Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 20/10/2022 08:49

@Lovelydogs24 But by and large how a Consultant Doctor ends up where they are - is due to a combination of factors that doesn't always have anything to do with what they thought they wanted to do when they started. But it clicked together for them, so that was the area they settled on and then professional success came.

We don’t want your logic here!!!
Its because they are perverts, okay?

Bangolads · 20/10/2022 08:34

@1HappyTraveller Actually I speak from experience as does the nurse above. It’s your ignorance that’s astounding and incredibly naive. How can you know all doctors motivation for what they do? Grow up.

MarvellousMrsMouse01 · 20/10/2022 08:30

Most of gyny is the reproductive system as a whole, womb, ovaries etc. The vagina is actually a relatively small part so can't imagine there is enough there to attract weirdos 😜 Plus, if you like vaginas, chances are seeing mostly 'problem' ones can't be very appealing! My gyno is male, he's been fantastic with my endometriosis. Nothing sexy about that 😂

clarehhh · 20/10/2022 08:28

Men much more gentle for smears in my opinion. However my latest GP is unable to do them and the female GP nearly snapped the speculum.

Lovelydogs24 · 20/10/2022 08:24

OK, sorry 27 pages - I'm not reading them but I have insight that is relevant (apologies if it's been covered though!).

When people start out in medicine it's general medicine. Everyone starts at the same spot, when a person starts to specialise it's usually down to a combination of factors - they happened to be really good at that part. They got a placement in a hospital and in that field they had a great mentor, and inspirational doctors working with them. I've known people go into medicine with a view that they want to be a surgeon - they've done a placement on the maternity ward and just loved it, maybe it's the atmosphere, maybe they had some great colleagues, maybe they found it easier to figure out, maybe they had some successes. Maybe a tutor at Uni said they thought it was a good idea, maybe the placement was in a location they wanted.

But by and large how a Consultant Doctor ends up where they are - is due to a combination of factors that doesn't always have anything to do with what they thought they wanted to do when they started. But it clicked together for them, so that was the area they settled on and then professional success came.

Plopplopplopplopplopploppy · 20/10/2022 08:02

is this seriously a question? I’ve had amazing make and females gynaecologists, it’s never even crossed my mind.

this is stereotyping.

next are going to check if a female gynaecologist is a lesbian just incase you wonder why she’s doing the job too? 🙄🙄

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 07:46

Aussiegirl123456 · 20/10/2022 07:29

That’s good for you. I’m the same. However don’t assume all women are okay with it just because you were.

Some women have been abused and will not cope with having a male in the room. Some women have cultural reasons. Some women have no reason, nor should they have a reason. It’s their body and it’s up to them who they’d want present.

For the record, I’ve given birth 4 times and I cared and noticed exactly who was in the room at all times. So that “you won’t care or notice” bullshit doesn’t apply to everyone. Women deserve to feel comfortable, especially with intimate care. Their comfort trumps the feelings of a male medic. Thank fuck the male doctors are more empathetic than the majority of posters who’ve commented on this post.

At no point did I say I didn’t notice who was in the room… everyone is entitled to an option and mine personally is I want the best care for both me and my baby whether that’s provided by a male or female.

YeOldNoName · 20/10/2022 07:43

"I WoUlD QuEsTiOn ThEiR mOtIvEs"
🤣🤣🤣

WHY?! How?!

You think that a male faced with a vagina must find it attractive? 🤣
Are vaginas that desirable that a male couldn't possibly even see one without having unpleasant ulterior motives?
Is that the same for male nurses having to wipe OAP's bums?
Do all female nurses and HCA's motives need to be questioned when they work on a urology ward? Or when they see male genitalia?

In my experience, when I have had male doctors/midwives/midwives, they have been so ridiculously gentle with me and very, very kind. The female midwives and doctors I had that had to examine me were brutal and made me bleed and nearly cry with pain.

I hOpE tHe MaLe DoCtOrS WeReN't TryInG tO SeDuCe mE!!

olivehater · 20/10/2022 07:34

Most gynecologists do obvs and gynae. Delivering babies is rather rewarding for either sex. It’s only as they get further into their careers they start to think getting called at hours of the day is not great for work life balance and the end up doing more gynae stuff, more office hours.

Aussiegirl123456 · 20/10/2022 07:29

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 07:20

All these comments are funny about specifically asking for a woman… I had a prem baby and had around 10 medical staff in the room men and women, all you care about is getting the best care not what gender the staff are. Imagine if I started demanding no men in the room... it’s laughable.

That’s good for you. I’m the same. However don’t assume all women are okay with it just because you were.

Some women have been abused and will not cope with having a male in the room. Some women have cultural reasons. Some women have no reason, nor should they have a reason. It’s their body and it’s up to them who they’d want present.

For the record, I’ve given birth 4 times and I cared and noticed exactly who was in the room at all times. So that “you won’t care or notice” bullshit doesn’t apply to everyone. Women deserve to feel comfortable, especially with intimate care. Their comfort trumps the feelings of a male medic. Thank fuck the male doctors are more empathetic than the majority of posters who’ve commented on this post.

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 07:20

All these comments are funny about specifically asking for a woman… I had a prem baby and had around 10 medical staff in the room men and women, all you care about is getting the best care not what gender the staff are. Imagine if I started demanding no men in the room... it’s laughable.

Welshmonster · 20/10/2022 07:17

Because being a doctor is a male dominated environment still and women are starting to come through. I have found some male doctors listen more whereas I’ve found some women gynae doctors dismissive of my problem because they don’t have painful periods and think it’s part of being a woman.

itsjustnotok · 20/10/2022 07:16

@VickyEadieofThigh ive had a few women who have been brutal. I think it’s luck sometimes. Not saying a guy would be better at all but I’ve met a few really poor female nurse do my smear.

1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 07:13

Theroad · 18/10/2022 11:08

Yes I've thought this too. Unless it was a life or death scenario I'll never let a male gyn treat me. Perhaps it's a "fascinating" field of medicine with ample "opportunities" but I'm not going to lie - I'd question their motives.

Question - how are they meant to learn about what is normal and what is not? how are they meant to learn about gynaecology, so that they can treat you in said emergency, if they aren’t allowed to treat you when there isn’t an emergency?

Doctors choose a route because it’s interesting to them. Your ignorance is astounding.

A doctor is a doctor. End of.

”I’d let them treat me in an emergency” get over yourself.

mezlou84 · 20/10/2022 06:59

Probably same reason they become midwives too. It's an interesting part of medicine and get job satisfaction. Only same for women, once you've seen one you've seen them all. I've had both women and men gynaecologist and trust me there has been no difference. My son is a science man and loves the science behind everything, he couldn't care less about body parts unless there is a scientific reason behind it. Imagine the satisfaction of finding out its nothing to worry about and being able to give good news. Finding out its bad but treatable and able to make the person well again. Even extending life to be able to give that person more time with family. I honestly think 99.9% men that go into female dominant medical roles do it because they're interested in that field. Same as 99.9% of women in a male dominant role. You get the odd person who does it for other reasons. The woman gynaecologist could be part of the lgbtq etc community, would you question her motives too? I've never had a bad experience with either male or female.

Cluelessat33 · 20/10/2022 06:52

When I gave birth I had a wonderful midwife, who was with me the whole time. However after I gave birth I was moved onto a ward with a male midwife. I was at my absolute most vulnerable, exhausted and in pain. My daughter wasnstuggling to breast feed and all I remember was this male midwife basically man handing my breast, no introduction, little explanation. I personally hated it, qnd insisted on leaving as soon as I could. For me it was an absolute no.

Aussiegirl123456 · 20/10/2022 02:43

askmenow · 20/10/2022 01:56

And there you have it ! Many years of experience in the nursing profession has taught me the same. If you've worked in Operating Theatres you would see the same. Snide, inappropriate comments abound, you really wouldn't want to know.
The power base /misogeny doesn't change just because they're in healthcare profession.

My brother in the US. When he did rotation in gynaecology he often spoke about how inappropriately some colleagues
spoke about their patients. Usually the most senior doctors with the most perfect bedside manner were the worst culprits.

Those who called out this behaviour and reported it were pretty much bullied and marginalised themselves sadly.

I would hazard a guess that most male gyns would go into that field because they want to help women and find that particular medical area fascinating. But, as with any profession, there are some bad, bad apples. However, most professions do not involve that level of intimacy.

askmenow · 20/10/2022 01:56

Bangolads · 19/10/2022 19:52

Having dated a now consultant when he’d just qualified I never ever have male doctors or nurses for Gyne appointments. He drunkenly told me they do ogle and they do talk about us and how our genitals look. My now husband also works in women’s health (not frontline) and showed me a watts app message from a top consultant with a joke about his fishy fingers. I actually avoid male doctors for everything unless I’m desperate.

And there you have it ! Many years of experience in the nursing profession has taught me the same. If you've worked in Operating Theatres you would see the same. Snide, inappropriate comments abound, you really wouldn't want to know.
The power base /misogeny doesn't change just because they're in healthcare profession.

NattyNatashia · 19/10/2022 23:28

In some ways I can sympathise with someone feeling uncomfortable, but it says much more about you and society in general. We're far too hung up in the UK about bodies and sex. If you spend your time looking a bits of bodies every day the obvious novelty that some might feel wears off quickly. You're also making assumptions about a persons sexuality based on sex/gender, would you be as concerned about a Lesbian doing the job?

notjaneausten · 19/10/2022 23:19

I had what was found to be a prolapse. When a surly bloke arrived, a good hour late, I thought he was the handyman, not a doctor. He was a wearing scruffy overalls.
At one point both he and his boss were peering intently at my nether regions, I felt very uncomfortable indeed, trussed up in the stirrups. Especially as they were both bald, overweight, middle aged and resembled my foul next door neighbour.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 19/10/2022 22:59

Hmm1234 · 19/10/2022 20:33

No one should want to look but someone’s got to do the job and I’d rather it be another woman that has the same anatomy as me. Or are you part of the fairy brigade?! Let’s not go there my point was clear

What on earth is "the fairy brigade"?

HowhardcanitB · 19/10/2022 22:52

I bet no woman having a smear test has ever said “I don’t want a woman doing it!” 😂

LadyRoughDiamond · 19/10/2022 22:51

Dr husband spent some time in Obs & Gyne when training. Said that male staff fell firmly into two camps: woman-lovers and woman-haters. That said, if you’re fascinated by the human body, I can see how it would be interesting. Plus it’s generally well-funded.

luxxlisbon · 19/10/2022 22:44

@Hmm1234 Or are you part of the fairy brigade?!

🙄 eugh.
Sometimes it amazes me that people like you still exist, but clearly they do and it’s depressing as fuck.

No doubt you also come from the school of thought ‘can’t say anything these days!’

Rottweilermummy · 19/10/2022 22:41

All gynae docs I've come across since pregnancy with eldest son 30+ years ago to my most recent issue 2 years ago have been men , I guess someone had to do it and not enough female consultants and maybe female consultants don't want to do gynae lol , good question op

Swipe left for the next trending thread