Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s a subtle sign that a person is a good person?

263 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 17/10/2022 21:03

As in you can just tell they are good people in an average situation.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
aSpanielintheworks · 18/10/2022 20:24

They like dogs.

MiniHouse · 18/10/2022 20:15

Chattycathydoll · 17/10/2022 22:11

dang, fallen at the hurdle of my resting anxiety face 😔

I just have a downturned mouth from years of frustrated computer face. Hope that doesn't rule me out.

MiniHouse · 18/10/2022 20:12

RiverSkater · 18/10/2022 01:22

If you're at a work or social event they aren't scanning the room while talking to you to to see who might be a better option for them. 😆

Actually I appear to do this. It's because I have ADHD and worry I'm boring the person I'm talking to. Am I good person?! Probably not but not for that reason 🤣

thecatsthecats · 18/10/2022 18:44

It's a shit show, is what happens!

Couple of examples:

Boss 1: Staff member had alcohol issues. Racially abused a member of public whilst drunk on company time during their probation. The disciplinary? Ended in a hug. Because they were sooooo understanding and empathetic. Staff member continued to be a problem. Any disciplinary actions repeatedly blocked because boss was being "understanding". Eventually, staff member came under my line management. Had to fire them for gross misconduct, and got given hell from the boss for not ignoring all policies, the impact of their behaviour and the fucking law.

Boss 1 (again): Was line manager of the line manager of the rest of the team. Team manager had anger issues and played favourites. But... He was continually undermined by the boss on his decisions. He might have made a decent manager if left to it, but became frustrated, which made him even more of a douche. Ended up with toxic atmosphere where people yelled at each other with impunity.

Boss 2: Manager has been on receiving end of pass agg behaviour and refusal from one of her managees. I've witnessed that myself. Line managee quits, and boss apologises for everything and begs them to stay, even though all the manager was only asking the managee to comply with basic standards. Manager now stressed, undermined and demotivated.

Tbh, soft management makes me so mad, because I have tonnes of experience of it causing havoc, and making people second guess themselves, and say, "well, x is a nice guy...". But I find it mega bullshit, because I find these types gravitate to those that they THINK need the most support, and ONLY them. They never look at the bigger picture, and be fair. A nice environment is a benefit to everyone.

DaughterofDawn · 18/10/2022 16:02

thecatsthecats · 18/10/2022 13:22

Complimenting people behind their backs.

Also, those who come down strongly and FAIRLY in difficult situations. I've had two managers who think they're all nicey nicey, but really, their inability to be clear and fair to all parties means more stress for everyone. Including being really sympathetic to whoever they think is the injured party, whn actually those people have been the one causing the problems.

Leads to a nasty culture, which is quite unkind in itself.

You know this is an interesting comment that’s opened my eyes a lot. My sister and I don’t see eye to eye on a lot of things. One of the biggest issues was her husband. I was not blatantly rude to him when they were dating but I did try to point out some red flags but my sister was constantly defending him saying he was just socially awkward, had a hard childhood, needed emotional support yada yada yada. Always excuses. But when he was unkind to her it was always her fault. He turned out to be very abusive. They are now divorced. I never thought about the fact that this could be applied on a much wider scale.

My sister was always big about being kind to others but she without realizing it set herself up to be a very passive aggressive personality because she would always put herself last in the name of being “nice” and she would whittle herself down to the last straw and then end up blowing up over something completely unrelated six months later and just unload everything that has been annoying her about you for the last few months. Which would not only be confusing but also frustrating and feel very unfair.

It’s not kind to not confront others or to allow transgressions to pass. She thinks ignoring things will make them go away but instead they just pile up like snow.

But when I think of how she is a nurse in charge of vulnerable people with questionable judgement like this. How does she handle the really complex issues when it is not “clear” in her mind who is lying and who is telling the truth?

What happens when people like this are in charge of tenants, or when they are a police officer or a politician? Very interesting.

Sorry for rambling. Thanks for reading my shower thoughts. 😂

thecatsthecats · 18/10/2022 13:43

Dutch1e · 18/10/2022 11:03

OP, this is a great question, and so difficult to pinpoint an answer!

Very much agree with the idea that the person will be true to their moral compass even when no-one is watching.

And I admire a person who is funny without it being at someone else's expense. Or if they are making fun of someone they do it in a way that the 'target' also finds genuinely funny. I think this is a skill that only a decent person can master, a nasty person's mask will always slip eventually.

My husband's best friend actually calls him out on things, and it's beautiful. Not big infractions, but they have the kind of relationship where that's normal. At our wedding, he came up to me and asked if there was anything he could talk about in particular with my parents to make them welcome etc. Lovely man.

In fact, anyone who treats my mum well is a good sign - she's had a lot of trauma and MH issues and frankly is difficult as fuck. But she's fundamentally harmless. Anyone who I can see has understood her behaviour is a result of difficulties, and treats her with gentle attention, is good in my book.

My husband, one of my male friends, my cousin and their MP all score well there.

thecatsthecats · 18/10/2022 13:22

Complimenting people behind their backs.

Also, those who come down strongly and FAIRLY in difficult situations. I've had two managers who think they're all nicey nicey, but really, their inability to be clear and fair to all parties means more stress for everyone. Including being really sympathetic to whoever they think is the injured party, whn actually those people have been the one causing the problems.

Leads to a nasty culture, which is quite unkind in itself.

hookiewookie29 · 18/10/2022 13:09

Thought I was a pretty good person but obviously not because I eat meat......

Coffeetree · 18/10/2022 13:07

Yes but the OP was asking for subtle signs, not grand gestures.

That's why the friends thing is such a good sign. Having a group of good people as friends, including old friends. It's a subtle but effective sign that the person has good judgement and clear values, and boundaries.

Cleotolstoy · 18/10/2022 12:27

It is a fascinating concept. I think of it like scales based on actions harmful and helpful. But is also more nuanced than that for example enabling addictions might feel helpful but are harmful in the long run. It is complicated but definitely worth pondering. Also how much good would outweigh harm? And does it ever without accountability? As others have said, Saville raised millions for charity but we all agree he wasn't a good person. It's not black and white no, but that doesn't mean we're all much of a muchness. We think that at ours and others peril.

Longerthanfiveweeks · 18/10/2022 11:21

Surely all of us are a mix of good and not so good? I think I am overall a pretty decent human being but sometimes I put myself first and sometimes I am irritable and sometimes things make me feel angry. Surely we are nearly all like this?
i don’t think to be a ‘good’ person you need to be at your best in all situations at all times.
Even the lovely Rabbi Lionel Blue admitted to being less generous and more cantankerous when he was in a bad mood.

PlainJaneSuperBrain99 · 18/10/2022 11:18

I think when someone is able to see their own flaws and take responsibility for mistakes they make. That is actually a very rare trait, I've found.

Dutch1e · 18/10/2022 11:03

OP, this is a great question, and so difficult to pinpoint an answer!

Very much agree with the idea that the person will be true to their moral compass even when no-one is watching.

And I admire a person who is funny without it being at someone else's expense. Or if they are making fun of someone they do it in a way that the 'target' also finds genuinely funny. I think this is a skill that only a decent person can master, a nasty person's mask will always slip eventually.

ShreddedMarmalade · 18/10/2022 10:30

Jeffrey Dahmer gave his neighbour $60 to buy a gift for a wedding and refused to be paid back. That was nice of him.

BlackeyedSusan · 18/10/2022 10:20

I rarely have clean shoes. And I sometimes dump the shopping trolley under the overhand at Morrisons if I am in too much pain to walk all the way to the trolley point...I am shit at talking to people and don't remember stuff...these are all disability related. I would like to think I am not a bad person and working towards being good:

I am autistic so can get a bit meltdowny and grumpy... Less so now I am diagnosed, peculiarly.

I agree though, being respectful to people who could be perceived as not important.

DarkDarkNight · 18/10/2022 10:14

Someone who is polite to waiters and retail staff. I can’t stand people who are rude and condescending.

People who don’t judge others on the clothes they wear, the cars they drive, the places they eat or go on holiday. My area can be very ‘keeping up with the Joneses’ and I find people who don’t live they’re lives like that really refreshing.

Including people in the conversation, being inviting to others who may be on the fringes. As someone who is often left out of things you occasionally come across someone who effortlessly involves you and it is really nice.

Someone who displays empathy towards people, who cares for those who are worse off.

ImAvingOops · 18/10/2022 10:02

Maybe being 'good' is simply not actively causing harm/doing a favour if you can manage it. Contributing more that is positive than negative - it doesn't mean being perfect all the time.

oopsfellover · 18/10/2022 09:56

Being naturally kind to people without trying to draw attention to the fact, holding doors, acknowledging greetings, saying thanks. That sort of thing. Personally I always wonder what ‘good person’ really means though. I felt the idea was a bit overstated during my religious upbringing, and always feel it finds me wanting!

Cleotolstoy · 18/10/2022 09:15

How do they cope with personal failure and flaws? People who get angry when they're wrong.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/10/2022 09:03

PriOn1 · 18/10/2022 06:00

”If you work hard to ensure you buy "humanely" produced meat, then you must be interested in the animal living a good life. So why does your interest in them living a good life not extend to the part where they're prematurely slaughtered?”

If an animal is well cared for during life and death is pain free, then I don’t see premature death as inherently bad. If you had your way, that animal would never have lived at all, or might have gone on to be old and in pain. I’m a vet. Much of the suffering I have seen was from people who kept their pets alive too long.

I agree with this- and especially the part about people keeping animals alive too long - this is for their own needs, not those of their pet.

However, re: eating meat: There is no easy death in a slaughterhouse.

ifonlylifewasthateasy · 18/10/2022 08:55

Someone who ensures their elderly parents are ok!

OctopusBreath · 18/10/2022 08:54

Safer · 18/10/2022 08:34

What I think people are predominantly describing is: Likeable.

Likeable is different to good though.

This, absolutely. I think that people can learn to be likeable, and use it for their own ends- even though this isn't always a conscious thing.

I think that good people tend not to be over-effusive. There are those who will always make a big fuss of complimenting your hair or makeup or whatever, to give you that short endorphin hit of good feelings. But the truly good people I know are a lot more sparing of their compliments, and they tend to give them quietly and without ceremony. I've never thought about it before, but maybe this is because the good folk aren't so preoccupied with being liked.

ifonlylifewasthateasy · 18/10/2022 08:53

Tiredforfive45 · 17/10/2022 21:42

I read about ‘the shopping cart theory’ once.

If somebody puts their shopping trolley in one of the designated points after they have finished with it then it is an indication they are a good person.

It is often easier/quicker/more convenient to the person to dump it close by and there is no negative consequence to them to do so, but returning it properly is respectful and more
convenient to others.

I read once that if you don't put your shopping trolley back then you are keeping a member of staff in employment 😀

SnoozyLucy7 · 18/10/2022 08:53

lljkk · 18/10/2022 08:32

Warmth, smiles that reach the eyes, listening more than talking. Calm, relaxed.

Gawd, I know at least 2 narcissists like this. Very charming, very dangerous.

Lotusmonster · 18/10/2022 08:50

Intellectual humility ….means they’re willing to admit to stuff they don’t know rather than pretending to be a know-it-all and spouting bullshit. Also people who are prepared to just listen without interruption….a rare, rare behaviour these days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread