Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still expect birthday presents at my age?!

89 replies

Cookienextdoor · 17/10/2022 16:21

I'm not sure if I ABU or not- I've been quietly stewing on this but don't feel I can actually bring it up as I will sound like a spoilt child!
It was my birthday a few weeks ago and I'm in my 30s, with a DH and two young kids. I received a small gift from each child (chocolates which they kindly helped me eat 😂), cards from them and my DH and a card from my parents and my MIL. And that is it. No card from my siblings (and actually no acknowledgement from one of them now I think of it) or dh siblings. No gift from any adults in my family. I have cards from friends but we generally don't give gifts. AIBU to be a little disappointed by the lack of attention?! To be clear I don't expect expensive gifts or to be taken out for lavish meals or outings, but normally we do something for birthdays beyond a card and a WhatsApp message! So, AIBU and a brat? Or not?! I need telling!

OP posts:
Itisour · 17/10/2022 17:53

That's the problem with gifts/cards then - people have different ideas about it!

I've sent two non-local friends birthday cards this week - empty - definitely didn't mean to be mean! If I had sent them a present too, something they almost certainly didn't really want, I'm potentially setting up an obligation for them to reciprocate on my birthday and thank me and deal with the item I thought was perfect but they probably didn't...My heart would sink if they suddenly started sending gifts.

I love getting a text or a birthday card or an in person 'happy birthday!' on my birthday - it really is enough, and all that is wanted. I guess the problem it is easy to assume that other think the same way when they don't.

nowhitestripeonthesausageplease · 17/10/2022 17:52

mast0650 · 17/10/2022 17:51

It's my birthday today and I'm stewing because my sister hasn't sent me a card.

Well according to nowhitestripe, that's better than sending you an EMPTY card!

Ha ha God I hope when it does come there is something in it!!!!😂

Rewis · 17/10/2022 17:52

I think it depends on your family arrangements. I expect a gift (or a nice day out) from my bf. Also my parents give a gift/cash. Siblings and extended family sends a text (which I prefere over a card) unless I host a party. But that is how it works for us.

mast0650 · 17/10/2022 17:51

It's my birthday today and I'm stewing because my sister hasn't sent me a card.

Well according to nowhitestripe, that's better than sending you an EMPTY card!

Luredbyapomegranate · 17/10/2022 17:50

You aren’t being unreasonable to want more.

But you have to make it happen - tell people what you’d like, organise your family b’day meal, your friends’ b’day drink.

People need direction. And actually once people get used to doing stuff for your b’day they do start to initiate

Chloefairydust · 17/10/2022 17:50

Toddlerteaplease · 17/10/2022 17:44

It's my birthday today and I'm stewing because my sister hasn't sent me a card. (First time she's ever not sent one.) and despite my parents cat sitting my cats yesterday. They didn't leave me a card. Apparently it's in the post. I'm 41 and it's made me really sad.

Happy birthday 🎂 @Toddlerteaplease

Sorry your family haven’t sent cards for your birthday, hope you have a good birthday and treat yourself to something nice 💐

mondaytosunday · 17/10/2022 17:48

I'd expect a nice dinner date or flowers from my partner. Wouldn't expect anything other than an e-card from my siblings and certainly nothing from anyone else (my parents are dead), certainly not my husband's family!
I am single however and I'd arrange a dinner with friends. They'd club together to buy me something - last time (my 60th) a fantastic voucher to an interiors shop, I was able to buy quite a few nice things for my new home.

Chloefairydust · 17/10/2022 17:47

You are not being unreasonable to expect birthday presents. I have a few family members like this, and it isn’t nice when you put a lot of effort in giving people nice and generous gifts for their birthday only to have them forget your birthday. I think it’s kind of a shitty thing to do to be honest.

At the very least they should get you a card to show they are thinking of you and haven’t forgotten your birthday.

Sorry you were treated like this by your family, and I hope you had a lovely birthday regardless. 💐

Toddlerteaplease · 17/10/2022 17:44

It's my birthday today and I'm stewing because my sister hasn't sent me a card. (First time she's ever not sent one.) and despite my parents cat sitting my cats yesterday. They didn't leave me a card. Apparently it's in the post. I'm 41 and it's made me really sad.

Quitelikeacatslife · 17/10/2022 17:40

I think that's really awful. I'd expect a few thoughtful gifts from DH , sometimes asked for ideas (treat things you wouldn't buy for yourself) always get gifts from mum , sister dad maybe vouchers from PIL and BIL. Sone friends pop in a bottle or plant of something. And I give to all those people too. It's one day of the year and just shows a bit of thought.
It doesn't need to be expensive at all. Even something home made , If money was really really tight then fair enough but I'd expect a conversation first

Sidking · 17/10/2022 17:38

YANBU imo, if you usually would receive a gift from OH or parents then unless it had been mentioned that they couldn't afford it ATM then that what I would expect.

My parents have never not got me a birthday present, I would be gutted if i just didn't get a gift with no conversation around stopping them (and they would never do that, they've always celebrated our birthdays and have a present or 2 even when everything is going to sh*t around the family - illnesses etc)

If it's cost of living or whatever then that's fine, but a discussion around it and acknowledgment that it would be the same for all in the family this year and that they don't expect any gifts either let's everyone know where they stand.

Badgirlriri · 17/10/2022 17:34

YANBU. It’s not grabby at all.

I often buy gifts knowing how much my family and partner will love them. I love giving just as much as receiving. To not receive any gifts as an adult is a real shame.

nowhitestripeonthesausageplease · 17/10/2022 17:34

They're for writing your good wishes on, you know, not just wrapping up a tenner 😂

Dear Nowhitestripe,

Wishing your an absolutely wonderful 35th birthday. I really do hope you are spoiled. Have a great day!

Love your sister Kate xxxxx

Which really boils down to, I didn't bother getting you a pressie, not only that I am too mean to throw some cash or a voucher in your card so here is....a card!
I remembered and marked your birthday. I am off the hook!

You scabby cow Kate.

ThreeblackCats · 17/10/2022 17:33

Once I’m buying gifts for the children of siblings, cousins, my own children etc, I’m not buying gifts for you
once you are a parent, you lose the right to expect gifts.

MimosaSunrise · 17/10/2022 17:32

No, you’re not ‘grabby’ (hate that word), op. I’d be expecting presents from DH and parents if that’s what was usual and I got them presents - unless we had a chat where we agreed to stop doing it going forward, of course. My family had a scaling-back of Xmas a few years ago, but it was agreed in advance.

Personally, I’m more into my birthday as I get older. Life is busy and stressful, and it’s lovely to have a day where you get made a fuss of!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 17/10/2022 17:32

Everyone is skint at the moment. You can't just 'expect' presents.

In our family, they stop over the age of 18. Might sound harsh, but saves wasting money of crap that no-one really wants and gets shoved under the bed, 're-gifted' or given to a charity shop.

I'd like a small present from my partner, but I certainly don't expect one.

Eleusa · 17/10/2022 17:31

Honestly think you are on your own with this one, @nowhitestripeonthesausageplease 😂

nowhitestripeonthesausageplease · 17/10/2022 17:30

mast0650 · 17/10/2022 17:25

No, I think it is incredibly mean. I am too mean to buy you a pressie but I will give you an empty card to look like I am giving you something. I would rather a text.

Well, it takes all sorts I suppose! I've never associated a card with money since my Great Aunty Thelma used to send me a birthday card in the 1980s. It's not an "empty card" - it's just a card.

Again I am talking about giving a card, just a card, nothing else and think that is ok to hand a loved one for a birthday. It's not.

nowhitestripeonthesausageplease · 17/10/2022 17:29

Bananamaman · 17/10/2022 17:24

Wow, this is a million miles away from how my family and driends do things. I'd never give another adult cash in a card and have never received cash as an adult, but would be very happy to receive a card (or as you put it, an "empty card"). They're for writing your good wishes on, you know, not just wrapping up a tenner 😂

OP, your husband should have got you something.

I meant to hand a loved one a card with no gift. Nothing, Just a card. To me, that is mean. I would rather have nothing. If I had to choose I would rather a thoughtful gift than money or a voucher in a card but to just had a sister or a mother a just a CARD is beyond mean to me.

lovenotwar149 · 17/10/2022 17:27

I dont know tbh. I have over the yrs on more than 1 occasion felt upset on my birthday for similar reasons. It's all to do with expectations. I would go above and beyond for others on their bday. I realised I wanted the praise from them for 'doing so much.' This generosity wasn't reciprocated and it hurt...well until I realised why I went above and beyond for others. Now I match what I receive and its been noticed. Others dont like it because I have changed my habit. Cant win. But I dont feel resentful now, so that's better for me.

mast0650 · 17/10/2022 17:25

No, I think it is incredibly mean. I am too mean to buy you a pressie but I will give you an empty card to look like I am giving you something. I would rather a text.

Well, it takes all sorts I suppose! I've never associated a card with money since my Great Aunty Thelma used to send me a birthday card in the 1980s. It's not an "empty card" - it's just a card.

Bananamaman · 17/10/2022 17:24

nowhitestripeonthesausageplease · 17/10/2022 16:52

I presume the cards had money in them? One thing I will never understand is people who don't buy a gift but hand someone a card. An empty card. Baffles me. Put a £1 scratch card in at least.

I would rather receive nothing than just a card with nothing in it.

Wow, this is a million miles away from how my family and driends do things. I'd never give another adult cash in a card and have never received cash as an adult, but would be very happy to receive a card (or as you put it, an "empty card"). They're for writing your good wishes on, you know, not just wrapping up a tenner 😂

OP, your husband should have got you something.

Ponderingwindow · 17/10/2022 17:22

only from DH and maybe your parents. Parents are going to depend on financial circumstances though. A card may be more appropriate.

nowhitestripeonthesausageplease · 17/10/2022 17:20

mast0650 · 17/10/2022 17:10

I presume the cards had money in them? One thing I will never understand is people who don't buy a gift but hand someone a card. An empty card. Baffles me. Put a £1 scratch card in at least.
I would rather receive nothing than just a card with nothing in it.

Really? I don't think most people think like this? A birthday card is a nice gesture in itself. Especially if carefully chosen. It shows someone is thinking of you and is one up from a WA message - which is also better than nothing!

No, I think it is incredibly mean. I am too mean to buy you a pressie but I will give you an empty card to look like I am giving you something. I would rather a text.

GlassesWearer · 17/10/2022 17:20

I wouldn't expect anything beyond token gifts from DCs to be honest. It'd be nice to get something from DH but, in truth, I'm better at choosing than he is and (because all our money is joint money) it feels like I'm just buying myself a gift that I don't really like and I'd rather have the money in the bank. DH's birthday was this weekend and I went a bit nutty on gifts for him because I recently got a bonus and he never spoils himself and would always go without to keep enough kept by - if he bought himself treats then I wouldn't feel compelled to on his birthday.

I get where you're coming from though OP. It's a bit like still wanting Father Christmas to bring you a stocking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread