Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make cooking from scratch a thing of the past?

187 replies

Mumhangingon · 17/10/2022 17:38

So I'm sat here 1 hour in to cooking a steak pie from scratch. I've totted up how much its cost me in ingredients along with the cost of the oven running for 3 hours and I'm thinking why am I bothering? I know it will be much nicer but is it worth paying 2 or 3 times the cost of a premade pie from the supermarket? Or even a butchers? Same for lasagne, cottage pie etc? I want to do my best for my family but the cost of living is making it too costly.
Is there a secret I'm missing? Or is it just cheaper to buy premade.
I'm grateful to be able to put food on the table of course, I'm just sat here thinking about ways to cut costs where we can.

OP posts:
DeannaFromHumanResources · 18/10/2022 06:18

We do both as they’re not mutually exclusive.

twinklystar23 · 18/10/2022 06:11

For those that declare us who cook from scratch snobs. I do not consider that it makes me a snob. The day OH found the remains of a cockroach in his shop bought curry (confirmed finally by environmental health) kind of ended shop bought for us.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 18/10/2022 06:10

I have a half hour rule during the week too, and always cook second portions to heat up next day.

Anything that needs the oven gets batch cooked on the weekend so the giant, leaky old thing only needs to be run once. I use the slow cooker and air fryer instead of the oven wherever possible.

A580Hojas · 18/10/2022 06:07

I'm sorry but you really cannot "bamg out" a lasagne or cottage pie in 40 minutes. At least not an edible one.

bobbinon · 18/10/2022 05:42

Never make things like pie from scratch - I batch cook varying curries, especially vegan as cheaper, saves time and money. And health.

Pie is a rare bought treat.

The rest is from
Scratch as in rice stir fry's, occasionally pasta, or just fresh cooked meat / fish and veg and potatoes. Sea bass and salad in a wrap for example.

Jamie O's 30 mins book (did he do 15 too?) is helpful.

Goatinthegarden · 18/10/2022 05:35

I haven’t really cooked big meat dishes for years because I married a vegetarian; so not sure how much it would cost,or how long it would take to cook a steak pie, but I can certainly make a sourdough pizza or quiche from scratch much cheaper and tastier than a supermarket version.

Its just DH and I, so no fussy eaters to cater for, or children to run around after and I quite happily cook for up to an hour or so most evenings.

My body is not a complete temple; I eat out a couple of times a week and I do eat processed foods like pasta, noodles, bread products like wraps and bagels, tofu, halloumi and the odd veggie ‘meat’. But ready meals just don’t taste good enough to be worth the salt and additives (even the Cook ones). For only slightly more effort involved in buying and heating a ready meal, I can quickly throw something fresh tasting and more nutritious together.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 18/10/2022 04:59

I cook everything 'from scratch' (isn't it just cooking?), mainly because most ready meals re horrible, and you don't get a huge choice of them here in Oz anyway. I enjoy cooking, but there is no way you'll get me slaving away for hours every night. I have a Thermomix, slow cooker and air fryer which helps a lot, and I batch things like spag bol, soups, stews curries etc. I get a lot of satisfaction out of having a freezer stocked with home cooked meals. We all cook in this house, which makes it easier, my student son is particularly good at pizzas and cakes (his black forest gateau is legendary). I think if you really enjoy food, its really worth it, but if you don't want to cook, don't!

eldora · 18/10/2022 04:56

BobbysGirly · 18/10/2022 03:11

If you don’t want to cook from scratch then don’t - nobody’s making you.

I’ve cooked from scratch every day for 40+ years. My choice.

Everyone has a choice in life. Nobody really cares about what someone else chooses. Go for whatever suits you

I don”t think OP is asking for permission Smile

Zonder · 18/10/2022 04:41

We cook everything from scratch but I wouldn't even look twice at a recipe that takes that long. We make lots of one pot slow cooker stuff or pasta or curry kind of things. If it's not ready in half an hour, including cooking time, I'm not really interested unless it's a special meal.

Sikaris · 18/10/2022 04:37

I make enough for 4 days and freeze them.

CrispyNoodles · 18/10/2022 03:34

Another poster here who is baffled as to why your steak pie takes 3 hours to cook ?? How big is it??

BobbysGirly · 18/10/2022 03:11

If you don’t want to cook from scratch then don’t - nobody’s making you.

I’ve cooked from scratch every day for 40+ years. My choice.

Everyone has a choice in life. Nobody really cares about what someone else chooses. Go for whatever suits you

Ragwort · 18/10/2022 02:37

I much prefer eating a 'cooked from scratch' meal as it tastes so much nice but I will only do two 'proper' meals each week .. other times I just have a sandwich, jacket potato, cheese on toast type meal or leftovers. DH does his own thing & likes cooking for himself so it works out that I am not spending too much time in the kitchen. But not so easy if you are cooking for a family.

JockTamsonsBairns · 18/10/2022 02:09

PickAChew · 17/10/2022 23:25

What's the fastest cake?

Scone.

^doesn't work if you mispronounce it.

You and I can be friends 😃

TheTeenageYears · 18/10/2022 00:50

Maybe it's more about adapting. The steak didn't need to go in the oven for 2 hours, simmering on the hob or better still 20/30 minutes in a pressure cooker would have slashed the energy costs for the pie. A shepherds/cottage pie can be put together and then put under the grill for a bit rather than put in the oven or just use the hob to make mince with veg in gravy & mashed potato and serve - it tastes the same.

musicviking1 · 18/10/2022 00:42

I stopped making my own lasagna because it used to be far cheaper to buy a family sized one - not so sure anymore.

VanGoghsDog · 18/10/2022 00:30

Cordeliathecat · 17/10/2022 23:19

A lot of PP taking about using slow cooker or pressure cooker. Don’t want to derail the thread but can anyone recommend one? I’ve never had/used one before. Also are pressure cookers and slow cookers the same thing??

They're not the same thing though there is a pressure cooker you can buy that has a slow cooker setting, confusingly.

I have a sc and a pc (with a sc setting). I use the sc a bit (not loads because it doesn't make the sort of food I like) but I've never used the pc because I'm scared of it!

BeatieBourke · 18/10/2022 00:30

This risks me sounding like a smug arse, so apologies if that's the case. It's not meant that way.

My mum (and her mum before her) had a very old school cooking approach. They were skint. Grandad was a poacher.

Pies are a way to make cheap ingredients go further. The economy comes from buying a cheap cut of meat that's roasted slowly on a Sunday, and then chucked in with a load of old (about to go off) veg to make a pie filling, stew, and casserole to feed the family for another three nights. In this context, a bit of butter and flour, a few potatoes, or some suet (dumplings) are all cheap ingredients to stretch out the cheap meat.

(Appreciate butter is v expensive atm. Wasn't always the case)

Buying the ingredients for a pie in isolation, never mind the man hours and oven running costs, is not economical at all. Shop bought does make more sense.

In my (old fashioned - I'm not a Tory, honest) view, this is why we have such a skewed food system and economy. We don't have the time or the resources to cook like this any more. My granny was poor, could make a mean pie, but didn't have to earn half the household income whilst simultaneously doing home exonomics magic.

I LOVE cooking. But I work full time and we're still mostly skint. It's a circle I can't square.

VikingLady · 18/10/2022 00:11

It's not just the cash price, it's the effort dvd thought involved. I'd need to have preplanned buying the ingredients etc, which I'm not likely to do. And it's so much effort to do, when the kids need watching/interacting with and I'm exhausted. I simply haven't the spoons.

Menopause, two kids with different SEN, food aversions and allergies, a flipping useless DH who is trying his best but actually makes life harder (ASD), I'm ASD as well, housework piling up - fuck it. Pizza for DD, fish fingers for DS and takeaway/something easy for DH and me.

The most I do these days is read the labels to avoid the worst additives and make sure everyone has fruit and fat in their diet. There's more important stuff to worry about.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/10/2022 23:56

Well as you've described it, no, it's not worth it. But you're not using a very cost/time efficient recipe I think planning ahead is key. Eg I use my slow cooker which is way lower cost than the oven. I make double the amount, one can be used eg for a stew and then use the remainder as a pie filling.

Or a big batch of bolognese sauce, frozen in family sized portions. One for spag bol, another adapted the following week for lasagne, another the week after that for chilli. For example.

I'd buy a pie before I spent the time and money on the recipe you're using. But then I'd never have chosen it knowing there are other ways of preparing a pie filling. .

DottyLittleRainbow · 17/10/2022 23:47

Pressure cooker. Perfect stewed steak in 15-20min max. And a million other things. Also batch cook to make the most of the prep, ingredients vs cost etc.

aintnothinbutagstring · 17/10/2022 23:32

I like Jon Thorners pies from Ocado - probably the only ready-made pie I'd happily switch from homemade - not cheap though. I guess you could just use ready-made pastry (all butter ones) and use fillings that are quicker to cook - not slow cook beef. Agree that planning so that leftover meat from a roast might be more economical than cooking meat especially for a pie. The thing is, the nicest ready-made meals are expensive now so I'm not sure, even factoring energy cost, that there's not much savings to be made unless you buy the very cheapest ready-made food.

Tadpoll · 17/10/2022 23:26

Oh, and a pie has a bottom.

PickAChew · 17/10/2022 23:25

What's the fastest cake?

Scone.

^doesn't work if you mispronounce it.

Dreamingcats · 17/10/2022 23:23

To me, yes it's usually worth it because it's healthier and tastes better.

I've been experimenting with cooking things from scratch and noting the cost pp and how much faff it was. Some things I've kept up with (eg amazing shepherd's pie recipe, and shop bought lasagna is grim), and others I've ditched as not worth the effort (gnocchi). I try to keep the cost down by buying reduced price ingredients and basing meals around those.