Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I invite her over to meet her new niece ? Or be done with her?

131 replies

BlueBunny23 · 17/10/2022 18:50

So to cut a long story short… me and my partner have two children. A son and a brand new baby girl, when I got pregnant with my son, my partners brother and his fiancée found out and the brother was real happy for us, the fiancee on the other hand wasn’t and blocked us on social media and blanked us when we bumped into her, the brother apologised and claimed he didn’t know what was up with her. When son was born we invited them over and fiancée stayed in the car glaring at her partner holding his brand new nephew who I believe was 3 days old at the time give or take. We didn’t speak for 2 years after this when she bumped into us and told me about her fertility issues and her many miscarriages. She explained seeing me pregnant was so difficult for her, I forgave her and we became friends again, she told me she’s always wanted a daughter and if I’d of had a daughter she couldn’t have coped.
I found out earlier this year I was pregnant and we later found out it was a girl, when we announced the news I was again blocked on social media until last week when she readied me when my baby was 1 week old she’s now 2 weeks old. She hasn’t liked any of my baby pictures, she hasn’t messaged to ask if I’m ok or if baby is ok.
so my partner wants his brother to come see the baby and his brother wants too….. so he’s going to come alone and Not tell fiancee.
im annoyed she hasn’t messaged me or liked a baby photo of her new niece….. so I feel perhaps if I invited her over then she wouldn’t want too, my partner thinks I should block her and not bother with her at all and that we should just enjoy our baby and our children regardless weather she’s family or not. I feel if I invited her over to meet the baby it would almost be like rubbing her nose in it, would this be the case? Should I invite her over and try to make a things work? Or just leave her to come around or just simply block her and move on with my life?

OP posts:
PMAmostofthetime · 18/10/2022 08:46

BlueBunny23 · 17/10/2022 18:50

So to cut a long story short… me and my partner have two children. A son and a brand new baby girl, when I got pregnant with my son, my partners brother and his fiancée found out and the brother was real happy for us, the fiancee on the other hand wasn’t and blocked us on social media and blanked us when we bumped into her, the brother apologised and claimed he didn’t know what was up with her. When son was born we invited them over and fiancée stayed in the car glaring at her partner holding his brand new nephew who I believe was 3 days old at the time give or take. We didn’t speak for 2 years after this when she bumped into us and told me about her fertility issues and her many miscarriages. She explained seeing me pregnant was so difficult for her, I forgave her and we became friends again, she told me she’s always wanted a daughter and if I’d of had a daughter she couldn’t have coped.
I found out earlier this year I was pregnant and we later found out it was a girl, when we announced the news I was again blocked on social media until last week when she readied me when my baby was 1 week old she’s now 2 weeks old. She hasn’t liked any of my baby pictures, she hasn’t messaged to ask if I’m ok or if baby is ok.
so my partner wants his brother to come see the baby and his brother wants too….. so he’s going to come alone and Not tell fiancee.
im annoyed she hasn’t messaged me or liked a baby photo of her new niece….. so I feel perhaps if I invited her over then she wouldn’t want too, my partner thinks I should block her and not bother with her at all and that we should just enjoy our baby and our children regardless weather she’s family or not. I feel if I invited her over to meet the baby it would almost be like rubbing her nose in it, would this be the case? Should I invite her over and try to make a things work? Or just leave her to come around or just simply block her and move on with my life?

I experienced fertility issues for years no one knew- but I wasn't like this.

Days after a failed cycle of IVF my brother and his wife told me I was going to be an Aunty- I was extremely happy for them.

Was I upset- yes do they know- no

I cried in the shower that night for the egg that didn't make it and could have grown up alongside their cousin.
Do they know about this no. Why because everybody's journey is different and they don't know about my struggles and I don't know how long it took them to get there.

I see it as a blessing that I get to have another child in my life and am hopeful that I can continue to be a hands on Aunty when they need me.

Enjoy your little one. Wait a few weeks and message and say I know this must be difficult for you, but when/if your ready, your niece would like to meet you.

Darkstar4855 · 18/10/2022 08:44

I think you can’t possibly understand how hard infertility is when you have been lucky enough not to experience it.

We couldn’t have a second and it has been incredibly painful for me watching friends and family adding to their families and being constantly bombarded with happy family photos on social media. I’ve temporarily muted a lot of people for the sake of my own sanity.

I think you should be grateful for what you have and accept that her pain and grief is immense right now. Maybe she could have been a bit more polite about it but she’s clearly suffering and if your biggest issue is “likes” on social media then I think you can afford to be the bigger person here.

I hope that you made sure she was informed privately and given a bit of time to process before you made your big announcement too.

billy1966 · 18/10/2022 08:40

She may not be behaving well but you should just leave her alone.

Infertility is a terrible grief stricken path.

Be happy with what you have been blessed with and try and find the maturity to move beyond SM likes and wanting upset and drama at a time like this🙄.

You are not obligated to feed drama and upset in your life.

Peridot1 · 18/10/2022 08:35

You sound quite childish with your blocking and unblocking and wanting likes on photos.

she has TOLD you why it’s hard for her. You have no idea how it feels to want a baby so desperately and not be able to have one.

Congratulations on your two babies. Maybe try and think about how you’d feel if the situation were reversed?

Shortname · 18/10/2022 08:35

You have what she desperately wants but may never ever have, have a little compassion, she's having to plan a completely different life to the one she wanted (I appreciate she's been unreasonable but i don't think you've thought about how hard this is for her at all)

Herejustforthisone · 18/10/2022 08:33

She explained seeing me pregnant was so difficult for her, I forgave her and we became friends again, she told me she’s always wanted a daughter and if I’d of had a daughter she couldn’t have coped.

Cone on. She told you she’d really struggled with her fertility, was so keen for a child and was desperately unhappy. Not only that, she told you she was desperate for a daughter.

You still didn’t warn her separately via text so she could process your news, something a friend would have done. You just did a Facebook post for her to find. Now you’re moaning she’s not asking after you and T your new baby girl?

You're either immensely dense or immensely unkind. I’m not sure.

jtaeapa · 18/10/2022 08:31

It would be like having a starving person over to your lovely banquet and telling them they can look at the food, maybe even touch it, but they can't eat it and still have to starve.

jtaeapa · 18/10/2022 08:30

You don't need to block her. Just leave her alone and let the brother come over quietly without any photos/social media involvement!

Can you see how her devastation at the infertility/MCs is pretty hefty compared to your hurt feelings that she isn't interested in her niece? Thank your lucky stars that your positions aren't reversed.

OCDmama · 18/10/2022 08:23

The not liking pictures thing is pretty childish, drop it if you're not 14.

Don't block her, just let her do what she wants. She's hurting massively.

Waveacrossabay · 18/10/2022 07:51

On a previous thread and you've made many about this and only posted one comment on all of them; you said she has been trying for a baby for 15 years... that's a long time. Enjoy your baby but don't expect her to change

MrsGhastlyCrumb · 18/10/2022 07:41

Hang on... she told you about her fertility issues and that she desperately wanted a girl. You forgave her. Then you find out you're having a girl, and 'announce it'. Apologies if I have missed a bit, but did anyone think to have a quiet worth with her fiancé first so he could gently prepare her? Because clearly this is incredibly difficult and raw for her- so I can see that, given your previous discussion, this must have felt very insensitive to her.

Congratulations, by the way.

Readmorebooks · 18/10/2022 07:22

I have now read the thread. I think it's first that some people don't have the empathy to understand why this is hard and I was obviously incredibly lucky in my friends and family. Honestly, anyone who takes this personally (the fact that she "doesn't want to meet her niece/nephew/whoever") is being a bit of a dick. As someone said upthread, the grief over infertility doesn't get easier with time but grows every time someone else has a baby and every time the woman gets a year older etc - please give her some time to get her head around this and I'm sure she will appreciate it.

Readmorebooks · 18/10/2022 07:13

I've not rtft but I was once your sil. I reacted differently in that I forced myself to visit and see all the new babies born whilst I was struggling but it was the hardest thing. My friends and family were truly amazing. No one expected me to gush or like photos - they let me do things at my pace. No one expected me to cuddle their babies or say/do anything - I remember I gave the crappest gifts as I couldn't face baby clothes shops (and this was before online shopping was as easy as it is now).

The kindest thing you could do would be to send a message saying "I love you. I know how hard this must be for you. You're welcome here any time" and let her go at her own speed. It sounds as though she wants a relationship with you all so try and be generous to her now when she can't be to you.

drpet49 · 17/10/2022 22:30

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 21:04

Mmm infertility is obviously terrible but I never understand why people have to accept rude and shitty behaviour because of it. Honestly, how hard would it have been to send a text saying “congratulations on your new baby and I hope you both are doing well. As you know I’ve been struggling for some time with my fertility and its going to be difficult for me to look at photos or come to visit at the moment so I’m deleting social media for a while and will probably keep my distance. I hope you understand and I hope in time I will feel differently.” I don’t think you need to block her OP but I also think she is being a bit of an arsehole.

This

Mamai90 · 17/10/2022 22:27

Unless you've been through infertility you can't even comprehend how painful it is. It's a grief that doesn't get better, it only gets worse. It's not something you expect to happen and it's lonely as other people can't understand and make stupid comparisons.

I suffered infertility through most of my 30s. Admittedly I coped quite well as I'm not the most maternal person and I had my two nephews who my life revolved around, it probably would have been different for me had I not had them. They are my sisters children and born before we started TTC. But some of the woman I spoke to during that time, they were absolutely broken.

My best friend also had infertility and by chance we ended up doing IVF at the same time she had a child and I had a miscarriage. I still met up with her but I have to admit that every meet up for the first few years filled me with dread, i was ok when we were together but then I'd dread seeing her again. It was really really hard. Then she got pregnant accidently a few years later, I had nightmares the night before her 12 week scan. Don't get me wrong I only wished for happiness for her but it highlighted my pain all over again. It was unbearable. But by some miracle I found myself pregnant a few months later and now we have children of a similar age. So I was one of the lucky ones and I'm grateful every day.

Cut your SIL some slack. Don't block her, just enjoy your children and move on with your life. She must be in hell. Let her come to you and be open when she does. Be the bigger person.

KimberleyClark · 17/10/2022 22:16

I found it hard meeting new babies when I was struggling with long term infertility. The pain was like my chest was being crushed. And yet that makes me a horrible person according to some on this thread. There is such a lack of compassion and understanding.

HighlandPony · 17/10/2022 22:07

It is pretty hard watching your other half hood someone’s baby knowing he should be holding yours/his own but you lost your baby. Can’t imagine how it would be if it happened multiple times. Give her space to work it out herself. It’s not you she’s mad at, it’s not the kids either. She’s upset with the hand she’s been dealt. Your brother in law seemingly not knowing how much she’s struggling with it is a bit hmm though.

sandytooth · 17/10/2022 22:06

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 21:59

Well the OP is not some randomer that’s had a baby. She’s part of her fiancé’s family. I think it’s very basic courtesy to send one text message in this situation.

I don't think it is necessary for her to have to explain yet again that she is uncomfortable around babies right now. OP should know this by now.

nozbottheblue · 17/10/2022 22:05

Ponoka7 · 17/10/2022 18:56

I don't see why you need to block her. Just move on. If she genuinely can't cope with being around pregnancy and newborns, then she's doing the right thing by staying away.

This. Totally.
Your b-I-l can of course visit and make the decision whether to tell her he’s visiting or not (would be a very strange relationship if he’s not able to tell her, in my opinion).
Just enjoy your baby ☺️

Babygirlnameq · 17/10/2022 22:04

No need to do anything. Leave it to your DH to sort out with his brother about seeing the new baby.

I would leave her alone, she doesn’t want to be part of it.

Cw112 · 17/10/2022 22:02

She's clearly really struggling with her own ongoing grief and loss and is struggling to be faced with all the things she has lost in the midst of your happiness. I think in an ideal world she would be able to set all that loss and pain and grief aside and stick on a happy face for your benefit but realistically I think we all know that's a lot easier said than done. I think you need to show her some compassion and grace because she's not just had a miscarriage and moved on from it, she's still smack bang in the middle of a really painful journey of disappointment and loss and she's obviously trying her best to protect herself by blocking you so she doesn't need to see pictures when she can't face them etc. I think you invite them both and continue just as you normally would and hopefully at some stage she'll either have a successful pregnancy and you can reconnect or she'll hopefully process her pain and accept that they might need a different way to form a family. You can't expect her to be a robot and just pretend like it's all fine when seeing you happy in your baby bubble when it's all she wants in the world and it's not working out for them.

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 21:59

sandytooth · 17/10/2022 21:43

Why should she need to write an essay out everytime someone has a baby.

Well the OP is not some randomer that’s had a baby. She’s part of her fiancé’s family. I think it’s very basic courtesy to send one text message in this situation.

sandytooth · 17/10/2022 21:43

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 21:04

Mmm infertility is obviously terrible but I never understand why people have to accept rude and shitty behaviour because of it. Honestly, how hard would it have been to send a text saying “congratulations on your new baby and I hope you both are doing well. As you know I’ve been struggling for some time with my fertility and its going to be difficult for me to look at photos or come to visit at the moment so I’m deleting social media for a while and will probably keep my distance. I hope you understand and I hope in time I will feel differently.” I don’t think you need to block her OP but I also think she is being a bit of an arsehole.

Why should she need to write an essay out everytime someone has a baby.

Dumbledormer · 17/10/2022 21:04

Mmm infertility is obviously terrible but I never understand why people have to accept rude and shitty behaviour because of it. Honestly, how hard would it have been to send a text saying “congratulations on your new baby and I hope you both are doing well. As you know I’ve been struggling for some time with my fertility and its going to be difficult for me to look at photos or come to visit at the moment so I’m deleting social media for a while and will probably keep my distance. I hope you understand and I hope in time I will feel differently.” I don’t think you need to block her OP but I also think she is being a bit of an arsehole.

Ottersmith · 17/10/2022 21:01

Don't let her make you feel bad. There's lots of reason s why women can't have babies and I've never understood why that should mean they resent anyone who has had a baby and not be happy for them. It's for her to work out with a therapist. I wanted kids for ten years but couldn't because of relationship circumstance but I could still enjoy other people's children. She is missing out but it's her choice.