Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
Brieandcamembert · 20/10/2022 17:56

Mine was the best I could ask for. He couldn't think of a greater pleasure than helping women have children for one thing (mixed obs and gynae,)

bluesapphire48 · 20/10/2022 17:39

What has this to do with male gynecologists? Did you not read the article. The woman wants to have only female medical personnel.

1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 16:55

@Bangolads clearly not EVERY doctor (🙄) but the vast majority go into their specialty because they’re interested it? Or do you disagree there too?

I’ve no idea what you and the other nurse have said because I’m not trawling through 29 pages of posts to find it. I’m not ignorant or naive. My comment was specific to the comment within the post I was replying to and I stand by that.

MichaelAndEagle · 20/10/2022 16:27

I don't think the question was should women be able to choose, or are women wrong to prefer a woman.
It was why do men go in to the field in the first place.
The question just shows ignorance about the medical profession and how doctors gain their qualifications and specialise.
I'm not a doctor by the way, but do work with them.

1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 16:10

ScotchPine · 20/10/2022 13:19

‘For whoever is stating that’. Many of those stating that are women with past trauma, including being sexually assaulted by male doctors. Should their feeling not count? Should they just ‘suck it up’ ?

Well if the best person for the job happens to be a male then I guess it’s up to the patient if their own feelings count more than the best outcome from the procedure. There are lots of brilliant male gynaecologists, and there’s some rubbish ones. In the same way as there’s lots of female gynaecologists who are good and bad.

Also not everyone stating that they don’t want a male gynaecologist has suffered trauma. In fact I suspect many have not. There is a lot of misandry in this thread.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 20/10/2022 15:29

bluesapphire48 · 20/10/2022 14:54

The Princess Grace hospital, a prestigious private facility in London, has axed a vulnerable woman’s urgent colo-rectal operation because they ‘don’t agree with her beliefs’.

Teresa, a retired solicitor, chose this specific hospital because it was one of a few hospitals in the UK that use the Da Vinci robot that can handle delicate and complex operations and believed they would offer single-sex care.

As a vulnerable victim of sexual assault, Teresa also thought that the Princess Grace hospital would be understanding and sensitive to the trauma that she had suffered.

Before she was admitted to the hospital for her pre-op checks, Teresa had already specified that she required a single-sex bathroom and stated that she would only answer questions on the form about her sex, not her ‘gender identity.

During the pre-op check which involved intimate care, a man in a blonde wig and bright lipstick entered the room, for no apparent reason other than to make eye contact with Teresa, which caused her to panic and obviously made her wonder whether she was being targeted or intimidated as a result of her previous requests.

Feeling frightened and vulnerable, Teresa reported the incident as a ‘patient dignity breach’ and requested that from now on, her care was only provided by female healthcare professionals - a request that is entirely lawful under the Equality Act.

Following the consultation, Teresa had to return home for three days to prepare for the operation, and pre-op medication was supposed to be couriered to her. Nothing arrived, so she called the hospital and was told that the urgent operation had been cancelled with no explanation given as to why.

The CEO then sent Teresa an email saying that the operation which was due the next working day, had been cancelled due to a ‘lack of shared values' and ‘to protect staff from unacceptable distress’.

The life-saving operation would have involved two leading surgeons, their clinical entourage, two surgery suites, a robot, a place in ICU and a patient bed for seven nights, and this was all cancelled at the last minute.

In contravention of healthcare regulations, the hospital CEO failed to confirm that she would register the patient dignity breach and did not offer to investigate it.

If the scheduled operation is no longer available to Teresa, her only alternative is to have open surgery, which was not the recommended option. Last week, just four days after the operation was due to take place, her condition began to deteriorate, and Teresa ended up in A&E, in considerable pain. She has rapidly lost weight and may now be too weak to have the open surgery.

The actions of the Princess Grace hospital are despicable. This is absolutely unconscionable.
The Chief Executive and their parent company, HCA Healthcare must be held accountable. Sign to demand that they reinstate Teresa’s operation with the utmost urgency.

What has this to do with male gynaecologists?

Mumof3PrettyBoys · 20/10/2022 15:22

I am grateful that there are men in all areas and professions because men are more compassionate when dealing with women and some women are total cow bags!! I'll give 2 of my own personal experiences to justify my view.

My first son was born early by emergency section, midwife, surgeon and the nurses looking after baby and me were male. I felt my care was outstanding and i was not in any pain. They listened to my phobia of needles and used only butterfly needles on me. I did not pass out!

My second son was born naturally, we had a female midwife who ignored what i was saying at various stages of pregnancy, ignoring my needle phobia and using a huge kneedle that collapsed my vein( my whole inner arm was black for days!!)and caused me to faint when she went for my other arm!! Everything was always because her text book said! what I was experiencing is unlikely because her book says no..!! - I was very poorly and in a lot of pain after childbirth because I had what my midwife told me was unlikely. The poor hospital learnt the hardway about my phobia of needles and they are the ones who documented the phobia stating butterfly needles only to be used on me if bloods etc are required. Awful ignorant woman!!

My 3rd son was born naturally we had a male midwife, Matt Proctor and this man deserves a medal, i will never forget him. From my unplanned arrival (i was booked in at the rosie but was close to huntingdon when my baby started coming) to finding out about me (considered a high risk pregnancy & my phobia of needles) to delivering my baby, i haemorraged and needed urgent care from loss of blood, Matt advised all 50 white coats who came rushing in that i had a phobia and there were no mistakes made to the after care and me leaving the hospital.

Women in control sometimes have control problems and dont listen very well. I find men to be a lot more chilled and they actually listen!! So YABU for asking even if it is a genuine question

pollymere · 20/10/2022 15:19

There was a male midwife when I was born. My Mum didn't care as long I was delivered safely. Loads of Consultants when I had mine, both genders, looking up my hoo-ha. I don't care as long as I'm treated with respect.

bluesapphire48 · 20/10/2022 14:54

The Princess Grace hospital, a prestigious private facility in London, has axed a vulnerable woman’s urgent colo-rectal operation because they ‘don’t agree with her beliefs’.

Teresa, a retired solicitor, chose this specific hospital because it was one of a few hospitals in the UK that use the Da Vinci robot that can handle delicate and complex operations and believed they would offer single-sex care.

As a vulnerable victim of sexual assault, Teresa also thought that the Princess Grace hospital would be understanding and sensitive to the trauma that she had suffered.

Before she was admitted to the hospital for her pre-op checks, Teresa had already specified that she required a single-sex bathroom and stated that she would only answer questions on the form about her sex, not her ‘gender identity.

During the pre-op check which involved intimate care, a man in a blonde wig and bright lipstick entered the room, for no apparent reason other than to make eye contact with Teresa, which caused her to panic and obviously made her wonder whether she was being targeted or intimidated as a result of her previous requests.

Feeling frightened and vulnerable, Teresa reported the incident as a ‘patient dignity breach’ and requested that from now on, her care was only provided by female healthcare professionals - a request that is entirely lawful under the Equality Act.

Following the consultation, Teresa had to return home for three days to prepare for the operation, and pre-op medication was supposed to be couriered to her. Nothing arrived, so she called the hospital and was told that the urgent operation had been cancelled with no explanation given as to why.

The CEO then sent Teresa an email saying that the operation which was due the next working day, had been cancelled due to a ‘lack of shared values' and ‘to protect staff from unacceptable distress’.

The life-saving operation would have involved two leading surgeons, their clinical entourage, two surgery suites, a robot, a place in ICU and a patient bed for seven nights, and this was all cancelled at the last minute.

In contravention of healthcare regulations, the hospital CEO failed to confirm that she would register the patient dignity breach and did not offer to investigate it.

If the scheduled operation is no longer available to Teresa, her only alternative is to have open surgery, which was not the recommended option. Last week, just four days after the operation was due to take place, her condition began to deteriorate, and Teresa ended up in A&E, in considerable pain. She has rapidly lost weight and may now be too weak to have the open surgery.

The actions of the Princess Grace hospital are despicable. This is absolutely unconscionable.
The Chief Executive and their parent company, HCA Healthcare must be held accountable. Sign to demand that they reinstate Teresa’s operation with the utmost urgency.

Loudhousefun · 20/10/2022 14:32

I have had better experience with make GP’s and hospital consultants and specialists. They have generally been less judgmental and shown more care and patience.

celticprincess · 20/10/2022 14:19

So I had a male consultant at the breast clinic when I went for a mammogram as part of the 2 week referral. This was after I’d requested a female gp at my own surgery for the initial appointment that got me referred. It hadn’t even dawned on me I’d see a man next. It bothered me less than I thought on the day though.

I recall going for my 6 week appointment with my requested female GP after my first daughter. She had a male medical student in with her and asked if he could observe. Why not I thought? She did my smear whilst she was down there and he observed and asked me questions. When I’d been in the hospital giving birth I’d had a range of male and female practitioners have a look down below during and after the process.

Interestingly, only male GPs have perisisted in trying to get me off the combined pill and onto the coil!! Female GPs have asked them taken my quick no as final.

As long as they’re qualified I now think I’m ok with either.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 20/10/2022 13:47

GreenIsle · 20/10/2022 11:23

Agree with this. Why would a man pick this specialism knowing the majority of the women would prefer a women doctor and feel uncomfortable and potentially traumatised/violated by a male doctor.

That's what I want to know. Screams power and misogyny to me over the women they are supposed to care for.

Do the majority of women prefer a woman doctor? I have no preference although my gynaecological issues were treated far more sympathetically by a male doctor.

My Crohn's Disease treatment has all been by male consultants.

KTMeetsTheRsUptown · 20/10/2022 13:28

I had lot of gynae problems and wanted female gynaecologist but after I saw her she just referred me onto male gynaecologist. I was so ill at the time but so angry that I put off my treatment by 6 months as I was adamant didn't want a male but when I finally went to see him Nurses told me he was the Doctor that Doctors go to. He really put me at ease and was absolutely amazing, saved my life as I was so ill at that point and I'm so grateful to him. I needed further gynae treatment and only wanted to see him... but saying that I had an internal ultrasound by a male radiologist and felt violated after and that was private appt so I'm on the fence re this

ScotchPine · 20/10/2022 13:19

1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 11:30

Absolutely this ☝🏻

Its not about the feelings on the male medics either for whoever is stating that. It’s about having the best doctor there to do the best job when you need it most.

‘For whoever is stating that’. Many of those stating that are women with past trauma, including being sexually assaulted by male doctors. Should their feeling not count? Should they just ‘suck it up’ ?

Elsiebear90 · 20/10/2022 12:38

I don’t think many go into it because they’re perverts, there’s much easier ways you can see naked women at work than going through medical school and training to become a gynaecologist e.g. HCA, theatre assistant, mortuary assistant etc. Im a HCP and I’ve come across and heard about a fair few pervy men in those jobs because they require next to no qualifications or experience to get into. I think it’s far too much effort and work to train as a gynaecologist if your only motivation is to see and examine naked women.

I used to date a doctor and he hated gynaecology because he said it put him off sex looking at infected/diseased/disfigured vaginas all day, which makes sense. I would imagine a man might just go into that specialism because they find it interesting. I work in cardiology and I got into that because I found it interesting and easier to get my around than other areas, I’m sure that’s true for people in specialisms like gynaecology too.

Sunnytwobridges · 20/10/2022 12:16

Ever since an ex male acquaintance of mine said he wished he was a gynecologist so he could look at vaginas all day, I’ve insisted on a female gyn. Altho I’ve never cared one way or the other before.

ancientgran · 20/10/2022 12:12

Just remembering my poor mother having a midwife who was a nun. She was totally mortified and felt it was terrible that the nun knew she wasn't a virgin.

I think maybe her Ulster protestant upbringing had given her a strange view of nuns.

ancientgran · 20/10/2022 12:10

sourcreampringle · 20/10/2022 12:04

Every time there is a thread about wanting female intimate care there are always the ‘I didn’t care if the Pope and a marching band in were in the room!!’ type replies. It’s like.. okay, good for you??

If it comes to labour/delivery I always liked being left alone, midwife coming in occasionally to check all was well and then clearing off till needed.

I still didn't care if the midwife/doctor was a man or a woman.

We come in all varieties don't we. The thing I hated about my female midwives was the pressure they put on me to have DH there. Not sure why they felt their feelings about the father being present was more important than mine.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 20/10/2022 12:08

@sourcreampringle Exactly 😂The idea that dignity is meaningless just because it's childbirth is pure gaslighting.

ancientgran · 20/10/2022 12:07

GreenIsle · 20/10/2022 11:23

Agree with this. Why would a man pick this specialism knowing the majority of the women would prefer a women doctor and feel uncomfortable and potentially traumatised/violated by a male doctor.

That's what I want to know. Screams power and misogyny to me over the women they are supposed to care for.

Do the majority of women prefer a woman doctor?

sourcreampringle · 20/10/2022 12:04

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 20/10/2022 11:45

@Mumclub the hard-as-nails 'ooh I could give birth in an auditorium and wouldn't care WHO was there' line gets so old.

Many women know and remember exactly who was in the room, and how they were treated, and how it made them feel, for a very long time.

So maybe go somewhere else if you can't show some empathy?

Every time there is a thread about wanting female intimate care there are always the ‘I didn’t care if the Pope and a marching band in were in the room!!’ type replies. It’s like.. okay, good for you??

rhianfitz · 20/10/2022 11:59

Because it's a good mixture of medicine and surgery

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 20/10/2022 11:45

@Mumclub the hard-as-nails 'ooh I could give birth in an auditorium and wouldn't care WHO was there' line gets so old.

Many women know and remember exactly who was in the room, and how they were treated, and how it made them feel, for a very long time.

So maybe go somewhere else if you can't show some empathy?

GreenIsle · 20/10/2022 11:44

I think it's slightly different if a male is performing an emergency surgery to save your life and child's than a male in an office who pokes vaginas all day in a calm manner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread