Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
ancientgran · 19/10/2022 10:41

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 09:52

also, examination of a female is so much more invasive than for a man
not suggesting it's a competition, just something I noted when working in sexual health
if I had an appendage I could just whip out and have one swab taken, then it would be marginally better
in fact, men without symptoms simply had to pee in a pot- no investigation of appendage!
women lie down, legs akimbo, and various swabs taken from various areas of vulva, clitoris, vagina, cervix (which can be deeply unpleasant- anyone felt sick/fainted when cervix involved?? I know I have)- by means of a frigging speculum- not a pleasant experience
look, I have a 13 year old daughter who is all "be kind" etc- she would scoff at what I'm saying
BUT she only has female hairdressers and I totally understand that- I manage to refrain from saying "I told you so: sex does matter" because I'll pick my battles- but at 13, she knows that she feels more comfortable with a female touching her- and we're only talking hair here
In our 20s and beyond, we try putting our discomforts away, we don't want to be the awkward one- we're liberated after all, not like those drudgy older women- a body's a body etc- it's nothing, meaningless
then we have babies, breast-feed, family life, peri-meno, menopause and are told by younger women- as well as some men- that if we ask for a female, we're making a fuss, we're "karens"
it's frustrating and I wish we could open younger women's eyes as I know that they will feel the same one day
ironically, I've had 2 young male gps have to perform intimate investigations on me and both were lovely and clearly embarrassed. This put me at my ease! This is completely normal human behaviour: good, young men should not find treating vulnerable women a walk in the park or exciting/funny/a story to tell.
I hope the poster who's son is helping "bring life into the world" or "creating life" (can't remember exactly what you said), reminds her offspring that there is a woman involved in this- he is not the hero in this story!

You don't know they will feel the same one day. It is incredibly arrogant to say that. I'm old and I'm as happy to be seen by a competent doctor, male or female, now as I was 60 years ago. You have a right to say you want to be treated by a woman and I have a right to say I want to be treated by the best person available regardless of their sex.

I say that as someone who was sexually assaulted by a doctor when I was a child, I didn't even understand what had happened until years later. The feeling of betrayal was strong, he was my mum's GP when she was expecting me, he was my doctor from before I was born but that was him and in no way do I think all male doctors are like that. I've seen some doctors I wasn't happy with, male and female, the same with nurses but I've seen far more who were fantastic.

You have every right to feel uncomfortable you have no right to say that all women will feel the same when they are older.

Confusion101 · 19/10/2022 10:35

I sincerely hope there's a shift away from men in intimate female care- leave it to the women

What about women who want to request males for their own reason? My experiences has been that any female gynae I've dealt with has been dismissive, cold, invasive. Male gynaes were kind, gentle, got the job done and actually explained things clearer to me. That is only my experience, and I know and respect that others may have experienced the opposite.

You said but if you have a girl, as she grows up, becomes a teenager- you'll get it by then. I have a baby girl, my main concern for her would be that she gets the best care available with best practice, I don't care if that's by a man or a woman. Surely that won't change throughout her life?

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 10:31

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 10:17

I get that- but it's not the point
I'm sorry, I just can't articulate well
I have no doubt that your surgeon was awesome- well done, surgeon, he's doing his job, which he's perfectly entitled to do
men have been doctors for centuries- inevitably they will have a high profile in most disciplines-but I sincerely hope there's a shift away from men in intimate female care- leave it to the women
I appreciate that it won't happen overnight but I cannot stomach male midwives/breast-care nurses etc, areas that have plenty of female staff- it's incredibly insensitive- the female patient is clearly not front and centre. this is not equality, it's immaturity or entitlement, neither of which is great
I had an EC with my first come to think of it and docs were male in the main- brilliant job that they did too- but I remember wondering if my nether regions were exposed- they probably weren't, but even then I had a niggle! i'd forgotten that, one of the many things shoved to the back of my mind
had all the docs been female- that experience would have been so much better- but I don't criticise the men for being there- there are centuries' old, institutional reasons for this
one day the penny will drop for you, I guarantee- I suspect your children are young at the moment- but if you have a girl, as she grows up, becomes a teenager- you'll get it by then

Oh don’t be ridiculous one day the penny will drop for you

You don’t need to belittle or invalidate other women’s opinion to build up your own. Ironic that you speak about equality when that is what you jump to.

I don’t agree with “leave it to the women” and I don’t see any logical reason why I would change my mind when my DD is a teenager.

I have no problem with a women preferring care from a woman but I fundamentally don’t agree that it is merely ‘entitlement or immaturity’ for a man to be in that sector.

I’m not invalidating your desire to request female care so why do you feel the need to be patronising to me? My feelings are not wrong.

ancientgran · 19/10/2022 10:27

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 09:54

I hope the poster who's son is helping "bring life into the world" or "creating life" (can't remember exactly what you said), reminds her offspring that there is a woman involved in this- he is not the hero in this story!

The consultant who performed my emergency section and saved my baby was absolutely the hero in my story.

Mine too, it was Christmas Day and I don't know who he was, he wasn't my Consultant as he wasn't working that day. I just remember the alarms going and this man walking in, looking at the situation and in seconds saying "We're going to theatre now." My husband didn't even get to speak to me, he was left standing there as the bed was grabbed and they ran. The anaesthetist was also lovely, I was panicking as I had been drinking and even eating during labour and he said, "Don't worry, I'm going to put my hands on your throat so you can't inhale anything, don't worry I'll keep you safe." and he was true to his words. I had to have a GA as there wasn't time for an epidural.

Two men whose names I don't even know, I could walk past them in the street and never know them but they did the most wonderful thing that anyone could have done for me.

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 10:17

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 09:54

I hope the poster who's son is helping "bring life into the world" or "creating life" (can't remember exactly what you said), reminds her offspring that there is a woman involved in this- he is not the hero in this story!

The consultant who performed my emergency section and saved my baby was absolutely the hero in my story.

I get that- but it's not the point
I'm sorry, I just can't articulate well
I have no doubt that your surgeon was awesome- well done, surgeon, he's doing his job, which he's perfectly entitled to do
men have been doctors for centuries- inevitably they will have a high profile in most disciplines-but I sincerely hope there's a shift away from men in intimate female care- leave it to the women
I appreciate that it won't happen overnight but I cannot stomach male midwives/breast-care nurses etc, areas that have plenty of female staff- it's incredibly insensitive- the female patient is clearly not front and centre. this is not equality, it's immaturity or entitlement, neither of which is great
I had an EC with my first come to think of it and docs were male in the main- brilliant job that they did too- but I remember wondering if my nether regions were exposed- they probably weren't, but even then I had a niggle! i'd forgotten that, one of the many things shoved to the back of my mind
had all the docs been female- that experience would have been so much better- but I don't criticise the men for being there- there are centuries' old, institutional reasons for this
one day the penny will drop for you, I guarantee- I suspect your children are young at the moment- but if you have a girl, as she grows up, becomes a teenager- you'll get it by then

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 10:02

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 19/10/2022 09:59

@luxxlisbon the only hero in my birthing suite was me. Everyone else was doing their job.

Which is fine for you. I’m just saying the poster doesn’t speak for every woman.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 19/10/2022 09:59

@luxxlisbon the only hero in my birthing suite was me. Everyone else was doing their job.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 19/10/2022 09:57

@sushi7 - it's not disgusting though, is it?

What's disgusting is the way you're calling her disgusting for quite rightfully saying she doesn't want men involved in her medical care, based on previous assaults.

What's disgusting is that women get assaulted. What's disgusting is that people like you berate someone for having valid feelings and significant trauma.

And what's really disgusting is that 98% of sexual assaults are committed by men, and many women carry the burden of those assaults their entire life, and yet here you are berating a woman for expressing a right to choose a same-sex health provider.

Grow up.

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 09:54

I hope the poster who's son is helping "bring life into the world" or "creating life" (can't remember exactly what you said), reminds her offspring that there is a woman involved in this- he is not the hero in this story!

The consultant who performed my emergency section and saved my baby was absolutely the hero in my story.

Novum · 19/10/2022 09:53

I wonder more why anyone wants to work in gastrics. Spending your day peering up people's imperfectly cleared digestive systems doesn't sound great to me. But the point is that some people find it interesting and rewarding, and presumably the same applies to gynae irrespective of the sex of the people concerned.

beastlyslumber · 19/10/2022 09:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 09:52

also, examination of a female is so much more invasive than for a man
not suggesting it's a competition, just something I noted when working in sexual health
if I had an appendage I could just whip out and have one swab taken, then it would be marginally better
in fact, men without symptoms simply had to pee in a pot- no investigation of appendage!
women lie down, legs akimbo, and various swabs taken from various areas of vulva, clitoris, vagina, cervix (which can be deeply unpleasant- anyone felt sick/fainted when cervix involved?? I know I have)- by means of a frigging speculum- not a pleasant experience
look, I have a 13 year old daughter who is all "be kind" etc- she would scoff at what I'm saying
BUT she only has female hairdressers and I totally understand that- I manage to refrain from saying "I told you so: sex does matter" because I'll pick my battles- but at 13, she knows that she feels more comfortable with a female touching her- and we're only talking hair here
In our 20s and beyond, we try putting our discomforts away, we don't want to be the awkward one- we're liberated after all, not like those drudgy older women- a body's a body etc- it's nothing, meaningless
then we have babies, breast-feed, family life, peri-meno, menopause and are told by younger women- as well as some men- that if we ask for a female, we're making a fuss, we're "karens"
it's frustrating and I wish we could open younger women's eyes as I know that they will feel the same one day
ironically, I've had 2 young male gps have to perform intimate investigations on me and both were lovely and clearly embarrassed. This put me at my ease! This is completely normal human behaviour: good, young men should not find treating vulnerable women a walk in the park or exciting/funny/a story to tell.
I hope the poster who's son is helping "bring life into the world" or "creating life" (can't remember exactly what you said), reminds her offspring that there is a woman involved in this- he is not the hero in this story!

Lemonlady22 · 19/10/2022 09:51

Rockingcloggs · 18/10/2022 17:55

The absolute bollocks being spouted on here is fucking reprehensible.

Yep

Sushi7 · 19/10/2022 09:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m sorry you were sexually assaulted (I’ve been too). However, the fact you said I don't know why a male would want to do this - I expect there are a range of reasons from the patrician to the perverse. Don't care is disgusting. It is fine to have a preference but most men aren’t rapists! There’s usually a female nurse that’ll sit in during pelvic examinations (for male and female gynaes).

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 09:25

Confusion101 · 18/10/2022 17:29

For all saying they would ask for female gynae. If u knew that female was a lesbian would u request a change?

No
she's still female- that's what is important to me
it's the fact that men, biologically, have no clue what it feels like to be female; it's the fact that men, socially, do not know what it's like to be female and therefore, crucially, how vulnerable we often feel because of a man- often at very low
levels- sometimes not
not men's fault, of course, but the way it is

Twentypast · 19/10/2022 09:19

Confusion101 · 18/10/2022 22:42

Same! I didn't need life saving surgery but I did need surgery. 6 months of being dismissed by female gynaes! Male gynae did a scan immediately and booked me in for urgent surgery! A friend had a very similar experience!

A female gynaecologist just said "you need a hysterectomy" with no sympathy or empathy. I was young and had just got married. One sentence that changed my (our) whole life plans and she seemed shocked at my upset response.

I then saw a male gynae for a 2nd opinion. He was empathetic and kind. He listed some options but explained that each one was only temporary and a hysterectomy was the only thing that would actually cure me. Despite being a man I felt he understood what I was going through much more than the previous Dr.

The female gynaecologist said "oh yes, your ovaries will come out too". The male one said "you're very young to remove your ovaries and I'd rather not. I'm not making promises and I may need to remove them but I'll do what I can to clean them up and try to save at least one". He saved both.

If I was asked to recommend a gynaecologist it would 100% be the male one. He had a female nurse as a chaperone every time he examined me but I guess that protects him as much as me.

Tippytappytoes · 19/10/2022 08:31

I’m forever grateful to the lovely male gynaecologist who took the time to recognise that I was scared after being admitted with a cyst on my ovary the size of a babies head that was crushing my Ureter nearly cutting off my kidney and before I knew whether it was cancerous or not (thankfully not). He was so kind. Having been in the hospital systems a few times now I’ve learned to cherish those drs that show empathy, whatever their sex.

nannybeach · 19/10/2022 07:37

When I did infertility, I worked with the husband (consultant) of a lovely nursing colleague, they were unable to have children,we never discussed the "why".

nannybeach · 19/10/2022 07:33

When my oldest DS was born I had a scarey older female obs/gn consultant, unmarried, she was really rough. I wanted to have a vaginal delivery after previous section, she fought my corner,and I got it.The males were much more gentle,(this was 45 years ago) especially in later years. I was nursing 40 plus years, never saw any weirdness. I worked in infertility clinic at one point,you are just focusing on one body area, during examination.

Aussiegirl123456 · 19/10/2022 07:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You don’t have to explain. It’s your body and your choice. You don’t have ‘issues’ just because you refuse to show your genitalia to a male stranger, just because he has a dr’s badge. The male doctors fully understand and respect your choice, thankfully.

beastlyslumber · 19/10/2022 06:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

readingismycardio · 19/10/2022 06:13

Thank God they do. I only ever went to male gynaecologists and I found them very gentle and professional.

MightyOaks · 19/10/2022 04:34

beastlyslumber · 18/10/2022 15:04

I would never let a male gynaecologist near me. I'd prefer not to have a male involved in any health or intimate care for me, ever.

I don't know why a male would want to do this - I expect there are a range of reasons from the patrician to the perverse. Don't care. Just stay away from me.

Wow you've got issues

Aussiegirl123456 · 19/10/2022 03:50

inappropriateraspberry · 18/10/2022 12:12

@Aussiegirl123456 But if it was a woman who had done and said that to you, would you insist on men only from then on? I doubt it. A woman could have done exactly the same to you, you can't tar all men with the same brush.

Think you’re confusing me with someone else, I didn’t have anything done to me!

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 19/10/2022 01:53

So what are you saying, that because they're men they shouldn't be allowed to be a nurse or doctor to females because you don't know whether they're a good un or not?!
You can't just discriminate against a whole class of people because of your own prejudices and fears.