Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to live to 95?

110 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 17/10/2022 19:47

Feeling a bit emotional tonight.

One of my granddads passed away from cancer in his mid 70s. He was fit and healthy, so the diagnosis shocked us all and it was a pretty awful couple of years watching him decline and pass away. However, he had many family and friends come to visit him, he stayed pretty mentally present until the end and his funeral was enormous - over a hundred people. He was well loved and well known in his local area. Most of his care was done by my grandma, his wife, and he died at home.

My other granddad passed away just after Christmas aged 95. He stayed in his house until he was 91 and way past being able to manage it, and his final years were spent between hospital and care facilities, worrying about my gran who has dementia and generally in pain. All bar one or two friends had long passed away, so few visitors, just his small family. He died in hospital fairly suddenly without any of us present 😢 his wife not there as it would’ve distressed her. His funeral was very small. He was such a proud man with such an interesting life and career, it makes me sad to think how few people were still alive to remember him at the end.

I don’t really know what I want from this thread, I guess it’s cathartic to write it down and cheaper than therapy! While illness and death is never pleasant, am I wrong to think that, in general, we’re actually making the end of our lives worse by living for too long?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blossomtoes · 19/10/2022 11:39

MigsandTiggs · 19/10/2022 10:37

@Blossomtoes

You can’t just trot off to Dignitas because you fancy dying. You have to be compos mentis and have a terminal illness, with six months or less to live.

I didn't know this. I have told my dc that I want to go to Dignitas if I get dementia, as soon as it gets worse. My DM is 96 with advanced dementia, bedridden and unable to recognise anyone for the past 5 years. She comes from a long lived family. Confused

I’m the same. The answer is an advance directive that you make now which states that in the event of a dementia diagnosis, no other condition is to be treated - UTI, chest infection, etc, no antibiotics just palliative care. DNAR so a heart attack takes its course, no cancer treatment. You also need a health power of attorney which names one or two people you trust to advocate for you so your wishes are carried out. My nearest and dearest are very, very clear about what I want.

MigsandTiggs · 19/10/2022 10:37

@Blossomtoes

You can’t just trot off to Dignitas because you fancy dying. You have to be compos mentis and have a terminal illness, with six months or less to live.

I didn't know this. I have told my dc that I want to go to Dignitas if I get dementia, as soon as it gets worse. My DM is 96 with advanced dementia, bedridden and unable to recognise anyone for the past 5 years. She comes from a long lived family. Confused

StarmanBobby · 18/10/2022 21:08

If I have all my marbles and am active like my DMiL was I’ll happily live til 95.
we don’t look after our old well enough in this county, we treat them as an inconvenience and stick them in homes, then complain that they aren’t cared for well enough.
in my culture we look after the old and the young.

KlopflopKop · 18/10/2022 13:08

It depends entirely on the person. My parents are the same age as my PIL. All in their early 70s.

PIL have been 'old' since I've known them (20 years). Retired. Old fashioned house with chintzy ornaments. Never did anything apart from sit and watch Gold all day everyday. MiL had a stroke 10 years ago and has pretty much declined since then. FIL is her carer.

My parents have been the exact opposite. DF still works. DM still out and about a lot. House is modern inside and out. Both spend a lot of time with the grand kids. In my mind, there is about 20 years between them.

My DGP died in their late 70s and early 80s. I can't get my head around the idea of my parents only having a decade or so left. But my PIL feel like a pair of old creaking gates that will outlive us all.

Caiti19 · 18/10/2022 12:58

I have always said I want to live into my 90s. But that's fear of missing out on grandchildren's lives talking. I might not have any grandchildren, and they might live a million miles away. I have never really thought about it before, but it must be dreadful to see all your closest friends/siblings etc go before you and be left alone.

BucketofTeaMassiveCake · 18/10/2022 12:50

You're right OP. Both my FIL and mother both died fairly suddenly in their mid-seventies after short illnesses. Both were a bit of a shock but at least neither of them lingered in pain for any length of time.

MIL and father survived until their mid-nineties. MIL had dementia and eventually had to go in a home as she could no longer look after herself. She became more aggressive and difficult to cope with and due to her condition, she never really settled there. I think she wanted to waste away quietly at home instead of being jollied into activities.

Father had a very rare cancer which spoiled his quality of life for the last couple of years. He lingered in hospital for a month before he passed away peacefully. Neither would have chosen that and if they'd had the mental capacity to truly realise their situations they'd have been appalled.

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/10/2022 12:47

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 12:35

Perhaps it's more the talking about these people like they are not - people. Without a thought that there are those much, much younger in similar situations - are they thought of in the same way?

What has anyone said to infer the elderly or disabled aren’t people?

OP posts:
Meili04 · 18/10/2022 12:44

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 12:35

Perhaps it's more the talking about these people like they are not - people. Without a thought that there are those much, much younger in similar situations - are they thought of in the same way?

The thing is people should have a choice when they die, instead we are left with the current system of slowly fading away against their will because some people might get upset. It's bodily autonomy.

I have worked in care homes for a number of years I know I do not want to slowly fade away, becoming doubly incontinent, getting contractures , get dysphagia and forced to eat disgusting pureed food until I waste away. That is my right I'm not saying people are worth less but I do not wish for my death to be like that. It is my body and my choice.

We don't discuss wishes or a good death until it's often too late in the UK.

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 12:35

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/10/2022 11:59

Nobody has said disabled or elderly people should be routinely euthanised. Why are people on here so dramatic?

Perhaps it's more the talking about these people like they are not - people. Without a thought that there are those much, much younger in similar situations - are they thought of in the same way?

warmeduppizza · 18/10/2022 12:10

I’m going to have no family left by the time I’m about 65, maybe sooner. I worry about it. I don’t want to rely on strangers. I often fantasise about taking myself off somewhere and just going missing - not that anyone will come looking.

BuryingAcorns · 18/10/2022 12:10

I have zero intention of living that long. One reason I'm not too careful about what I eat and drink is because I don't see the point of eking out an ascetic life for an extra couple of decades. Happy to go in my seventies, which really doesn't leave me many more years and it's focusing my mind. I know there are about 12 things I still want to do in my life, but after that I'm ready to shuffle off and give someone else a bit more space on the planet.

If DC had children I might want to hang around longer and help out but can;t guarantee that.

urbanbuddha · 18/10/2022 12:06

So I’ve chosen 85 (maybe 90 depending on how life and finances hold out) but hope I have the guts to stop all my life-sustaining medication and take my chances. And I have an Advance Decision in place already.

I'd forgotten about Advance Decisions. They should send out information about them when you qualify for your pension.

Advance Decisions

Compassion in dying

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/10/2022 11:59

Nobody has said disabled or elderly people should be routinely euthanised. Why are people on here so dramatic?

OP posts:
MeetPi · 18/10/2022 11:57

@Cuppasoupmonster

Oh is it really 🙄

Have you read some of the posts? Confused

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 11:55

@antelopevalley

I agree. But it is common thought that it is better to be dead than rely on carers. I have looked after people who thought that, they change their mind when they get to this stage and realise there can still be a lot of joy in life.

You're saying this to a disabled person. I don't wish to be dead, just so you know. And it's not better for me to be dead. I still have much to contribute to life and to those I love. (I'm very far from elderly.)

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/10/2022 11:35

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 11:28

I agree wholeheartedly with you. This is a deeply disturbing, ableist thread.

Oh is it really 🙄

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 18/10/2022 11:35

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 11:28

I agree wholeheartedly with you. This is a deeply disturbing, ableist thread.

I agree. But it is common thought that it is better to be dead than rely on carers. I have looked after people who thought that, they change their mind when they get to this stage and realise there can still be a lot of joy in life.

antelopevalley · 18/10/2022 11:34

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 11:15

Interestingly today I received an invitation this morning to get a pneumonia vaccination. If I didn’t know that it confers lifelong immunity and that pneumonia is often the old person’s friend, I might have had it. As it is I might be very grateful to get pneumonia one day so the answer is “No thanks”.

It probably won't stop you getting pneumonia when you are on your last legs. It will be likely to stop you getting it when you are elderly, living at home independently, but have a chest infection during a cold winter.

MeetPi · 18/10/2022 11:28

caroleanboneparte · 18/10/2022 08:21

I became disabled in my 20s.

At times my mobility/ life has been like the elderly people discussed here.

But no one suggests euthanasia for 20 somethings.

Yes it's not a full life being stuck in front of the tv all day, struggling to wash or dress yourself. But it's a hell of a lot better than being dead.

Don't speak for others if you haven't walked in their shoes.

I agree wholeheartedly with you. This is a deeply disturbing, ableist thread.

Blossomtoes · 18/10/2022 11:15

Interestingly today I received an invitation this morning to get a pneumonia vaccination. If I didn’t know that it confers lifelong immunity and that pneumonia is often the old person’s friend, I might have had it. As it is I might be very grateful to get pneumonia one day so the answer is “No thanks”.

BogRollBOGOF · 18/10/2022 11:04

It's quality of life that matters.

This year we lost a relative at 90 and she did brilliantly until 85. When I was last able to see her in 2019 (Covid travel and health care restrictions) her energy and interest was fading and there was something that tripped mentally at 86-87 that went into decline. That was then accelerated by the isolation of shielding.

She spent much of her last year in and out of hospital and ending up in a care home and her last weeks were spent going no further than the chair next to her bed on a good day. She's have happily have died at any point in the last year. There was nothing inspiring to look forwards to through the pain of a failing body. On being told that her sibling had died her response was that they were lucky. Her body gave up a month or so later.

Fortunately family all agreed that the priority was care to make her comfortable not to prolong life, and we've mainly felt a relief at the end of her suffering. It was a well attended funeral and lovely to look back on happier dats when she was able to be herself.

A shock premature death is an awful form of grief where there's so much lost potential. I'm currently reeling from a very recent one and it's my third family bereavement this year. The ideal is to live out your potential, experience the normal life stages including retirement, younger generations. Have some loved ones including peers to mourn you and not end up lonely. I suppose some winding down is necessary to feel that completion of potential, but too long in to that where your sense of self is lost in pain, hopelessness, immobility, exhaustion and lonliness is superflous suffering.

It's not purely about age. On losing a very disabled relative at an arithmaticly young age, it was the same as losing a relative of the same state of health of double the age because it was the same state of acknowledging the completion of life. Losing him 10 years earlier when he enjoyed life would have been tragic, even 5 years earlier before he was so deeply lost in himself.

My naive grand plan is to live well, maximise my potential to live actively well into my mid 80s and when life gets too tediously sedate, have a short illness to accept the next stage. Past 80 I'm eating all the cake I can and pickling my liver!
My family has good genes for long life and an unfortunate tendency for arthritis. My knees and hips will probably be several decades younger than the rest of me 😂

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 18/10/2022 10:00

I know of one or two who’ve made it to well over 90 with both their marbles and their mobility intact, but most people lose one or the other. If you don’t, I’m increasingly convinced that a lot of it is down to genes. Who doesn’t know someone who always did the right, healthy things, and died early anyway? And vice versa?

IMO too many people are kept alive just because it’s possible to do so, when their quality of life is very poor and it’d probably be kinder to let them go. But from all I’ve ever heard, it’s often family who insist on everything possible being done, and get very indignant/angry if medics suggest that it might be kinder to give palliative care and let Nature take its course.

My DF died of cancer in his early 70s - my DM went on to 97 - having had dementia for at least 15 years - she was in a most pitiful state for her last 5 or 6. She wasn’t ‘kept alive’ - we would not have wanted it and would have fought any suggestion of it - it was simply down to having the general constitution of a rhinoceros - she came from a generally long-lived family.

If I had to choose between an earlier death from illness and the fate my poor mother suffered, I know which I’d choose. Who wants to go on until your family cannot really grieve that you’re gone, because you have become a most pitiful shell of what you were, and they ‘lost’ you long ago? I know it’s a horrible cliche but my mother’s death really was a merciful release.

IMO, if we don’t want any ‘striving to keep alive’ in certain circumstances, then it’s up to all of us to make our wishes crystal clear in a Power of Attorney - there is space for you to add them. Dh and I have done this, and dds are in no doubt as to our wishes.

Sittingonabench · 18/10/2022 09:46

I think about this sometimes. You never know what’s going to happen or how your health may turn. But if I am still fit and healthy into old age I would like to be able to end my life in a legal, pain free way before I lose my independence.

Ethelswith · 18/10/2022 09:34

You can't put an age to when life gets to be too much for you. If you were still, as my DMum is, living independently at home in her 90s, you wouldn't be rushing to end your life.

You will however have outlived many friends and your generation of the family. But that doesn't have to leave an unfillable void (unless surrounded by narrowminded youngsters who can't make friends across generations).

So yes YABU to put an age on it, or to assume that it will become unbearable.

But everyone wants life to be kind to them and death to come without fear or pain.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/10/2022 09:28

sparkle17 · 17/10/2022 23:27

I don't want to live that long. I think post 80 years old I won't get vaccines for flu/covid and other basic medications and see where life takes me.

I strongly suspect that if at 80 you are well & active you won't feel like that.

It is all to do with health & social connection. I'm in my 40s and work hard at my fitness, I really hope I enjoy good health in my later decades to keep doing so. I know many retired colleagues who are doing amazing things, so active & well.

But so much of that is chance; I do my best to maximise the parts within my control & hope for the best.

It's ridiculous to decide a particular age denotes a certain fragility or inability to do something. I know quite a number of nonagenarians who are active, mentally agile & having a great life. We should aspire to that but also recognise that elements are beyond our control, as indeed they are for all of us, at any age.