Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
listsandbudgets · 18/10/2022 14:29

DS was delivered by a male student midwife. In fact he was his qualifying baby. The bizarre thing as that it never crossed my mind I'd have .an delivering my baby. I went from 2 to 9cm in a rather painful 40 minutes and I till midwife on ward told me I was making a fuss about nothing and I could ha e a paracetamol! Then I insisted she examined me and she almost threw me in a trolly saying " you can't hVe baby in the ward think.of the paperwork"..

Next thing I knew I was in a lift and a man's voice was saying " don't push yet Lists you're not quite ready.. jist listen to me and wait a while".. and the only reason I paid any attention at all was because I thought it was the porter, there was no one else in the lift and he didn't fancy delivering a baby 😂

In tbe end I couldn't asked for better midwife. He was superb and made me feel so safe and cared for. I really hope he went on to have a great career and no one else mistook him for the porter I think some men are just suited to the work and it does t bother me

crunchieroxks · 18/10/2022 14:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Few comments on here have made me as angry as this @Theroad

I'm a daughter with a father, a sister with a brother, a wife with a husband and the mother of a son. Not all men are sexual predators.

I am not naïve about the existence of sexual depravity and I don't need your patronising dismissal of my opinion.

Notanotherwindow · 18/10/2022 14:27

It's very common to shit yourself while giving birth. I doubt they're getting their rocks off somehow...

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 14:26

@Lullabies2Paralyze what you said WAS NOT FUNNY OR A JOKE IT WAS JUST DISGUSTING LESBOPHOBIA

dutysuite · 18/10/2022 14:25

I can imagine for every nice fanny they see there’s going to be many more that are grim. My friend is a midwife and has told me some horror stories, some women don’t think to wash before any of these appointments!

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 18/10/2022 14:24

Sorry that was directed at @88milesanhour not @ScotchPine

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 14:23

For anyone who wants female clinicians any hospital would absolutely accomodate this where possible. If it absolutely has to be a male (eg it's overnight and only one doc on call) then you can ask for a female chaperone tp be present during any procedure/examination and this should be accomodated no questions.
I guess what some might be suggesting though is, if for some women and girls with trauma from assault, it feels like sexual assault, shouldn’t it be something that isn’t ‘avoided’ but can’t happen. There should always be a female available for this reason. I know potentially there aren’t the numbers for that now, but to completely eliminate that group of women suffering what feels like assault, that would be the ideal scenario. It’s just not obviously a priority for anyone.

RaininginDarling · 18/10/2022 14:23

@ScotchPine that's a great question! I do think there is a gap in care around managing trauma which is often carrued in the body unconsciously. I suffered serious abuse as a child and whilst I'm pretty emotionally sound (lots of work there), I found being prodded unexpectedly when sleeping (when I was in hospital) deeply disturbing. There was zero acknowledgement that suddenly pulling sheets back, grabbing someone's arm or roughly waking a sleeping person might actually be distressing particularly when you're sick and vulnerable

Lullabies2Paralyze · 18/10/2022 14:23

@YouSirNeighMmmm clearly my bit about lesbian was tongue in cheek as some people do think males do it to get off on staring at vag all day hence why some people think males shouldn’t do the role (not saying anyone on this post has said that as there’s too many to read through all of them, but it’s a known fact that some women in the world do think this)

sarcasm is evidently too hard to convey through texts though and my cat amongst the pigeons part didn’t give you any extra hints either. READ THE FUCKING TEXT AND GET THE FUCKING JOKE NEXT TIME!

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 18/10/2022 14:22

@ScotchPine Without stereotyping men perhaps tend to cope with the stress of this on the whole a little better than women.

That is stereotyping.

If you're a doctor, you're a very patronising one.

Dinosaurhearmeroar · 18/10/2022 14:22

some of the answers here are so po faced! It is not analogous to other areas like paeds, ortho etc, this is one very specific area that only women have and most men would have only encountered them through sexual experience (unless - no I can’t think of another scenario!) so I think it’s totally a fair question. I often wonder why - I would never have a male do my smear, only feel comfortable with women.

ilytmab · 18/10/2022 14:21

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 14:10

I'm so sorry @ilytmab - I posted without seeing your post. This is a dreadful thing to have happened and I can absolutely understand you not wanting any men around you in such an intimate and vulnerable situation.

Perhaps I have been very fortunate in my medical treatment.

Flowers I think my situation was - I hope - extreme. I worked with him on another ward before I was his patient and he was a creep even then I think . He did something that could have been seen by a witness as being completely normal but it very definitely wasn’t - I remember realising what was actually happening and freezing . It would have been very difficult for a chaperone to see what was actually happening and I’ve been told since that there was probably a certain amount of ‘talking me into making me think was my fault’ . I’ve had a hell of a lot of therapy from the NHS and still am now, they’re completely accepting that it happened as I remember - although I can’t go to the police .

I do think it’s at the extreme end, I hope .

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 18/10/2022 14:21

ScotchPine · 18/10/2022 14:13

Tone is hard to get across on here so I’m not saying this unkindly and I realise that you wrote your post in response to the OP, but I have a genuine question. While looking at ‘lady parts’ might be the last thing on their mind (most of the time - we’ve all seen the harrowing stories of women being assaulted under the guise of medical care), it is a horror for some women to be examined internally by a male doctor. For multiple reasons, including past trauma. Do doctors commonly understand this? It doesn’t really seem to me like there is much understanding of trauma-informed care in the medical community. I’ve been lucky on some occasions, but otherwise have come up against a wall of ‘we’ve seen it all before’ and ‘don’t worry, he’s very nice’. Do doctors understand that gynaecological procedures and childbirth can have a long-lasting psychological impact and do conversations happen about the importance of patients being able to see a practitioner of their choice wherever possible for their psychological well-being?

I take on board what you're saying fully. I'm not disputing this and nor would I ever even question any woman (or man for that matter) who wants a say over who examines them intimately. My point was simply a reassurance that most men aren't doing this specialism because they're a creep they're doing it because they have a genuine and wholesome interest. Hospitals do what they can to be respectful and understanding of how intimidating it can be being a patient. However, in the chaos of a typical day in an NHS hospital I'm sure this isn't always communicated effectively sadly

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 14:19

For multiple reasons, including past trauma. Do doctors commonly understand this? It doesn’t really seem to me like there is much understanding of trauma-informed care in the medical community.

Yes, this

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 18/10/2022 14:19

not to put the cat amongst the pigeons, but the female you requested may be a lesbian!! 😮😮

What a truly, truly stupid comment.

This isn't about sexual orientation - it's about power and misogyny. Some men like having power over women, seeing them in pain, getting them alone in rooms and abusing them. Some of those men are doctors. Does anyone recall the gymnastics doctor? Constant abuse.

Isn't it 98% of sex crimes committed by men?

So no, it matters not at all to me if my female doctor is a lesbian. It's about the very real risk of abuse, which is largely committed by one sex - men.

And yes, yes, I know #notallmen - but enough of them for me to stick with female HCPs whenever I have a say in it.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 14:19

The malpractice insurance for obstetrics is eye-watering;

That would explain the very high caesarian section rates in the US, I would think.

WahineToa · 18/10/2022 14:18

@ilytmab so sorry that happened to you 💐

Hadjab · 18/10/2022 14:18

dottypotter · 18/10/2022 11:32

By creating this thread you are saying that men should have mens jobs and women should have women's jobs.
Do you question female decorators or plumbers or male nanny's or nurses or female football referees?

I had a female Gas Engineer come round to fix my hot water this morning - I was definitely thinking who allowed her out of the kitchen, rather than hoping she'd be able to sort the issue 🙄

knitnerd90 · 18/10/2022 14:17

IN the USA OB/GYN is regarded as a relatively low paying speciality, especially if you are in general practice rather than a sub-speciality such as gyn/onc. 80% of US OB-GYN residents are women, and analysts do link poor pay and prestige to the feminization of the specialty (also an issue in paediatrics). The malpractice insurance for obstetrics is eye-watering; some doctors only practice gynaecology because of that.

I know quite a few OB/GYNs and it's a fascinating area that offers a big variety of practice. I can't say that no man ever went in for the wrong reasons, including the power dynamic, but I certainly wouldn't automatically assume that.

RaininginDarling · 18/10/2022 14:16

@Emotionalsupportviper yes, its hard to truly appreciate just how extraordinarily painful constipation can be. I speak as someone who was on IV morphine for ten days to manage the agony last year (whilst knocking back Laxido to no effect). I was so grateful when, after surgery, two weeks later, I could finally go. I came out of hospital a stone lighter and with a new appreciation for working bowels

88milesanhour · 18/10/2022 14:14

I'm so sorry @ilytmab Sadly there is a tiny number of monsters out there who abuse their position and cause us to need to have these conversations :-(

For anyone who wants female clinicians any hospital would absolutely accomodate this where possible. If it absolutely has to be a male (eg it's overnight and only one doc on call) then you can ask for a female chaperone tp be present during any procedure/examination and this should be accomodated no questions.

temporarysecrettellingnamechange · 18/10/2022 14:13

@BadNomad The private hospital in a place I once lived had a 55% c-section rate. Women were basically told - "at this point we go to caesarian" and that was more or less that.

The doctor in charge was also head of the AMA (in Australia) and he would always say, when questioned about such high rates that women were older and fatter.

And yes, he was very into his local sports.

ScotchPine · 18/10/2022 14:13

88milesanhour · 18/10/2022 13:57

I'm a doctor and will try and answer..

Firstly, not every doctor/nurse you see in a gynaecology setting will be specialising in that area. Doctors spend at least 2 years rotating specialisms quite randomly and they may well be in gynaecology having zero interest in it. However they will always be working under more senior doctors who are very much specialists

Gynaecology is a fascinating specialism for lots of reasons. Not to sound corny but the miracle of childbirth is incredible to assist in whether you're man or woman. What greater privledge is there than to help someone do this safely?! Also, it has lots of fascinating subspecialisms that I can imagine are incredibly stimulating to be involved with eg in-utero surgery and infertility treatment. Also obstetrics and gynae is fundamentally a surgical specialism and one in which there is a heavy risk of litigation. I think you have to have nerves of steal to do it tbh. Without stereotyping men perhaps tend to cope with the stress of this on the whole a little better than women. Not to say there aren't plenty of just as capable women out there making incredible surgeons though so please don't take this to mean I'm knocking them!

It's a far more complex specialism than just looking at lady parts all day and for most male doctors that's honestly the last thing on their mind

Tone is hard to get across on here so I’m not saying this unkindly and I realise that you wrote your post in response to the OP, but I have a genuine question. While looking at ‘lady parts’ might be the last thing on their mind (most of the time - we’ve all seen the harrowing stories of women being assaulted under the guise of medical care), it is a horror for some women to be examined internally by a male doctor. For multiple reasons, including past trauma. Do doctors commonly understand this? It doesn’t really seem to me like there is much understanding of trauma-informed care in the medical community. I’ve been lucky on some occasions, but otherwise have come up against a wall of ‘we’ve seen it all before’ and ‘don’t worry, he’s very nice’. Do doctors understand that gynaecological procedures and childbirth can have a long-lasting psychological impact and do conversations happen about the importance of patients being able to see a practitioner of their choice wherever possible for their psychological well-being?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 18/10/2022 14:13

All gynaecologists have also trained as obstetricians, though many eventually specialise in either one or the other.

O&G is a fascinating speciality, with a broad range of medical (i.e. non-surgical) and surgical issues. There are not many areas of medicine where you could find yourself managing complex hormonal problems and also performing surgery.

Are there some predators amongst male gynaecologists? For sure - as sadly, we know that predators are attracted to all professions that give them access to vulnerable patients. But most doctors don't choose a speciality because they particularly like a body part. Urologists aren't all penis-obsessed, proctologists aren't really into arseholes. You choose a speciality because you are interested in the medical conditions it involves.

Lopilo · 18/10/2022 14:12

The only male gynaecologist I ever had, made several very creepy comments to me about my sex life and my tightness. I have absolutely no illusions about why he got into that area of medicine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread