Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
ancientgran · 21/10/2022 17:42

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 10:40

@ancientgran Yes that's another way of looking at it - that you miss out on excellent men by excluding them, and there is an overall shortage anyway so we don't want that either. I guess we've also missed out on excellent women for centuries and ended up with some very average men in all areas of life too.

I do think though that men are sometimes given an easier ride or more credit for doing the same job. In my field of publishing, which is dominated by women, a man is automatically given more publicity, better reviews, seen as more of a great artist than a woman writing the exact same book.

Not that it was the OP's question, and sorry to derail, but I just wonder if there's something similar going on here.

I agree with you though that male doctors tend to be one extreme or the other, and the good ones are often lovely. It's interesting what you say about the younger female doctors, though - someone i know is a nurse in Oz and she says that the dominance there of very privileged, entitled, super competitive students getting into medicine and currently starting their careers means that many of them are absolutely hopeless at patient care – it's just not part of their schooling or their upbringing. And that is an issue. As may have been the case with the one you dealt with, who sounds horrendous.

I did have a funny run in with a young female doctor. She came to go through paperwork and consent before my op (hysterectomy) and asked about family history. I said my paternal grandmother died of ovarian cancer. She looked at me in disgust and in a very patronising way explained that paternal meant male so I couldn't have a paternal grandmother. Through laughter I explained that I had two grandmothers, my mother's mother who was my maternal grandmother and my father's mother who was my paternal grandmother. She looked absolutely furious, didn't speak again and slammed her folder shut as she marched off.

The thought of her screwed up angry face still makes me laugh as it was so bizarre. At least she did learn something that day.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 11:21

@TheLassWiADelicateAir Good point. I've had some horrible female doctors too, including one who was very dismissive of my mastitis which turned out to be a huge abscess, which was then drained by a very sympathetic and kind man. She was a mother of four and didn't seem to have a lot of patience for me struggling with half that number.

I don't know. If I take anything from this thread it's going to be praying that I can away from hospital for as long as possible, being sick and at the mercy of whoever you get is terrifying.

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 11:14

What puzzles me is the assumption by some posters that female doctors will be more sympathetic because of the shared experience of being women. There is definitely an assumption by some posters that female doctors will be better just because they are women.

This. I’ve had a female GP being dismissive of my menopause symptoms.

EvAlSa · 21/10/2022 11:11

I remember seeing a lovely young male doctor when pregnant with my last baby.

He was hopeful that she would turn at 37 weeks, and told me to get out walking..

Me: will I feel baby turning? Will it hurt?

Him: ummmm.. I have no idea. 😂

As it turns out.. she did turn, I didn't notice at all and I still needed a section.

But it made me laugh, he just shrugged his shoulders and gave me look of "I've read the books but honestly, I don't know."

I really liked him.

red4321 · 21/10/2022 11:02

We were having a conversation at work recently about men's innate self-confidence and their 'fake it til you make it' mentality. Led by my male colleagues who self-diagnosed themselves as being far more prone to bullshitting than the women.

I wonder whether this manifests itself particularly acutely in doctors and the female doctors have to put aside the modesty that is perhaps more typical in women. Not saying it's a good thing, just an observation.

I saw a female breast surgeon recently and she was everything I'd want in a doctor. Supremely confident without being arrogant, very personable and chatty. Same for my male orthopaedic surgeon. It's quite a skill to balance both and you don't want their modesty to come across as self-doubt.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 21/10/2022 10:58

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 08:47

I find the fact that so many women here have said they prefer men over women so intriguing. And that men are nicer. And kinder.

Not my experience at all, but something I have noticed about male doctors (both acquaintances and in medical settings) is that they are very nice, very charming, very agreeable - until you challenge them, or disagree with them. And then the change can be startling.

So part of me wonders if the reason these men are so charming is that they are in a professional situation where they don't get challenged, women do what they want, they do what they want, everyone's happy. I have heard more than once of women I know being told by a male doctor - "this is what I would want if you were my daughter." Which I also find odd and inappropriate in a clinical setting.

Meanwhile female doctors presumably aren't granted that automatic authority with a female patient - they are seen more as equal (which I prefer.) And wouldn't get away with a paternalistic line like "if you were my daughter" either.

I just don't believe that male gynaes are automatically better, I don't buy that. Yet that seems to be the belief of a lot of women on here.

Has anyone said they prefer men ? I'm not sure they have. A number of posters have said they have no preference and some posters have given examples of better treatment from men. I don't think anyone has said male doctors are automatically better

What puzzles me is the assumption by some posters that female doctors will be more sympathetic because of the shared experience of being women. There is definitely an assumption by some posters that female doctors will be better just because they are women.

From my personal experience the female doctor specialising in women's health who I saw about increasingly heavy periods in my mid 40s was unsympathetic and offered only the option of a long term hormonal contraceptive implant. She told me all the drawbacks and when I asked if it could be removed early if I reacted badly actually said - these things cost money- the NHS can't spend money and you then just change your mind.

The obvious solution for someone in their mid 40s with no intention of getting pregnant was endometrial ablation. She never mentioned it. The male consultant offered it and solved the problem.

I still have no preference which sex of doctor I see.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 10:40

@ancientgran Yes that's another way of looking at it - that you miss out on excellent men by excluding them, and there is an overall shortage anyway so we don't want that either. I guess we've also missed out on excellent women for centuries and ended up with some very average men in all areas of life too.

I do think though that men are sometimes given an easier ride or more credit for doing the same job. In my field of publishing, which is dominated by women, a man is automatically given more publicity, better reviews, seen as more of a great artist than a woman writing the exact same book.

Not that it was the OP's question, and sorry to derail, but I just wonder if there's something similar going on here.

I agree with you though that male doctors tend to be one extreme or the other, and the good ones are often lovely. It's interesting what you say about the younger female doctors, though - someone i know is a nurse in Oz and she says that the dominance there of very privileged, entitled, super competitive students getting into medicine and currently starting their careers means that many of them are absolutely hopeless at patient care – it's just not part of their schooling or their upbringing. And that is an issue. As may have been the case with the one you dealt with, who sounds horrendous.

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 10:14

red4321 · 21/10/2022 10:03

I don't think they are automatically better but if, just a random figure, there are 500 places for trainee doctors in obs&gynae I want the 500 best candidates to get the places. If that means 250 male and 250 female great but if we exclude the 250 males are we going to have 250 less suitable female candidates getting the places? That isn't great and over time it will build so there is the potential for care for women deteriorating.

Or you end up with unfilled places as not all women want to go into obs&gynae. Given there's an overall shortage of doctors in the NHS.

Good point I hadn't even thought of that. We can't assume all women would want the job.

koalacharmer · 21/10/2022 10:04

I think this too. I had a very upsetting in ident when going through a miscarriage with a male who had to do a vaginal scan. I didn't even realise men would do them so didn't request female only staff.
I have zero problem seeing a male doctor but this made me feel the most uncomfortable I had felt in my life, made me wonder do men realise that they might make women feel uncomfortable in that job, could they not have chosen a different healthcare role. The worst bit is he kept getting it wrong and a lady was behind him shouting left left left and he was jabbing around.
I know it sounds almost comical but I cried for days afterwards. I can't explain it as I'm usually fine around men but this was a terrible intimate experience to go through. The worst bit was I went back the following week and tbh I wasn't all there because of the miscarriage and had to go through it a second time. I didn't complain or anything because I just wanted all of it to be over and behind me but for me I'd be happier if men avoided these roles. I know I don't speak for everyone though.

red4321 · 21/10/2022 10:03

I don't think they are automatically better but if, just a random figure, there are 500 places for trainee doctors in obs&gynae I want the 500 best candidates to get the places. If that means 250 male and 250 female great but if we exclude the 250 males are we going to have 250 less suitable female candidates getting the places? That isn't great and over time it will build so there is the potential for care for women deteriorating.

Or you end up with unfilled places as not all women want to go into obs&gynae. Given there's an overall shortage of doctors in the NHS.

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 09:59

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 08:47

I find the fact that so many women here have said they prefer men over women so intriguing. And that men are nicer. And kinder.

Not my experience at all, but something I have noticed about male doctors (both acquaintances and in medical settings) is that they are very nice, very charming, very agreeable - until you challenge them, or disagree with them. And then the change can be startling.

So part of me wonders if the reason these men are so charming is that they are in a professional situation where they don't get challenged, women do what they want, they do what they want, everyone's happy. I have heard more than once of women I know being told by a male doctor - "this is what I would want if you were my daughter." Which I also find odd and inappropriate in a clinical setting.

Meanwhile female doctors presumably aren't granted that automatic authority with a female patient - they are seen more as equal (which I prefer.) And wouldn't get away with a paternalistic line like "if you were my daughter" either.

I just don't believe that male gynaes are automatically better, I don't buy that. Yet that seems to be the belief of a lot of women on here.

I don't think they are automatically better but if, just a random figure, there are 500 places for trainee doctors in obs&gynae I want the 500 best candidates to get the places. If that means 250 male and 250 female great but if we exclude the 250 males are we going to have 250 less suitable female candidates getting the places? That isn't great and over time it will build so there is the potential for care for women deteriorating.

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 09:53

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 08:47

I find the fact that so many women here have said they prefer men over women so intriguing. And that men are nicer. And kinder.

Not my experience at all, but something I have noticed about male doctors (both acquaintances and in medical settings) is that they are very nice, very charming, very agreeable - until you challenge them, or disagree with them. And then the change can be startling.

So part of me wonders if the reason these men are so charming is that they are in a professional situation where they don't get challenged, women do what they want, they do what they want, everyone's happy. I have heard more than once of women I know being told by a male doctor - "this is what I would want if you were my daughter." Which I also find odd and inappropriate in a clinical setting.

Meanwhile female doctors presumably aren't granted that automatic authority with a female patient - they are seen more as equal (which I prefer.) And wouldn't get away with a paternalistic line like "if you were my daughter" either.

I just don't believe that male gynaes are automatically better, I don't buy that. Yet that seems to be the belief of a lot of women on here.

The thing I've found with male doctors is that they are more likely to be one extreme or the other, so I'd say the nicest, kindest, most gentle doctors I've seen have been male but the only doctors I've ever made a formal complaint about (2) were also male and very arrogant and unpleasant.

The female doctors I've seen have tended to be fine although when my DD was seriously ill the young female doctor was downright cruel unless the Consultant was present when she had a complete personality change. If it hadn't been so upsetting it would have been fascinating to watch. When DD was recovering from surgery we couldn't see her immediately. When we got a call to say we could go in we dashed over to find her Consultant (male) was sitting on her bed holding her hand and talking to her, he was so caring and a friend who was a nurse told me he was always like that. He said the operation had been difficult and taken longer than expected, it was 8 pm and he should have been home but he said he didn't want to leave until she was well enough to come out of recovery and then he didn't want to leave her alone until we got there.

We are all influenced by our own experiences, I know that not all young female doctors are closet sadists but my DDs doctor certainly planted that thought somewhere in my mind just like her Consultant influenced my view of male surgeons. I'm not stupid, I know that it is neither true nor fair to hold onto those views but on an instinctive basis I can't avoid it I can only check my prejudice.

Confusion101 · 21/10/2022 09:13

I have heard more than once of women I know being told by a male doctor - "this is what I would want if you were my daughter." Which I also find odd and inappropriate in a clinical setting

That's his equivalent of "if I were you this is what I'd do". Would you have an issue with a female doctor saying that? He can't exactly use those words, as has been pointed out here, he doesn't have a vagina! 😂

There seems to be a good mix of people who would choose male, people who would choose female, and people who don't care either way, so it's a good thing there are both male and female available and we can all have our choice

teathyme · 21/10/2022 09:03

Outside of the UK and particularly in the developing world, obstetrics/gynaecology is very lucrative. Women have to pay to see them and there is never a shortage of pregnant women. It's also not uncommon to have a mistrust of female gynaecologists ("they are hormonal!" 🤔) so any females will have less business.

KimberleyClark · 21/10/2022 08:57

piesforever · 21/10/2022 07:56

What an awful childish thread. In the Breast Unit there are loads of male doctors. Doctors might have an interest in obs/gyn due to a family member, a really interesting placement, a great team, not because they are pervs and want to look up your flue! Medical people are professional!

In my experience of fertility issues/IVF clinics, which was admittedly a while ago, the vast majority of doctors I came across were male. I never had a problem with them. To me a HCP is a HCP regardless of sex. I accept I might feel differently if I was traumatised though.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 21/10/2022 08:47

I find the fact that so many women here have said they prefer men over women so intriguing. And that men are nicer. And kinder.

Not my experience at all, but something I have noticed about male doctors (both acquaintances and in medical settings) is that they are very nice, very charming, very agreeable - until you challenge them, or disagree with them. And then the change can be startling.

So part of me wonders if the reason these men are so charming is that they are in a professional situation where they don't get challenged, women do what they want, they do what they want, everyone's happy. I have heard more than once of women I know being told by a male doctor - "this is what I would want if you were my daughter." Which I also find odd and inappropriate in a clinical setting.

Meanwhile female doctors presumably aren't granted that automatic authority with a female patient - they are seen more as equal (which I prefer.) And wouldn't get away with a paternalistic line like "if you were my daughter" either.

I just don't believe that male gynaes are automatically better, I don't buy that. Yet that seems to be the belief of a lot of women on here.

teathyme · 21/10/2022 08:43

Obstetrics/gynaecology is a particularly gruelling speciality with very long hours. A female obstetrician who was about to do my c/s told me that she'd been on duty for 36 hours and hadn't slept yet. She was supposed to leave after 24 hours but they were short staffed and she had no choice. It's not a child friendly speciality at all. It can also be very traumatic.
A (female) doctor friend of mine told me that a lot of women go into opthalmology as its the only speciality where there are very few true emergencies. Even if you get stabbed in the eye they can just cover it and leave it until the next day! This makes it a much more realistic 9-5 job.

ancientgran · 21/10/2022 08:38

sourcreampringle · 20/10/2022 21:01

If someone is going to find it traumatic to have a male then automatically they are not the ‘best person’ and feeling traumatised after a procedure is certainly not the ‘best outcome’

But that means they should have the choice of doctor, it doesn't mean other women who are happy to see a male doctor shouldn't have the choice.

piesforever · 21/10/2022 07:56

What an awful childish thread. In the Breast Unit there are loads of male doctors. Doctors might have an interest in obs/gyn due to a family member, a really interesting placement, a great team, not because they are pervs and want to look up your flue! Medical people are professional!

sourcreampringle · 20/10/2022 21:01

1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 16:10

Well if the best person for the job happens to be a male then I guess it’s up to the patient if their own feelings count more than the best outcome from the procedure. There are lots of brilliant male gynaecologists, and there’s some rubbish ones. In the same way as there’s lots of female gynaecologists who are good and bad.

Also not everyone stating that they don’t want a male gynaecologist has suffered trauma. In fact I suspect many have not. There is a lot of misandry in this thread.

If someone is going to find it traumatic to have a male then automatically they are not the ‘best person’ and feeling traumatised after a procedure is certainly not the ‘best outcome’

TastefulRainbowUnicorn · 20/10/2022 20:00

Thanks for informing me you don’t care about my preferences, it’s very mutual! I wasn’t talking to you.

I was talking to the person who described it as misandry for women to prefer female hcps.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 20/10/2022 19:28

TastefulRainbowUnicorn · 20/10/2022 18:14

If it’s misandry to prefer getting a smear test from a woman then I’m a proud misandrist 😂. Look at me shamelessly misandering over here with my boundaries and my willingness to use my words and prioritising my own feelings over men’s and there’s nothing you can do about it.

I personally couldn't care less what your preference is.

It's just a bit tedious that any woman who doesn't care about the sex of a doctor or even prefers a male doctor is assumed to be either too young / too naive/ too thick to know better or is suffering from internalised misogyny/ is doing other women down/ when expressing their views.

NattyNatashia · 20/10/2022 18:57

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 20/10/2022 15:29

What has this to do with male gynaecologists?

Based on this only, I don't know the full story, it certainly sounds like the hospital failed in treating a patient with care. I do feel that someone who has trauma related to a sex attack may want all female team, whether that is practical or possible is a different matter and if not the hospital should have been clear. I suspect the alarm bell in this case though relates to the comment about refusing questions about gender so would suggest there is another agenda here. I do respect someones desire to want an all female team but I also respect the team desire to be respected too.

TastefulRainbowUnicorn · 20/10/2022 18:14

If it’s misandry to prefer getting a smear test from a woman then I’m a proud misandrist 😂. Look at me shamelessly misandering over here with my boundaries and my willingness to use my words and prioritising my own feelings over men’s and there’s nothing you can do about it.

ScotchPine · 20/10/2022 18:00

1HappyTraveller · 20/10/2022 16:10

Well if the best person for the job happens to be a male then I guess it’s up to the patient if their own feelings count more than the best outcome from the procedure. There are lots of brilliant male gynaecologists, and there’s some rubbish ones. In the same way as there’s lots of female gynaecologists who are good and bad.

Also not everyone stating that they don’t want a male gynaecologist has suffered trauma. In fact I suspect many have not. There is a lot of misandry in this thread.

Nowhere have I stated that ‘everyone’ is citing reasons of past trauma, but many are. Nor have I failed to acknowledge that there are some good male practitioners and poor female ones.

When you say ‘best outcome’, presumably you are referring solely to the best physical outcome. I am also taking into
consideration the psychological impact which can adversely affect both mother and child. The best scenario would be that women can have a choice at an incredibly vulnerable moment of their lives about who performs the most invasive and intimate procedures imaginable so that they are not traumatised. Currently they can’t always. That is an issue.

Women who have not experienced prior trauma are also allowed to have feelings about who penetrates their vagina! And to request a practitioner of their choice. That isn’t misandry, that’s having bodily autonomy.

For the record, I don’t believe that all men enter this field for nefarious reasons. Many will be competent and compassionate. Unfortunately, though, there have been numerous cases of male HCPs sexually assaulting female patients. I know women personally who have had some disturbing experiences. So, I can understand the perspective of someone who wants to safeguard themselves and minimise the risk by requesting a female. Nothing ‘laughable’ about it, sadly it’s an indictment of the gender-based violence that still exists in our society.

Swipe left for the next trending thread