Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/10/2022 12:54

More recently I remember the lovely male obs. who came to visit dd after delivering her baby - it was a very difficult birth and the midwives had kept her in the midwife unit for far too long, when she could have just been taken downstairs to obstetrics and had help a lot sooner - saving her hours of pain and subsequent damage.

They knew it was going to be difficult - back to back - but didn’t tell dd.
Give me a male obs. any day, rather than evangelically- minded midwives who are determined to keep doctors out of it. 🤬

viques · 18/10/2022 12:52

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 18/10/2022 12:48

When my vulvodynia was particularly bad (which is an understatement for fucking horrendous) I was passed from pillar to post fobbed off along the way. The last doctor I saw (just a meeting not examination), was a bloke in gynecology, and could not have been more rude. Barely looked at me and actually shrugged his shoulders. So bad when I left I had a panic attack and a nurse had to take me to a side room.

So I saw a private consultant, also a bloke. Yes I was paying him but he came highly recommended and was the first person who actually looked like he gave a shit and wanted to help me. I had my husband with me (couldn't drive at the time) and always a female nurse for examinations. I never felt uncomfortable. Mind you I was in that much pain with it I'd have taken whatever help I could get! But he was fab.

The fertility consultant who also diagnosed and sorted out my endometriosis was a man. DD conceived a few months later. He was also fab.

I'm glad those men were there to help me. Not the first one, he was shit. However, I am firmly in the camp of patient choice and that you should always be able to request a female practitioner, and no justification or questions asked.

So were they better doctors because they were better doctors or better doctors because they were better men?

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 18/10/2022 12:48

When my vulvodynia was particularly bad (which is an understatement for fucking horrendous) I was passed from pillar to post fobbed off along the way. The last doctor I saw (just a meeting not examination), was a bloke in gynecology, and could not have been more rude. Barely looked at me and actually shrugged his shoulders. So bad when I left I had a panic attack and a nurse had to take me to a side room.

So I saw a private consultant, also a bloke. Yes I was paying him but he came highly recommended and was the first person who actually looked like he gave a shit and wanted to help me. I had my husband with me (couldn't drive at the time) and always a female nurse for examinations. I never felt uncomfortable. Mind you I was in that much pain with it I'd have taken whatever help I could get! But he was fab.

The fertility consultant who also diagnosed and sorted out my endometriosis was a man. DD conceived a few months later. He was also fab.

I'm glad those men were there to help me. Not the first one, he was shit. However, I am firmly in the camp of patient choice and that you should always be able to request a female practitioner, and no justification or questions asked.

RaininginDarling · 18/10/2022 12:48

RaininginDarling · 18/10/2022 12:42

Ha ha ha! @mam0918mam0918 I'm glad it's not just me! BTW, I've been under the care of two male proctologists in different cities and both have been a delight. I've only met nice bum HCPs so whilst we may ponder the 'why' it does seem to attract some thoroughly decent people. (I find this also true of my dealings with Audiology). Yes, this is only my experience being extrapolated outwards but I sometimes wonder about department cultures....

@Emotionalsupportviper I meant this for you! I struggle with this app!

Cappucinoextrachocolate · 18/10/2022 12:47

I had a total hysterectomy due to severe endometriosis. I had a female surgeon a few years ago, who misdiagnosed me and was generally not great, and my hysterectomy with a brilliant male surgeon, a specialist in his field who was not only exceedingly professional but also reassuring and had a very good bedside manner. I very much doubt that he had any interest in my private parts other than professionally. When it came to having such a major op, the sex of the surgeon was the last thing on my mind.

AryaStarkWolf · 18/10/2022 12:46

Longdayathomeorwork · 18/10/2022 12:41

If you read my post properly, you would understand that I am not for a moment suggesting that women should not have a preference or a choice if they feel strongly.
The OP was suggesting that male doctors do obs and gynae for sexual thrills.
Two completely different issues.

The OP suggested no such thing

SimonaRazowska · 18/10/2022 12:45

Why does anyone choose any profession?

what a question

just asking the question casts aspersions, which I think shows a depressing mindset

FennelAndOnions · 18/10/2022 12:45

Why do people specialise in paediatrics if they don’t have children?

A few years ago I remember one Mum on the childrens ward I worked on telling us that she only wanted nurses who had children, looking after her child 🙄. Unfortunately for her, none of us did…

Glitterspy · 18/10/2022 12:44

Longdayathomeorwork · 18/10/2022 12:34

Long time reader but the OP is so absurd, I have finally signed up just to reply.
As a female GP, I am absolutely horrified that the OP could possibly think that we as a profession would get sexual gratification out of ANY body part that we are dealing with.
Of course there are always going to be isolated and shocking cases of unprofessional behaviour. But to suggest that male doctors would choose gynaecology for thrills is so disappointing. We are professionals and trust between us and our patients underpins absolutely everything that we do.
I would really like to know if the OP has any basis for the question, or whether they just fancied a pop.
We have a workforce crisis throughout the NHS. Want to put off make doctors? You can wait even longer for your outpatient appointment, operation or free birth your child without.

Honestly this is exactly the kind of response I’d expect from a GP in the NHS. Rude, aggressive, world-weary and with the attitude, “if you don’t like it you can lump it”.

The OP was asking a genuine question. I’ve often wondered the same thing. Honestly this is the second thread in a 24 hour period where some healthcare worker thinks they have the right of moral authority over everyone else.

AryaStarkWolf · 18/10/2022 12:44

Galaktoboureko · 18/10/2022 12:18

Whilst women can no doubt empathise better, on the flipside I do find that women who've 'been there, done that' can be more likely to be dismissive.

Certainly in office jobs I've found many female managers to be surprisingly unsympathetic around childcare issues etc. Many seem to have the view that you need to make the sacrifices that they made and you'd better not complain because that's what it takes. Same with the 'woman up, I've given birth three times' types.

That's the complete opposite of my experiences in dealing with female and male Dr's & Gynecologists. I always found the women much more understanding and relatable.

BigRockCandyMountain · 18/10/2022 12:44

to the poster who says how marvellous it must be for a man to deliver a baby

It's not about him!!

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 12:43

@Longdayathomeorwork If you read the OPs post properly you’d see she never suggested that! At all. She simply asked why? Go back and look at it.

RaininginDarling · 18/10/2022 12:42

Ha ha ha! @mam0918mam0918 I'm glad it's not just me! BTW, I've been under the care of two male proctologists in different cities and both have been a delight. I've only met nice bum HCPs so whilst we may ponder the 'why' it does seem to attract some thoroughly decent people. (I find this also true of my dealings with Audiology). Yes, this is only my experience being extrapolated outwards but I sometimes wonder about department cultures....

Longdayathomeorwork · 18/10/2022 12:41

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 12:38

@Longdayathomeorwork Of course there are always going to be isolated and shocking cases of unprofessional behaviour. But to suggest that male doctors would choose gynaecology for thrills is so disappointing.

Well it happens doesn’t it. They’re not that isolated either so stop shaming women for discussing it. The idea we should not discuss it at all or even dare to not want a male doctor because of an NHS crisis is silly. If you’re so professional you should be more invested in making sure patients are always comfortable and not suggesting they should shut up when they’re not. Some women don’t want male doctors. That’s our right.

If you read my post properly, you would understand that I am not for a moment suggesting that women should not have a preference or a choice if they feel strongly.
The OP was suggesting that male doctors do obs and gynae for sexual thrills.
Two completely different issues.

Septemberintherain · 18/10/2022 12:40

I was thinking the same thing a few months ago when I was having an uterine ablation.
Whilst it was being performed (by my male gynaecologist), the nurse asked me on a scale of 1-10 how painful it was. I gave my answer from which then the gynaecologist popped his head up and said ‘Mmmm, I wouldn’t call it a pain as such, more a slight discomfort’!
I wanted to snap back ‘Well that may have been YOUR experience whilst YOUR uterus was being burnt to an inch of its life but for me with the all too real, not imaginary womb, I beg to differ’!!
I have had lots of gynae issues and have seen various gynaecologist over the years and in all honesty, as great as some of the male ones are, professionally, it has been the female ones (especially age 40 onwards) who appear to have the most empathy. Just my experience.

itsjustnotok · 18/10/2022 12:40

Given how many posts I see about male GP’s who give poor medical treatment to women, you would think we would be thankful that some do actually care. DH is a nurse in A&E so they generally bear the brunt of peoples annoyance, he’s had some of the most awful shifts but I always remember the 2 occasions he came home absolutely thrilled that he got to deliver a baby unexpectedly because there was literally no time to get the poor ladies upstairs. He has seen the awful side to delivery as well but he said on both those occasions it just made him feel happy and he was over the moon to be able to help. Why do some women immediately go for pervy. We need more male doctors to take womens health issues seriously.

viques · 18/10/2022 12:39

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 18/10/2022 11:11

Just a question, if a man said he does not want a female andrologist and questions why she is in the field will it get the same response as women not happy being with men gynaecologists.

Probably not, I imagine that centuries of fairly widespread sexual abuse of women by men versus the historically very small number of reported cases of sexual abuse of men by women has something to do with this, but have absolutely no data to back this up. Call it a hunch.

BigRockCandyMountain · 18/10/2022 12:39

I actually think I've talked myself out of male gynaecologists, too! Now that we have good numbers of female med students- I'm not sure that we should have male gynaes/sexual health docs. I don't know how practical that is? In my 30s, early 40s I would have scoffed at what I'm now saying- but now that I'm a gnarly 50 year old, I see more clearly. I'm perfectly prepared to accept that men may also prefer male docs when it concerns their willy! but men do not have the same physical vulnerabilities that women have- but certainly from a dignity POV they should be given the same consideration.

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 12:39

I'm a nurse and went to see a gyn about a small prolapse. he was about 7 foot tall and had the most enormous hands Ive ever seen. I'm very small.
It was not the finest experience of my life even with lots of lube.

Another good point. Men have bigger hands. This is a biological difference I guess we aren’t allowed to mention anymore.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 18/10/2022 12:38

I mentioned to my absolutely lovely female gynae that I was glad more women worked in the field now and she said that her male colleagues went into it as it was a field where they would not see things that they would suffer from.

I thought that was interesting, although I will now only ever see female doctors for anything intimate as I've had a few weird/creepy experiences with male ones and fortunately can make that choice.

Having said that my first baby was delivered by a male obstetrician and he was great - very kind, clearly loved his job and was good at it.

Something that has always stuck with me is someone saying (on MN actually) that the majority of men will go into the field for the right reasons, and a small percentage will do it because they really, really hate women. And we know some men hate women. We know that.

A recent case in Queensland of an ob-gyn who was struck off for causing huge injuries to his patients springs to mind (I wouldn't advise googling it, it ruined my day).

So I don't take that risk. And I imagine that in future the field will become female dominated, and hopefully more diverse, that will lead to better outcomes for all women. And I'm happy about that.

N0tfinished · 18/10/2022 12:38

Sestriere · 18/10/2022 11:19

A woman I once worked with, who lived in a very naice area with consultant neighbours told me that men go into gynaecology as there’s a lot to be made from private work.

not sure if that’s true or not.

Definitely the case where I live. All middle class women go private (not uk so you're still in public hospital) and all but 1 of the local OB's were men. I had no issue with them, but I do prefer women for smears etc

NancyDrawed · 18/10/2022 12:38

This isn't the first time that this question has been asked on here, but I remember on a previous thread that someone said if a male doctor was something of a hypochondriac, gynae was a good specialism because he would never be at risk of the problems he was treating, which made sense to me.

FWIW I've been seen by male and female gynaes and the nicest and most gentle was the male gynae I saw first, who was extremely gentle and dealt sensitively with the issues I was having. His (male) replacement when he retired was insensitive and rough.

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 12:38

@Longdayathomeorwork Of course there are always going to be isolated and shocking cases of unprofessional behaviour. But to suggest that male doctors would choose gynaecology for thrills is so disappointing.

Well it happens doesn’t it. They’re not that isolated either so stop shaming women for discussing it. The idea we should not discuss it at all or even dare to not want a male doctor because of an NHS crisis is silly. If you’re so professional you should be more invested in making sure patients are always comfortable and not suggesting they should shut up when they’re not. Some women don’t want male doctors. That’s our right.

Lolacat1234 · 18/10/2022 12:38

I was under the care of a male consultant when I had abnormal cells and needed LLETZ treatment. He was fantastic, felt really at ease and always had a female nurse in attendance during treatment. I have wondered this too though, but then wonder about what makes any consultant choose any particular field of medicine. Then I got to thinking, maybe it's to do with where and when they studied, there are probably grants and opportunities available to all different routes in the medical field and if you asked a male consultant how he ended up in this field I can imagine it being a combination of being generally interested in a certain field during study combined with a good vocational opportunity opening up during the course of their career that sent them down a particular path.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/10/2022 12:36

Absolutely not an issue for me. The only rough treatment I ever had from any gynae/obstetrician was from a woman. Both my babies (difficult births) were delivered by male obs. and not only could I not have cared less who got them out safely, I was extremely grateful to them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread