Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 11:30

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 07:20

All these comments are funny about specifically asking for a woman… I had a prem baby and had around 10 medical staff in the room men and women, all you care about is getting the best care not what gender the staff are. Imagine if I started demanding no men in the room... it’s laughable.

Absolutely this ☝🏻

Its not about the feelings on the male medics either for whoever is stating that. It’s about having the best doctor there to do the best job when you need it most.

GreenIsle · 20/10/2022 11:23

sourcreampringle · 20/10/2022 10:36

But perverts in the profession DO exist as countless news stories and court documents show.

Somebody on Twitter did a thread of male obs/gynae doctors in the news for assaulting patients and it went on forever! Was really disturbing.

And these are just the ones who were caught and had enough evidence to be charged. So clearly the argument about no male dr would EVER see patients in that way it’s so gross bla bla is silly.

I also would not be surprised if those attracted to the specialism (even if they didn’t initially study medicine with these motives) happened to be misogynistic and disrespectful of women in average.

Agree with this. Why would a man pick this specialism knowing the majority of the women would prefer a women doctor and feel uncomfortable and potentially traumatised/violated by a male doctor.

That's what I want to know. Screams power and misogyny to me over the women they are supposed to care for.

Aussiegirl123456 · 20/10/2022 11:17

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 11:08

New flash I also never said I spoke on behalf of all women…. I said I wanted the best care. I spoke about myself. Jumping to conclusions about a statement someone made on the internet and getting mad about it is also pretty funny so I’m just gunna leave that there.

I’m not mad, you’re the one jumping to conclusions if you think that.

You said “all you care about is getting the best care not what gender the staff are”. That ‘you’ means someone else. If you were speaking about your experience, then you should have said “all I cared about was getting the best care…”. so you did speak on behalf of others.

You also did say it was funny that some women ask for female care givers. You said it twice in the same post.

I am not the only poster who has pointed this out to you…

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 11:08

New flash I also never said I spoke on behalf of all women…. I said I wanted the best care. I spoke about myself. Jumping to conclusions about a statement someone made on the internet and getting mad about it is also pretty funny so I’m just gunna leave that there.

Aussiegirl123456 · 20/10/2022 10:47

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 07:46

At no point did I say I didn’t notice who was in the room… everyone is entitled to an option and mine personally is I want the best care for both me and my baby whether that’s provided by a male or female.

No babe, these were your words “all you care about is getting the best care not what gender the staff are”. Newsflash. You don’t speak on behalf of all women. You also said you found it ‘funny’ that some women request female HCPs. Hilarious is it when a sexually abused women doesn’t want to be intimately exposed to a male? 🙄

EBearhug · 20/10/2022 10:43

Bangolads · 19/10/2022 19:52

Having dated a now consultant when he’d just qualified I never ever have male doctors or nurses for Gyne appointments. He drunkenly told me they do ogle and they do talk about us and how our genitals look. My now husband also works in women’s health (not frontline) and showed me a watts app message from a top consultant with a joke about his fishy fingers. I actually avoid male doctors for everything unless I’m desperate.

I think it would be normal to have some discussion about what you see - I work in IT, and I can understand talking about what you work with - "OMG, the cabling in that datacentre was just so neat and beautiful and tidy/ the cabling was a total rats nest, really disorganised!" Or my farmer father talking enviously about soil or a wheat crop or a great milker of a cow. I think if you can't appreciate the amazing parts of your job (be it an ear, a lower intestine, or a vagina, or whatever rlse,) you're probably in the wrong job - but that is different from just ogling and misogynistically commenting.

I would hope most med students get over this pretty quickly, and most have more respect from the outset. The trouble is, mostly we don't know which are the bad ones, so it's easier to avoid the whole class.

sourcreampringle · 20/10/2022 10:36

But perverts in the profession DO exist as countless news stories and court documents show.

Somebody on Twitter did a thread of male obs/gynae doctors in the news for assaulting patients and it went on forever! Was really disturbing.

And these are just the ones who were caught and had enough evidence to be charged. So clearly the argument about no male dr would EVER see patients in that way it’s so gross bla bla is silly.

I also would not be surprised if those attracted to the specialism (even if they didn’t initially study medicine with these motives) happened to be misogynistic and disrespectful of women in average.

ScotchPine · 20/10/2022 10:10

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 09:57

My post clearly isn’t about people who have experienced trauma so don’t put words in my mouth. Apologies I have not had chance to read the 1000’s of comments on this thread so by the word ‘‘all’’ I meant the comments I had read about presuming men in this field are in it for the wrong reasons and to me that is ‘laughable’.

I haven’t put any words in your mouth. You said ‘all these comments about specifically asking for a woman are funny’. Those are your words. But glad to hear that you meant something different. Your post certainly wasn’t clear to me, nor to the previous poster.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 20/10/2022 10:05

I do wonder if Adam Kay realises just how much he has damaged the reputation of male gynaes. For me he's totally destroyed the idea that HCPs are totally professional and see all body parts as just body parts and so we shouldn't feel embarrassed. I think we're all aware of how young (male) medical students can be misogynistic arseholes but the confirmation by nurses on here that they don't necessarily grow out of that is something that I find worrying.

Renalmum · 20/10/2022 10:04

senior30 · 18/10/2022 11:17

Why does anybody choose gynaecology? This always astounds me, do you think that men just do it so they can look at vaginas all day? It’s a specialisation, the same as cardiology or any other but for some reason women sexualise it and act as if men are strange for choosing that career path. I could say so much more but won’t bother to allow myself to be worked up

Totally agree with this and plus it's not just about vaginas!

Purple52 · 20/10/2022 10:02

My mum told me to book my first smear with a man. Because he’s more gentle!

based on specific experiences at our doctors surgery

there was another lady present to chaperone.

I was 21 & open minded.

I don’t get why it’s an issue?

if you’re suggesting sexy motivations I think you’ve clearly missed the point about professionalism !!

& so many people are so openly gay/bi is that even a realistic concern? I also refer again to professionalism!

remember they’re looking after your health no giving you a sexual experience. I’d like to think there’s nice things to turn you on than a different terrified dry fanny every 10 minutes 😂

purplehair1 · 20/10/2022 10:00

Well, why not? Women doctors treat male patients for sexual health issues as well. Surely it’s a good thing.

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 09:57

My post clearly isn’t about people who have experienced trauma so don’t put words in my mouth. Apologies I have not had chance to read the 1000’s of comments on this thread so by the word ‘‘all’’ I meant the comments I had read about presuming men in this field are in it for the wrong reasons and to me that is ‘laughable’.

ScotchPine · 20/10/2022 09:54

MamaBearof4 · 20/10/2022 09:07

Putting it simply, Why shouldn't they work in gynea? When I had a retained placenta, it was a male consultant who performed a manual removal. He'd initially popped in to check prior to getting me moved to theatre to have it surgically removed (been waiting 2 hours in absolute agony for an anaesthetist to be available)
I didn't give a fig about his gender, I just needed someone who knew what they were doing.
My m-i-l is a retired doctor. When she began her career in the 60's she faced similar issues - people asked for a different doctor because of her gender. They saw a "woman" and refused to acknowledge that she had the same training as any male doctor. She retired as an oncology doctor. She had to face patients with testicular and prostate cancer, who still demanded a different doctor because of her gender. Can we still not see past gender to the knowledge and skill set of a trained professional?

Several women here have explained that they request a female doctor due to past trauma, including having been sexually assaulted by male doctors. It’s great that you don’t give a give a fig about the sex of a given doctor, genuinely, but many women do for cultural and religious reasons and due to previous traumatic events. I’m not saying that men shouldn’t work in the field, but that those requests should be understood and honoured.

Lovelydogs24 · 20/10/2022 09:49

DarkDayforMN · 20/10/2022 09:22

Case in point re obnoxiousness.

A lot of women on this thread have described experiences with perverts in this profession; why do you think “lol 😂 😂” is an appropriate response?

There are many others on the thread just as bad as this person, I’m picking them as an example because they’re the most recent.

Because I was laughing at the poster who made a funny joke about me presenting a logical reason about why men go into gynae.

I was replying to one person who made a joke about what I'd specifically written.

Do remember that the thread began with- why do males go into gynae? And my first post said - I haven't read the whole thread but I have insight and explained how people generally end up specialising where they do.

ScotchPine · 20/10/2022 09:40

Mumclub · 20/10/2022 07:20

All these comments are funny about specifically asking for a woman… I had a prem baby and had around 10 medical staff in the room men and women, all you care about is getting the best care not what gender the staff are. Imagine if I started demanding no men in the room... it’s laughable.

All of those comments are funny? Really? Many of the comments on this thread are from women who have been sexually abused by men who find having a man penetrating their vagina retraumatising. What in god’s name are you finding to laugh at?

MamaBearof4 · 20/10/2022 09:25

For me, it's not a clear gender-specific issue, as I've also had awful experiences with a female gynae consultant and midwives.
I don't deny that Adam Kay though comes across as a terribly misogynistic person and if he was allocated as my gynae, I'd have to request another based on his well publicised views. But should we really let one male be the standard that we hold all others too?

DarkDayforMN · 20/10/2022 09:22

Lovelydogs24 · 20/10/2022 09:14

😂😂lol.

Oh yep. That. All raving perverts in gynae.

Case in point re obnoxiousness.

A lot of women on this thread have described experiences with perverts in this profession; why do you think “lol 😂 😂” is an appropriate response?

There are many others on the thread just as bad as this person, I’m picking them as an example because they’re the most recent.

red4321 · 20/10/2022 09:21

*Wow, the people who don’t care/ haven’t had bad experiences with male doctors/ don’t understand the relative risks are really snotty and condescending about it.

Newsflash: You’re not a better person because you don’t care who’s touching your fanny.*

I don't think that's what the vast majority of posters are saying. Pretty much without exception, everyone has supported the right for women to be treated by a female gynae. Every woman should have that choice.

Those of us that have shared positive experiences of male gynaes were responding to the original question about understanding why men go into gynaecology. Because they feel they can make a difference and treat their female patients with compassion and stories have been shared to back that up.

In answer to your particular point, I do care who's touching my fanny. As I mentioned earlier, I've found gynae exams very traumatic after a female nurse made an internal tear after being too rough with the speculum (apparently mine is very small anatomically...). My number one priority is that it's as painless as possible, and completely anecdotally, that's been the case for the three male gynaes I've seen. Completely different experience altogether.

I'm appalled by people who've been mistreated by male gynaecologists (and female). It's unacceptable and of course I can understand why they want to be treated by female doctors only. Sharing my willingness to be seen by a male gynae doesn't negate theirs.

Shortfatandangry · 20/10/2022 09:19

I went to school with a bloke who's now a gynae. He's minted 👌

Lovelydogs24 · 20/10/2022 09:14

luxxlisbon · 20/10/2022 08:49

@Lovelydogs24 But by and large how a Consultant Doctor ends up where they are - is due to a combination of factors that doesn't always have anything to do with what they thought they wanted to do when they started. But it clicked together for them, so that was the area they settled on and then professional success came.

We don’t want your logic here!!!
Its because they are perverts, okay?

😂😂lol.

Oh yep. That. All raving perverts in gynae.

DarkDayforMN · 20/10/2022 09:10

SleeplessInEngland · 20/10/2022 09:03

Until we have mind-reading devices it's a bit of a pointless question, because we'll never know.

But as far as this thread goes I'm sure the vast majority of posters who don't care about the gender of their gynos still understand that some would prefer to be treated by a woman.

Have you read the thread, because that’s really not what’s coming through. Though probably you are right that the majority are reasonable, and the obnoxious ones are just more noticeable.

MamaBearof4 · 20/10/2022 09:07

Putting it simply, Why shouldn't they work in gynea? When I had a retained placenta, it was a male consultant who performed a manual removal. He'd initially popped in to check prior to getting me moved to theatre to have it surgically removed (been waiting 2 hours in absolute agony for an anaesthetist to be available)
I didn't give a fig about his gender, I just needed someone who knew what they were doing.
My m-i-l is a retired doctor. When she began her career in the 60's she faced similar issues - people asked for a different doctor because of her gender. They saw a "woman" and refused to acknowledge that she had the same training as any male doctor. She retired as an oncology doctor. She had to face patients with testicular and prostate cancer, who still demanded a different doctor because of her gender. Can we still not see past gender to the knowledge and skill set of a trained professional?

SleeplessInEngland · 20/10/2022 09:03

DarkDayforMN · 20/10/2022 09:00

Wow, the people who don’t care/ haven’t had bad experiences with male doctors/ don’t understand the relative risks are really snotty and condescending about it.

Newsflash: You’re not a better person because you don’t care who’s touching your fanny.

for me personally, Adam Kay alone is enough to put me off male gynae. How many others, even ones who aren’t actually predators like so many described in on this thread, are disgusting freakish misogynists like him?

Until we have mind-reading devices it's a bit of a pointless question, because we'll never know.

But as far as this thread goes I'm sure the vast majority of posters who don't care about the gender of their gynos still understand that some would prefer to be treated by a woman.

DarkDayforMN · 20/10/2022 09:00

Wow, the people who don’t care/ haven’t had bad experiences with male doctors/ don’t understand the relative risks are really snotty and condescending about it.

Newsflash: You’re not a better person because you don’t care who’s touching your fanny.

for me personally, Adam Kay alone is enough to put me off male gynae. How many others, even ones who aren’t actually predators like so many described in on this thread, are disgusting freakish misogynists like him?

Swipe left for the next trending thread