Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist my DP is harsher with her ex

61 replies

TiredManDad · 17/10/2022 21:41

A long time lurker and reader wanting a bit of advice and a heads up to see if the flavour on here is that I'm being unreasonable.

Quick back story, been with my DP for 3 years and we have a wonderful relationship. We both have kids from previous relationships. We have one of her children full time and the other one 10 days out of 14.

Dp ex partner was very controlling and is older. Since we have got together he has had nails put in our tyres. Threatened us etc etc. Seems to have calmed down a but he only pays 50 per month maintenence as he gets paid a lot cash in hand. Even then he hardly ever pays it on time and we often get the kids dropped off with us without any notice at all on his days.

He is now 17 days late with his measly maintenance. Also yesterday he said he couldn't have his DD ruining our plans because he is ill, yet has been seen out with his GF.

I want my DP to challenge him, tell him we will go through the courts and also to say he's a nasty pathetic excuse for a human being. We are not nasty about him in front of his kids even though he always is about us and his kids find it funny.

I love my DP dearly and I understand she was mentally abused by him so doesn't want to or feel she can stand up to him, but today she has basically had a massive go at me because I have told her she needs to not put up with it and call him out for his behaviour, saying its not worth it and not up to me. I've said I will do it myself but she angrily told me not to, and then to underline matters she has been as nice as pie to him on the phone when he's said he will get his child tomorrow after school now he's feeling better. Arrrgh. Just needed to vent but also ask, AIBU to ask her to challenge and call out his behaviour?

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 18/10/2022 03:10

I understand how you'd be annoyed. I'd be wanting my partner to stand up for what's right too. But unfortunately some people aren't like that and they just can't. Maybe that gives her the personality that you love? Or maybe she knows if she starts being awkward, those nails will start appearing in the tyres again and it's just not worth it.
It looks like you'll just have to bite your lip. You have a child living at yours full time anyway, can't you just pretend that the other one lives there full time too, but occasionally and randomly, she sees her father. Rather than thinking she should be at her fathers on fixed days.
However if the children are laughing at or being rude about you at his instigation, your partner should put her foot down and stop that.

Dogscanteatonions · 18/10/2022 01:45

Stop. Just fucking stop. Please please please listen to what people are saying to you. I've been there in this exact position with my ex. It's awful, it doesn't help and it makes things far far worse.

You cannot change what he is like and getting worked up about it only makes things worse. And I tell you know like countless other women can tell you that if he gets paid cash in hand a lot then going through child maintenance is pointless and in fact may end up in his favour with him paying less!

The only way forward is to accept he is useless and not expect anything from him. I know it's shit, I know it's unfair but I promise you it is the best thing to do.

Please for heavens sake listen to what people here are saying

TiredManDad · 18/10/2022 00:13

TooTrusting · 17/10/2022 23:12

The two posts already seconded by others really resonated with me for personal reasons. But the reason I'm posting is to say you don't go through the courts for child maintenance. You simply apply to the CMS.
If he earns over £158k (or if he has significant assets) then the CMS issues the maximum assessment it can and the court then acquires jurisdiction to award more than the CMS can).
Assuming he is under that threshold, the CMS will look direct at his HMRC records to determine his declared income and will issue an assessment based on that. You then either accept direct pay or you get the CMS to collect it (and they charge the paying parent a fee and deduct a further fee from the receiving parent).

Unless you can clearly demonstrate undeclared earnings and prove what they are, the CMS's hands are tied. They will base the assessment on what he declares.

The CMS is not fit for purpose and with any cases that don't fit the simple mould they spend months doing nothing and not implementing their own regulations, and giving you the runaround. You tend not to see any sense until you have exhausted their review/reconsideration processes and have been moved onto the CMS Tribunal process.

Thank you.

I thought the CMS may do more background checks once they saw his ridiculously low basic wage but it appears not. What a shame it allows people like him to get away with not paying taxes or maintenance. But eh well, thank you for the advice.

OP posts:
TiredManDad · 18/10/2022 00:06

Aquamarine1029 · 17/10/2022 22:02

You are bullying her and you have no right whatsoever to tell her how to manage her relationship with her abusive ex. If you don't like it, you know where the door is. As for you confronting him, only an idiot would do that. You'd only make her life 100x harder. Wind your neck in, FFS.

Honestly I think you're misjudging the situation but I take your points on board.

The door is the last thing I'd want, the main reason I get angry is because of the way he acts and talks to the woman I love still. It's an incredibly difficult situation but I think you're being overly harsh.

We are a team, I too have an abusive ex and we often talk and help each other. I'd suggest as best friends and lovers we do have the right to give our opinions on how we should manage each of our relationships with our ex's.

I do agree that I have no right to demand or insist on anything though, perhaps that was the wrong choice of words. Upshot is, he is a dickhead, I hate that sometimes, but I'm going to have to learn to live with it until that glorious day that we don't have to deal with him again.

I just felt I needed to address the somewhat aggressive tone in your response though.

OP posts:
TiredManDad · 17/10/2022 23:57

SudocremOnEverything · 17/10/2022 23:20

You might also want to try talking to her about why she doesn’t go through CMS. There will be a reason. It might be that she’s been there, tried that, and it was pointless. It might be that she doesn’t want to poke the bear. It might be that she’s experienced how useless the CMS were and the effects of poking the bear with that particular stick.

The best thing you can do is expect nothing good from him. except no maintenance. Whatever he bothers to contribute is a bonus. Expect him to not show up and mess everyone around. Expect him to say terrible things to the children.

And support your partner in trying to deal with that, and to support her children despite their father’s inadequacies. Be there to say: ‘it doesn’t matter. We’ll be fine anyway’.

"And support your partner in trying to deal with that, and to support her children despite their father’s inadequacies. Be there to say: ‘it doesn’t matter. We’ll be fine anyway’."

I do constantly and have for three years. I guess sometimes frustration and anger of him 'getting away' with being horrible, controlling still and seemingly able to do as he pleases with no consequences just gets too much for me and I have to say something.

I do get the reasoning that I shouldn't though. I think people are misjudging the situation somewhat in interpreting that I'm being forceful in my insistence. I'm not at all, me and my DP have a close friendship and relationship and talk to each other about everything. We have about this today, we respect each others opinion and I won't push it. I just wanted to see people's views on here.

To make it clear as well we have no issue with having DD 100 per cent of the time, we wouldn't want her to have to go to him. However when we aren't scheduled to have her and she gets dropped off with no communication (especially when it gets back to him.that we have plans) it is that aspect that is frustrating.

I just wish people like him.would get there comeuppance but he never seems to. I guess we go on as we are and just accept he's going to be a c bomb of the highest magnitude while making out to the world he's an amazing person/father.

OP posts:
SudocremOnEverything · 17/10/2022 23:20

You might also want to try talking to her about why she doesn’t go through CMS. There will be a reason. It might be that she’s been there, tried that, and it was pointless. It might be that she doesn’t want to poke the bear. It might be that she’s experienced how useless the CMS were and the effects of poking the bear with that particular stick.

The best thing you can do is expect nothing good from him. except no maintenance. Whatever he bothers to contribute is a bonus. Expect him to not show up and mess everyone around. Expect him to say terrible things to the children.

And support your partner in trying to deal with that, and to support her children despite their father’s inadequacies. Be there to say: ‘it doesn’t matter. We’ll be fine anyway’.

TooTrusting · 17/10/2022 23:14

And it is absolutely correct as pointed out that she can't make him have the DC. As annoying as that is, that's the reality.
Family lawyer here, btw.

TooTrusting · 17/10/2022 23:12

The two posts already seconded by others really resonated with me for personal reasons. But the reason I'm posting is to say you don't go through the courts for child maintenance. You simply apply to the CMS.
If he earns over £158k (or if he has significant assets) then the CMS issues the maximum assessment it can and the court then acquires jurisdiction to award more than the CMS can).
Assuming he is under that threshold, the CMS will look direct at his HMRC records to determine his declared income and will issue an assessment based on that. You then either accept direct pay or you get the CMS to collect it (and they charge the paying parent a fee and deduct a further fee from the receiving parent).

Unless you can clearly demonstrate undeclared earnings and prove what they are, the CMS's hands are tied. They will base the assessment on what he declares.

The CMS is not fit for purpose and with any cases that don't fit the simple mould they spend months doing nothing and not implementing their own regulations, and giving you the runaround. You tend not to see any sense until you have exhausted their review/reconsideration processes and have been moved onto the CMS Tribunal process.

PickAChew · 17/10/2022 23:05

You need to be angry with him, not her.

negomi90 · 17/10/2022 23:03

If he gets paid cash in hand, he is probably fiddling the books and going through CMS is likely to do nothing other than piss him off and make him pay even less. No registered income (ie cash in hand) = minimum/no CMS money.
Going to court will guarantee times she has to make the child available for him, it does not make him take the child on these dates.
Being tough in this situation on either of these is liable to make things worse by Pissing him off and making him nastier. It is unlikely to get you more money or him to take the child more or be more reliable.

Dotcheck · 17/10/2022 22:56

To be clear I'm not bullying or putting her under pressure, I just think she needs to go through the courts to try and get the maintenance she deserves

That is literally the definition of pressuring someone. Seriously. Stop!

Cloverforever · 17/10/2022 22:54

"I have told her she needs to not put up with it and call him out for his behaviour", sounds like putting her under pressure to me!

TiredManDad · 17/10/2022 22:37

To be clear I'm not bullying or putting her under pressure, I just think she needs to go through the courts to try and get the maintenance she deserves.

I haven't kicked off, I have said the above and when she said she doesn't want to go down that route or have me confront his behaviour I haven't.

And we always back down to his still controlling nature and just provide a loving home for the kids. However it just seems incredibly unfair as he just continually gets away with not only being a shit, but actively being nasty about us while getting away with his own behaviour.

I love my DP dearly and we always talk about everything. I think I get the flavour from this thread and you're right, next time he is terrible U'll just go for a run, get the endorphins going then cook us a nice tea and just be happy she doesn't have to actively deal with him in her life always anymore.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 17/10/2022 22:36

I was in your dp's position 3.5 years ago. My ex put me through hell. My dp, who I'd only been with for 6 months, was subjected to all sorts of shit from a man who'd long abandoned me, but who was affronted that I'd moved on. Not once did my lovely dp ever pressure me to act in the way that HE thought I should act, because he was very very aware that it would not be him having to manage the emotional and mental load.

Sometimes you have to walk away from things. Sometimes, you know that this isn't a book or a film with a hero's ending, where the bad guy gets what's coming to him, and the good guys get the happy ending.

Sometimes you just have to manage things as best you can, day by day, whilst preserving what sanity you have left to make sure you have enough left for you and the kids to survive.

Your intentions are admirable but this is not your call, so please don't make it harder for her by creating ANOTHER battle she has to deal with,

Discovereads · 17/10/2022 22:33

YABU
Your DP knows her ex better than you do. He’s put nails in your tyres, that’s someone who is willing to go all violent and dangerous if challenged. She is being accommodating with him to manage him. £50/mo sometimes late, while measly is better than nothing. It’s also better than him turning up and smashing your car to bits. Or god forbid harming your partner or their children.

You need to support her and take the threat he poses to her and their DC more seriously.

asdasult · 17/10/2022 22:29

Cloverforever · 17/10/2022 22:28

She's gone from one bully to another...

Yup.

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 17/10/2022 22:29

lifeissweet · 17/10/2022 22:16

This sort of pressure is awful to live with.

I was in your DP's position and every time DD's useless Dad messed up plans or didn't pay what he should, I knew I would get it in the neck from my current DP for not handling it the way he wanted me too.

It added insult to injury. It made it all so much more stressful having to deal with one person being unreliable and the other blaming me for it.

It was a major reason we split in the end. He was resentful. I was sick of dealing with his feelings about it all.

Now, I deal with DD's dad by shrugging it off and moving on without getting the sinking feeling of knowing I was in for a bollocking on top of being dicked about. It's much calmer.

I came to comment almost the exact same as this AND @SudocremOnEverything commented perfectly.

@TiredManDad this post was triggering to me as I was your DP in this situation.

My ex boyfriend had a massive go at me multiple times about my DD's dad. It was one of the main reasons we split up.

I would go as far as to say YOU are exhibiting controlling behaviour as you are frustrated at being unable to CONTROL her ex through your DP.

So she gets a shit time because of her ex (which she is resigned to) then a shit time off you because she 'Allowed' him to be a shit!

There is NO way to control or force an ex not to be a twat. The ONLY leverage a woman has in this situation is 1. The courts (which will work for money but probably not if he plays the system) 2. Using the child as a pawn (something I and other decent people refuse to do)

Calling them out does nothing, you can set your own boundaries on communication and timekeeping etc but that's it

BE HER PARTNER AND SUPPORT HER!
Or you might be the next ex

Cloverforever · 17/10/2022 22:28

She's gone from one bully to another...

nozbottheblue · 17/10/2022 22:27

Imagine the scenario if you wade in and “do it yourself”. You go round and tell him what a nasty piece of work he is and how he should be more reliable and pay more for his kids.
How is he likely to react? Welcome you warmly and say “oh yes I’m sorry I now see the error of my ways, I didn’t understand until you told me”?
More likely it would be at least a shouting match which would upset everyone and possibly make things worse- as why should he be told what to do by you?

Accept that’s how he is and he’s not going to change. Expect as little from him as possible (which is probably your DP’s attitude) then you can’t be disappointed.

Dotcheck · 17/10/2022 22:26

OP
Just STOP!
Everyone has their battleground where they grapple with their sense of self worth. For some people it’s food, others it’s career. Although it may seem that she is appeasing him, she is ultimately doing what she feels is best for her children. This is not for you to decide.

Does she pick apart your weaknesses, and get exasperated because you are not doing what she feels is right? I suspect not.

Do you know the message you are sending to her when you tell her how she ought to run her life? You are telling her that you think she is weak, that she isn’t worthy of your respect, and that you know best.

She has survived abuse. People who end up in abusive situations often end up that way because they didn’t get the love and care needed when they were young to develop a strong sense of self worth. And yet she survived, is a functioning adult who puts her kids first.

So, OP the way I see it, this can pan out one of two ways. You could be a supportive partner, who treats her like an adult who is capable of making the decisions she needs to make for her children, OR carry on. One day she’ll develop the ‘ backbone’ you want her to have, and is likely to get rid of all the men in her life who treat her poorly. You included

Onlyforcake · 17/10/2022 22:25

In my experience the useless twats when called out just go off in a strop further damaging the experience of the child.

It's shit, he's shit. All you can do is be there for the children because ultimately- your home is the one good thing they've got. All of these rejections will be eating away at the kids like a death of a thousand cuts to their confidence

My solution was to book childcare for any important plans and to never react to him, only to how my children felt.

InWalksBarberalla · 17/10/2022 22:25

You are BU to insist your partner does anything.

asdasult · 17/10/2022 22:21

This isn't your battle to fight.

What @SudocremOnEverything said.

lifeissweet · 17/10/2022 22:16

This sort of pressure is awful to live with.

I was in your DP's position and every time DD's useless Dad messed up plans or didn't pay what he should, I knew I would get it in the neck from my current DP for not handling it the way he wanted me too.

It added insult to injury. It made it all so much more stressful having to deal with one person being unreliable and the other blaming me for it.

It was a major reason we split in the end. He was resentful. I was sick of dealing with his feelings about it all.

Now, I deal with DD's dad by shrugging it off and moving on without getting the sinking feeling of knowing I was in for a bollocking on top of being dicked about. It's much calmer.

whatdodos · 17/10/2022 22:15

There is literally no point in "calling him out" because you can't change a man like that and she knows it too. Please don't make her life harder. Allow her to feel safe and in control and know she has younto moan and groan with her knowing you won't go in guns blazing and making her life 10x harder. There's so many things I could call my ex out on but I just don't bother because it gets me nowhere and it's exhausting. I just carry on and hope my little gu