Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to live to 95?

110 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 17/10/2022 19:47

Feeling a bit emotional tonight.

One of my granddads passed away from cancer in his mid 70s. He was fit and healthy, so the diagnosis shocked us all and it was a pretty awful couple of years watching him decline and pass away. However, he had many family and friends come to visit him, he stayed pretty mentally present until the end and his funeral was enormous - over a hundred people. He was well loved and well known in his local area. Most of his care was done by my grandma, his wife, and he died at home.

My other granddad passed away just after Christmas aged 95. He stayed in his house until he was 91 and way past being able to manage it, and his final years were spent between hospital and care facilities, worrying about my gran who has dementia and generally in pain. All bar one or two friends had long passed away, so few visitors, just his small family. He died in hospital fairly suddenly without any of us present 😢 his wife not there as it would’ve distressed her. His funeral was very small. He was such a proud man with such an interesting life and career, it makes me sad to think how few people were still alive to remember him at the end.

I don’t really know what I want from this thread, I guess it’s cathartic to write it down and cheaper than therapy! While illness and death is never pleasant, am I wrong to think that, in general, we’re actually making the end of our lives worse by living for too long?

OP posts:
AnnapurnaSanctuary · 18/10/2022 09:25

My parents and PILs are all in their 80s and are in varying states of health (both physically and mentally). The one who was most physically fit a year ago has declined dramatically. Ageing is hard Sad

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 09:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Members who wish to commit suicide must have sound judgement, as determined by the organization; be themselves able to bring about death; and submit a formal request including a letter explaining their wish to die and medical reports showing diagnosis and attempted treatment.

caroleanboneparte · 18/10/2022 08:21

I became disabled in my 20s.

At times my mobility/ life has been like the elderly people discussed here.

But no one suggests euthanasia for 20 somethings.

Yes it's not a full life being stuck in front of the tv all day, struggling to wash or dress yourself. But it's a hell of a lot better than being dead.

Don't speak for others if you haven't walked in their shoes.

HighlandPony · 18/10/2022 00:28

urbanbuddha · 17/10/2022 23:06

@HighlandPony

That's awful.
I think hospital consultants can have an inflated sense of their own worth sometimes.
He very much feels fulfilled in his life and has achieved most of what he wanted out of life and he feels nature has called his cards but modern medicine won’t let him go - those are his poker related words not mine.
If he is clear about it and can express himself as well as that I think he has the right to be listened to. If you can, have a chat with his GP. Maybe PALS or one of the age related charities could help. Also, he has the right to a second opinion.
I really hope I'm not upsetting you here or being insensitive. My grandmother died of her 13th stroke in 7 years. I know how heartbreaking it was to watch her decline from an elegant witty woman as she lost mobility and speech.

Not at all. I’m more sad for him. It’s the dignity thing too. Back in July one of the carers that came in to help him wash and dress was the great grand daughter of a family friend. Because we live in such a small place that’s always going to be a possibility and he’s embarrassed by it.

The way the gp system works here if you phone in the morning from half 8 until it’s not engaged and you try to get an appointment but usually there isn’t any left. I could ask for the duty gp to call me or my auntie back as we are down as his carers but all they will do is refer him back to the hospital. We’ve tried. I genuinely think the neurologist at the hospital just disagrees with my grandad and his beliefs so decides no. We tried to get a second opinion and he was sent fir assessment where they said he was depressed after the loss of my gran and the restrictions of covid and that it would pass. It’s like they feel he should be grateful to be alive and try to go in as long as possible. Like they can’t understand why someone of reasonable sound mind wouldn’t want to live. but that’s not my grandads beliefs

VikingLady · 18/10/2022 00:05

It's difficult. One side of my family has early onset dementia and die horribly in their 50s. The other side seem to last forever. My grandad is late 90s and doesn't appear to have changed much since his 70s and possibly before. He is less mobile, and he's had to adjust his friendship group as they've died off (fortunately he's in a very tight knit community so that's not a problem).

It very much depends which side I take after, and whether I have an adequate pension etc.

NancyDrooo · 18/10/2022 00:00

I think it was Jack Dee who, upon being advised to eat healthier and exercise more so he’d live ten years longer, replied something like “yeah but it’s the last ten years, when you’re just dribbling and pissing yourself”.

NancyDrooo · 17/10/2022 23:56

This reminds me of going through a relatives address book with her when she was about 95, reading all the names out for her Xmas card list:

Bob &Jean? Dead
Doris? Dead
George & Elsie? Dead and only just dead
Joan? Might as well be dead

She was being tongue-in-cheek but the fact remained her husband, siblings, cousins, colleagues and all her mates were long gone. I definitely don’t want to get that old.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 17/10/2022 23:52

Yanbu - to some extent. Certainly I agree that the last 10 years are often miserable for those who live into their 90s and beyond. But my parents are in their late 70s and I don't think they are anywhere near ready to go. It's a good thing we can't choose when to go as the dilemma would be overwhelming.

Shmithecat2 · 17/10/2022 23:45

Yanbu. My dh's nana is 96, I adore her. She's still able to live by herself, but has slowly, physically lost her independence over the last few years and is housebound. She looks so sad now. Her dh died approx 15 years ago and she's lonely. Mil is an only child and takes care of her needs, but it's a miserable existence. Not something I look forward to.

Luredbyapomegranate · 17/10/2022 23:41

Faded 95.. I have to go to bed.

Luredbyapomegranate · 17/10/2022 23:40

Yep - we have got good at prolonging life without increasing the quality

I hope i made a a lively 85 year old, but if that’s not an option. I’d take a sprightly 75 over a very faded 75 ant day of the week.

Meili04 · 17/10/2022 23:40

If I'm in good health at 95 sure , if I'm doubly incontinent slowly wasting away on a pureed diet because of dysphagia then no. There's a difference between quantity and quality of life and we get it wrong in this country.

yellowroses7 · 17/10/2022 23:36

My Grandad died 87 and gave up on life the last few years he just sat in his chair in his living room watching tele all day..got to the point where he wouldn't wash and dress any more. His mind was fine his body was against him, it was so sad.

His wife, my grandma on the other hand is 93, she drives, goes to lunch with all her family and friend's multiple times a week. She's goes mine dancing once a week. She keeps a 3 bedroom house immaculate and bakes & mows her own lawn. Does her own shopping cooking washing & cleaning.She had had some minor issues & health problems over the years but bounces back quickly but on the whole she is amazing. We cherish her daily.

She told me once the reason why she doesn't deteriorate is because 'she's not going to sit in the corner' she said you can give up n wither away in the corner sat down all day or get up and carry on. If I can get to anywhere near her I would be proud 🥲

Mother87 · 17/10/2022 23:28

Agree with various PP's - health being a major factor. My DFather died @ 89 after a very short illness. Despite his age, we were honestly "shocked" as he was driving/cooking/"looking after" me & my home/meeting his adult grandkids for lunch. And he was "frequently grumpy" about life shall we say (possibly depressed at times - not a subject he'd ever discuss or acknowledge. He would say from his 70's that he didn't always want to wake up, had had enough - and he was fit and healthy. (he was Singaporean Chinese. Emotions weren't a "thing") When he DID realise he was seriously ill & might not have long - he was truly devastated, regardless of age. It was my first parent-loss & I too was/am heartbroken as we don't talk about grief, the implications, the effect on all. It sounds naive I know - but I thought it musn't be "so bad" if you were older. Sorry, I know that's a slightly different but related subject. Whereas DM 82 struggles health-wise/is "lost" without DF and despite having just a few but meaningful people around, has many "what's it all about now" moments. So, I think living such a long time and it being "worthwhile" is about it having meaning/good health/autonomy/connections...

sparkle17 · 17/10/2022 23:27

I don't want to live that long. I think post 80 years old I won't get vaccines for flu/covid and other basic medications and see where life takes me.

FrazzledHippy · 17/10/2022 23:25

YANBU.

I work in a care home and have watched lots of people literally shrink away to nothing once they're on palliative care. It's awful and I wouldn't wish that type of end on anyone.

Sympathy for your losses OP

Florenz · 17/10/2022 23:11

Years ago people who lived into their 80s would have been in the same position who die now in their 90s are.

I personally would not want to live too long and have my faculties or physical abilities decline too much. 80-85 probably.

I always remember that French woman who lived to 122. She was 70 at the end of WW2 and then died in the same month as Princess Diana.

urbanbuddha · 17/10/2022 23:06

@HighlandPony

That's awful.
I think hospital consultants can have an inflated sense of their own worth sometimes.
He very much feels fulfilled in his life and has achieved most of what he wanted out of life and he feels nature has called his cards but modern medicine won’t let him go - those are his poker related words not mine.
If he is clear about it and can express himself as well as that I think he has the right to be listened to. If you can, have a chat with his GP. Maybe PALS or one of the age related charities could help. Also, he has the right to a second opinion.
I really hope I'm not upsetting you here or being insensitive. My grandmother died of her 13th stroke in 7 years. I know how heartbreaking it was to watch her decline from an elegant witty woman as she lost mobility and speech.

LikeAStar1994 · 17/10/2022 23:02

I'm so sorry for your losses OP.

I've always said I don't want to live a long life. In fact if I was ever told I wouldn't make it past 50, I'd be perfectly fine with it. I'm very much a "It is what it is" person.

However I would never try to end my life. That's one thing I definitely wouldn't do. I can't tell anyone this is in real life because they'll only say I'm depressed and I'm not.

I just know what I want and I'm not a people pleaser. My life is my own.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 17/10/2022 22:53

85 for me.

Mum lived to 97, one day was cooking for us, died the following night (I pray in her sleep but no way of telling).

Objectively she had a great life - lived near us, relatively good health and mobility, still sharp as a tack. The crem was packed for her funeral and she would have loved the afterparty.

But in her last 7 years she lost a beloved daughter, lost all her friends to death or dementia, moved 200 miles from where she’d lived since 1946 to be near family, was dependent on us for her social life, moved into a care home because she found living in sheltered accommodation lonely, developed a nasty but not life threatening condition. She toughed it out and put the most positive spin on everything but If she had died at 90 she would have missed so much sadness and difficulty.

So I’ve chosen 85 (maybe 90 depending on how life and finances hold out) but hope I have the guts to stop all my life-sustaining medication and take my chances. And I have an Advance Decision in place already.

Mogginsthemog · 17/10/2022 22:51

It depends. My grandad lived to over 100 and yes he slowed up and became more dependent on others. He manged to weather a couple of hospital stays, but came out the other side.
He wasn't doing much towards the end of his life but I think he was mainly contented seeing family etc. until he had to go into a care home , but he was not there that long until he died.

It's true he didn't have that many at his funeral, maybe 15ish but , does that matter?

Turquoisesea · 17/10/2022 22:40

I think it very much depends on your health and quality of life. My DFil is 91, although old is still mentally very sharp, can still walk a fair distance without any walking aids, still drives, still married to DMil who is 10 years younger. Lives round the corner and sees DH every day and loves to come round for a chat / meal and a couple of glasses of wine, can still beat us all at scrabble! My DM however is 87, has advanced dementia and in a care home, is bed bound, incontinent and just asleep most of the time. So similar ages but very different lives.

Toddlerteaplease · 17/10/2022 22:33

I do think the Queen got it right though! Had all her faculties right to the end. Very quick decline and death.

Toddlerteaplease · 17/10/2022 22:31

Only 7 at my grandmas funeral as well.

Toddlerteaplease · 17/10/2022 22:30

My Maternal grandma died at 83. She'd outlined her husband by many years and all her friends had died. Get house was too big to manage and she was going to probably come and live with us in a granny flat. It was definitely the right time for her. Any longer would have been miserable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread