Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s a subtle sign that a person is a good person?

263 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 17/10/2022 21:03

As in you can just tell they are good people in an average situation.

OP posts:
bippityboppity87 · 18/10/2022 00:27

Judges people based on their name (IRL or otherwise)

I'm not sure what the baby names thread is like now (haven't looked in about 6 years) But it was quite horrible at one point. If I had met anyone of those posters, I wouldn't think of them as a nice person

BoxOfCats · 18/10/2022 00:27

They are kind to animals

ElLuisa · 18/10/2022 00:20

Integrity, kindness, being considerate. I like the C.S. Lewis quote about integrity - doing the right thing even when no one is watching. My DH and his siblings are like that, and I'm lucky to know a handful of others.

I plod along, trying to follow their excellent example!

Vegay · 18/10/2022 00:03

@DaughterofDawn you took all that from my little paragraph?

So, as far as I'm concerned, any obligate carnivore can kill it's prey, and although I don't wish to see it, humans are not carnivores! We are classed as omnivores - although we can certainly live on a plant-based diet. I have done for the last 6 years. I haven't died of protein deficiency yet.

Does the lion, tiger, wolf or bear get to shop at Tesco, Sainsbury's or Asda? More to the point, do they perpetuate and agree with 75 billion land animals slaughtered each year for human consumption? They kill animals as they see fit - they are obligatory carnivores.

Then you go on to talk about procreation. Sorry if you've had some stupid conversations with some idiotic vegans. I'm not one of those.

cesspoolclowncar · 18/10/2022 00:02

I eat meat and work hard to ensure it’s produced humanely.

If you work hard to ensure you buy "humanely" produced meat, then you must be interested in the animal living a good life. So why does your interest in them living a good life not extend to the part where they're prematurely slaughtered?

Vegay · 17/10/2022 23:37

@PriOn1 I can assure you that I don't virtue signal. I live by the decisions I've made to be cruelty-free, I felt like a big hypocrite! I'm sure there are others out there too.

It is called cognitive dissonance too. Are you refuting that?

What the hell does 'produced humanely' mean by the way? Are you producing meat?

Stoic123 · 17/10/2022 23:31

Always observe how they treat the least powerful person in the room or talk about the least powerful members of society.

It always comes down to kindness. Not charm, not clean shoes, not remembering conversations - just kindness.

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 17/10/2022 23:31

PriOn1 · 17/10/2022 23:22

Unlike all the vegans on this thread?

”I do get a little frustrated with people who 'love' animals, yet continue to consume them. It's called cognitive dissonance. I was that person once. It's like feeling like a hypocrite.”

Has it ever crossed your mind that some people might have assessed the way meat is produced and come to a different conclusion from yours.

I eat meat and work hard to ensure it’s produced humanely. That is literally what my job entails. I have absolutely no cognitive dissonance over my decision.

Well, I wasn’t going to get into it at this hour for my own sanity but… yeah!

BadNomad · 17/10/2022 23:28

CandyLeBonBon · 17/10/2022 23:21

Lots of people thought Jimmy Savile was 'good' because he was a prolific raiser of funds for charity. I've no idea if he was a a clean-shoe-wearing vegetarian, but if he was, it still didn't make him a good person.

A lot of these examples are so subjective. I don't always have clean shoes. Ive lost touch with friends over the years, for various reasons and I eat meat, I'm still an inherently good person, even though I cock things up.

I'm always worried about threads like this, because actually what most are describing is the female socialisation/accommodation, often to the detriment of ourselves - always putting others first etc.

But tl:dr - simply clean shoes and vegetarianism do not a good person make!

I would agree with this.

I'm autistic. I find it awkward talking to people. I forget to smile. I don't make eye contact. I come across abrupt at times. If these things are indicators of "good" then I must be very bad.

OldWivesTale · 17/10/2022 23:28

*stand offish

DaughterofDawn · 17/10/2022 23:27

Vegay · 17/10/2022 23:07

Honest and true to their word.

I do get a little frustrated with people who 'love' animals, yet continue to consume them. It's called cognitive dissonance. I was that person once. It's like feeling like a hypocrite.

Do you think that carnivores are bad unethical animals? I’m legitimately curious. Should we ethically eliminate them until they are extinct because their existence requires the consumption of other species? I mean it’s only the right thing to do you know. After all other animals are suffering as a result of their existence.

Shall I euthanize my cat because he is an obligate carnivore or shall I switch him to a vegan diet and shorten his life by permanently damaging his kidneys? Yes I’ve actually looked into feline vegan diets. They do not bode well for cats.

Or does this line of thinking only apply to humans?

Its unethical for a wolf to violently tear a rabbit apart for a meal but for a human to shoot one is awful?

I hear vegans and vegetarians often boldly saying things like “I WOULD RATHER DIE THAN EAT AN ANIMAL.” But when they are asked the hard questions like

but would you rather your child starve/die than eat an animal?

They suddenly start dodging the question and proclaiming things like “oh but I would never be so selfish as to procreate. That is the worse thing you can possibly do!” forgetting that not every woman gets this option. Consider rape or sexual assault or simply “oops the pill didn’t work/condom broke.” Especially now that abortion is banned in many parts of the united states.

I find the most unethical people are often the ones proclaiming to be unquestionably ethically superior to others never doubting their choices. Never asking themselves if it is fair to project their decisions onto others. Assuming that it is a perfect cookie cutter for decisions for all. When it’s really not always that black and white.

And I think that is why many folks distance themselves from folks that state things like this.

Vegans and vegetarians are really quick to turn their backs on themselves. lol So I think that makes the biggest statement of all about them as a general group of people. 😂

OldWivesTale · 17/10/2022 23:26

Julia234 · 17/10/2022 23:09

The way somebody treats somebody they don’t know. Either meeting for them first time or vaguely knows them, if they are inclusive and friendly, I always find these people to be genuinely good people. On the other hand, if they are stand offish, uninterested or just unfriendly with new people, I instantly know they’re not particularly pleasant people.

But these are just social skills that can be learnt. Often people who are standing offish are very shy. These things don't indicate whether someone is "good".

BadNomad · 17/10/2022 23:24

RealFeminist · 17/10/2022 23:19

No. I'd say that the idea of a 'good' or a 'bad' person is wildly oversimplifying the vast majority of cases.

There are a few horrors and yes Saville was one but if we are talking everyday people you meets we are mostly a big old mix of a bit craps a bit good, and lots indifferent. It'd be meaningless to try and sort most people into one of 2 reductive categories.

Maybe you just haven't met any sociopaths, then. They are bad people. That's just the way they are made. They don't care about hurting people, and are perfectly capable of doing good things if it will benefit them. But it doesn't change that they are bad in their core. These are every day people, not anomalies.

Boudica66 · 17/10/2022 23:24

kerstina · 17/10/2022 21:07

My personal view. If they are good to animals and don’t eat them . On the other end of the scale people who abuse animals are often the same with children . Evil.

I eat chicken, I'm a serial killer

PriOn1 · 17/10/2022 23:22

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 17/10/2022 23:14

They don’t virtue signal

Unlike all the vegans on this thread?

”I do get a little frustrated with people who 'love' animals, yet continue to consume them. It's called cognitive dissonance. I was that person once. It's like feeling like a hypocrite.”

Has it ever crossed your mind that some people might have assessed the way meat is produced and come to a different conclusion from yours.

I eat meat and work hard to ensure it’s produced humanely. That is literally what my job entails. I have absolutely no cognitive dissonance over my decision.

CandyLeBonBon · 17/10/2022 23:21

Lots of people thought Jimmy Savile was 'good' because he was a prolific raiser of funds for charity. I've no idea if he was a a clean-shoe-wearing vegetarian, but if he was, it still didn't make him a good person.

A lot of these examples are so subjective. I don't always have clean shoes. Ive lost touch with friends over the years, for various reasons and I eat meat, I'm still an inherently good person, even though I cock things up.

I'm always worried about threads like this, because actually what most are describing is the female socialisation/accommodation, often to the detriment of ourselves - always putting others first etc.

But tl:dr - simply clean shoes and vegetarianism do not a good person make!

RealFeminist · 17/10/2022 23:19

BadNomad · 17/10/2022 22:58

Because some actions have motives. Look at Jimmy Saville. Visiting kids in hospital, giving to charity, smiley and friendly. Would you say he was good because he did good things?

No. I'd say that the idea of a 'good' or a 'bad' person is wildly oversimplifying the vast majority of cases.

There are a few horrors and yes Saville was one but if we are talking everyday people you meets we are mostly a big old mix of a bit craps a bit good, and lots indifferent. It'd be meaningless to try and sort most people into one of 2 reductive categories.

CellarBellaatemycoal · 17/10/2022 23:18

I’m not sure about the idea that looking after the small things (clean shoes for example) is an indicator they look after the big things?
I have a tendency to be attracted to be friends who are less fussy over small things. Their toddler may be unkempt but happy, they’ll have crumbs on the kitchen floor, bobbly jumpers, worn /patched up clothes, mad hair… drive an old car etc.
I guess we’re all just wired differently when it comes to how we suss people out. Of course there’s some sort of inverse snobbery at play here because I’d quite like them to have a nice bookshelf too 😀
But generally I’m a bit wary of people who obsess over keeping stuff immaculate.
I’d be horrified at anyone who was horrible to waiting staff though, that’s a good indicator of a baddie. Good manners are important.

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 17/10/2022 23:14

They don’t virtue signal

LeMoo · 17/10/2022 23:14

Dont bitch about people behind theirs backs or delivery backhanded compliments - all done behind smiles and faux niceness.

Usually a good indication.

lingle · 17/10/2022 23:13

Without time/adversity to test them, these signs are worthless (except their friends)

Nomorefuckstogive · 17/10/2022 23:12

Really listening to someone. General kindness and checking in on someone. Empathy, not sympathy.

Backtoblack1 · 17/10/2022 23:12

Empathy for animals and others in general.

ThatBliddyWoman · 17/10/2022 23:09

OoooohMatron · 17/10/2022 21:12

Wasn't Hitler a vegetarian? Agree about cruelty to animals though.

No he bliddy wasn't and Ive been sick of seeing/hearing people say he was since the birth of the internet (and possibly before)!

I agree the being inclusive of everyone, making sure people are paid attention to in conversations.
In a similar vein, people who will adapt to include people (not beyond boundaries obviously but people who consider people, explain things well, adapt their language etc in a group setting for example).

shedwithivy · 17/10/2022 23:09

StopFeckingFaffing · 17/10/2022 21:17

They don't treat people differently depending on how important they may or may not be

Good one..

Although I think a lot of the posts about people who are good conversationalists/listeners etc doesn't necessarily mean they are better people than those who are socially awkward or struggle with conversation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread