Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
Bluetree89 · 18/10/2022 12:36

Loopyloopy · 18/10/2022 11:12

Because obs/gyn is one of the few specialties that includes surgery and medicine ( most medical subspecialties are one or the other ).

Because Obs/gyn is one of the only areas of medicine in which patients want to be there.

Years ago my friend dated a male gyn. We used to spend a lot of time together in groups going out on weekends socialising. One day whilst having some drinks we asked him the same question and he gave the same response due to the surgery and medicine components. He was very mature, passionate and professional answering questions about his line of work although a lot of our questions to him probably were not so mature.

Absolutelyguttedxmas · 18/10/2022 12:36

Hmm. I do get this question and I also prefer a female doc, although I did see a male OB when I had post partum issues.
My BIL is an OB-GYN, although mostly delivers babies. He is gay and has no interest in babies, and always says its his job to get them out but after that he had no idea or interest in the baby. For him I think, although I haven't asked him, he likes the adrenaline of a high risk procedure. He's extremely smart and a very good doctor and enjoys his job very much.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 18/10/2022 12:36

I had a male doctor deliver DS and frankly I’d have accepted a MArtian or a Klingon if it meant a healthy baby

Bestcatmum · 18/10/2022 12:35

I'm a nurse and went to see a gyn about a small prolapse. he was about 7 foot tall and had the most enormous hands Ive ever seen. I'm very small.
It was not the finest experience of my life even with lots of lube.

user1471538283 · 18/10/2022 12:35

They probably find it interesting. And it must be wonderful to deliver a baby!

One of the doctors who induced me was amazing, it didn't hurt at all. And the doctor who delivered my DS was the most competent doctor I have ever met.

I've always had a female nurse for my smears but I don't think I would might a man (I think all my modesty was removed having my DS!).

Wexone · 18/10/2022 12:34

@UncomfortableSofa well my 1st two female specialist dismissed my terrible period pains ect as me not able to cope aswell as am a naturally tired person. It took a male doctor to diagnose me with severe endometriosis and now adenomyosis. I actually made a complaint about the second female doctor as she was such a bitch. Not one caring bone in her body dunno how she is still in her profession. my male doctor has been nothing but kind and reassuring to me. Plus listens to me. To me its nothing to do with gender, you can be shite at your job regardless of your gender

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 12:34

So only people who have the correspondingly same organs, should work in the same field?

Who here even said this? Wondering why someone chooses it isn’t the same as saying they shouldn’t.

Longdayathomeorwork · 18/10/2022 12:34

Long time reader but the OP is so absurd, I have finally signed up just to reply.
As a female GP, I am absolutely horrified that the OP could possibly think that we as a profession would get sexual gratification out of ANY body part that we are dealing with.
Of course there are always going to be isolated and shocking cases of unprofessional behaviour. But to suggest that male doctors would choose gynaecology for thrills is so disappointing. We are professionals and trust between us and our patients underpins absolutely everything that we do.
I would really like to know if the OP has any basis for the question, or whether they just fancied a pop.
We have a workforce crisis throughout the NHS. Want to put off make doctors? You can wait even longer for your outpatient appointment, operation or free birth your child without.

mam0918 · 18/10/2022 12:33

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 12:23

@RaininginDarling
I have Crohn's. Not to derail but I often wonder why anybody would choose bums as their field of medicine. I do not assume, for one second, sinister motives.

We've practically cross-posted!

I also said I don't know why anyone would want to be a bum doctor.

I studied medicine myself and most of us (the people I studied with and talked to) get into it for personal reasons.

Among the reasons people I knew got into their specialist areas was things like losing a parent to cervical cancer or having diabetes themselves or knowing they're a genetic carrier that could pass it on to their children etc... and wanting to 'fix' things for themselves and others.

I dont think I know anyone that became a 'bum' doctor though lol.

MoggyMittens23 · 18/10/2022 12:32

mam0918 · 18/10/2022 12:26

I have been through 15 years of fertility treatments and given birth 4 times... I have encountered several men and never once questioned their motive.

If anyone thinks they are in any way 'getting off on' the awful shit they have to see day in and day out then give your heads a wobble.

It was a man that had to ram he arm elbow deep into to repair a tear when I was heamorraging to death - nothing sexy about that

It was a man that spent 4 HOURS repairing the horrific tearing I had after DS2 - definately not sexy

I have had an exuberatly effeminate walking rainbow of man for my smear before too and while I never asked Im almost certain I dont have enough penis for his sexual taste so highly doubt he was getting thrills from my unshaven minge while my DH stood a thin curtain away and a nurse watched over with hawk like gaze.

I think woman who are fussy about this clearly have been lucky enough to never be in a life or death situation where you litrally could not care less if the person saving your life has a cock or not. Most of the higher up in obstetrics are men, if you ever need anything 'serious' or 'life saving' doing it will likely be a male.

As for why, Im not certain it applies to the NHS but in most other countries its for the money... fertility and womens medicing is a VERY well paid area of medicine (especially in the private sector... IVF in America can easily be $20k for example).

Sounds like you have been through a lot. And thank god for the man that saved your life.

But, I'm really sorry. The way you described the smear test really made me laugh!

Ticksallboxes · 18/10/2022 12:32

A gynaecologist examining me after I'd had a suspected ectopic pregnancy back in 2005 got visibly aroused!

I did wonder after that...

Galaktoboureko · 18/10/2022 12:31

Spanielsarepainless · 18/10/2022 12:20

I prefer a male medic because they don't presume they know how you feel. They believe you rather than say, for example in a smear test, that it's minor discomfort.

This is what I was getting at.

ButtercreamBaker · 18/10/2022 12:31

Dotjones · 18/10/2022 12:18

Bizarre question - you may as well ask why anyone would choose to be a midwife or work with children, because surely only a paedophile would want access to them.

When I was on the maternity ward the family next to me was visited by the Paediatrician. As she walked away they began whispering amongst themselves how weird and inappropriate it was that a Doctor had a name that sounded so much like paedophile. Especially one who worked with kids, it was a bit suspicious.

So it honestly wouldn't surprise me if a select few thought that!

HailAdrian · 18/10/2022 12:31

I saw a male gynaecologist when I was either late teens or early 20s, I wish I'd had the confidence to ask to see a woman instead. He did nothing wrong but I did feel uncomfortable.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 18/10/2022 12:31

Much prefer the male gynaes I've encountered to the female ones....they seem more aware of themselves and more respectful of the fact I'm not a human glove puppet.

CallieQ · 18/10/2022 12:31

Doesn't bother me either... I certainly wouldn't question their motives' Confused Would you question a female doctor looking into prostate etc?

butterfliedtwo · 18/10/2022 12:30

girlfriend44 · 18/10/2022 11:23

Exactly this. Spot on. Goady thread.

This.

In my case, it was the male gynaecologist who listened and helped me. The women thought I was overreacting and needed to get a grip. So your goady thread can do one.

BigRockCandyMountain · 18/10/2022 12:30

I don't mind male gynaecologists- there's a lot of practical/academic training behind every gynaecologist BUT there should ideally be a female back-up at the time- and get-outs for the female patients- no disapproval if female patient wants a woman- make saying "no" easy/understandable- explain at appt booking likelihood of male doc

There's probably a sociological reason for large number of male gynaes in that female doctors (especially surgeons) have historically been thin on the ground so gynaecology was inevitably populated by men- we've got used to it

I would mind a male nurse taking a smear etc- so I'm with you there- I would find it odd

I find it really hard to articulate why, but I will say that I was a nurse myself for 20 years (in sexual health). The male nurses stuck to the male floor, whereas male doctors worked on either floor (with female chaperones).
As a nurse, you're much more about the the nicey, nicey- putting people at ease stuff. Why on earth do you think you'd be the best person for the job where naked women are concerned? it's naive/arrogant/insensitive at best. there are so many other fields you could be in.
There's a lot more graft/training involved in being a doctor - gynaes are surgeons and often obstetricians, too- it's not something you walk into easily
It's not so difficult to become a nurse and "specialist" training is very short- you could do anything and you, as a man, choose fannies...nah! something off

I'm not running nursing down- a good nurse is worth their weight and can be the difference between life and death and certainly between dignity and indignity.
But any man who chooses to nurse vulnerable (ie undressed) women is not a man I want near my fanny!
If your sister's male nurse is a Practice nurse then I appreciate that taking smears would not be a huge part of his job description. But there should be a female back up, and he should advertise this. Even then, women are likely to want to spare his feelings.
We women are taught from a young age not to kick up a fuss, to "be kind", compliant and it's so wrong. there is a physical imbalance of power between the sexes- girls and women unfortunately experience sexual hassle or worse throughout life.
these" little encroachments" all feed into that.

SophiaLarsen · 18/10/2022 12:29

Well I knew a student doc who wanted to specialise in gynae because he said, and I quote "I want to be able to look at women's fannys all day long"

I am sure now he has seen a huge range of fannys from women of varying ages he's not so drooly about the idea.

My mum who was a midwife used to say her male obs and gynae doctors did it because they had a 'natural interest' in the subject.

Also as said earlier in the thread, it's one of the only disciplines to cover medicine and surgery and there are often good outcomes. And heartbreaking ones. Adam Kay said that's why he went into it.

So a mix of nefarious intent and noble intent I think.

Georgeskitchen · 18/10/2022 12:29

Never had a male nurse for a smear but a male medical student under supervision delivered one of my babies. He was lovely and I was happy to help him progress in his medical studies. 30 years on and I sometimes wonder if he passed his exams and flourished in the medical world 😀

BucketofTeaMassiveCake · 18/10/2022 12:28

I've heard that it's either because male gynaes love women - or they hate them. Also, women's bodies are considered to be more interesting due to being able to give birth.

HuzzahIndeed · 18/10/2022 12:28

My last smear was with a female nurse. She hurt me, said pain was normal, made me bleed and then made me feel dirty for bleeding.

I also had a female Dr when giving birth who treated me like a slab of meat.

The male nurse who dealt with my husband's vasectomy was horrible apparently.

They were awful because they were awful at their jobs, not because of their gender.

mam0918 · 18/10/2022 12:27

Also I have always found men more understanding than many women... women doctors in infertilty can be fucking nasty sometimes and very dismissive.

mam0918 · 18/10/2022 12:26

I have been through 15 years of fertility treatments and given birth 4 times... I have encountered several men and never once questioned their motive.

If anyone thinks they are in any way 'getting off on' the awful shit they have to see day in and day out then give your heads a wobble.

It was a man that had to ram he arm elbow deep into to repair a tear when I was heamorraging to death - nothing sexy about that

It was a man that spent 4 HOURS repairing the horrific tearing I had after DS2 - definately not sexy

I have had an exuberatly effeminate walking rainbow of man for my smear before too and while I never asked Im almost certain I dont have enough penis for his sexual taste so highly doubt he was getting thrills from my unshaven minge while my DH stood a thin curtain away and a nurse watched over with hawk like gaze.

I think woman who are fussy about this clearly have been lucky enough to never be in a life or death situation where you litrally could not care less if the person saving your life has a cock or not. Most of the higher up in obstetrics are men, if you ever need anything 'serious' or 'life saving' doing it will likely be a male.

As for why, Im not certain it applies to the NHS but in most other countries its for the money... fertility and womens medicing is a VERY well paid area of medicine (especially in the private sector... IVF in America can easily be $20k for example).

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 12:24

So nobody should ever be treated by someone who isn't exactly the same as them, because we can't possibly empathise?

Should we only ever be treated by people of the same ethnicity as us? Elderly only treated by doctors who are 60+? Obese people only treated by obese doctors? People with cancer only treated by people who have/ have had cancer?

Don't be ridiculous.

Im not! You are!! I never said nobody should be treated by anyone not exactly the same, you did. What I said was, it’s a perfectly reasonable question. There is no difference like the difference between the sexes, biologically. Your examples are stupid analogies that show your childish attitude. Our sexed bodies are uniquely different to males, so it’s perfectly valid and allowed to prefer someone of the same sex treat you medically. It doesn’t extend to any other differences because they don’t matter and most mature people understand why. We separate bathrooms and changing rooms by sex, not anything else. So it’s absolutely valid and accepted by most sane people in society that our physical bodies are different and some people prefer to be examined by someone of the same sex. They don’t have to be, but it’s an option.

I think the immature people on this thread are those that don’t ‘get this’ and try to compare to things that don’t matter or make a difference.