Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Sarah Ockwell Smith actually has any useful advice in her books?

140 replies

Spicycurry · 17/10/2022 20:02

I am sure she is a lovely lady and very good parent.

But I read her sleep book and it pretty much just told me to put up with it until my child slept better.

Ordered her toddler book and it seems to be much of the same.

it is helpful of course to understand where my child is coming from if you like but I am not sure it’s particularly useful to read when at the end of your tether!

or will I be flamed by her fans?

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 18/10/2022 13:49

I went through the same thing with hitting/biting. You can't solve that one with logical/natural/related consequences so you have two (three) choices:

You can do the calm, non-scary, non-related punishment thing e.g. time out/sitting on step/loss of screen time (if over about 3-4 otherwise it has to be instant) combined (or not) with insistence on apology.

Or if you want non-punitive then you just need to hover and intercept, Janet Lansbury style "I won't let you hit/bite". Which means never leaving siblings alone together - you can do the RIE thing and create separate "yes spaces" - I never had any patience for this though.

Either way, it's a phase which will pass when they gain better conflict resolution skills, so working on conflict resolution and alternatives to hitting helps too. I keep reminding DS2 (4) to ask for help if he feels like he wants to hit his brother, which does actually work about 80-90% of the time as long as we treat it as an emergency and jump in to help (referee/problem solve/just remove the baby) before it gets to the point of hitting - if he's at the point of asking for help, then he can't really wait, and that's OK. Next stage will probably be trying to get them to do some problem solving between themselves before seeking help, but DS3 is only 1 so can't talk or problem solve or follow 4yo instructions yet.

Lots of emphasis on alternatives too - you can't hit/bite people but you can hit/bite the sofa/the stairs/that cushion/this teething toy.

Surelyitscoffeetime · 18/10/2022 13:33

I taught in early years in a very naice school. You could spot the children whose parents bought into the ‘gentle parenting’ thing. After that year I decided I would not be doing it with my children.

HoHoHowMuch · 18/10/2022 13:32

Ds1 was an absolutely terrible sleeper as a baby. I bought the book as I wasn't prepared to do cry it out and wanted different tips. Trouble is, if you aren't going to train then it's not going to change any faster. He eventually got there and from about 2.5 slept through deeply. No amount of noise wakes him up now! But I do regret the money I spent on the book for it to tell me bugger all. I could have waited it out without the book expense.

Spicycurry · 18/10/2022 13:26

It was actually hitting / biting I was wanting advice about, although things have improved lately there is room for improvement so to speak!

OP posts:
WhiteFire · 18/10/2022 13:24

JenniferBarkley · 18/10/2022 12:23

Sleep teaching - that gave me a giggle, I'm picturing myself standing in front of a whiteboard with a powerpoint and some markers trying to explain to my two year old that we're all happier when she just sleeps through. Grin

If someone had told me it would work I would have been right up there. 😁

The memories are fading, but they are still there in the darkest part of my mind. I did "gentle night weaning" (some guy, can't remember who) but it was absolutely brutal and not particularly gentle.

Onceinnever · 18/10/2022 12:45

Lesserspottedmama · 18/10/2022 11:28

But not breastfeeding isn’t doing the best for your baby? That’s the truth.

Can we not ? This isn't a thread about breastfeeding.

BabynotblueHouse · 18/10/2022 12:43

It's interesting to see this thread as there is a group of us who were on a forum with SOS while she was birthing and raising babies and toddlers.
We quite often met up IRL too and can assure you all that SOS did not practice what she preaches in her books at all.
She often asked for and got advice about most of the topics she has written books about, so there are a lot of people out there paying for advice they could probably find online.
And she is not a better mother than anyone else. She's certainly no parenting expert!
We have been baffled by why her writings are so popular for some time. It's nice to know we aren't alone.

facefit · 18/10/2022 12:35

There is a group on Facebook and the sheer amount of miserable mothers is astounding. The book basically says to completely sacrifice yourself for the baby. No at all healthy

SlashBeef · 18/10/2022 12:32

Lesserspottedmama · 18/10/2022 11:28

But not breastfeeding isn’t doing the best for your baby? That’s the truth.

You're absolutely right. It's much better to starve them.

KlopflopKop · 18/10/2022 12:32

KweenieBeanz · 18/10/2022 07:19

No but there are lots of things you can do to encourage your baby to stop waking 12 times a night. Sleep training is GREAT. Baby sleeps (and is then much happier in the day, too, because it's well rested!), Parents are happier. What's not to like?
Proud sleep trainer here and I'm seeing the results now many years later with happy well-adjusted kids doing well at school. My friend who followed S O-S religiously ended up with a child who now has major sleep issues, gets up at 4am for the day, is constantly exhausted and it shows.

I was 'fortunate' enough to have two children who slept through from very early on and everyone wanted to know my 'secret' when there isn't one. I put them in the cot and they slept. That was it.

Neither napped much in the day and the eldest pretty much cried for 12 hours a day straight for the first 3 months so I wasn't surprised he was exhausted to be honest. I know I was. They are 9 and 7 now and don't go to sleep until about 10pm now.

This is it though. For all the ways you can have a 'perfect' child that does XY and Z, there will be some other disaster waiting for you.

JenniferBarkley · 18/10/2022 12:23

Sleep teaching - that gave me a giggle, I'm picturing myself standing in front of a whiteboard with a powerpoint and some markers trying to explain to my two year old that we're all happier when she just sleeps through. Grin

BertieBotts · 18/10/2022 12:16

I've just looked up calmandbright sleep and they are doing the nonsensical renaming thing as well!

If you think sleep training is fine, then... fine? But why rename it "sleep teaching" (it's more training than teaching...) just be upfront FGS. Don't pretend you've invented a new thing that has none of the downsides people associate with the other thing.

morechocolateneededtoday · 18/10/2022 11:51

Lesserspottedmama · 18/10/2022 11:28

But not breastfeeding isn’t doing the best for your baby? That’s the truth.

If only it were that simple....

Breastfeeding is the best if baby is not gaining weight and getting dehydrated in early days? Breastfeeding is best if baby cannot latch properly and is not getting adequate milk? (Because lets be honest, breastfeeding support is dismal in UK) Breastfeeding is best if older baby/toddler is waking hourly at night needing it for comfort and mother is unable to focus at work/ mental health is suffering as a result?

Just a few examples from many where it may not be best.

I breastfed both of mine but a lot of it working was down to luck - luck that I have my mother who breastfed to guide me, that I was able to access and afford any further support where needed and that my babies latched easily.

BertieBotts · 18/10/2022 11:49

I actually agree with her overall approach and I find some of her blog posts helpful but the books I read... not really.

I do think there's a place for authors/pages that basically say ditch the sleep guilt and let them sleep in your bed if it works for you, but it's also not v helpful for that to be the only input. Some suggestions for what to do when it's not working would also be helpful. Unfortunately it seems to be you either get reassurance about feeding to sleep/bedsharing but mass guilt trips about any form of intervention or you get useful workable plans for intervention with mass guilt trips about "bad habits" Halloween Hmm Just fuck off and somebody write one in the middle? Maybe I should but I'm no good at the sleep training part Halloween Grin

Gentle parenting I've had my puzzles with for 14 years now but I've eventually realised that it's all wildly inconsistent because the only thing gentle parents agree on is that gentle parenting = not authoritarian parenting, and therefore lots of it will wax lyrical about why authoritarian parenting (obedience, discipline, control) is bad but not actually provide much insight about what to do instead. And if they do tell you what to do instead it can vary so enormously you can get really confused if you mistakenly think it's one cohesive thing. Also, a lot wang on about how they are soooo special and different to the mainstream but... "mainstream" is also anti authoritarian parenting now as well and has been for ages - it's recognised that authoritative parenting is the ideal type.

I still have the same general principles that first attracted me to gentle parenting but I'm done with wishy washy unhelpful and elitist guides to it... I just look for guides to parenting approaches that seem to align whether or not they call themselves "gentle" - it's become a bit of a buzzword now anyway, and a lot of the "gentle parenting" accounts on social media are totally bog standard old rules and punishment except you call it "natural consequences" and that makes it nice Halloween Confused

Interestingly, her latest book explores the issue of what to do when you're burned out/know what you want to do but can't keep it up and I think it's actually trying to follow books like hers that made me feel like that Halloween Blush It's a really interesting topic but unfortunately from reading the sample, I think it has the same issue and doesn't really address the issue that it wants to, which is a shame, because I think she has really good intentions/principles in general but just lacks something in communicating them. And actually the biggest thing that helped me feel less burned out and "can't keep up" was being less perfectionist about "methods" and understanding that it doesn't actually matter that much what exact wording you use and just generally being a bit nicer to myself and ditching the guilt, also, learning how and when to have boundaries.

She's not the only one either. I was listening to an interview recently with Tina Payne Bryson and she was laughing at people who get really intently into methods and think you have to do everything perfectly, but I follow her on FB and every week for the last forever it feels like, she's been posting "mistake Mondays" which show you all the parenting mistakes you're making, and it makes me feel stabby. Less guilt inducing please.

MyBuggyIsOutToGetMe · 18/10/2022 11:47

The sleep book was indeed effing useless and just gave me the rage! I’m not sure how I was supposed to take time for myself while just accepting I was never going to get more than two hours’ sleep in one go. Although I think it is helpful to know bad sleepers are developmentally normal and not a reflection of your parenting, as some people might imply…

MyBuggyIsOutToGetMe · 18/10/2022 11:45

I found the toddler book good at helping me see things from the toddler’s perspective but not good at helping me actually do anything about the behaviour - and you can’t accept all the behaviour. The section on how to handle hitting and biting, for example, is very thin indeed (from memory), with no plan B as to what to try if it persists. I find a lot of her stuff simply doesn’t work if you don’t have all the time in the world to centre around your precious DC..

I am also not a fan of hours of negotiating/empathising with strong-willed toddlers. I don’t think it does them any good to be handed even more power. It’s sensible to separate responsibilities, eg it being your job to provide good food, their job to eat it (or not). But I don’t have time to spend 20 minutes negotiating about whether we’re going in the car when we need to leave t he house now. There comes a point where you have to just bundle them into their car seat sometimes and power on through, and they need to just get with the programme….

SandraOMG · 18/10/2022 11:32

@Lesserspottedmama

I breastfed both dcs and I yoir post is hugely goady.

You know as well as I do that it's only "best for baby" if the baby ends up well fed (which isn't always the case) and efforts to breastfeed don't end up causing the mother distress or mh problems (which is sometimes what happens).

It's clearly a lot less black and white than you imply and I think you must know that unless you live under a rock

Lesserspottedmama · 18/10/2022 11:28

morechocolateneededtoday · 17/10/2022 20:57

Can't stand the woman. She is about as judgemental as can be and dresses it all up as 'gentle parenting'. Explicitly states that having a c-section is bad, not breastfeeding means you aren't doing best for your baby, you shouldn't send your child to childcare and by 'sleep training' in any form is tantamount to abuse. Absolutely no consideration for mothers' mental state.

As far as evidence goes, she cherry picks studies to choose her and draws conclusions that are wildly different to that the author has stated. She writes her opinions as though they are facts rather than her opinions. She has no post graduate qualifications and is not a healthcare professional. As a healthcare professional who critiques research for a living, I can confirm she spouts nonsense rather than evidence to back her theories

She gives the full guilt trip if a parent needs 5 minute break from their child.... then later in the same book says self care is important. She talks about importance of routine at one stage... then at another how babies and children should be allowed to sleep when it suits them.

For those who choose to co-sleep until their child is ready to move into their own bed, this could provide some validation but there are far better books and blogs for this. If you genuinely need some help for sleep/discipline/eating/potty training, avoid her entirely. There are lots of excellent books out there for all types of parenting.

FWIW I don't think any lovely ladies or good parents would be so smug and judgemental about other ways of doing things. You can be an excellent gentle parent without taking every opportunity to put others down

But not breastfeeding isn’t doing the best for your baby? That’s the truth.

NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet · 18/10/2022 11:23

@morechocolateneededtoday Jesus...I had a c section! I requested it about 30 hours into an induction that was getting me absolutely nowhere with a large, back to back baby who apparently had his arm up in an awkward position too! I have no regrets and think a VB would have possibly gone very wrong.

Your experience sounds awful. The last thing mums need is additional guilt, especially with things out of their control. As someone who also 'failed' to breastfeed I suppose Sarah Ockwell Smith would deem me a shite mother! I had no idea she had those beliefs having just seen snippets of what she has to say and thinking it made some sense to me..

Ergonomicallydesigned · 18/10/2022 11:23

I live locally to her so she’s quite often on the local mums page peddling her books and seminars on parenting. She released a book recently on child development. Can’t say I’m a huge fan of hers at all.

Hugasauras · 18/10/2022 11:18

@bruffin Well exactly. So a book advocating cosleeping and bed sharing would have had the same effect on you that books about sleep training had on me!

redredwineub40 · 18/10/2022 11:07

I agree with @Hugasauras - most parenting books are written based on a combo of parental preferences and personality of child and spending time identifying those two factors is your best bet before you pick any book up.

And sometimes, for some parents and some kids, giving up IS all that works - I've got one I sleep trained who is a 12 year old who loves routine and needs a lot of sleep, and one who even at 8 needs much less sleep, wakes all the time and I'm still co sleeping with to get to drop off.

It's the same with discipline - one size does not fit all.

bruffin · 18/10/2022 11:01

Hugasauras · 18/10/2022 10:43

I think most books about sleep are a waste of paper. Either you decide to be child-led and adjust your sleeping patterns to follow that (co-sleeping, etc). Or you want them in their own room and you have to do varying levels of sleep training to get them there.

The one good thing about her books is it was a bit of an antidote for me to all the material there seems to be about sleep training, getting babies to sleep in their cots. That wasn't the approach for us and actually reading her sleep book I was kinda like 'why am I spending and wasting so much time sitting by the cot soothing and stressing and trying all these gradual retreat, disappearing chair, pick up out down stuff?' And I took DD into bed with me, she fell asleep being cuddled and then I got back up and had an actual evening to myself and we all got plenty of sleep from then on.

But essentially they are all just to make money off sleep-deprived parents when there's no magic bullet to fix things, just your child's temperament and what you are willing to accept/do.

If I did that DD would have been awake and increasingly agitated because what she needed to be was in her cot by herself. She used to make a noise which meant I'm tired and need to go to bed now!

Hugasauras · 18/10/2022 10:43

I think most books about sleep are a waste of paper. Either you decide to be child-led and adjust your sleeping patterns to follow that (co-sleeping, etc). Or you want them in their own room and you have to do varying levels of sleep training to get them there.

The one good thing about her books is it was a bit of an antidote for me to all the material there seems to be about sleep training, getting babies to sleep in their cots. That wasn't the approach for us and actually reading her sleep book I was kinda like 'why am I spending and wasting so much time sitting by the cot soothing and stressing and trying all these gradual retreat, disappearing chair, pick up out down stuff?' And I took DD into bed with me, she fell asleep being cuddled and then I got back up and had an actual evening to myself and we all got plenty of sleep from then on.

But essentially they are all just to make money off sleep-deprived parents when there's no magic bullet to fix things, just your child's temperament and what you are willing to accept/do.

Devo1818 · 18/10/2022 10:36

And agree she is anti- feminist. She pretty much states mothers - and only mothers- must be stay at home mothers. Fathers and other care givers won't do. Imagine if all women took that advice, we would be absolutely fucked.