Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teenager - I need some help please.

34 replies

NotSureICanParentAnymore · 17/10/2022 18:21

I'm struggling to get on with my eldest child to the point that I don't really like her and what she stands for any more. She's 17.

It's very difficult because she's a good lass. She's got good results and generally behaves herself. She is polite and amiable to others.

The problem comes with me and her siblings. At home she is sullen, negative, critical and argumentative. She constantly puts me and them down. Her tone is negative and critical and she's constantly causing arguments, though she can NEVER see her role in any of it and always feels picked on and slighted.

She is so entitled. She's recently got into labels and is buying lots of second hand designer stuff online. Fine. But then she expects us to pay for expensive trips abroad with school. Expects it like it's her right to go, and our duty to pay. She has a job and likes to treat herself but there's never any thought about others/helping around the house (unless it's her day to do a job and even then she needs asking multiple times). Driving lessons- on her birthday- no thanks for the investment or organising it, no acknowledgement of the support or gift- just criticism about what I do wrong. Nevermind none of her peers have had a lesson yet as their parents didn't organise it.

Her view is that money is the biggest driver. She asks why I have 'wasted myself on low paid (highly qualified) public service jobs??'

Yuk, yuk, yuk I hate all of this. I can't imagine her friends are impressed by it, either. They don't seem the type.

I'm struggling to put in boundaries. I've no idea where to start to unpick this -monster- mess.

We had very high expectations when they were all small and drummed into them the value of kindness, honesty and compassion. I feel like someone has stolen my child and replaced her with a stranger. One that, if it were a peer, I would avoid as we'd have so little in common and who in fact I would find difficult to tolerate.

I just don't know where to start. The constant negativity and walking on eggshells is so exhausting. I'm thinking it'd be easier to live separately from her.

Am I asking too much for a little gratitude or kindness? A little respect or giving back. Maybe I am. Maybe it is just what's expected

Please help. I can't see the wood for the trees.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NotSureICanParentAnymore · 18/10/2022 15:55

Thank you everyone for your time and advice. Lots of food for thought. It seems it's very much a case of 'pick your battles' which I'm not very good at. I hate the rudeness and see it as a reflection on us. It's not.

I am very guilty of 'losing it' every few months when I just can't take it any more. I do worry about the effects of my nasty (lost control) words. Plus it never (or if it does, it's only for a few days) makes a difference. But then again, I'm also worried though about the impact of the constant negativity and putdowns from her towards her siblings.

You're also right in that I'm very proud and thankful of the adult she is becoming and the way she conducts herself outside of our family. It's a classic... she does it to those of us who love her most.

I will read all your advice again and try and remember it when I need it most.

Much appreciated.

OP posts:
NotSureICanParentAnymore · 18/10/2022 15:06

GilbertlovesAnne · 18/10/2022 07:23

I remember being a teenage girl vividly. Hormones completely changed my personality between ages 15-17. They made me anxious and defensive and pretty depressed in all honesty.

I was one of four and my parents sort of ignored me as the difficult one because I was highly strung, emotional, argumentative and negative.

no one really tried to get through to me and I made some bad choices further isolating myself.

I guess the point I’m trying to make is, I knew I wasn’t feeling myself but I was so ravaged by hormones that I couldn’t help it and it sort of became a self fulfilling cycle.

Id encourage you to keep your expectations and boundaries but also to really seek opportunities for connection with your daughter. Perhaps go vintage label shopping together? Or something else that might interest her.

I came full circle by the time I was 18 (I didn’t move out to uni stayed at home to save money) and lived at home til I was 25.

My parents still talk now 20 years later about how awful I was, and I try my best to explain to them that through my adult lens now I would describe my feelings at that time as anxiety and depression that manifested as teenage angst.

It's such a fine balance isn't it? A parental tightrope! I'm glad you still have a good relationship now. Thank you for taking the time to reply.

OP posts:
NotSureICanParentAnymore · 18/10/2022 15:04

PorridgewithQuark · 18/10/2022 06:32

I've been thinking about this NotSureICanParentAnymore and think there's actually a lot to keep separate/ unpick in your opening post; as you say yourself you can't see the wood for the trees.

It's developmentally appropriate that she wants to be a clearly separate and distinct, different adult from you. You don't like the person she is becoming/ seems to be because she's materialistic (but polite, hard working and respectful outside the home). Aside from her behaviour at home it's important to remember that other parents would be delighted with her pragmatic approach and the signs of hardworking, career oriented "successful" independent woman.

That's not my idea of "success" either but I do think it's so important we accept that our teens are allowed to have different world views and different values and big opinions (as long as these are legal and not damaging in an immediate rather than theoretical/ philosophical context or to our egos!).

Although I have a 17 year old myself I am reminded of my own mother (and in the background father, though he was less vocal and demonstratively emotional so I was somewhat oblivious to his role at the time) who used to cry and try to emotionally blackmail me into church (and all the associated social and cultural events which go with being heavily involved in a religious group) attendance and belief in her religious ideas . She's never really forgiven me for not returning to her church, contrite after a brief rebellion, which is what she often informed me I would do. She never accepted or respected that I had actually given the matter thought and come to my own conclusions about religion and the religious community. In the same way she never accepted that I had different political opinions and different priorities and a very different career nor later that I brought my children up quite differently, by conscious choice not by accident, to the way I was brought up.

I know that you're not trying to manipulate your daughter into church involvement and religious beliefs with tears btw! I'm just saying it's really important that you accept and express pride in your daughter for who she is (including her priorities which are different from yours, as long as they're not illegal or evil, which being materialistic and driven by a wish to be a high earner isn't, however distasteful it might be).

Not liking her because she isn't like you (even though I'm sure you try not to let it show) will show and be part of the reason she's rejecting yu more nastily than her father. I think a mental reset is important as a parent to actually try to feel proud of the young woman she is and the excellent grounding and stable base you've given her to allow her to develop into her own person and be anything she wants to be.

Separate from that is the rudeness/ nasty comments to you and her siblings. Absolutely don't tolerate that obviously. A sharp word every time should be enough, but if not have a conversation with her father next to you and pre-briefed solely about this. Respectful behaviour towards members of the household. Present a united front and remind her of behavioural expectations but don't muddy the waters talking about values or gratitude - stick to the concrete, measurable behaviour. If she's not receptive get transactional and remind her of the extras that you provide (phone contract, optional "fun" not subject related school trips, extra money for driving lessons but not the birthday present ones; you can't take a birthday present back and be considered fair - or whatever and point out that they're conditional based on mutually respect, and if her behaviour at home is rude they'll be withdrawn). An intelligent but materialistic teen should respond to that!

I think it's really important to respond only to concrete behaviour not different values, is what I'm saying! It's effectively "pick your battles" as with toddlers! Also as others say don't ever apportion blame in sibling disputes (unless every moment of the dispute and background happened in front of you! Sometimes better not even then!). It's really important to remain impartial and not give the impression you're siding with ine child.

If she believes that you don't like her she'll never listen to you or behave pleasantly towards you out of unconscious emotional self defense.

Such a great bunch of insight and advice. Thank you so much for taking the time to think about this and write such a clear response. I've cried a little bit reading it (in a good way) as you've unpicked so much confusion (differentiating between behaviour and values, for example). It's all stuff I know but when it's happening to your family, in such an emotionally charged way, it's impossible to see objectively. Thank you.

OP posts:
GilbertlovesAnne · 18/10/2022 07:23

I remember being a teenage girl vividly. Hormones completely changed my personality between ages 15-17. They made me anxious and defensive and pretty depressed in all honesty.

I was one of four and my parents sort of ignored me as the difficult one because I was highly strung, emotional, argumentative and negative.

no one really tried to get through to me and I made some bad choices further isolating myself.

I guess the point I’m trying to make is, I knew I wasn’t feeling myself but I was so ravaged by hormones that I couldn’t help it and it sort of became a self fulfilling cycle.

Id encourage you to keep your expectations and boundaries but also to really seek opportunities for connection with your daughter. Perhaps go vintage label shopping together? Or something else that might interest her.

I came full circle by the time I was 18 (I didn’t move out to uni stayed at home to save money) and lived at home til I was 25.

My parents still talk now 20 years later about how awful I was, and I try my best to explain to them that through my adult lens now I would describe my feelings at that time as anxiety and depression that manifested as teenage angst.

PorridgewithQuark · 18/10/2022 06:32

I've been thinking about this NotSureICanParentAnymore and think there's actually a lot to keep separate/ unpick in your opening post; as you say yourself you can't see the wood for the trees.

It's developmentally appropriate that she wants to be a clearly separate and distinct, different adult from you. You don't like the person she is becoming/ seems to be because she's materialistic (but polite, hard working and respectful outside the home). Aside from her behaviour at home it's important to remember that other parents would be delighted with her pragmatic approach and the signs of hardworking, career oriented "successful" independent woman.

That's not my idea of "success" either but I do think it's so important we accept that our teens are allowed to have different world views and different values and big opinions (as long as these are legal and not damaging in an immediate rather than theoretical/ philosophical context or to our egos!).

Although I have a 17 year old myself I am reminded of my own mother (and in the background father, though he was less vocal and demonstratively emotional so I was somewhat oblivious to his role at the time) who used to cry and try to emotionally blackmail me into church (and all the associated social and cultural events which go with being heavily involved in a religious group) attendance and belief in her religious ideas . She's never really forgiven me for not returning to her church, contrite after a brief rebellion, which is what she often informed me I would do. She never accepted or respected that I had actually given the matter thought and come to my own conclusions about religion and the religious community. In the same way she never accepted that I had different political opinions and different priorities and a very different career nor later that I brought my children up quite differently, by conscious choice not by accident, to the way I was brought up.

I know that you're not trying to manipulate your daughter into church involvement and religious beliefs with tears btw! I'm just saying it's really important that you accept and express pride in your daughter for who she is (including her priorities which are different from yours, as long as they're not illegal or evil, which being materialistic and driven by a wish to be a high earner isn't, however distasteful it might be).

Not liking her because she isn't like you (even though I'm sure you try not to let it show) will show and be part of the reason she's rejecting yu more nastily than her father. I think a mental reset is important as a parent to actually try to feel proud of the young woman she is and the excellent grounding and stable base you've given her to allow her to develop into her own person and be anything she wants to be.

Separate from that is the rudeness/ nasty comments to you and her siblings. Absolutely don't tolerate that obviously. A sharp word every time should be enough, but if not have a conversation with her father next to you and pre-briefed solely about this. Respectful behaviour towards members of the household. Present a united front and remind her of behavioural expectations but don't muddy the waters talking about values or gratitude - stick to the concrete, measurable behaviour. If she's not receptive get transactional and remind her of the extras that you provide (phone contract, optional "fun" not subject related school trips, extra money for driving lessons but not the birthday present ones; you can't take a birthday present back and be considered fair - or whatever and point out that they're conditional based on mutually respect, and if her behaviour at home is rude they'll be withdrawn). An intelligent but materialistic teen should respond to that!

I think it's really important to respond only to concrete behaviour not different values, is what I'm saying! It's effectively "pick your battles" as with toddlers! Also as others say don't ever apportion blame in sibling disputes (unless every moment of the dispute and background happened in front of you! Sometimes better not even then!). It's really important to remain impartial and not give the impression you're siding with ine child.

If she believes that you don't like her she'll never listen to you or behave pleasantly towards you out of unconscious emotional self defense.

DoodlePug · 17/10/2022 22:15

This is possibly a ridiculous suggestion and a completely different situation but....

My DS is asd and can be extremely oppositional to the point of seeming nasty.

One day he was being mega oppositional, arguing for hours about something ridiculous and obviously just trying to be difficult and I was trying to be reasonable and logical and it all got too much for me and I burst into tears and couldn't stop, literally howling. Not my finest moment.

He was so shocked, I don't think he had ever thought I had feelings or it affected me. Probably an asd thing but he really scaled it back after that.

So I'm possibly suggesting you burst into tears. Or at least that you find a way to be sure she really understands how much her behaviour is hurting you and the family. It sounds like you brought her up well and you're sure there's a caring person in there so if you can just get past the self centered-ness.

Or, family counselling? If she has reasonable respect for other adults that could work.

Hellopello · 17/10/2022 21:57

I have learnt to mostly discuss issues only when serious, otherwise let it be. Another parent of teens once told me that the best advice they could help with the teen issues was to “ let things go over your head” as much as possible. It’s hard to watch your teens make glaring mistakes and/or take on different roles and ways of getting through life than you can relate to, yet this is what they need to do at this point in their lives.

Although you’ve had enough of DD’s selfishness and rudeness , ( totally been there, it’s absolutely shit) , the fact that you have reasonable boundaries and are doing whatever you can to provide a loving, stable and secure home means the world to your Dd. ( although she won’t be telling you this ;) ) Teens that don’t have a stable home and someone batting for them, or have a breakdown in their home situation will often continue to seriously struggle with life through adulthood . Also, don’t underestimate how important the wonderfully supportive and positive foundation years are that you have laid before.
I’m guessing that if your DD previously had a great connection with family , she will likely return to this, somewhere between 18-25, but either way, some wonderful kind advice here to get you through the bumpy years.

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 17/10/2022 21:29

I disagree with those that say this is normal teenage behaviour- not in my experience or those of my peers.

One thing i did pick up on was you saying that you had very high expectations of your DC in terms of values.... this can often be difficult for children to cope with , especially during adolescent years when hormones and emotions are all over the place .

Eupraxia · 17/10/2022 21:13

How do you instill/enforce boundaries when the other person does not recognise their part in the situation/conflict?

I've currently got 3 teens. I try to not take sides or aportion blame as much as possible. So my role in sibling conflict is to de-esculate. I aim to calm everyone down, which means actively not allowing any blame, just solving the problem.

Dacadactyl · 17/10/2022 20:09

I wpuld give her consequences. If she acts disrespectfully stop doing x, y or z for her.

I wouldmt pay for driving lessons if she was disrespecting me, i can tell you now.

Make her pay for her own phone.

NotSureICanParentAnymore · 17/10/2022 20:04

Eupraxia · 17/10/2022 19:52

We had very high expectations when they were all small and drummed into them the value of kindness, honesty and compassion

With respect, teaching morals isn't a stand-alone task you do once. It's ongoing and changes as they grow.

its easy to teach these morals to little children. It's much harder to continue yo teach them to older children and teens. You read as though you've given up trying because its hard snd challenging for you to do.

You sound like lack personal boundaries. Why are you tolerating her bring repeatedly rude and unkind to you and her siblings?

If she was rude and unkind as a 4 year old, you'd have pulled her up on it and not tolerated it, especially if repeated. This is part of the high expectations of values you mention when she was small. You have to change the way you respond to a 17yo compared to a 4yo, but you can be just as insistent on high moral expectations.

Ok perhaps it should have read, 'Since they were small...'. Of course we still have high expectations. The problem is when the other person doesn't respect/recognise their part in the conflict. How do you instill/enforce boundaries when the other person does not recognise their part in the situation/conflict? That's why I'm asking for help here.

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 17/10/2022 20:01

Your Dh needs to step up in this. Yes it’s great that he gets on with her, and shares hobbies, but he must present a united front with you. He must not tolerate texts or reports from her slagging you off. Parenting is team work.

Eupraxia · 17/10/2022 19:52

We had very high expectations when they were all small and drummed into them the value of kindness, honesty and compassion

With respect, teaching morals isn't a stand-alone task you do once. It's ongoing and changes as they grow.

its easy to teach these morals to little children. It's much harder to continue yo teach them to older children and teens. You read as though you've given up trying because its hard snd challenging for you to do.

You sound like lack personal boundaries. Why are you tolerating her bring repeatedly rude and unkind to you and her siblings?

If she was rude and unkind as a 4 year old, you'd have pulled her up on it and not tolerated it, especially if repeated. This is part of the high expectations of values you mention when she was small. You have to change the way you respond to a 17yo compared to a 4yo, but you can be just as insistent on high moral expectations.

PorridgewithQuark · 17/10/2022 19:28

She's rebelling against you - it's pretty much compulsory to reject your parents' values in your teens. It's also standard to be fairly self obsessed because navigating the transition to adulthood is a fairly full on rollercoaster, the hormones are wild and there's huge pressure from multiple sources - academic, social, romantic, family, pressure to decide who you are and where you're going (life wise) and who with. It's an intense pressure cooker time between 15/16 and 18/19 especially.

Expecting gratitude is an absolute hiding to nothing on multiple levels (not least that if it's understood that gratitude is expected/ seen as owed it isn't really gratitude, and the gift or whatever you did for the recipient clearly had strings, so being grateful is complex and sullied by that).

I have a lovely 17 year old daughter too but yes - she expects... She doesn't always get, but she expects. She has to be reminded of reality/ our expectations sometimes (I expect manners not "kindness" as I think the "be kind" movement is really dangerous in terms of telling children and women to ignore their own needs, fears and instincts) and it only takes a word or just a look to prevent rudeness. She actually is kind but not a pushover, and I'm very glad.

WarblingEttie · 17/10/2022 19:27

Teenagers are vile

Most aren't. It's fine to show solidarity with OP but don't tarnish all teens.

Tfif133 · 17/10/2022 19:27

I could have written this myself, except my DD treats DH (her father) with as much contempt as she does me - she just plays us off though only ever being pleasant to one of us at a time. She does great in school and gets highly rewarded for her efforts, she point blank refuses to get a job though - the sense of entitlement is unreal. I totally understand the walking on eggshells and the sheer exhaustion of it! I’ve got no advice but so good to read I’m not the only one struggling with it!

MacroTwigg · 17/10/2022 19:14

They do come out the other side. In fact you describe a very similar person to me as a 16/17 year old. I'm lucky I have a wonderful relationship with my mum, from in my early 20's and now in my 30's she's my best friend. I also realised to true value of money very quickly after leaving home! There's hope OP!

MojoMoon · 17/10/2022 19:14

Perhaps at some level she is sniping at you because you represent a woman doing lots of undervalued labour at home and at work? And at some level she fears this as her path?

Designer clothes, focus on money etc as a way to rebel against you and your values?

Could your DH talk to her about how her behaviour is impacting on the family? Would she listen?

NotSureICanParentAnymore · 17/10/2022 19:13

clopper · 17/10/2022 19:04

My DD was just like this at 17. I loved her but found it hard to like her at that point. She went to uni at 18 and it was like a weight lifted off the house. She lived in halls even though it was a local uni. Anyway she became much nicer at around 24ish and now we get on great as she has two children of her own. I felt very much as you do when she was 17, where has my lovely kind girl gone? I’m adding to this thread to give you hope… but it might be a few years yet. She is just pushing boundaries and asserting her independence.

24...!!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭

OP posts:
NotSureICanParentAnymore · 17/10/2022 19:08

MojoMoon · 17/10/2022 19:01

Why do you thinks she gets on better with your husband?

Is he allowed to be the fun parent and you are the one who has to do all the nagging and organising and sorting things out? Does he leave all emotional stuff to you?

What is her relationship like with her siblings? Are they closer to each other than her?

They have a shared interest and do stuff together. I've always taken on the traditional female role and been the parent who is 'always there'. Always. DH has his hobby that she shares an interest in. Yes, being the parent that's 'always there' means the rough with the smooth.

Yes, the other siblings are closer to each other than her. She tries to parent them and put them in their place (put them down).

OP posts:
clopper · 17/10/2022 19:04

My DD was just like this at 17. I loved her but found it hard to like her at that point. She went to uni at 18 and it was like a weight lifted off the house. She lived in halls even though it was a local uni. Anyway she became much nicer at around 24ish and now we get on great as she has two children of her own. I felt very much as you do when she was 17, where has my lovely kind girl gone? I’m adding to this thread to give you hope… but it might be a few years yet. She is just pushing boundaries and asserting her independence.

MojoMoon · 17/10/2022 19:01

Why do you thinks she gets on better with your husband?

Is he allowed to be the fun parent and you are the one who has to do all the nagging and organising and sorting things out? Does he leave all emotional stuff to you?

What is her relationship like with her siblings? Are they closer to each other than her?

NotSureICanParentAnymore · 17/10/2022 18:56

MatildaTheCat · 17/10/2022 18:34

Haha, yes, absolutely. The received wisdom is that they become so awful you won’t care so much when they leave home. I’m not sure that’s true but certainly this really grim selfishness is very very common. I bet she’s sweetness and light outside of home.

Hang on in there. And don’t just tolerate any old shit. If you have a DP make sure you stand together, that helps.

I have a DH who she gets on well with. He is stuck in the middle. I've seen some texts to DH that are just blatant lies about me losing my temper and causing a row (when it was her). Absolute lies. I do hold my hands up the fact that I bite and can't let it wash over me as it's so poisonous. I feel like if I do, I'm condoning it. That and I am often aghast at the hypocrisy of her views (and try to help her see it) but to no avail and huge rows erupt.

I literally want to just move out, it's so unpleasant.

OP posts:
eskappe · 17/10/2022 18:56

That sounds tough. You can be quite robust about your career choices though and give her a sense that there are no ethical, very well-paid, interesting, 45-hours-a-week jobs sitting around. She'll possibly have to find that out for herself - but yikes, the fantasy thinking.

Fedupwithmondays · 17/10/2022 18:55

I have a DD 15. She was so lovely, kind, thoughtful. Then the teenager years hit. She is lovely with everyone else but vile to me and my DH. (Her father). Doesn't help I am going through the memopause. Have to really pick my battles at the moment. Gin helps at the weekends. 😀

Swipe left for the next trending thread