Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men work in gynecology?

759 replies

CustardC · 18/10/2022 11:04

Genuine question, my sisters and I were discussing our most recent smear tests and sister 1 commented on how her nurse was male. I've always asked for a female when I book a smear or any type of gyne issues and it's always been respected, but it got me thinking...if there are any men here who work in that field, why?

I'm fully prepared for the backlash that ill probably get but honest question👍

OP posts:
Ireolu · 18/10/2022 19:47

It's the same as asking why are some women urologists...we have a female family friend who is a urologist. She has done it for years is great at her Job and it just so happens that most of her customers are men and their prostates. urologists will see women too though. There are a significant number of obstetricians and gynaecologists that are men. It is what it is.

IrisVersicolor · 18/10/2022 19:41

EdgeOfACoin · 18/10/2022 19:31

85% of gynaecology students are female and it climbs higher each year, also makes it harder for the minority of males trying to make it in the field as women patients decline them far more often now they have a choice and female doctors are the norms.

Interesting. It seems to match up with what a PP said about her GP friend getting fed up of treating 'women's issues' as female patients keep requesting a woman doctor.

It appears as though in the real world women prefer to see female doctors when it comes to intimate healthcare.

And potentially men prefer to see men about prostates/testicular disorders.

EdgeOfACoin · 18/10/2022 19:31

85% of gynaecology students are female and it climbs higher each year, also makes it harder for the minority of males trying to make it in the field as women patients decline them far more often now they have a choice and female doctors are the norms.

Interesting. It seems to match up with what a PP said about her GP friend getting fed up of treating 'women's issues' as female patients keep requesting a woman doctor.

It appears as though in the real world women prefer to see female doctors when it comes to intimate healthcare.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 18/10/2022 19:25

No where did I say it didn't happen. But there are some in this thread suggesting all men in that field are in for the kicks.

And yes. Trauma can happen in many way. My trauma was caused by women. And it's not insubstantial trauma.

Bestcatmum · 18/10/2022 19:21

2bazookas · 18/10/2022 13:37

You think that's bad? During labour I refused an internal examination by a female doctor wearing huge false talon nails. Behind her , the midwife was rolling her eyes and mouthing "thankyou".

OMG!!!!! That's horrifying.

sourcreampringle · 18/10/2022 19:13

oviraptor21 · 18/10/2022 19:07

Although the poll would indicate that it's actually nearer 50:50

Meh I just think about the fact men are disappearing from gynaecology- 85% of gynaecology students are female and it climbs higher each year, also makes it harder for the minority of males trying to make it in the field as women patients decline them far more often now they have a choice and female doctors are the norms.

So the debate about being for or against male gynaes won’t matter as there will be nothing to debate 😂

oviraptor21 · 18/10/2022 19:07

SleeplessInEngland · 18/10/2022 12:07

Good to see the posters against male gynecologists are in the stark (and at times raving) minority.

Although the poll would indicate that it's actually nearer 50:50

GlassesWearer · 18/10/2022 19:02

Wombat100 · 18/10/2022 12:19

👏

Thanks for agreeing. Unfortunately HQ have taken down my comment despite it not breaching any of the Talk Guidelines - I checked. Apparently stating that people aren't naive just because they're not sexist is unacceptable on here (the exact words I used).

SummerCarnival · 18/10/2022 18:58

My gynaecologist is a male, he's fabulous. Although I haven't seen him in a long time.

I think to be a (decent) gynae as a male you need to have utmost respect for female anatomy.

The worst gynae I saw was a middle aged female. I changed from her to the male one and it was one of the best things I did. I got fobbed off by the female one.
The male one made it possible to get my diagnosis (which ended up being cancer, after many fobs.)

sourcreampringle · 18/10/2022 18:57

If I couldn’t get an appointment with a female nurse for a smear test I probably wouldn’t go.

sourcreampringle · 18/10/2022 18:56

Rlt8990 · 18/10/2022 18:51

Apologies if this has been mentioned already but if you have been for a smear test in general practice, that is a practice nurse you see not someone who works in gynae. They have many different skills/ aspects of their job and male nurses shouldn't be stopped from doing that part of the job because they are male. If all of you were seen in hospital for follow up then that would be a gynae consultant but as others have said why does it matter ?! You can request female staff but drs can be any speciality...

hmm there is always drive to try and increase smear test uptake though, and many women are still declining or missing their smear tests. In reality having male staff perform them would be very detrimental to this cause.

GreenIsle · 18/10/2022 18:55

Rlt8990 · 18/10/2022 18:51

Apologies if this has been mentioned already but if you have been for a smear test in general practice, that is a practice nurse you see not someone who works in gynae. They have many different skills/ aspects of their job and male nurses shouldn't be stopped from doing that part of the job because they are male. If all of you were seen in hospital for follow up then that would be a gynae consultant but as others have said why does it matter ?! You can request female staff but drs can be any speciality...

Yes but if I was to feel even slightly comfortable with a male performing a procedure I would rather it was solely his job not something of a novelty. There would be more declines of a male nurse for a smear than for a specialist gynaecologist issue.

Rlt8990 · 18/10/2022 18:51

Apologies if this has been mentioned already but if you have been for a smear test in general practice, that is a practice nurse you see not someone who works in gynae. They have many different skills/ aspects of their job and male nurses shouldn't be stopped from doing that part of the job because they are male. If all of you were seen in hospital for follow up then that would be a gynae consultant but as others have said why does it matter ?! You can request female staff but drs can be any speciality...

SnoopyNoseTits · 18/10/2022 18:41

My (female) dr didn’t believe me when I said I thought my issues were XYZ thing and took ages to send me to gynaecology, instead sending me round the houses for 6 months. When I eventually got to the see a (male) gynaecologist, he was very respectful, listened to me, and confirmed that yes it was indeed XYZ that I was suffering from.

Felix125 · 18/10/2022 18:36

And yet when women complain about men sleazing on them, and men minimise groping, and the women say "How would you like it if strange women grabbed your crotch" etc, the blokes invariably respond with "I should be so lucky", "I'd love it, darling!", "Oh yes please!' A totally different attitude - women don't joke about it like this.

i think most men will use this as a defence mechanism to stop it happening - kind of reverse psychology.

And sexual assaults do traumatise people no matter if your male or female. Its not a question of being physically stronger so you can overpower them - by the time you realise what is happening - its happened.

luxxlisbon · 18/10/2022 18:29

And yet when women complain about men sleazing on them, and men minimise groping, and the women say "How would you like it if strange women grabbed your crotch" etc, the blokes invariably respond with "I should be so lucky", "I'd love it, darling!", "Oh yes please!' A totally different attitude - women don't joke about it like this.

Do they?
Maybe you need to reconsider the men in your life. I have never heard a single man say that.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 18:20

luxxlisbon · 18/10/2022 15:49

Do you think that on average a man who is sexually assaulted by a woman is as harmed by the experience as when it happens the other way round?

Yes, what a ridiculous comment. A man who is sexually assaulted by a woman is likely to be just as harmed as the other way around. FS we don’t build up women by minimising sexual assault against men.
That sort of thinking throws back to a time when it isn’t ‘real’ rape if it wasn’t a stranger in a dark alley.

And yet when women complain about men sleazing on them, and men minimise groping, and the women say "How would you like it if strange women grabbed your crotch" etc, the blokes invariably respond with "I should be so lucky", "I'd love it, darling!", "Oh yes please!' A totally different attitude - women don't joke about it like this.

I'm sure men wouldn't like it if elderly, or unattractive women touched them - but it certainly wouldn't traumatise them the way an assault does a women. For one thing, men are physically stronger - they are highly unlikely to be overpowered, and taken advantage of. They have the strength to repel an assault if they needed to.

Not saying in never happens (eg Joyce McKinnon), but it is far from the same dynamic - and it certainly doesn't happen to "millions" of men.

Bintymcbintface · 18/10/2022 18:12

If I had medical issues and needed seen I couldn't give two hoots if it was a man, woman or a feckin leopard that was helping me so long as they were qualified...

glassfully · 18/10/2022 18:08

@glassfully... He decided the best way to stop it happening to other women would be to retrain and change his specialism to gynaecology.

Was he right though? Would he have had a more positive impact had he spent his spare time encouraging women into gynaecology and encouraging research into best pricatice*.

How could he have done that as a cardiologist? Even with the best will in the world, nothing changes if the people in charge don't care or brush mistakes under the carpet rather than look at how to fix them.

Felix125 · 18/10/2022 18:05

YouSirNeighMmmm · 18/10/2022 16:40

One might be able to approximate it though? Compare male victims of women and vice versa by reference to length of time before therapist and patient agree that much of the worst trauma has been dealt with; percentage of each sex who develop an addiction afterwards; whether it changes behaviour or whether people's day to day livs carry on as before?

Anecdotal i know - but as a male, I was sexually assaulted when i was about 18 by a woman in a bar/club (early 90's). Tried to 'get over it' at the time but it did effect me with confidence & trust issues for quite some time after.

Fast forward to when i was early 40's and now as a police officer - dealing with a fight in a pub and crouching on the floor with a male detained on the floor and crowd gathering around us, when some female grabbed at me again then disappeared into the crowd. Brought everything back from when i was 18 again, flashbacks, anxiety etc. So it does effect us blokes - but we do what blokes do and try and put it in a box in the back of our brain and blot it out.

Iheartmysmart · 18/10/2022 17:59

It’s not something I would have given a second thought to until I supported a friend through an incredibly traumatic experience with her male GP. She was contacted by the police after it was discovered he was secretly filming himself examining female patients and she was one of his victims. She was and still is devastated and will never trust a male health care professional again and I don’t blame her.

JFDIYOLO · 18/10/2022 17:57

Two of my #metoo moments were at the hands of male hcps, one optician, one GP, maaaany years ago. And a male gynaecologist LIED to me to get me into the stirrups - female nurse had to make him stop because of the pain he had assured me would be 'mild discomfort'.

Rockingcloggs · 18/10/2022 17:55

The absolute bollocks being spouted on here is fucking reprehensible.

Schulte · 18/10/2022 17:54

Maybe they simply find it fascinating? I’ve had very good male gynaecologists. And bad female ones too.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 18/10/2022 17:50

Ottersmith · 18/10/2022 17:37

Because they are perverts! Or want to control women, or both. Any man who wants to specialise in womens vaginas can fuck off and treat balls as far as I'm concerned. In the last few years there were 50 registered male midwives in UK and 2 of them got convicted of sex crimes. That's just the ones who got convicted.

I googled to check your stats and one thing I found was "Of the 450 midwives permanently employed at Lewisham and Greenwich NHS Trust, three are men, including the head of midwifery, Giuseppe Labriola". 447 woman and it just so happens that the best candidate for the top job was one of three men.

FWIW it seems like more like 100 male midwives now, and that at least one was convicted of a sex crime in the last year, and at least one other was found guilty of misconduct that involved a sexual element. Your stats appear to be in the right ball park.

I think the way you have phrased that is unnecessarily blunt, and I don't agree with you... but I do have some sympathy with your view.

@glassfully... He decided the best way to stop it happening to other women would be to retrain and change his specialism to gynaecology.

Was he right though? Would he have had a more positive impact had he spent his spare time encouraging women into gynaecology and encouraging research into best pricatice