Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving away guilt. Would you move back to help family?

132 replies

LiberatedMind · 18/10/2022 08:06

Dh and I moved about 4/5 hours away two years ago for early retirement. We're approaching 60 and just wanted to live somewhere more peaceful, in a village setting. We enjoy our hobbies and interests here - gardening, dog walks, canoeing, visiting pubs, tea rooms, etc. We don't have any other family nearby but have got to know the locals well.

We moved away from our daughter and her family. They have two young children under 5 and I know their lives can be very difficult. Sil has had quite complex mental health problems and our daughter has really struggled with this. Especially as she's had her own health problems too. One of the children has got special needs and I know that can be very draining for them. Both dd and sil work and financially I think they're managing (just over £2000pm between them) so only just. The house looks like it's falling apart because they don't have the time or extra money to do anything about it.

Sil's family live near them but they are older than us and I know that their capabilities to support are limited.

We visit when we can for a couple of days. They've only been to see us once. The offer has been there any time to stay but I think their life difficulties mentioned make this hard. For instance, I rang them last weekend and sil had had a terrible time with his mental health problems. This impacted on them all and it sounded like them children were struggling too. BTW, sil is getting treatment so it's not like it's not being helped but still debilitating at times. I've also offered for the gc to cone and stay with us but our daughter isn't keen on them being so far away from them yet. They are young still.

I feel so guilty. We have an idealic, peaceful, comfortable life where we are but we know that they are finding day to day life a massive challenge. Maybe they are angry with us about it to a certain extent but they've never said that and I sort of get why.

If this was your family, would you move back to support them? Should I feel guilty?

OP posts:
sheepdogdelight · 18/10/2022 15:54

amicissimma · 18/10/2022 15:43

I find it quite sad how many people think that, although their parents (presumably) gave up their time, energy, money, possibly health in order to raise them (the parents' own DC), they should only provide support when it's needed in later life based on the amount of support those parents gave as grandparents.

I was very happy that my parents were able to enjoy their lives in their own way when I was grown, paired off and raising my own DC. They had less healthy time than expected and I'm so glad they didn't spend a lot of it wearing themselves out helping to raise my small DCs. But when my parents needed my help I was happy to step up because they had looked after me when I was a child.

Parents choose to have and bring up children

Children do not necessarily choose to care for their parents.

My observation is that it's not a question of how much support they provided as grandparents that influence how much a child cares for their parent in later life - but the relationships between the two. In general, if relationships are good, family members are happy and willing to help each other out (in both directions). Of course there is a high correlation between families with strong relationships providing support as grandparents. Equally if grandparents are not providing support to their DC (I don't necessarily mean day by day support here as health/distance may not allow) it will tend to suggest relationships are poor.

Or, put another way. I don't know of a single family where there are great relationships where the parents wouldn't support their children and the children their parents. And this is nothing to do with the fact that parents brought up their children (which is a pretty low bar).

amicissimma · 18/10/2022 15:43

I find it quite sad how many people think that, although their parents (presumably) gave up their time, energy, money, possibly health in order to raise them (the parents' own DC), they should only provide support when it's needed in later life based on the amount of support those parents gave as grandparents.

I was very happy that my parents were able to enjoy their lives in their own way when I was grown, paired off and raising my own DC. They had less healthy time than expected and I'm so glad they didn't spend a lot of it wearing themselves out helping to raise my small DCs. But when my parents needed my help I was happy to step up because they had looked after me when I was a child.

PossiblyOverstepping · 18/10/2022 14:58

I’d have loved to have my parents help with DCs but they are very very far away indeed because they died. It’s awful but it happens. You only get one life OP (if this is not a reverse) so live it as you see fit. I do agree late 50s is very early for Last of the Summer Wine but you do you !

Snoredoeurve · 18/10/2022 14:09

passport123 · 18/10/2022 13:12

Yes, this. You're really young to be spending your days pootling round the countryside. When you get old and need help, don't expect it from your daughter.

Too young?
What!?
The GPs should be out having a whale of time before its too late.
My own DP did in their early 60s and Im so glad they did.
The whole I wont look after you then thing is so immature and petty.
Emotional blackmail.
I dont want my DCs to look after me.

passport123 · 18/10/2022 13:12

Blackberrybunnet · 18/10/2022 11:36

You deserve to live your own life without feeling guilty about it. However, you have to also recognise that when (if) you need help when you are older, that's on you - not your family. Having said that, I would help from a distance, as others have suggested - take children for days out/stay over for a weekend and let adults go off for a break/pay for grocery deliveries every now and again/pay for treats: whatever would be most appreciated.

Yes, this. You're really young to be spending your days pootling round the countryside. When you get old and need help, don't expect it from your daughter.

covilha · 18/10/2022 13:01

What happens when the children are older? Would you be able to afford to your current setting or would you be outpriced?
I have moved back, to support an older family member. In the meantime she had become friendly with someone so barely wanted to see me whilst I had a quit a job which would have taken me around the world
can you hire an Air bnb and stay for a few weeks at a time

justasking111 · 18/10/2022 12:54

Mumsnet will work out if this is a reverse. I'd leave it to them

Butchyrestingface · 18/10/2022 12:28

I think posters who repeatedly post reverses should get the ban hammer, or at the very least, a month's suspension.

It's such a manipulative and dishonest thing to do - the opposite of good-faith posting.

Nanny0gg · 18/10/2022 12:17

LiberatedMind · 18/10/2022 09:08

Sometimes I feel bad putting photos of ours lives on social media every so often, like a beautiful beach scene or lunch at a country pub. I'm not saying I do that all the time but dd and sil never like those things despite them being on social media. I know that's very trivial but possibly shows how they feel.

Wow!

What on earth is the need to do that?

Tone deaf!

Cherry35 · 18/10/2022 11:47

If it's reverse, just communicate with your parents, ask them for help. Most parents would try to help their children. I expect you had a good relationship before moving. Ask them to move for a couple of years or so.

If this is real, talk to your daughter, offer to move; she may say no and in that case help in other ways, with a cleaner or money.

Regardless of your decision to leave close to your DC and help them doesn't equal they will care for you in old age. Some children are just ungrateful and not empathetic, they take their money even when adults and when old parents need help are not there for them, it has happened with relatives.

whumpthereitis · 18/10/2022 11:38

OP, you seriously need to look at getting help for yourself. You are unwell. Every time you make a thread you acknowledge that you can’t control your in laws and that you need to let it go, but a month later your back with the same issue, either playing it straight or as a reverse.

for whatever reason your in laws have become the focal point of your illness, and your obsession with them likely frightens, if not terrifies, them. If we’re able to see it just based on your threads I can’t imagine what it must be like to deal with it directed at you in real life.

this isn’t normal behaviour, and it’s not healthy behaviour.

Blackberrybunnet · 18/10/2022 11:36

You deserve to live your own life without feeling guilty about it. However, you have to also recognise that when (if) you need help when you are older, that's on you - not your family. Having said that, I would help from a distance, as others have suggested - take children for days out/stay over for a weekend and let adults go off for a break/pay for grocery deliveries every now and again/pay for treats: whatever would be most appreciated.

thedoofus · 18/10/2022 11:27

Taking the OP at face value:

It's up to you. Extended families are all different - some are close (geographically and/or emotionally) and some aren't. Some people will think it's totally reasonable and understandable to prioritise your own lives and your own happiness; some will think it's heartless to not be on hand to provide support to your daughter and her family. But it's what you think that matters - there aren't any right or wrong answers.

I've never lived close to my parents as an adult. They retired overseas when my niece was a baby and I was pregnant with my first child. I think they did feel some guilt/sadness that they weren't closer when we had young children, but they also were fulfilling their lifelong dream of living abroad. I imagine it must have been quite difficult seeing us struggle with young children from a distance. To be fair, in an emergency they have always come over and helped (as we have for them) - only been an issue a couple of times in the 17 years.

I don't resent the choice they have made; in many ways I admire it and I'm glad they've been able to do it. But there have been and continue to be consequences of it in terms of the relationships they have with their grandchildren and with us. Kids are now teens, and I don't know how the relationship with their grandparents will evolve once they leave home and don't, for example, come on our family holidays where we see them. And my parents are getting older, and obviously we will not be able to offer them any day-to-day practical support or care even if we wanted to.

sheepdogdelight · 18/10/2022 11:25

Surely you made this decision when you moved?
You are free to enjoy your retirement as you wish; however you will have to accept that with the distance you will be seeing your family infrequently, and it may be up to you to do the running.

My parents made a similar move. They said "oh you can come and visit all the time" - but fitting in a visit that now has to be 2 days and is exhausting is not that easy.

It's up to you whether you want to prioritise spending time with your family or enjoying retirement. I don't think either is wrong - but both have consequences.

One thing I would say is to spell it out to your DC that you don't expect any support from them in later life (if indeed you don't?). That might be the thing that breaks them.

BillHadersLeftEye · 18/10/2022 11:21

I've just read the reverse. Leave your folks in peace.

BillHadersLeftEye · 18/10/2022 11:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

LindyLou2020 · 18/10/2022 11:11

I wrote my previous post before scrolling back, and being told the OP's opening post is a reverse. So bloody annoying 😡

whumpthereitis · 18/10/2022 11:11

IncompleteSenten · 18/10/2022 11:00

Well holy fuck. 4 hours isn't far enough away!

Does the op think they can go to the parents and say move back now! The internet says you have to.

🤦

They’ve only just moved as well. OP’s presenting them as feeling guilty when, if anything, they’ll be breathing sighs of relief at having escaped.

she’s been making threads about them for months. I bet it’s been hell for them in real life, and I do wonder if OP and her husband’s obsessive behaviour towards them is why they decided to move away in the first place.

LindyLou2020 · 18/10/2022 11:08

LiberatedMind · 18/10/2022 09:08

Sometimes I feel bad putting photos of ours lives on social media every so often, like a beautiful beach scene or lunch at a country pub. I'm not saying I do that all the time but dd and sil never like those things despite them being on social media. I know that's very trivial but possibly shows how they feel.

@LiberatedMind
As I was reading this thread, I was developing a lot of empathy for both you and your husband, and your daughter and son-in-law......until I saw this post of yours. I had to read it several times as I couldn't believe what I was reading.
Why on earth are you bragging about your beach scenes or country pub lunches on social media if you suspect this would upset them?
Sorry, but that just seems so tone-deaf and totally insensitive 🙄

IncompleteSenten · 18/10/2022 11:00

whumpthereitis · 18/10/2022 10:35

And this is OP’s last ‘as herself’ post:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4638351-would-you-prioritise-your-grandchilds-birthday?page=1

Her in laws were afraid enough of their son and DIL’s reaction to them moving to a house they already own, with the elderly GM they already act as carers for, that they put off telling them as long as possible. With good reason, because OP is absolutely obsessed with them.

Well holy fuck. 4 hours isn't far enough away!

Does the op think they can go to the parents and say move back now! The internet says you have to.

🤦

FiveShelties · 18/10/2022 10:45

IncompleteSenten · 18/10/2022 10:33

I'm pissed off by reverses. They are manipulative.

Tbh, I would move back but they don't have to and if they don't want to you can't make them. You can either be bitter or accept it's their choice. You can't go get a court order forcing them to come help take care of you.

I hate reverses too. Such a childish way to get support.

rookiemere · 18/10/2022 10:45

I hope this isn't a reverse, they are very tiresome.

On the basis that it's not, there have been some useful suggestions. Firstly if you can offer some financial support, I'm sure that would be gratefully received. £200 a month would probably make a huge difference to their quality of life by allowing them to buy in some respite care.

Or the other option is buying a caravan or small apartment near them so you aren't under their feet when visiting and can come more frequently. If that's not an option, then definitely look at Airbnb when you do visit so you could stay for longer without being a burden.

I don't necessarily think you did the wrong thing following your dreams. But I believe you can offer more support and still have your idyllic life most of the time.

Princessglittery · 18/10/2022 10:45

LiberatedMind · 18/10/2022 09:08

Sometimes I feel bad putting photos of ours lives on social media every so often, like a beautiful beach scene or lunch at a country pub. I'm not saying I do that all the time but dd and sil never like those things despite them being on social media. I know that's very trivial but possibly shows how they feel.

It is not obligatory to like SM posts. To be honest given you description of their lives I would not be surprised if they don’t even see them.

Any guilt you are feeling is not because you have comfortable lives it’s because you know you could help them more. It’s not an either or it’s about balance.

Despite the fact my parents did not physically look after their respective Mums in their old age, I visit my Mum (1hour away) twice a week and have just come back from taking her away from a long weekend. Yes It can be a chore but I still have my life.

There is no reason you couldn’t visit at least once a month to help out and give your DD some respite. Find an airbnb nearby so you have some space and are not overcrowded, it makes it easier on everyone.

InsertPunHere · 18/10/2022 10:44

If this is a reverse, do jog on.

If it’s legitimate, don’t be daft, of course you shouldn’t feel guilty for where you want to live. It sounds a lovely place. Ask your DD how you can support her but don’t up sticks and move.

SleeplessInEngland · 18/10/2022 10:42

Yeah I would move back. I couldn’t enjoy that sort of life knowing how much my daughter was struggling

The OP is the daughter. She's utterly obsessed with her parents and has made multiple reverse threads on this topic. I feel sorry for her family.