Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Sarah Ockwell Smith actually has any useful advice in her books?

140 replies

Spicycurry · 17/10/2022 20:02

I am sure she is a lovely lady and very good parent.

But I read her sleep book and it pretty much just told me to put up with it until my child slept better.

Ordered her toddler book and it seems to be much of the same.

it is helpful of course to understand where my child is coming from if you like but I am not sure it’s particularly useful to read when at the end of your tether!

or will I be flamed by her fans?

OP posts:
mavismorpoth · 20/10/2022 10:32

Suzi888 · 18/10/2022 06:20

You don’t need a book. Newborns are hard, they cry. There’s not a lot you can do about it apart from put up with it, because it doesn’t last forever. None of it does. There is no magic wand.

They don't really if you just give them your tit. It's all they want. They're crying because they have an innate need to suckle and if they can't it's very distressing. They just want their mummy, that's it. It's not forever.

JenniferBarkley · 20/10/2022 09:15

Absolutely Chesure. We moved my DD from our room to her own at 7 months. In our room she was waking every two hours. First night in her room she slept 11 hours straight.

The sleep was amazing enough, but the most interesting thing was the difference it made in her. She was a much happier, more settled, sunnier baby during the day from that moment on, which is obvious when you think about it. Sleep is just as important for them as it is for us.

Chesure · 19/10/2022 22:14

The thing with SOS/co sleeping/ gentle parenting etc. is that it needs to give you results you're happy with/can live with or it's not actually working for you.

I couldn't sleep co sleeping because I was terrified of smothering my DC. I got a worse night's sleep because of it. People only have a sleep problem if their child's sleep is causing problems for them or their child. Adults do wake several times in the night, most smart watches prove that. But if I shook my DH awake every time I woke up and told him 'I'm awake. I can't sleep' then we have a sleep problem! Same as if your child comes into your room and wakes you up. You have a sleep problem!

I had a colleague who was unfunctioning because she'd co slept until her DC was 3 and she just couldn't do it anymore because of the poor sleep she got but had massive SOS gentle parenting guilt. She had a sleep problem!

It's no more unkind to teach your child to sleep than it is to teach them to wear clothes when you leave the house. They might protest fiercely about doing both but somehow SOS tells us that bedtime teaching isn't gentle parenting. There are always ways to get your child to comply with what needs to happen for them and you to be functioning members of society ie clothed and well rested. Books that tell you to just live with it are hugely unhelpful.

Eurydice84 · 19/10/2022 20:26

Topgub · 17/10/2022 20:11

Pseudo science and guilt tripping bullshit at its worst

Chuck it in the bin.

This GrinGrin

Yazo · 19/10/2022 19:49

I quite liked some of between but then it got very smug towards the end when she said her tweens knew the difference between a mortgage and an ISA/fed the homeless/solved climate change by 12. When she said they got a 'mental health day' on demand every term I also rolled my eyes a bit, there's a week off every 6 weeks for school holidays, I'm not sure you need an extra 6 term time duvet days. The teachers must love her.

lochmaree · 19/10/2022 18:15

but to add to my post above, I have a friend who generally follows gentle parenting / SOS and her 3yo DD is quite wild and hits other kids A LOT. but, I do similar and my DS does not and is generally pretty good BUT he is pretty placid.

And another but, I tend to get less stressed about most stuff. e.g. I send my DS to a childminder who he loves and I think she's great but she disciplines differently to me. my friend wouldn't send her DD there, and won't send her to any childcare even though she has 30 free hrs because she can't find anywhere that will follow her methods. instead takes her to a specific school almost an hour away from their house which means she has to wait there and doesn't get any free time. I think she seems so rundown a lot but I dont want to suggest / imply criticism as I know what it's like when you want to do something and other people suggest not doing it as it might be easier. anyway, a ramble but this thread has got me thinking!

lochmaree · 19/10/2022 18:05

finding this thread really interesting! I have read a couple of SOS books. found bits of the potty training and second baby book good. and also the why is my baby's sleep important. but having seen what people said here, yes I can see how actually its very much about just saying everything is normal and basically just keep going.

I do bedshare with my nearly 3yo and he can and often does sleep through, he does like me there at bedtime to lie with him and bf before cuddle to sleep. but he'll go to sleep for DH or childminder with no crying. I'm doing the same with my newborn. I find SOSs reassurance comforting but I guess I wasn't looking for any strategies to change anything.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 19/10/2022 17:11

I agree i prefer that! I must be mediaeval too 😂

Hugasauras · 19/10/2022 17:07

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 19/10/2022 17:01

I actually like a split sleep. If i go to bed early sometimes i get up and potter round at 3am for an hour then go back to bed.

It's funny, DD1 went through a spate of split nights when she was 2 where she would wake about 11pm and be awake till 1am and in the end I just embraced it and we had some hilarious chats and things during that time. I miss it a little.

I might be odd but I would rather 8/9 hours split sleep and get up at 8am or something than fewer hours in one block and have to get up for the day earlier. Maybe I would be better suited to the Middle Ages Grin

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 19/10/2022 17:01

I actually like a split sleep. If i go to bed early sometimes i get up and potter round at 3am for an hour then go back to bed.

Miniforce · 19/10/2022 16:59

I read 'The Second Baby Book' by Sarah OS when I was pregnant with my second and it did have some quite practical tips in it. I remember thinking this was strange because I'd found her book about baby sleep so useless! I think generally her ideas are not much practical help.

Just the term 'gentle parenting' seems so judgmental. What's the opposite of gentle - rough, aggressive, etc? In my experience most parents are pretty gentle with their children regardless of whether or not they co-sleep, breastfeed on demand for two years, and so on.

Hugasauras · 19/10/2022 16:56

I don't disagree, it's just that adult sleep isn't always that simple either. And developmentally there's a lot of difference between a 6mo and a 3yo in terms of what support is 'appropriate' to help them sleep. I don't really buy that you need to teach 'self-soothing' in most kids, it's more a case of hurrying it along rather than then never learning it all.

Split nights are called biphasic sleep. BBC has a really interesting article about it.

www.bbc.com/future/article/20220107-the-lost-medieval-habit-of-biphasic-sleep

facefit · 19/10/2022 16:41

Of course adults wake up sometimes and resettle themselves - that is exactly what babies and children need to learn to do without parental input.

Agree. Imagine being utterly dependant on another person to fall asleep! I don't think that's kind to the child at all.

Runaway1 · 19/10/2022 16:22

This split sleep thing doesn’t have much evidence as far as I can see. I’ve only ever seen a few literary references. Interested to learn more.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 19/10/2022 16:20

Hugasauras · 19/10/2022 13:13

Actually adult sleep isn't sleeping through either. We wake up quite a few times in the night, we just aren't aware of it. In fact a few hundred years ago split nights were common: people would go to sleep for 3-4 hours, get up and eat, etc. and then go back to bed. Sleep has kind of changed with society.

I have never understood this point of view. Of course adults wake up sometimes and resettle themselves - that is exactly what babies and children need to learn to do without parental input. As with all developmental milestones, some kids achieve it without any help, some kids need a nudge and some kids need a lot of support.

facefit · 19/10/2022 13:15

Hugasauras · 19/10/2022 13:13

Actually adult sleep isn't sleeping through either. We wake up quite a few times in the night, we just aren't aware of it. In fact a few hundred years ago split nights were common: people would go to sleep for 3-4 hours, get up and eat, etc. and then go back to bed. Sleep has kind of changed with society.

I know we wake briefly and then resettle. Toddlers and children should also be doing this. Not having many unsettled nights. It doesn't benefit anyone to properly wake up every 90 minutes/2 hours.

Split nights is fine if that's what you want to do. I'm talking about unsettled nights that are benefitting no one.

Hugasauras · 19/10/2022 13:13

Actually adult sleep isn't sleeping through either. We wake up quite a few times in the night, we just aren't aware of it. In fact a few hundred years ago split nights were common: people would go to sleep for 3-4 hours, get up and eat, etc. and then go back to bed. Sleep has kind of changed with society.

facefit · 19/10/2022 13:07

I disagree. It’s actually totally normal and the reason that humans in the majority of the world sleep with their children. Literally the same as every other mammal.

Our society has changed this as we have other needs and that’s also ok.

Humans aren't the same as 'every other mammal' though.

Regardless, it's not normal for humans to have unsettled night every night past the age of about 6 months, maybe a year.

It's normal to sleep through the night!

BiscuitLover3678 · 19/10/2022 12:59

facefit · 19/10/2022 12:49

Yeah I hate this.

It's really not normal for a child to wake multiple times overnight. Children need to sleep for their development.

I disagree. It’s actually totally normal and the reason that humans in the majority of the world sleep with their children. Literally the same as every other mammal.

Our society has changed this as we have other needs and that’s also ok.

BiscuitLover3678 · 19/10/2022 12:57

I half love her books because they made me feel normal and good for not being able to (or wanting to) sleep train.

But I also agree that if you just wanted help then it wasn’t helpful. And I do have more guilt thinking about these things and if my son ever cries.

But she’s also right about a lot of it. If you actually look at up to date psychology.

facefit · 19/10/2022 12:49

Onceinnever · 18/10/2022 21:16

I find the Facebook group in particular is full of women posting, despairing that their four year old won't sleep or needs to lie with a parent for an hour to sleep etc, and everyone responds 'this is totally normal'
Yes maybe normal if you want to also be exhausted or you don't want an evening to yourself. But it is unhelpful to parents to just say 'little children act like this and you can't affect any change so put up with it'

Yeah I hate this.

It's really not normal for a child to wake multiple times overnight. Children need to sleep for their development.

BrilliantGreenFlamingo · 19/10/2022 07:54

I threw her book across the room. I didn’t want to sleep train and never did. Had awful sleepers but her book was full of shite. So so so unhelpful. It made me feel so inadequate

bitachey · 19/10/2022 07:51

BabynotblueHouse · 18/10/2022 12:43

It's interesting to see this thread as there is a group of us who were on a forum with SOS while she was birthing and raising babies and toddlers.
We quite often met up IRL too and can assure you all that SOS did not practice what she preaches in her books at all.
She often asked for and got advice about most of the topics she has written books about, so there are a lot of people out there paying for advice they could probably find online.
And she is not a better mother than anyone else. She's certainly no parenting expert!
We have been baffled by why her writings are so popular for some time. It's nice to know we aren't alone.

Oooh - I was on that forum too and I was to say the same thing!

BertieBotts · 19/10/2022 07:45

SnackSizeRaisin · 18/10/2022 22:11

I breastfed my babies until they were toddlers.... But there is very little scientific evidence that breastfeeding a full term baby in a developed country with a clean water supply is actually better than formula feeding. There are definitely benefits in terms of cost savings and environmental impact and on the mother's risk of breast cancer. But for the baby the benefits are more theoretical than backed up with evidence.

If you believe this you've swallowed the formula propaganda which is rife on SM at the moment.

There are definite benefits to baby. No, they aren't so miraculous that they wipe out all contextual factors - a mother struggling with depression who would be helped by formula feeding, it's probably going to be a net benefit to her baby to formula feed, for example. (and not all depression cases would be helped by FF, just one example) But it is absolutely not true that the only benefits are for premature babies or in places where water is unsafe.

There's no point beating people up if BF doesn't work for them for whatever reason, people should largely pick what works for their family. But to say there are no benefits is false.

SnackSizeRaisin · 18/10/2022 22:11

Lesserspottedmama · 18/10/2022 11:28

But not breastfeeding isn’t doing the best for your baby? That’s the truth.

I breastfed my babies until they were toddlers.... But there is very little scientific evidence that breastfeeding a full term baby in a developed country with a clean water supply is actually better than formula feeding. There are definitely benefits in terms of cost savings and environmental impact and on the mother's risk of breast cancer. But for the baby the benefits are more theoretical than backed up with evidence.