Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Sarah Ockwell Smith actually has any useful advice in her books?

140 replies

Spicycurry · 17/10/2022 20:02

I am sure she is a lovely lady and very good parent.

But I read her sleep book and it pretty much just told me to put up with it until my child slept better.

Ordered her toddler book and it seems to be much of the same.

it is helpful of course to understand where my child is coming from if you like but I am not sure it’s particularly useful to read when at the end of your tether!

or will I be flamed by her fans?

OP posts:
Squirrelvillage · 18/10/2022 22:05

I once read a comment on MN along the lines of... the person who benefits the most from Sarah Ockwell Smith giving out advice is Sarah Ockwell Smith. This has proven to be true.

iCouldSleepForAYear · 18/10/2022 21:53

I found Sarah OS useless. Two non-sleepers, but her book had no advice or reassurance. It's not reasonable to suggest to a working mother that maybe a distressed child shouldn't have to go to nursery that day.

But I also didn't find the Baby Whisperer or any of the sleep training books useful either. My girls did not respond. At all.

Things may have been easier for them if they'd been spared reflux. Or if their big sister (my DSD) had lived with us every day rather than going to her mother's house on a rota: maybe there would have been less separation anxiety at night. Or if I had a calmer demeanour rather than an anxious one. Or if I found routines easy to establish without Elvanse and CBT. But we didn't have those things working in our favour at the time.

I think the only thing I gained out of all the books I read is that a bedtime routine helps massively with getting your kid down in the first place. That is the one consistent message from all of them. And a consistent routine eventually led to fewer wakeups, and eventually wakeups that were easier to settle, and then eventually no wakeups.

None of the books really talk about how dads can or should be consistently involved with nighttime support.

Chesure · 18/10/2022 21:45

Try 1, 2, 3 Magic @Spicycurry if you're looking for behaviour techniques.

BiasedBinding · 18/10/2022 21:26

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 20:35

And that's great, but quite a lot of women in my social circle do, and in particular are vocal about never having sex because their kids share their bed instead of their husband.

Just because you wouldn't share that level of detail with acquaintances doesn't mean I'm making it up 🤷‍♀️

I didn’t suggest you were :)

Onceinnever · 18/10/2022 21:16

I find the Facebook group in particular is full of women posting, despairing that their four year old won't sleep or needs to lie with a parent for an hour to sleep etc, and everyone responds 'this is totally normal'
Yes maybe normal if you want to also be exhausted or you don't want an evening to yourself. But it is unhelpful to parents to just say 'little children act like this and you can't affect any change so put up with it'

allfurcoatnoknickers · 18/10/2022 21:14

@JardinsduBasil Really hit the nail on the head there. It pisses me off so much that so many parenting guides seem to be stuck in some 1950s Stepford model where it's just assumed that the mother stays home. DH and I both work full time demanding jobs - I need a parenting book for that. A non-guilty one.

ThirtyFourty · 18/10/2022 21:03

I wouldn't even give her book away on Olio, as I didn't want to inflict the guilt on another tired, vulnerable parent.

BettyCake · 18/10/2022 20:48

Amen to this thread. I bought one of her books when DS was younger, thought the book was the biggest crock of shite ever!

Tomorrowisalatterday · 18/10/2022 20:38

She is known as Sarah Ockwell Bollocks in our house

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 20:35

BiasedBinding · 18/10/2022 20:15

Gosh I can’t imagine knowing that much detail. I don’t talk about my children’s sleep or my sex life with anyone.

And that's great, but quite a lot of women in my social circle do, and in particular are vocal about never having sex because their kids share their bed instead of their husband.

Just because you wouldn't share that level of detail with acquaintances doesn't mean I'm making it up 🤷‍♀️

JardinsduBasil · 18/10/2022 20:32

Exactly @BertieBotts there needs to be a 'just doing some stuff and bits of childrearing are still inevitably going to be annoying'..

I had 2 non sleepers. I also went back to work when they were still quite young and thought i was actually going mad. The 6yo is still pretty bad. I did try and sleep train them (didn't work) so there is a place for someone saying it's ok just to do whatever you need to do to get through, blah blah, when I was feeling like I shouldn't let them sleep in my bed but also had to be up for work in 2 hours.

But the whole idea of methods is just so tedious, is in general a bunch of sexist crap around another load of feminized labour, and is almost never aimed at working mothers (because one must spend all their time submitting to the method). I think it preys on the inevitable loss of identity that comes with early motherhood. You can't just use a sling because it's convenient when you take the bus a lot, you have to 'do babywearing'.

The same goes for the opposite direction as well, Gina Ford style.

The whole thing seems bloody ridiculous by the time they're 7 or 8 anyway.

Runaway1 · 18/10/2022 20:26

She has some good ideas about managing nap dropping I thought.

BiasedBinding · 18/10/2022 20:15

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 18:28

While in theory you can have sex whenever and wherever you want, most people with jobs and children tend to have sex in their bedroom for privacy's sake, and early morning and bedtime are the two most convenient times if you're working during the day.

Of all the co-sleeping parents I know, the vast majority report rarely if ever having sex, and only one has told me she's happy with her sex life. I realise not everybody feels comfortable discussing their sex life even with friends, but it's striking how many of them are vocal about their lack of a sex life.

Gosh I can’t imagine knowing that much detail. I don’t talk about my children’s sleep or my sex life with anyone.

Confrontayshunme · 18/10/2022 19:02

My SIL was so into cosleeping and feeding every time her child turned over at night that she couldn't get pregnant again for nearly five years...because sex wasn't happening and frequent feeding meant her period didn't come back. I still can't imagine feeding a talking school aged child so much that you are unable to get pregnant. That is no life really. And she did it all spouting some nonsense about how well bonded they were and how my actually independent DS was irreparably damaged by non evidence based parenting. 🙄

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 18:28

Lucidas · 18/10/2022 18:25

’Gentle parenting and some of its consequences such as co-sleeping are regressive and reinforce traditional norms’

‘You can only have sex at night in your bedroom’

While in theory you can have sex whenever and wherever you want, most people with jobs and children tend to have sex in their bedroom for privacy's sake, and early morning and bedtime are the two most convenient times if you're working during the day.

Of all the co-sleeping parents I know, the vast majority report rarely if ever having sex, and only one has told me she's happy with her sex life. I realise not everybody feels comfortable discussing their sex life even with friends, but it's striking how many of them are vocal about their lack of a sex life.

Lucidas · 18/10/2022 18:25

’Gentle parenting and some of its consequences such as co-sleeping are regressive and reinforce traditional norms’

‘You can only have sex at night in your bedroom’

morechocolateneededtoday · 18/10/2022 17:55

One of the reviews talks about how many advocates of this kind of parenting wear exhaustion as a badge of honour, and I agree - in my social circles maternal exhaustion is utterly normalised and it seems to be accepted that children will wake several times overnight well into their primary school years.

This was my experience of the sleep board on here just under 6 years ago. The number of women who shot me down for needing some rest all because they lived on 1-2hours/night all through the baby and toddler years. No matter how exhausted they were, they did it all because they loved their child(ren) so so much and were much better parents than I could ever be. I was made to feel like an awful mother for wanting some rest. Once in a better place and rested, I did go on from time to time to defend the decision to do what is best for each individual but I was wasting my time and breath.

I do sometimes wonder how their children are now (but not enough to revisit the board!)

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 17:38

It's interesting though. One of the reviews talks about how many advocates of this kind of parenting wear exhaustion as a badge of honour, and I agree - in my social circles maternal exhaustion is utterly normalised and it seems to be accepted that children will wake several times overnight well into their primary school years. If mums are happy with this, that's fine - but actually the mums I know who live this way don't seem happy at all.

It also seems to be normalised that co-sleeping means that the parents can't share a bed for years, and that therefore they don't have much (if any) sex. I just wouldn't want to live like that.

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 17:29

Thanks to this thread I've spent the last 20 minutes reading 1- and 2-star reviews of Sarah Ockwell-Smith books on Amazon. Laughed out loud at some of them!

HauntedPencil · 18/10/2022 16:12

She's always been recommended to me by the most guilt triply people ever so never been tempted remotely to read

Reallybadidea · 18/10/2022 15:25

Like others, I'm also infuriated by her books being touted as being 'evidence based' when they're anything but.

I knew her slightly years ago when she was a homeopath/hypnobirth/doula and I can confirm that she is all about creating an image of scientific rigour but has absolutely no understanding of how to analyse research. She's basically a quack who has built a business out of Googling stuff and writing it down.

WhiteFire · 18/10/2022 14:42

The baby guru, who shall not be named, on the other end of the scale is the other side of the same coin.

Read the book, couldn't find the time to pee.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 18/10/2022 14:36

There are other better gentle parenting books.

houseargh · 18/10/2022 14:30

Oh god yes, 'attachment parenting' is another one - that school of childrearing philosophy and actual attachment theory have literally nothing to do with each other. It just got that name because the author of that particular parenting book thought it would be a good fit. And then you come on Mumsnet and read thread after thread of people justifying whatever because it results in a nice, strong attachment. And the idea that mega-close, wear them at all times, attachment parenting leads to children suddenly become more independent than they would have been if they were pushed around in a pram instead is completely laughable (and certainly not borne out by the children I know who were the product of hardcore attachment parenting, most of whom remain incredibly clingy well past the baby/toddler years, though obviously this is a small sample - I'm sure some aren't clingy at all, but it's got nothing to do with the babywearing!)

CakeIsNotAvailable · 18/10/2022 14:25

So pleased to have found this thread and some likeminded parents! In the circles I move in, almost everybody is a "gentle parent", and I find a lot of them quite unpleasant and intolerant - one of them described me as "selfish" for admitting that I preferred formula-feeding to breastfeeding! In general the attitude of the gentle parents in my life is that "gentle parents" know best - lots of posts on Facebook about how their husband doesn't parent exactly like they do, and how can they make him see the error of his ways? The idea that Dad's opinion might be of equal weight to Mum's is never entertained.

"Attachment parenting" is the other term I hate. It's a complete distortion of attachment theory. Most "gentle parenting" and "attachment parenting" stuff is scientifically illiterate and is based on misquoting or exaggerating studies, or looking at inappropriate surrogate outcome markers (like how people talk about serum cortisol levels re: sleep training, when more relevant outcome measures would include attachment and wellbeing later in life).

When I was pregnant I had intended to breastfeed and babywear and all that stuff, but my child had other ideas - he preferred cot naps to contact naps almost from birth, and even while I was exclusively breastfeeding neither of us liked co-sleeping! And he didn't enjoy being in a baby carrier, either.

I looked at Sarah Ockwell-Smith's website once when I had a young baby. It made me feel horrendous and I cried for the rest of the day.

I really struggle to meet like-minded mums because the gentle parenting thing is so prevalent now, and any time I say anything that deviates from that narrative I get shouted down.