Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 18/10/2022 13:16

@ShineyCrab Exactly this. I have been to an all-women scanning centre and the entire place feels different. No men. And that's not "sexist" as someone just claimed, or anti male, it's that some women are - with good reason - not comfortable around men.

Honestly the dismissive attitude of some people on this thread - particularly a certain GP, who I very much hope never to require "care" from is depressing. Just so ignorant, condescending and lacking in empathy.

ShineyCrab · 18/10/2022 13:14

Opaljewel · 18/10/2022 13:11

Well at our hospital you can ask for female only.

That's nice for you. At mine you can't because they don't know until the date. It's fucking heartbreaking that you have to wait for an appointment because you don't want to feel like you're being sexually assaulted again.

FattyAirways · 18/10/2022 13:14

All of my gynaecologists apart from one have been men and all have been amazing. One in particular, I had an examination and was trembling and crying afterwards. It didn't even hurt that much, possibly shock? Anyway, he was absolutely lovely and I will never forget how kind he was when he was trying to console me as I cried and cried about possible infertility.

Other gynaecologists I've had have been gay, so definitely not in it for sexual pleasure.

The one gynaecologist I had, when I told her the nurse was treating me for severe anaemia, sneered at me, looked at me like I was shit on her shoe and told me I didn't need treatment for anaemia and that I was fine. I was absolutely not and had six lots of blood in a blood transfusion later that same day. Fucking cow.

passport123 · 18/10/2022 13:14

Longdayathomeorwork · 18/10/2022 12:34

Long time reader but the OP is so absurd, I have finally signed up just to reply.
As a female GP, I am absolutely horrified that the OP could possibly think that we as a profession would get sexual gratification out of ANY body part that we are dealing with.
Of course there are always going to be isolated and shocking cases of unprofessional behaviour. But to suggest that male doctors would choose gynaecology for thrills is so disappointing. We are professionals and trust between us and our patients underpins absolutely everything that we do.
I would really like to know if the OP has any basis for the question, or whether they just fancied a pop.
We have a workforce crisis throughout the NHS. Want to put off make doctors? You can wait even longer for your outpatient appointment, operation or free birth your child without.

Absolutely. I've got an interest in women's health and sexual health. So I see a lot of men's bits. Believe me, none of them turn me on.

ShineyCrab · 18/10/2022 13:14

Opaljewel · 18/10/2022 13:08

Like when my nama asked why nurses were male I answered this. We are in a society now where it should be equal that all sexes can be many roles. Like asking why are so many women doctors or why is there a male medical secretary. It's sexist as hell.

Medical care is not sexual as I told my nana. She wanted to know why handsome young men were cleaning up old ladies and changing their pads.

Roles are not just automatically directed towards one's gender. I thought as forward thinking women we should be encouraging this for both genders. I believe their should me midwives as men and rename it to something gender free. I work for a hospital and we see all genders doing all roles.

I for one applaud it.

It's not sexism FFS. No one believes men can't do the job down to being incapable. It's about the privacy and dignity of the patient.

It's not the same as saying women can't be mechanic or airplane pilots.

passport123 · 18/10/2022 13:13

It's a surgical specialty. Up until a couple of decades ago, surgery was very male dominated. If you split gynaecologists by the date of their CCT (certificate of specialist training) and took them in 5 year bands, I suspect you'd find the male % dropping each time.

Opaljewel · 18/10/2022 13:11

Well at our hospital you can ask for female only.

ShineyCrab · 18/10/2022 13:11

TheyHaveNoIdea · 18/10/2022 12:58

My friend asked that question of her male gynaecologist who said this - ' you ladies have to go through so much and I like to help'.
Also I had a male gynaecologist myself who was fantastic.

Yes, but some of us 'ladies' found having not having any option but a male gynaecologist made us relive that thing we 'had to go through '.

Opaljewel · 18/10/2022 13:11

Also there are just as many men who want to make a difference and want to care for people. Often doctors will nove sround specialities as they learn and then they can specialise in certain areas.

StickofVeg · 18/10/2022 13:10

One of my sons is very interested in women's gynae care, particularly coupled with HIV/AIDs (he's doing biomed). I asked him when he went to a gynae placement - because we talk about everything! And he said it was for 2 reasons (1) he finds it really interesting because it is not "just medicine" it's creating life and (2) he thinks he has the right skills to look after people in vulnerable situations and has a great understanding of the HIV/AIDs side.

elm26 · 18/10/2022 13:09

I have endometriosis and recurrent miscarriages, I've had 1 female consultant and 2 male and the males have been the best in terms of really listening to me, offering the best care and treatments.

I've had so many internals I have lost count and most of them have been male, it doesn't bother me one bit, they are just professionals doing their job.

Opaljewel · 18/10/2022 13:08

Like when my nama asked why nurses were male I answered this. We are in a society now where it should be equal that all sexes can be many roles. Like asking why are so many women doctors or why is there a male medical secretary. It's sexist as hell.

Medical care is not sexual as I told my nana. She wanted to know why handsome young men were cleaning up old ladies and changing their pads.

Roles are not just automatically directed towards one's gender. I thought as forward thinking women we should be encouraging this for both genders. I believe their should me midwives as men and rename it to something gender free. I work for a hospital and we see all genders doing all roles.

I for one applaud it.

Dogtooth · 18/10/2022 13:07

Because it's interesting? You know doctors have to learn stuff about bodies and understand the biology and how treatments work etc, it's not just poking about in vagines all day?

WoodstockJ · 18/10/2022 13:07

Do we also think a female urologists have made an odd career choice that needs justification! And should breast surgeons all be female too!

ShineyCrab · 18/10/2022 13:06

It's a kind of ultimate mansplaining at best and actually abusive at worst. I've known women who have experienced both. I don't care why they go into Tbh. They know some women will not want them there and for either practical reasons or shame reasons won't be able to argue it. It's abusive. Fuck em.

ancientgran · 18/10/2022 13:06

blameless · 18/10/2022 11:45

My DD was interested in Medicine and a GP we know recommended dermatology because you won't be called out at 3am for an emergency and there were issues with her intended field for a woman of childbearing age.
Men may be more open-minded because they don't have any personal experience to cloud their judgement about whether periods are heavy or light, or how mothers should expect pregnancy to change their bodies.

That's interesting. This thread made me think what would be a good speciality and I decided on dermatology because of the 3 am emergency issue. There seems to be a real shortage of dermatologists, when I had a suspected skin cancer I waited ages for an appointment and when I got one it was at an ungodly hour on a Saturday when a doctor from another area was doing a long shift to try and clear some of the backlog. I bet he got paid well for the day.

Also I reckon there is money to be made in dermatology from private work. I say that as a mother who has had to pay privately for help for an acne covered child who wasn't getting help with the NHS, well it's not life threatening is it. Unless of course your child is very depressed because of the acne but that is a whole different thread.

So yes if I come back to another life I will certainly consider dermatology.

Maerchentante · 18/10/2022 13:04

My first gynaecologist in Germany was male, there was always a nurse in the room during examinations.
Then went to a female gyn, who was lovely. My sister still uses this gyn who saw her through two pregnancies.

Had to have an examination last year followed by a hysteroscopy. Two male gyns. The first one was not very nice and didn't come across as very competent. The one who did the actual hysteroscopy was lovely, both before and after the surgery. He explained everything he would do and went over what he had seen after. Compassionate and kind.

CornishGem1975 · 18/10/2022 13:03

The worst obs and gynae consultants I've met have been women. To the point where I think I'd actively ask for a man now!

My friend is a specialist urology nurse, and spends her days confronted with men's parts. Nothing deviant there but she loves her job.

2ManyPjs · 18/10/2022 13:00

Men have been working in gynae (and obstetrics) for hundreds of years. It's a fascinating area of medicine.

2ManyPjs · 18/10/2022 12:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Pathetic.

OriginalUsername3 · 18/10/2022 12:58

I imagine there are some that do it for not nice reasons. But I would also imagine that during their medical training they found a fascination for the medicine or that they were particularly good at it or preferred it to other things.
I had a male doctor during my pregnancy, he was one of the most respectful doctors I had and didn't once call me darling/sweetheart/lovey/my love like the women did, or try to pressure me, I'm not a person comfortable with intimacy so I much preferred him maintaining professional boundaries.

TheyHaveNoIdea · 18/10/2022 12:58

My friend asked that question of her male gynaecologist who said this - ' you ladies have to go through so much and I like to help'.
Also I had a male gynaecologist myself who was fantastic.

Candlesoftime · 18/10/2022 12:56

Smear tests aren't done by nurses who only specialise in gynaecology. Can be the same nurse who takes your blood or urine sample.

As for nurses and doctors who do specialise in gynaecology, i expect part of it is because it's something they're good at and is a good fit for them. There are all sorts of reasons why healthcare professionals choose any area - they just happen to be good with that topic, they thrive under that area's routine, hours, get on with the staff... Same as if they'd chosen working with the elderly or cardiology.

You have access to nudity, vulnerable people, etc. in most areas of healthcare. Working in gynaecology doesn't make a great deal of difference, i don't think, if someone was out to abuse people. That's why all doctors need to go through DBS checks and so on.

Finally, most healthcare professionals become desensitised - by which I mean they don't feel embarrassed or even very aware of nudity and bodily functions, etc. Whilst you're sensitive to how the patient is feeling, it's just another Tuesday - whether you're looking at a fungal toenail or a rectum!

Freegal · 18/10/2022 12:55

I've never thought about it to be honest. Personally, if I had a male Dr for a smear or anything to do with that area I wouldn't be fussed at all. But I also understand why some women prefer female drs.

drspouse · 18/10/2022 12:55

I have a friend who's an anaesthetist and she went into it because it was an interesting mix of physics/chemistry and medicine. I had a gynaecologist who said she was astounded that pregnancy actually worked sometimes because it's so complicated.
So a mixture of those I'd imagine: it includes the parts of medicine they are interested in.
I can also see the motivation to help bring new life into the world and on the more geeky (or money-spinning) side to be able to do both medicine and surgery.
And there are bound to be a few who want to do a load of TUBEs. Those ones would also pick e.g. GP, oncology etc.