Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

London Begging - it’s changed

106 replies

Stupidbonfire · 17/10/2022 16:40

So I’m the first person to admit I’m a complete country bumpkin so please forgive my naivety here.

ive just returned from a wonderful weekend in London. Haven’t been for about 5 years but used to visit regularly and my sister lived there for 10 years. So it’s not like we’re strangers to it. But where there used to be plentiful big issue sellers outside the tube stations and the usual homeless people with clear alcohol or substance misuse issues begging. They seem to have disappeared. We didn’t see one big issue seller. And whilst there were still the occasional doorway sleeper in a winter coat with a sleeping bag with a sign etc, there was also a new kind of beggars I have never seen in the uk before.
clearly very vulnerable individuals just plonked in the middle of the pavement on regent street. Dressed utterly in rags. And not worn out modern clothing. Complete rags. Like flour sacks. It’s was almost Dickensian. He was shaking and loudly begging for help and money. Similar Romanian looking women, really loudly begging for help. Like I’m extreme distress. Rather than just huddled in a doorway. And obviously everyone walks on by. I am assuming that these people are trafficked and there are minders watching them. The man on regent street was clearly severely disability and would have in no way managed to get himself there.
what can we do to help. These don’t look like clientele for shelter or big issue, which is what I would normally donate to or purchase to support. What if anything is being done?
It reminds me of the gangs in India sending the poor street children out.

OP posts:
MRex · 19/10/2022 08:35

@FanniesFlaps - children begging should always be reported to police, not just left, because it is a child protection issue. If you didn't report at the time, you still can do so now if it was in the last two weeks.

Buttons294749 · 18/10/2022 17:49

I went to my local "town centre" in london today and actually my earlier post was wrong. Their are more of the people with physical disabilities, fewer of the females that sit down and more of the men who use sticks

FanniesFlaps · 18/10/2022 09:52

LondonWolf · 17/10/2022 17:18

Some with apparent disabilities- ie on a crutch, shaking - feigning possible Cerebral palsy? Are not disabled. You can see by the fact that their supposed unusable limb is not wasted and they are well fed. They usually come up to cars at junctions and move away pretty fast once the traffic starts flowing. I drive around London each day and I know exactly what you're talking about OP. It's organised begging and anything you give them will be passed along to gang masters.

The most worrying thing I saw was a young boy, no more than 8 or 9, playing a guitar and dancing on Piccadilly Circus - we stopped because my dd absolutely loved the movie "Coco" and this young boy was the imagine of Miguel - same style of singing and dancing, he was so talented. You look around though and there is a very tough looking "minder" stood nearby, keeping an eye on things. How did that boy come to be here? - he couldn't speak any English. Worries me what the sequence of events was for him to be on Piccadilly Circus playing to tourists.

We stopped to watch a young lad 12-14 years old playing the violin. His “Mother” was with him. I stood long enough to realise he actually wasn’t playing. His fingers and bow weren’t moving in time with the music. I think the “ Mother” heard me mention it to my DH and she had a face like thunder and started moving towards us so we shifted pretty quick.

BlodynGwyn · 17/10/2022 23:08

EmmaH2022 · 17/10/2022 19:02

Londoner born and raised

none of this seems new, it probably just depends on your own experience

i had a chat with one bloke - not trafficked, an English boy who tells me he lefts because his dad beat him up - at Bank recently. He's moving to a more tourist spot as no one seems to carry cash in the city now. I think he sofa surfs somewhere or has a bed for the night somewhere, he's told me he won't go to the nearest shelter.

lots of Big Issue sellers near major stations.

I remember Marble Arch man with the god awful whistle but that was from 2000s? I avoid the area if I can and maybe haven't been, except through on the bus, for about 10 years. The gangs are still visible. That area is a disgrace to London.

anyway, none of it sounds different. Some real, some not. I buy food and hot drinks if I get to know any but I have worked mostly from home since 2016 so rarely chat to them now.

I beg to differ.

I used to spend a lot of time in London in the late 60's and very early 70's. I never saw anyone begging or homeless people sleeping on the streets. I can even remember shopping trips during the 1950's with my mum and we certainly never saw beggars/homeless. So, based on that, I'd say this wasn't happening before the early 70's.

I emigrated almost 50 years ago but used to return for visits.

On a trip to UK/London in 1976 a lady approached me and pinned some lavender to my clothes and then asked for payment. This would have been around Oxford Street. In 1986 my husband and I were walking into the Museum of Natural History and a nicely dressed woman with an Irish accent ran up to my American husband, (who looked every inch the tourist as he was sporting two cameras around his neck), and gave him a story about needing money to feed her children. Other than that, things looked beggar/homeless street sleeper free.

I remember being very shocked when I walked out of Grand Central Station (50 + yrs ago - when NYC was a dangerous shit-hole) and saw a small group of men begging - one had no legs at all and was pushing himself around on a skate board thing using his poor knuckles. We never saw that sort of thing in London back then, so it was shocking and very depressing.

I don't understand why these gangs are being allowed to exploit the vulnerable. It's so very cruel.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 17/10/2022 21:49

My council goes to them and talk to them, offers housing and support. They don’t come back because they don’t need support. It’s a racket. Some have homes back in Albania.

Jollywren · 17/10/2022 21:39

I utterly just fail to understand why the authorities do nothing about all of this? Same with the nail bars etc where the staff appear to possibly be victims of trafficking/ modern slavery. All in plain sight in the UK in 2022. Baffling to me.

CentralLondonLife · 17/10/2022 21:27

EmmaH2022 · 17/10/2022 20:29

Oh right
I was puzzled by the tissue ones, I've seen many

but aren't those Heathrow trains too full to find empty seats for the tissues?

They put them on the suitcases- lots of those on that line.

KingaBee · 17/10/2022 21:25

absolutely true. I have noticed the shift in the last few years.

there was a guy with a dog always reading a book I used to pass on my way to work. I sometimes bought him a sandwich.

one day he disappeared and was replaced by a Roma woman in rags.
i saw the guy a few days later walking near the tube station. He looked badly beaten up. He told me a bunch of Romanian thugs roughed him up to “explain” he was no longer allowed to beg on that street.

Namechangenoidea · 17/10/2022 21:25

Testina · 17/10/2022 19:23

I live in a large village - 2 pubs, 1 primary, no post office sort of thing. 30 mins drive from a small city. Very very white population, former northern mining community.

And yet, we have a regular Romanian (?) woman selling the Big Issue and wailing a bit. She was seen following an elderly lady who’d been to the cash point, community police had a strong word. She disappeared. A week later, lo and behold there’s another Romanian (?) woman working the patch. And yes, they’ve been seen getting dropped off by expensive cars.

The very last people I’d ever assume to have any legitimacy are the “Romanian” women.

How do you know they are romanian?

I think alot if people on this thread are referring to romani gypsies. Roma gypsies and romanians are not the same thing. The tan women sometimes with gold teeth that hang around london are romani gypsies. The word romani has nothing to do with romania. They originated from India and now live all across europe not specifically Romania.

Greenbks · 17/10/2022 21:08

I see someone has already offered useful
advice around providing them with numbers/ contacts etc.

mamas for what you can do immediately, buy them food.

Silverangels · 17/10/2022 20:50

I used to live in York and I remember standing chatting to a mate in the city centre (it would have been about 1996/97) and I well known begger came up behind us to talk to his mate
clear as a bell,we both heard ‘it’s been shit today mate,I’ve only made £200 in the last hour’
jesus,£200 in one hour? (I was on £2.50 an hour at that point)
I dread how much he could have got on a ‘good’ day (I heard he died of drugs a few years later)
pall those £1 coins added up and where shot straight up his arm

EmmaH2022 · 17/10/2022 20:29

CentralLondonLife · 17/10/2022 20:07

The tube tissues is a distraction theft
You are so busy watching them and their accomplices who have got on several stops before then rob bags. Usually trains from Heathrow- tourist with plenty of money/goods who are a bit tired.

Oh right
I was puzzled by the tissue ones, I've seen many

but aren't those Heathrow trains too full to find empty seats for the tissues?

CentralLondonLife · 17/10/2022 20:07

The tube tissues is a distraction theft
You are so busy watching them and their accomplices who have got on several stops before then rob bags. Usually trains from Heathrow- tourist with plenty of money/goods who are a bit tired.

eurochick · 17/10/2022 20:05

About 20 years ago I saw a van/minibus driving around the city dropping off beggars and distributing children among them. It wasn't London but another European capital. I was pretty horrified and haven't given to street beggars since. I give to a homeless charity monthly and t feel that is much more likely to do good.

CentralLondonLife · 17/10/2022 20:05

astarsheis · 17/10/2022 19:17

@Darbs76 you need to go a bit further than Regent Street...that's probably one of the streets where you don't really see them. Too many burly security guards that move then on.

There is a man near to COS every single day. I have noticed that his toe nails are now so long that he couldn't get shoes on.

Coldymccold · 17/10/2022 19:28

Autumndays123 · 17/10/2022 18:02

Well that's me told. You organised meetings and typed up documents for a community mental health team. I apologise, I wasn't aware of your clear and advanced expertise on the causes and impact of homelessness 😂

You come on here acting self righteous and then mock someone's occupation. Have a word with yourself and try to be a bit nicer

Testina · 17/10/2022 19:23

I live in a large village - 2 pubs, 1 primary, no post office sort of thing. 30 mins drive from a small city. Very very white population, former northern mining community.

And yet, we have a regular Romanian (?) woman selling the Big Issue and wailing a bit. She was seen following an elderly lady who’d been to the cash point, community police had a strong word. She disappeared. A week later, lo and behold there’s another Romanian (?) woman working the patch. And yes, they’ve been seen getting dropped off by expensive cars.

The very last people I’d ever assume to have any legitimacy are the “Romanian” women.

Changechangychange · 17/10/2022 19:17

LondonWolf · 17/10/2022 17:18

Some with apparent disabilities- ie on a crutch, shaking - feigning possible Cerebral palsy? Are not disabled. You can see by the fact that their supposed unusable limb is not wasted and they are well fed. They usually come up to cars at junctions and move away pretty fast once the traffic starts flowing. I drive around London each day and I know exactly what you're talking about OP. It's organised begging and anything you give them will be passed along to gang masters.

The most worrying thing I saw was a young boy, no more than 8 or 9, playing a guitar and dancing on Piccadilly Circus - we stopped because my dd absolutely loved the movie "Coco" and this young boy was the imagine of Miguel - same style of singing and dancing, he was so talented. You look around though and there is a very tough looking "minder" stood nearby, keeping an eye on things. How did that boy come to be here? - he couldn't speak any English. Worries me what the sequence of events was for him to be on Piccadilly Circus playing to tourists.

Some of them are disabled, because I recognise them as my patients - they are IVDUs with abscesses/ischaemic legs from injecting into their femoral veins. Or they have side effects from years of antipsychotics causing tremors/facial tics. The ones I recognise aren’t homeless though, just alcoholics or drug addicts. They all have either flats or a place in supported housing, and claim benefits. They are begging to subside their drug habit (and are more than happy to receive food, not because they can’t afford to eat, but because then they can save their money for drugs instead).

The ones in rags in central London, and the children, are trafficked. The ones with tissues on the trains are often involved in organised crime - you get the same ones working each train route every single day.

Give money to Shelter, or Centrepoint, or St Martin’s.

astarsheis · 17/10/2022 19:17

@Darbs76 you need to go a bit further than Regent Street...that's probably one of the streets where you don't really see them. Too many burly security guards that move then on.

doittwice · 17/10/2022 19:15

No I never give money to beggars. They all get collected, get given commission and 99% goes to the gang leader. Be careful of your watches, your designer handbags because you will get surrounded instantly and knifed or punched up. In the 90s there were some saying they fled the war from Bosnia and begging in front of banks in London. My dad confronted one in Bosnian and he froze and of course he disappeared suddenly with his both legs working! I give to charities, the local food banks and even give some of my multipack food from my shopping to the homeless chap with obvious drug issues but never money. The homeless chap doesn't ask for any money or anything though.

ilukp · 17/10/2022 19:14

I live near a city in central Europe which is very popular with tourists. I go in quite often for various reasons.
The beggars there are all part of an organized crime ring. Nothing is ever done about it.
There's a meeting at around 8 am at Mcdonald's near the station - they all drink a coffee from there (which used to be 1 Euro but has gone up...) and sit around chatting. A couple of men go around with clipboards - possibly allocating people to spots to beg. They then take their empty McDs cup and wander out into the city where they can later be seen waving the cup at passers-by and all saying the same few phrases in the local language here - obviously told what to say.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 17/10/2022 19:06

I was in London recently and they all had matching handmade signs. I assume they round them all up in a van and big bosses/people traffickers get the funds. I agree it was different to times gone by in London.

EmmaH2022 · 17/10/2022 19:02

Londoner born and raised

none of this seems new, it probably just depends on your own experience

i had a chat with one bloke - not trafficked, an English boy who tells me he lefts because his dad beat him up - at Bank recently. He's moving to a more tourist spot as no one seems to carry cash in the city now. I think he sofa surfs somewhere or has a bed for the night somewhere, he's told me he won't go to the nearest shelter.

lots of Big Issue sellers near major stations.

I remember Marble Arch man with the god awful whistle but that was from 2000s? I avoid the area if I can and maybe haven't been, except through on the bus, for about 10 years. The gangs are still visible. That area is a disgrace to London.

anyway, none of it sounds different. Some real, some not. I buy food and hot drinks if I get to know any but I have worked mostly from home since 2016 so rarely chat to them now.

GonnaGonnaGoing · 17/10/2022 18:54

wherethewildthingis · 17/10/2022 18:44

Not you OP but the person up thread. You saw a child you thought had been trafficked, dancing and begging in the street.
You should have called the police (obviously), not stopped because your own child was amused that he looked like a cartoon.
I can't be the only person who finds this shocking. What have you taught your child in this interaction?

👏👏👏

Darbs76 · 17/10/2022 18:51

I live in the suburbs and travel in all the time and haven’t noticed this to be honest. I will keep an eye out next time I’m in regent street