Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Sarah Ockwell Smith actually has any useful advice in her books?

140 replies

Spicycurry · 17/10/2022 20:02

I am sure she is a lovely lady and very good parent.

But I read her sleep book and it pretty much just told me to put up with it until my child slept better.

Ordered her toddler book and it seems to be much of the same.

it is helpful of course to understand where my child is coming from if you like but I am not sure it’s particularly useful to read when at the end of your tether!

or will I be flamed by her fans?

OP posts:
Devo1818 · 18/10/2022 10:33

Yep, it's all bollocks. These so-called experts are only experts on their own children, but they make their fortune by convincing everyone else they are somehow doing it all wrong and need to pay for their holy advice.

You know everything you need to know about your family and your child. The answers are already in you and they don't cost money.

As soon as I realised this simple truth all of the parenting books, blogs and websites went in the bin and I was a much happier, better and more effective parent.

MrsToadflax · 18/10/2022 10:12

I was briefly in her FB group. One poor woman was on her knees, with her mental health in tatters. She dared to ask if sleep training might help. Good grief the responses were just horrific - basically, 'you chose to have a baby so suck it up buttercup', 'you're being selfish', 'your baby needs you so just get on with it.' I was disgusted and left the group. I agree with the 'anti feminist cult' comment. She gives no room for balance or happy mum, happy baby. Apparently we should all push ourselves to our utter limits because we chose to have children. There will always be those who think she's fantastic, but I think many will look back and think, 'what the hell was I thinking?'

Hopelessacademic · 18/10/2022 10:08

Agree with most of the posters! All that book did was make me feel guilty for eventually sleep training!
It basically made me feel that I should be a complete martyr and anything other than just completely sacrificing myself until my baby CHOSE to sleep through was unnatural and cruel and damaging her forever!

We did Ferber at 10.5 months and it was amazing! She's now 20 months and apart from illnes and one random 2-week blip has slept 10+ hours every night since.

I also stopped following a few "sleep experts" on instagram, basically realised that if they had only one child, who was 2/3 years and STILL not sleeping, then they were not good examples! (justchillmama I think was one!)
I do follow calmndbright sleep, who seem very realistic and are pro (gentle) sleep training! They each have 4 kids I think who sleep well lol!

IamnotSethRogan · 18/10/2022 10:07

Sorry I was on a different thread and I don't know how this ended up here !

IamnotSethRogan · 18/10/2022 10:06

I'd be using the absolute mess he made when he was health secretary as a more comprehensive reason why he's unfit for such an important job.

They really are the most talentless bunch. If what they're saying is "this is the best people we have" then we need to believe them and get rid of the lot.

SlashBeef · 18/10/2022 09:52

I genuinely believe her books contributed to my PND with my second child. I felt like I had to just be quiet and suffer and tolerate so much otherwise my baby would feel neglected and be damaged forever.

fleurdelee · 18/10/2022 09:46

Wheresmysewjo · 17/10/2022 20:27

I absolutely hated it. I bought it, in lockdown 1 when my 4th was about 8m. I was on my knees, he was waking 1.5hrly to feed, he hit the "regression" at 4m and never came out the other side.

This book made me feel 100 x worse about myself, i was so cross I asked Amazon for a refund (and I got one!) Because it had zero tips to help him or me get more sleep.

I then bought Precious Little Sleep by Alexis Dubeif and that was a better fit for me.

Love that you asked Amazon for a refund
But sorry you went through this
Lockdown was shit
Can't imagine doing it with thee kids and non sleeping 8mo

bruffin · 18/10/2022 09:40

I think the issue is also that all children are different and my 2 needed completely different parenting although i was more of benign neglect parent and meet problems when they arose.

murmuration · 18/10/2022 09:27

morechocolateneededtoday · 18/10/2022 09:09

Check out 'How to talk so little children listen' or 'The whole brain child' if you want a book. I did find behavioural books useful for toddler years and beyond to understand how your child's brain works and whether expectations we have for them are realistic or not.

His behaviour probably is normal, usually is the case but when we find the right way to respond to it, you start to notice a difference. I despise the term gentle parenting - people have picked up on it and use it as a reason to not bother enforcing any boundaries. I do believe in understanding what your child is and is not capable of processing and picking your battles so they know what is absolutely non-negotiable

Simple things like giving them warnings they understand (eg you can play on 3 more things before we leave the park rather than you have 5 mins) made a huge difference. Seems so obvious when you write it down but can't always see it when caught up in the moment

I do gravitate to the ‘gentle parenting’ techniques, and also like reading parenting books, but I read one Sarah Ockwell Smith and found it basically useless. Platitudes, guilt tripping, and no real information.

I echo the ‘How to talk’ books (I read the first one ‘How to talk so kids will listen and listen so kids will talk’, as the little kids one didn’t come out until my child was older, but I was even able to modify things for that for a toddler). Also ‘raising human beings’ by the guy who wore ‘the explosive child’ (I’ve read both, the newer one is geared towards NT kids who don’t have severe problems, whereas ‘explosive child’ is). And I did like ‘whole brain child’ too, although I don’t remember as many practical suggestions as the other two I mentioned.

morechocolateneededtoday · 18/10/2022 09:09

Spicycurry · 18/10/2022 07:15

I genuinely believe that it was detrimental to both my child and myself to go on the way we were with sleep. Looking back, he must have been so tired and I was in such a bad way, seething with resentment and not enjoying parenting at all as a result.

I got the toddler one as there are a couple of aspects of DS behaviour I’ve found challenging but it’s just told me it’s normal. Which is reassuring but the problem is she says everything is normal so I’m not actually sure what is.

Check out 'How to talk so little children listen' or 'The whole brain child' if you want a book. I did find behavioural books useful for toddler years and beyond to understand how your child's brain works and whether expectations we have for them are realistic or not.

His behaviour probably is normal, usually is the case but when we find the right way to respond to it, you start to notice a difference. I despise the term gentle parenting - people have picked up on it and use it as a reason to not bother enforcing any boundaries. I do believe in understanding what your child is and is not capable of processing and picking your battles so they know what is absolutely non-negotiable

Simple things like giving them warnings they understand (eg you can play on 3 more things before we leave the park rather than you have 5 mins) made a huge difference. Seems so obvious when you write it down but can't always see it when caught up in the moment

SandraOMG · 18/10/2022 09:08

I tend to agree with the "anti-feminist cult" comment. I also hate competitive empathisers. I come across it at work all the time and it's one of the many reasons I'm getting out of that line of work!

Most people empathise with and adore their babies. It's completely natural and does not need to be taught. When they're in pain, you wish you could take the pain for them. Most parents hate leaving their dcs at childcare to begin with, but needs must to prevent homelessness and starvation - the BASTARDS 🙄😂.

To make a very lucrative living selling books instructing women to "be kind" and put themselves last at all times is some shit.

morechocolateneededtoday · 18/10/2022 09:03

@NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet I can't remember the exact details (borrowed her book from the library when my now 6yr old was a newborn) but I remember my jaw almost hitting the floor from how openly she discredited the validity of requiring a c-section then lots of talk about how not being exposed to the natural bacteria in the birth canal/vagina would be of detriment. She then went on to recommend exposing the baby to these bacteria another way (which has been widely discredited too).

As a parent of older children, I agree a lot of books out there are not necessary but I also remember very clearly the desperation in early days and your baby will not feed/sleep/be put down. I was also one who had other illnesses triggered by sleep deprivation - I developed really severe IBS and dermatitis all over my body. Both only happen when I go through a stressful time and the stress of a non-sleeping baby (who was then irritable) plus no sleep myself brought it on. There were too many martyrs on the sleep board who went on about how they had dealt with it for 4/5 years and implied how weak I was for not coping. Coupled with local fb groups also recommending SOS and her co-sleeping recommendations as 'she made a lot of sense'. Thankfully DH made me see sense and life as a parent was SO much better once I had some rest

DC2 was a terrible sleeper in a different way but was the kind of baby I could co-sleep with and just 'roll with it'. Each parent and each child are different. These blanket instructions not to do things are of no use at all

JenniferBarkley · 18/10/2022 08:58

So glad to see this thread. I've never read her books but the shite spouted on FB groups and the like of "well Sarah OS says..." has been enough to put me off her.

Gentle parenting is some awful, anti-feminist cult, there I said it.

Completely agree.

BiasedBinding · 18/10/2022 08:38

KweenieBeanz · 18/10/2022 07:19

No but there are lots of things you can do to encourage your baby to stop waking 12 times a night. Sleep training is GREAT. Baby sleeps (and is then much happier in the day, too, because it's well rested!), Parents are happier. What's not to like?
Proud sleep trainer here and I'm seeing the results now many years later with happy well-adjusted kids doing well at school. My friend who followed S O-S religiously ended up with a child who now has major sleep issues, gets up at 4am for the day, is constantly exhausted and it shows.

I know people who sleep trained who now have school aged children with massive sleep issues, and people who didn’t who don’t. And many people in between. I don’t really care whether people sleep train or not but the one doesn’t follow the other just because it worked out for you and didn’t for the one other person you know who did things differently to you.

WhiteFire · 18/10/2022 07:58

Suzi888 · 18/10/2022 06:20

You don’t need a book. Newborns are hard, they cry. There’s not a lot you can do about it apart from put up with it, because it doesn’t last forever. None of it does. There is no magic wand.

The majority of parents realise that, however those reaching for her books often have much older babies/ toddlers.

No the rubbish sleeping didn't last forever, just till she was gone 4. It was hell, and had a massive negative effect on my sleep pattern in the long term. The number of 9 month old babies who would glibly quote her at me when I was up numerous times with a 2.5 year old was ridiculous.

She was (is) however a stubborn old fool and didn't respond to anything.

My eldest was one of those fairy children, which people tend not to believe occurs naturally.

I never read her books, she always struck me as talking rubbish.

NameChange30 · 18/10/2022 07:46

YANBU, I hate her with a passion, she is completely unqualified and has written books based on her opinion. The sleep book uses ONE study to back up her opinions, using "science" to guilt-trip sleep deprived parents.

The only unreasonable thing you did was buying another of her books when you knew the first one was useless!

bruffin · 18/10/2022 07:40

She is a quack. She used to claim to be a practicing Homeopath , but notice that has disappeared from her website

Her sleep research is cherry picked definitely. She is just another self proclaimed expert that desperate and gullable parents have fallen for

MumThyme · 18/10/2022 07:40

I just want to add thank you op. This has been quite cathartic, I feel like everyone in my group worships her and when I've stated my opinion I just get a look of shock and when I say I'm just going to do what I think is right as I go along, they patronise me then in the next breath they say how lovely my baby is, it takes all the politeness in me to be like so which is it. A lot of my friends have 4-5 year olds with similar behaviour others have described and its hard for them at school.

I agree with others about her shaming c sections and I even saw her share something once that falsely claimed women who take pain relief in child birth may have problems bonding and breastfeeding their baby. At that point I stopped following her social media even for the laughs.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 18/10/2022 07:32

You're not wrong. I found her books a bit samey and they could have been condensed into leaflets tbh. The odd nugget of support / useful info.
If its any consolation my son was a nightmare sleeper. Single Mum breastfeeding with limited support. I was getting vertigo from the sleep deprivation it was horrific. Co sleeping did help a little for me but i know that isnt an option for everyone. He's 18 months still bfing and still in my bed. I didnt have the option of sleep training him as we were in a 1 bedroom flat and by the time we moved he was a little better.

KweenieBeanz · 18/10/2022 07:19

KlopflopKop · 18/10/2022 06:32

I agree with this. As much as every clown writing a parenting book wants you to believe otherwise, there is no magical one size fits all approach to parenting that makes everything perfect.

Short of drugging your child, you can't actually make them sleep.

No but there are lots of things you can do to encourage your baby to stop waking 12 times a night. Sleep training is GREAT. Baby sleeps (and is then much happier in the day, too, because it's well rested!), Parents are happier. What's not to like?
Proud sleep trainer here and I'm seeing the results now many years later with happy well-adjusted kids doing well at school. My friend who followed S O-S religiously ended up with a child who now has major sleep issues, gets up at 4am for the day, is constantly exhausted and it shows.

Spicycurry · 18/10/2022 07:15

I genuinely believe that it was detrimental to both my child and myself to go on the way we were with sleep. Looking back, he must have been so tired and I was in such a bad way, seething with resentment and not enjoying parenting at all as a result.

I got the toddler one as there are a couple of aspects of DS behaviour I’ve found challenging but it’s just told me it’s normal. Which is reassuring but the problem is she says everything is normal so I’m not actually sure what is.

OP posts:
houseargh · 18/10/2022 06:54

It's awful. She does a lot of cherry picking of evidence as well. XYZ gentle parenting approach will be justified on the basis that 'its what they do in traditional societies' though she acknowledges there is no authoritative data to say it works; then elsewhere in the book she says 'in traditional societies they do XYZ non-gentle parenting approach - there is no data to confirm if this works or not but it almost definitely doesn't.' I probably haven't made that clear at all but it gave me the rage given the number of half-dead women at the end of their tether who are afraid to do anything to improve their lives because of vague unknown 'studies.' Gentle parenting is some awful, anti-feminist cult, there I said it.

Hardbackwriter · 18/10/2022 06:45

Totally agree. I really tortured myself by reading her stuff while trying to decide whether or not to sleep train and it was so unhelpful, shaming and completely unevidenced. Looking back I don't know why I paid it any heed at all, but at the time it was so unhelpful to me at a point where I was struggling.

What really blows my mind is that at that point she was also offering a sort of 'sleep consultancy', but was clear that it wouldn't involve any sleep training and that she wouldn't do anything that aimed at getting the baby to sleep through. Who on earth was/is paying for that?!

Spicycurry · 18/10/2022 06:38

thank you but that’s not what I was asking Smile

OP posts:
KlopflopKop · 18/10/2022 06:32

Suzi888 · 18/10/2022 06:20

You don’t need a book. Newborns are hard, they cry. There’s not a lot you can do about it apart from put up with it, because it doesn’t last forever. None of it does. There is no magic wand.

I agree with this. As much as every clown writing a parenting book wants you to believe otherwise, there is no magical one size fits all approach to parenting that makes everything perfect.

Short of drugging your child, you can't actually make them sleep.