Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
THEDEACON · 19/10/2022 18:32

Unless you have cultural sensitivities you are being VERY unreasonable!

Nannygoat151 · 19/10/2022 18:26

I’ve always thought that. Most gynaecologists seem to be make . Why ???

Stationsofthecross · 19/10/2022 18:18

Christ. What a ridiculous post. I actually had a smear yesterday by a - shock horror - male gynaecologist!!!!😱😱😱😱😱😱😱…. Maybe. Just maybe - they are interested in it as a …. Job?

YorkshireRog · 19/10/2022 18:16

I am deaf in one ear, but I still find ENT fascinating.

I had no kids (up until this week) but I have spent many years training in paeds.

gynaecology is a mixed specialty.. some medicine and some surgery. This is much more likely to be the appeal of working in it. Also, there aren’t (I don’t believe) many gynaecology emergencies. So yours hours likely to be better. (As opposed to obstetrics where it is high drama and high risk). Your junior male dr might have opted for obstetrics cos they like babies and seeing families being made and the mix of medicine and surgery. But then specialised again to Gynae only for lifestyle.

For me I find it even odder that you think you have to share anatomy/ issues with your patients. I have worked with loads of brilliant men in obstetrics and gynaecology.

Rosie22xx · 19/10/2022 18:16

I would think they have gone into the field that has scientifically interested them. As women's reproductive system is very complex and you have to be super knowledgeable about so many aspects. I think it must be very interesting to learn and I imagine there is always new things, new technologies to learn about in this field. I have wondered too, but now have come to realise there is so much behind becoming a doctor or nurse and sooo many different paths and fields they could go down. So picking the one that interests them the most and stimulates the mind for constantly learning, growth and new challenges would be why. Its a very complex area, nothing is simple. Also so grateful at what an amazing job that they do and just how knowledgeable they are.

Lulibee · 19/10/2022 18:14

They weren’t up the level required for more competitive specialities such cardiology, oncology or neurology. Probably came down to a choice between geriatrics, ophthalmology or paediatrics.

Pmen · 19/10/2022 18:12

I once had a VERY bad experience with a gynaecologist. I was very young and did not speak up and today 34 years later it still makes me so angry. I would always now ask for a female dr but if it was absolutely necessary to see a male gynaecologist I would always insist a female nurse was present.

bloodynamechangethe3rd · 19/10/2022 18:10

By your theory should men also not want to be midwives? Because I had two male midwives and out of four births they were definitely the best by far. So so much more compassionate and understanding than the women!

Zoomattheinn · 19/10/2022 17:57

Apologies if this has already been pointed out but it is largely because it is a specialism which involves a lot of surgery. Surgery in general is a competitive area of medicine. These days I’d be surprised if there are not as many female as male consultants in Obstetrics and gynaecology. There are more female than male medical students entering the profession generally.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 19/10/2022 16:42

FiveShelties · 18/10/2022 11:09

Are you saying that you can only specialise in a field where you have the same issues?

Why do young doctors specialise in gerontology?
Why do doctors with no children specialise in Paediatrics?
Do you have to have mental health issues to specialise etc etc

Quite

sourcreampringle · 19/10/2022 15:13

ScotchPine · 19/10/2022 12:57

I absolutely agree that there should be a choice and can understand why some women may be happy with, or even prefer, a male gynaecologist or obstetrician. Unfortunately, there isn’t always a choice in labour as it’s dependent upon who is on shift. If I had had to have a man deliver my child, given my own prior traumatic experiences, and given that I was in the most vulnerable position of my life, I don’t think I would ever have got over that. I’m not really sure what the answer is, as it’s a resource issue. But, there’s no getting away from the fact that it’s a horrific thing for many women to have no choice as to who penetrates your vagina. I wish there was more understanding of this, instead of the ‘surely it doesn’t matter as long as they’re the best person for the job’ and ‘they’ve seen a million lady parts before, there’s nothing special about yours’, or even the ‘don’t be so sexist’ narrative that seems so prevalent.

I had to have a male doctor perform a vaginal exam in labour and it was horrible, it was one of those situations where it had to be done and there wasn’t a female dr available so I just had to suck it up and get on with it for the sake of me and baby, but it still really effected afterwards and I found it horribly traumatic.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 19/10/2022 14:17

@Sushi7 You're misquoting her.

She actually said "a range of reasons, from the patrician to the perverse" which is a reasonable comment and really not disgusting at all.

Some of them do it for perverse reasons, as court records, news reports and personal stories on this thread alone prove.

My point is that what is really disgusting is that we live in a world where women have to worry about a medical professional being a total creep and abusing his power. I have had three sleazy doctors that I can recall.

None of them were women. I'm sure that all three still have thriving practices and when a woman comes out and says "can I have a female doctor next time" the receptionists simply give each other a knowing look and arrange it without question. Powerful men get protected by everyone.

Now that is disgusting.

Sushi7 · 19/10/2022 13:56

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 19/10/2022 09:57

@sushi7 - it's not disgusting though, is it?

What's disgusting is the way you're calling her disgusting for quite rightfully saying she doesn't want men involved in her medical care, based on previous assaults.

What's disgusting is that women get assaulted. What's disgusting is that people like you berate someone for having valid feelings and significant trauma.

And what's really disgusting is that 98% of sexual assaults are committed by men, and many women carry the burden of those assaults their entire life, and yet here you are berating a woman for expressing a right to choose a same-sex health provider.

Grow up.

You should quote my entire post rather than taking it out of context. I said it’s within her rights to choose a female doctor, but it’s disgusting that she thinks male gyanes and nurses went into the profession for ‘perverse’ reasons. I also mentioned that I’ve been a victim of SA a few times. I won’t engage further with you because you didn’t read my entire post on the page just before this.

ScotchPine · 19/10/2022 12:57

I absolutely agree that there should be a choice and can understand why some women may be happy with, or even prefer, a male gynaecologist or obstetrician. Unfortunately, there isn’t always a choice in labour as it’s dependent upon who is on shift. If I had had to have a man deliver my child, given my own prior traumatic experiences, and given that I was in the most vulnerable position of my life, I don’t think I would ever have got over that. I’m not really sure what the answer is, as it’s a resource issue. But, there’s no getting away from the fact that it’s a horrific thing for many women to have no choice as to who penetrates your vagina. I wish there was more understanding of this, instead of the ‘surely it doesn’t matter as long as they’re the best person for the job’ and ‘they’ve seen a million lady parts before, there’s nothing special about yours’, or even the ‘don’t be so sexist’ narrative that seems so prevalent.

red4321 · 19/10/2022 11:33

Looking at the NHS competition ratios for 2021, obs/gyn is one of the most competitive specialities in terms of applications per place.

Provided that women have the option not to be seen by a male gynaecologist, which they do, I'm not really sure why male gynaes are so contentious. Those who've had bad experiences should absolutely be able to see a female gynae, but this thread also shows lots of us are indifferent as to whether they're male or female, provided they're kind and good at their job.

I doubt all female med students want to specialise in obs/gyn so it seems a positive that's it's sufficiently popular amongst both male and female doctors to be well staffed.

ancientgran · 19/10/2022 11:08

EBearhug · 19/10/2022 10:49

If I were a woman training in medicine, I might want to go into ovs/gynae because it's interesting, varied, etc, but I don't know if I'd be happy if I felt pushed into it because men weren't allowed to do it.

I had an internal exam at the GP last year, and they advised me to book with one of the female GPs - it's a large practice with a number of male and female doctors. I'm registered with one of the male ones, but I'll see whoever is available usually. It wouldn't have bothered me to see a male GP (and he's looked at my bits in the past for a different matter,) but I wasn't given a choice, and I did wonder how the women GPs felt about being expected to deal with any gynaecological appointments. Didn't ask, though, and she then quizzed me about menopause, which wasn't why I was there, so she's certainly made it her specialism, whether or not she felt she had a choice in it. Maybe the male GP gets sick of having to deal with all the enlarged prostates. The gynae consultant at the hospital I was referred to was a man.

But I still wonder that some women medics feel pushed into it, and I'm not comfortable with that if they are.

I wondered that about paediatrics when one of my children was having hospital care 50 years ago. Lots of female doctors who quite frankly were hopeless with him, then I had to take him in when he had worrying symptoms after surgery. He was frightened and in pain and his experience of hospital wasn't great.

A man walked into the examination room, he was built like the proverbial brick outhouse and by the state of his nose and ears I reckon he was probably a rugby player or boxer. He was wonderful, won my little one over in minutes, was fantastically gentle and sorted everything out, his change of treatment was a big improvement and meant we didn't need to go back to the hospital again until a regular appointment (at that point we had been attending as an emergency two or three times a week.)

He was clearly cut out to work with children but he didn't look the part like all the nice young women and I wondered if his choice of speciality had been questioned.

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 10:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Badgirlriri · 19/10/2022 10:50

BigRockCandyMountain · 19/10/2022 10:17

I get that- but it's not the point
I'm sorry, I just can't articulate well
I have no doubt that your surgeon was awesome- well done, surgeon, he's doing his job, which he's perfectly entitled to do
men have been doctors for centuries- inevitably they will have a high profile in most disciplines-but I sincerely hope there's a shift away from men in intimate female care- leave it to the women
I appreciate that it won't happen overnight but I cannot stomach male midwives/breast-care nurses etc, areas that have plenty of female staff- it's incredibly insensitive- the female patient is clearly not front and centre. this is not equality, it's immaturity or entitlement, neither of which is great
I had an EC with my first come to think of it and docs were male in the main- brilliant job that they did too- but I remember wondering if my nether regions were exposed- they probably weren't, but even then I had a niggle! i'd forgotten that, one of the many things shoved to the back of my mind
had all the docs been female- that experience would have been so much better- but I don't criticise the men for being there- there are centuries' old, institutional reasons for this
one day the penny will drop for you, I guarantee- I suspect your children are young at the moment- but if you have a girl, as she grows up, becomes a teenager- you'll get it by then

How patronising and offensive. Ugh.

DixonD · 19/10/2022 10:49

I had a daughter as a result of that embryo transfer (that consultant is my hero). I’d be happy for her to receive care from a male physician, as long as she is happy to.

EBearhug · 19/10/2022 10:49

If I were a woman training in medicine, I might want to go into ovs/gynae because it's interesting, varied, etc, but I don't know if I'd be happy if I felt pushed into it because men weren't allowed to do it.

I had an internal exam at the GP last year, and they advised me to book with one of the female GPs - it's a large practice with a number of male and female doctors. I'm registered with one of the male ones, but I'll see whoever is available usually. It wouldn't have bothered me to see a male GP (and he's looked at my bits in the past for a different matter,) but I wasn't given a choice, and I did wonder how the women GPs felt about being expected to deal with any gynaecological appointments. Didn't ask, though, and she then quizzed me about menopause, which wasn't why I was there, so she's certainly made it her specialism, whether or not she felt she had a choice in it. Maybe the male GP gets sick of having to deal with all the enlarged prostates. The gynae consultant at the hospital I was referred to was a man.

But I still wonder that some women medics feel pushed into it, and I'm not comfortable with that if they are.

DixonD · 19/10/2022 10:47

A male consultant performed my embryo transfer for me. I have to say I didn’t feel a thing - not something I can say for any time I’ve had a female nurse do internal scans or smear tests!

ancientgran · 19/10/2022 10:45

SleeplessInEngland · 19/10/2022 10:42

The cleaners were the heroes for my son's birth.

I think the work cleaners do in hospitals is undervalued.

ancientgran · 19/10/2022 10:44

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 10:31

Oh don’t be ridiculous one day the penny will drop for you

You don’t need to belittle or invalidate other women’s opinion to build up your own. Ironic that you speak about equality when that is what you jump to.

I don’t agree with “leave it to the women” and I don’t see any logical reason why I would change my mind when my DD is a teenager.

I have no problem with a women preferring care from a woman but I fundamentally don’t agree that it is merely ‘entitlement or immaturity’ for a man to be in that sector.

I’m not invalidating your desire to request female care so why do you feel the need to be patronising to me? My feelings are not wrong.

Yes it is the patronising and arrogant attitude that we just haven't reached their level of enlightenment yet.

My DD is in her 30s and I just want her to have first class medical treatment.

notapervert · 19/10/2022 10:44

but if you have a girl, as she grows up, becomes a teenager- you'll get it by then

I have two who are in their 20s. I still don't agree.

SleeplessInEngland · 19/10/2022 10:42

The cleaners were the heroes for my son's birth.