies

BoobBoobBaby · 18/10/2022 12:41

I’ve been reading about the proposed plan for power blackouts and they’re saying 4-7 on week days. Why then? Surely longer blackouts during the day, when we don’t need lights and kids are at school and most people are at work would be better? Or even 10pm-6am when most people are sleeping? Or is it because we don’t use much electricity then, so they’re picking peak times? I just don’t understand why those specific times? does anyone know?

OP posts:
Daxis · 18/10/2022 22:15

I should have said: They won't cut it for everyone at the same time.

Daxis · 18/10/2022 22:14

lilroo87 · 18/10/2022 21:41

I was thinking about this earlier, if they cut the power to all areas between 4-7pm wouldn't there just be a surge when it's back on of people trying to use everything?
Or are they planning to stagger it somehow? So maybe certain postcodes off between certain times to reduce the usage but not cause a surge all in one go 🤷🏻‍♀️

They won't cut it for everyone - it'll be rolling so areas will be disconnected in turn. If you look on your electricity bill (or check your postcode here www.powercut105.com/findoperator) you'll find your block identifier. So all the 'A's will be off together then all the 'B's.

jcyclops · 18/10/2022 22:01

Lifted from another thread
Why power cuts will be between 4pm and 8pm.

The graph shows that National Grid have to supply around 50GW through the daytime in winter, but demand peaks around 5:30pm and they have to find another 10% from short term generation, which is invariably gas powered. By cutting power to around 10% of users at that time, they can maintain demand at the base load 50GW level and avoid firing up the emergency gas generators.

Power blackouts- why not during the day?  *MNHQ editing to say this has become a more general power outage chat*
mumda · 18/10/2022 21:54

The cooking of food at tea time puts huge strain on the grid.

Untitledsquatboulder · 18/10/2022 21:54

thanksamillion · 18/10/2022 19:42

In Moldova they've had a social media campaign asking people to conserve power in peak hours (morning and evening). We could have something like that to help to flatten the peak but I suspect that a lot of people.would just ignore it.
There are some small changes that could help like not running your washing machine or dishwasher then, and reducing oven use. It just requires some planning and thought but we're all used to having what we want whenever we want it!

It was suggested. Truss vetoed it.

lilroo87 · 18/10/2022 21:41

I was thinking about this earlier, if they cut the power to all areas between 4-7pm wouldn't there just be a surge when it's back on of people trying to use everything?
Or are they planning to stagger it somehow? So maybe certain postcodes off between certain times to reduce the usage but not cause a surge all in one go 🤷🏻‍♀️

F4chrissakes · 18/10/2022 21:18

I've read somewhere that you should set your fridge/freezer to the coldest setting(s) in preparation for power cuts. But doesn't that just use more fuel?

Caramac555 · 18/10/2022 21:07

Will there be notice of these blackouts? Any presumably the same area won't have endless consecutive days?

What about flushing the loo and sewage pumps? And petrol pumps? Will shops close early?

I'm thinking for tea we'll do tinned sausages with beans or ravioli if there's no notice, and reheated leftover overs on the hob if we can plan ahead. Or a fry up breakfast, but for tea.

I'm more worried about uncharged hearing aids and the moaning about no WiFi. I think I might just go to bed early to be honest

WomBat55 · 18/10/2022 21:02

LetItGoHome · 18/10/2022 14:05

Is there a way to only turn off power for some and not others?
There are some households (mine included ) who rely on power for medical equipment or for temperature sensitive medications that need refrigeration.
I wonder how that would work?

I don’t know about the UK but I’d imagine it’s similar to here in Ireland where you can register with your supplier or with the network operator that you are a vulnerable customer. So yes they would avoid cutting power to your area of the network (if they can) and in the event of an unplanned outage like a storm they will prioritise getting you reconnected before others.

Daxis · 18/10/2022 20:56

We can store gas, but we might not be able to replenish our stores as much as we'd like. So we'd have to ration it, essentially.

TheIsaacs · 18/10/2022 20:53

Daxis · 18/10/2022 20:06

It's not a stupid question 😊

Gas fired power stations are used to cover peak demand. During the day we're more likely to be able to meet demand via baseload power stations (eg nuclear) and renewables. But for the peak demand we need to temporarily increase supply and we need to use power stations which can "ramp up" and "ramp down" quickly so that we're only producing extra energy for the peak. At the moment gas is one of the best ways to do this.

Oh, I see! So actually, even if we were able to store the gas and preserve it during the day, it wouldn’t matter because it’s only used to cover ramp up and down.

Daxis · 18/10/2022 20:45

Hydro is great for quick response! Because it's so quick to bring online it's often used for frequency response rather than to cover peak demand periods.

ILeclercreturn · 18/10/2022 20:43

{"ramp up" and "ramp down" quickly so that we're only producing extra energy for the peak. At the moment gas is one of the best ways to do this.}
Hydro storage is actually better but there aren't enough mountains in the areas of the UK that need the power most. They use electricity at times where there is not much demand to pump water to a 'top' reservoir and when more electricity is needed the pumps become generators and the water flows down. Dinorwic in Wales being the biggest example.

slowquickstep · 18/10/2022 20:17

If there were power cuts during the school day the children wouldn't be at school

Daxis · 18/10/2022 20:06

TheIsaacs · 18/10/2022 18:45

Here’s my probably stupid question: if they’re using gas power to create the electricity, and it’s the gas shortage that’s the problem, does a power outage during the day not preserve gas levels for peak times? Or is it that there is also no storage for the gas?

It's not a stupid question 😊

Gas fired power stations are used to cover peak demand. During the day we're more likely to be able to meet demand via baseload power stations (eg nuclear) and renewables. But for the peak demand we need to temporarily increase supply and we need to use power stations which can "ramp up" and "ramp down" quickly so that we're only producing extra energy for the peak. At the moment gas is one of the best ways to do this.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 18/10/2022 19:43

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 18/10/2022 19:12

That's a good point, although not all power stations are powered by gas. Drax, I believe, is powered by wood pellets shipped from Canada. I wonder how environmentally friendly that is?

It's not environmentally friendly though. They cut whole forests there for it. We really should have invested in nuclear power stations.

thanksamillion · 18/10/2022 19:42

In Moldova they've had a social media campaign asking people to conserve power in peak hours (morning and evening). We could have something like that to help to flatten the peak but I suspect that a lot of people.would just ignore it.
There are some small changes that could help like not running your washing machine or dishwasher then, and reducing oven use. It just requires some planning and thought but we're all used to having what we want whenever we want it!

MissPoldark · 18/10/2022 19:42

I think that the powers that be like to give us worse case scenarios so that we don't worry about reality

It’s not really about trying to scare people with worst case scenarios .
It’s just a normal part of risk management for any business or organisation.
It would be more worrying if plans weren’t being made to cover various eventualities.

I suppose the question is whether they’ve been overly optimistic about what they think worst case scenario is!

Leakingroofagain · 18/10/2022 19:29

I wonder if they do wind up laptops?

isthismylifenow · 18/10/2022 19:25

Gosh apologies for all the typos.

isthismylifenow · 18/10/2022 19:24

LetItGoHome · 18/10/2022 14:18

Not really. I've had to dump a load of medication. Advised by our consultant and then again when I checked with the pharmacy. After a power cut for just over 3 hours. Some medications are very temperature sensitive and too important to try it and see.

Just a suggestion, but if you freeze watse in 2l bottles and pop them into the fridge when the power goes out. Will help to reduce temp dropping too much.

We do this for our freezer if it's not full and it does help. Bit of a conundrum for me right now as I usually have fullish freezer as I shop monthly. But with the huge amount of outages we have had, it's a risk to have a lot of meat in. So I'm do the water bite thing so what is in there isn't affected too much.

I am having 3 x 2hr outages today. Two down and one to go.

Hence why I had a roast dinner on the go at 2pm today. 🙈

fizzypop100 · 18/10/2022 19:17

Bought mum a power bank for her mobile and an Energizer lantern in case.of powercut. Little things can make a big difference to elderly in those circumstances

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 18/10/2022 19:12

TheIsaacs · 18/10/2022 18:45

Here’s my probably stupid question: if they’re using gas power to create the electricity, and it’s the gas shortage that’s the problem, does a power outage during the day not preserve gas levels for peak times? Or is it that there is also no storage for the gas?

That's a good point, although not all power stations are powered by gas. Drax, I believe, is powered by wood pellets shipped from Canada. I wonder how environmentally friendly that is?

TheIsaacs · 18/10/2022 18:45

Here’s my probably stupid question: if they’re using gas power to create the electricity, and it’s the gas shortage that’s the problem, does a power outage during the day not preserve gas levels for peak times? Or is it that there is also no storage for the gas?

BiddyPop · 18/10/2022 18:30

It's difficult to store electricity. The peak hours of 4-7 are when most people are looking for power and when the demand may match or be more than the capacity of the grid to supply it. If there are limits on the amount of gas/oil/coal etc available to burn for more traditional power stations, and the wind doesn't blow, sun has gone down for the night and there is not a lot of water in the rivers where there is hydro, then there will be a need to cut power to some areas so that others still have it and there isn't a cascade failure of the entire grid.

The demand is far lower at 10pm-6am, so even if the wind and sun are lower, the traditional stations may be able to cope at that stage.

If the wind is blowing well and it is still sunny, there is more capacity available.

There is a hydro station in Ireland (Poulaphouca?) where the water from the upper lake runs through the turbines to generate electricity at peak demand times. The water runs into the lower lake from the turbines. But during the night, when demand on the system is low and the traditional stations need to be online anyway (and especially if it is a windy night and there's LOADS of power!), they can use that power to pump water back up to the upper lake to be available again tomorrow for extra peak supply. Which is great if the normal amounts of rain fall and we haven't had a drought emptying the lakes/rivers. (At least we're not as bad as Lake Mead/Hoover Dam hydro stations near Las Vegas in the USA!).

But it's hard to store power on a large scale otherwise. We don't have massive banks of batteries to recharge - but it is a reason why recharging electric cars overnight is a good thing to take that excess power and make it useful. There is research going into converting electricity into Hydrogen and storing that, and converting it back to electricity or to use it to fuel cars (whole different engine system!), when it is needed.

But the other thing that WE can do, as people living here, is to try and flatten the demand curve by reducing what we want at the peak and using it more spread out. So this is why people talk about running the washing machine and tumble dryer and dishwasher earlier in the day or later in the evening. Or using a slow cooker or having the oven on a timer to cook dinner earlier in the day before the peak, so it just needs a small heat through later. Or fill the oven one night (dinner for that night - meat, potatoes, veggies; as well as cooking other bits to just quickly reheat tomorrow or do some baking) and then not need the oven on the following day as that takes a lot of energy to heat. Don't turn all your devices on to recharge as soon as you all get in from work/school at 5pm but wait until after dinner and cleaning up when the overall demand on the grid is a bit lower. Lag your hot water cylinder and heat the water overnight to have your shower in the morning. Wait until there's a windy day to wash the sheets and towels as the wind will also give more power to the grid (and then hang them on the line to dry as well as the wind will get them soft and dry in no time without the tumble dryer Grin).

There should still be plenty of power to do everything - it's just a case of thinking about when certain things NEED to be done (like needing to warm up from travelling home and feeding everyone at dinner time) and if you can organise your household to do certain other things at a slightly different time. So it's about rationing when you do things rather than rationing being able to do them at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread